CrowdfundedWealth
Reviews · Platform teardown

Carrington Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Denials, Costs, CFPB Record

By Jorge··22 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the carrington mortgage numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick Answer

Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC filed 52,599 records in the 2025 federal HMDA file, of which 15,089 were loans it originated ($3.60 billion): 7,441 conventional, 5,141 FHA, 2,492 VA and 15 USDA, as of the data we read on November 16, 2026. Cash-out refinances were 74.9% of those loans (11,304) and home purchases only 15.0% (2,268). It denied 23,245 applications, 54.2% of its decisions (our arithmetic), against 21.8% for FHA loans nationwide and 58.4% for its own; but 17,184 of the denials (73.9%) list an incomplete credit application as the first reason, and 95.1% of the denied applications came to Carrington directly. On home-purchase loans it denied 37.1% of FHA decisions against 13.1% for all lenders. Its median note rate on 30-year owner-occupied FHA purchase loans was 6.625% against 6.25% for all lenders. The CFPB database lists 700 complaints for 2025 (511 about mortgages, 406 of those about payments or trouble paying) and 1,196 for 2026 through the data we pulled on November 16, 2026. The CFPB issued a $5.25 million order in 2022 over pandemic forbearances and terminated it on July 21, 2025.

Key Takeaways

  • Scale, from the 2025 HMDA file: 52,599 records reconcile to 15,089 originated loans ($3,597,275,000), 4,558 approved but not accepted, 23,245 denied, 9,305 withdrawn, 209 purchased loans and 193 other records. Carrington sold every FHA and VA loan it originated in 2025 to Ginnie Mae.
  • Mix: 49.3% conventional (7,441), 34.1% FHA (5,141), 16.5% VA (2,492). By purpose, 11,304 cash-out refinances (74.9%), 2,268 purchases (15.0%) and 1,516 rate-and-term refinances (10.0%). Second-lien loans were 3,737 of the 15,089.
  • Denials: 58.4% on FHA, 53.0% on conventional, 47.0% on VA, against 21.8%, 23.4% and 16.2% for all lenders nationwide (denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied, our arithmetic). The first reason on 17,184 denials (73.9%) is a credit application that was incomplete; debt-to-income ratio is first on 1,489.
  • Purchase loans (first lien, closed-end): denial rate 37.1% on FHA, 30.0% on conventional and 21.2% on VA, against 13.1%, 15.3% and 8.4% for all lenders. On 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans the median note rate was 6.625% on FHA (332 loans), 7.0% on VA (145) and 7.125% on conventional (540), against 6.25%, 6.125% and 6.5% for all lenders.
  • Complaints, CFPB database: 497 for 2024, 700 for 2025 and 1,196 for January 1 to November 16, 2026. Mortgage complaints were 411, 511 and 1,006; trouble during the payment process and struggling to pay were 79.5% of the 2025 mortgage complaints, applying or closing 10.0%.
  • Documents: CFPB consent order 2022-CFPB-0010 (November 17, 2022, $5,250,000, CARES Act forbearances and credit reporting; terminated July 21, 2025); HUD Mortgagee Review Board settlement of October 31, 2018 ($311,800); HUD inspector general audit 2025-KC-1002 of January 30, 2025 (an estimated 1,451 FHA foreclosures started in 2022 without the required loss mitigation, which Carrington disputes).
  • Carrington Mortgage Services files no 10-K or 10-Q. A parent, Carrington Holding Company, LLC, filed a Form D in March 2021 for $180 million of 8.00% Senior Secured Notes. HMDA has no credit scores, and the CFPB does not verify complaints.

CSV · 166 rows

Carrington Mortgage Services: 2025 HMDA record, purchase costs, CFPB complaints and the CFPB, HUD and SEC documents

166 rows: the 52,599 HMDA records reconciled by action, loan type, purpose and lien, denial rates and reasons, 30-year purchase medians against all lenders, CFPB complaint counts by year and issue, and the 2018, 2022, 2025 enforcement and audit documents. One source per row.

Which Carrington number is right: 52,599 or 15,089

Both are counts of the same 2025 file. The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) requires lenders to report every application they decide and every loan they buy; the CFPB and FFIEC published the 2025 data on March 31, 2026. Carrington filed 52,599 records. Only 15,089 are loans it made.

2025 HMDA actionRecordsWhat it means
Loan originated15,089Closed loans, $3,597,275,000
Approved, not accepted4,558Offer made, borrower did not take it
Denied23,245Application refused
Withdrawn by applicant9,305Borrower walked away before a decision
Purchased loan209Bought from another lender
Preapproval denied or approved, file closed193Preapproval requests and files closed for incompleteness
All records52,599Sum of the lines

A reader looking at 23,245 denials next to 15,089 loans will think most people who apply to Carrington are refused. That is not what the file shows for a person applying to buy a home, and the next two sections show why.

What it lends: conventional and FHA, mostly cash-out refinances

Loan typeOriginatedDollarsShare of its loansCarrington denial rateAll lenders, denial rate
Conventional7,441$1.43 billion49.3%53.0%23.4%
FHA5,141$1.26 billion34.1%58.4%21.8%
VA2,492$0.90 billion16.5%47.0%16.2%
USDA15$3.16 million0.1%61.0% (36 of 59 decisions)12.9%
All15,089$3.60 billion100%54.2%n/a

Denial rate is denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025). Our ranked pages show where Carrington stands against every other lender: it is 25th among FHA lenders in FHA lenders ranked by 2025 loans, and the VA table is in VA lenders ranked by 2025 loans.

Originated loans and denials by purpose, 2025

PurposeOriginatedApproved, not acceptedDeniedDenial rate
Home purchase2,26868099925.3%
Refinance1,5167363,23158.9%
Cash-out refinance11,3043,14219,01456.8%

Three quarters of what Carrington originates is a cash-out refinance, and cash-out applications are 81.8% of its denials (19,014 of 23,245, our arithmetic). Of the 15,089 loans, 3,737 (24.8%) are second liens, with an average of about $69,000 each (our arithmetic from $258,165,000 originated), so a share of the book is small home-equity-style borrowing. Home purchases, the case a first-time buyer has in mind, are 2,268 loans, of which 379 were for investment properties.

Why the denial rate looks so high

The first denial reason entered, across all 23,245 denials:

First denial reasonDenialsShare
Credit application incomplete17,18473.9%
Credit history1,6697.2%
Debt-to-income ratio1,4896.4%
Other1,2095.2%
Collateral8993.9%
Unverifiable information3591.5%
Insufficient cash2361.0%
Employment history1990.9%

Of the 17,184 incomplete-application denials, 14,320 (83.3%) were cash-out refinances. And 22,100 of the 23,245 denials (95.1%) were applications submitted directly to Carrington rather than through a broker. Our reading, which HMDA does not confirm, is that many of these records are applications that were started, often by customers whose loans Carrington already services, and never finished with the documents the file needed. A denial for an incomplete application is not a judgment on the borrower's credit; by comparison, credit history is the first reason on only 7.2% of its denials. For anyone comparing lenders by denial rate, 54.2% for Carrington is not comparable with a lender that has few such records.

The purchase file is cleaner, because a purchase needs a contract and a closing date. In the purchase extract (first lien, closed-end, not reverse, not business purpose, originated or denied only) Carrington's denial rate is still well above the national one:

Home-purchase loans, 2025Carrington originatedCarrington deniedCarrington denial rateAll lenders
Conventional57324630.0%15.3%
FHA67439737.1%13.1%
VA62916921.2%8.4%
USDA131350.0%13.6%

In this extract the denial rate is denied divided by originated plus denied, because approved-not-accepted records are not in it (our arithmetic). Among Carrington's 825 denied purchase applications, the first reason was an incomplete application on 262 (31.8%), debt-to-income ratio on 156, credit history on 124 and other reasons on 120. So even for buyers, about a third of the refusals are files recorded as incomplete. The HMDA file does not say why.

Rate, points and total loan costs on a 30-year purchase loan

For rates we compare like with like: first-lien, owner-occupied home-purchase loans that closed in 2025 with a 360-month term, excluding reverse mortgages, lines of credit and business-purpose loans, for Carrington and for all lenders in the same extract (which includes Carrington's own loans, a negligible share). The Carrington samples are small.

30-year purchase loans, 2025Carrington FHAAll lenders FHACarrington VAAll lenders VACarrington conventionalAll lenders conventional
Loans in the filter332613,512145320,2405401,733,969
Median note rate6.625%6.25%7.0%6.125%7.125%6.5%
Median discount points paid$2,811$2,946$3,226$2,744$2,757$2,490
Median origination charges$4,615$2,547$0$950$10,240$1,890
Median total loan costs$12,782$11,316$3,744$6,597$14,780$5,606
Median loan amount$275,000$305,000$315,000$355,000$435,000$345,000

Points and some cost fields are blank on part of the loans, so those medians use fewer loans than the first row: for Carrington, discount points are reported on 228 of 332 FHA loans, 123 of 145 VA loans and 336 of 540 conventional loans. The pattern differs by product. On FHA, Carrington's median rate and total loan costs are both above the all-lender median. On VA, its rate is 0.875 percentage points higher and its discount points are higher, but its median total loan costs and origination charges are lower, with a median of $0 in origination charges. That fits loans priced with a higher rate in exchange for lower closing costs, though HMDA does not say how a loan was priced. On conventional loans the median origination charges, $10,240 against $1,890, are far above the all-lender median, a gap that matches the channel: 471 of its 573 conventional purchase loans (82.2%) were not submitted directly to Carrington, and 5,804 of its 7,441 conventional loans (78.0%) were sold in 2025 to a purchaser type HMDA labels "other" rather than to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. These look like a different kind of conventional loan from the agency-conforming loan behind the all-lender median (our reading).

What the rate differences cost on $300,000 over 30 years (our arithmetic)

ComparisonRateMonthly principal and interestOver 30 years
Carrington median, FHA purchase6.625%$1,921$691,536
All-lender median, FHA purchase6.25%$1,847$664,975
Carrington median, VA purchase7.0%$1,996$718,527
All-lender median, VA purchase6.125%$1,823$656,219

On FHA the median rate gap costs $74 a month, $26,561 over the full 30 years, and median total loan costs are $1,466 higher at closing. On VA the rate gap costs $173 a month, $62,308 over 30 years, while closing costs are $2,854 lower, so the lower costs are used up in about 16 months of payments (our arithmetic). A median describes a book of loans, not a quote: the borrower mix differs by lender and HMDA has no credit score. Only a Loan Estimate for your own file is a price.

How its loans reach it, and where they go

Of Carrington's 15,089 loans, 1,478 of the 7,441 conventional (19.9%), 381 of the 5,141 FHA (7.4%) and 174 of the 2,492 VA (7.0%) came through someone else; the rest were submitted directly. Home purchases have a different channel mix: 471 of 573 conventional, 242 of 674 FHA (35.9%) and 91 of 629 VA (14.5%) purchase loans were not submitted directly, so conventional purchase loans lean on brokers or correspondents (see mortgage broker vs direct lender by 2025 costs). All 5,141 FHA and 2,492 VA loans, and the 15 USDA loans, were sold during 2025 to Ginnie Mae, the usual path for government-insured loans, which is also why servicing is what a borrower deals with for years.

Carrington bought 209 loans in 2025. In September 2020 its servicing portfolio held nearly half a million federally backed loans, according to the CFPB order, and in 2022 nearly 350,000 FHA loans, according to the HUD inspector general. It also bought Reliance First Capital on May 1, 2026; see our Reliance First Capital review. 2026 loans will appear only in the 2027 HMDA release.

What the complaints say: servicing, not origination

The CFPB publishes the complaints consumers submit about financial companies, under the name CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES, LLC. The CFPB sends each complaint to the company and does not verify what the consumer says, so a count measures how many people complained, not how many were right.

CFPB complaints about Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC, by year received

Measure202420252026 to November 16
All complaints4977001,196
About mortgages4115111,006
About credit reporting74171156
Mortgage: trouble during payment process193243455
Mortgage: struggling to pay mortgage149163392
Mortgage: applying for a mortgage or refinancing212843
Mortgage: closing on a mortgage212339
Mortgage: incorrect information on your report183445

The latest complaint in the database was received on November 6, 2026, so the 2026 column covers about ten months. In 2025, 700 complaints on 15,089 originated loans is 46.4 per 1,000 (our arithmetic), but that ratio overstates how a new applicant is treated: of the 511 mortgage complaints, 406 (79.5%) are about payments or trouble paying and 51 (10.0%) about applying or closing, which is 3.4 per 1,000 originated loans. The people complaining are mostly borrowers whose loans Carrington services, a book of hundreds of thousands of loans that the originations do not measure. Our reading is that the number to watch is the trend: 2026 mortgage complaints (1,006 in about ten months) are already 1.97 times the 511 of all 2025, and the two payment issues alone are 847 of the 1,006. The company answered 2 of the 700 complaints of 2025 late, and 155 of the 2026 complaints were still marked in progress when we pulled the data. All 700 complaints of 2025 were closed with explanation.

The documents: a CFPB order, a HUD settlement and a HUD audit

DateDocumentWhat it coversAmount or result
October 31, 2018HUD Mortgagee Review Board, docket 16-1859-MR (Federal Register, April 13, 2020)Alleged failure to accurately and timely report the status of defaulted FHA mortgages in HUD's default monitoring system during fiscal year 2016; no admission of liability or fault$311,800 civil money penalty
November 17, 2022CFPB consent order 2022-CFPB-0010CARES Act forbearances and credit reporting on loans Carrington services; consented without admitting or denying the findings$5,250,000 civil money penalty
July 21, 2025CFPB order terminating the consent orderBureau terminated the order and waived any alleged non-compliance; it records that the penalty was paidTerminated
January 30, 2025HUD Office of Inspector General audit report 2025-KC-1002FHA foreclosures started in 2022: sample of 88 of 7,998 loansEstimated 1,451 loans; Carrington disputes

The CFPB order found that Carrington made false or misleading statements to some borrowers who asked for a forbearance, and its first paragraph describes them as “deceptive acts or practices by making material representations likely to mislead reasonable consumers in connection with Forbearances”. Examples listed in the order include telling borrowers with a fraud alert, or who had paid ahead, that they were not eligible, and letters saying late charges would be assessed on payments not made during forbearance. The order also found violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act in how forbearance information was furnished, and it says Carrington provided forbearances to over 115,000 borrowers in the period. Carrington consented to the order without admitting or denying the findings, paid the $5,250,000, and the Bureau terminated the order on July 21, 2025.

The HUD inspector general audit is not an enforcement action. It reports that Carrington “did not complete the required loss mitigation activities before initiating or continuing foreclosure for an estimated 1,451 loans”, projected from a sample of 88 loans drawn from 7,998 FHA-insured loans with a foreclosure started in 2022 and an unpaid balance above $907 million; in the sample, most borrowers ultimately received loss mitigation and kept their homes, and five lost their homes in foreclosure sales. Carrington's response, reproduced in the report, disagrees with the extrapolation and says it maintains that the 18.15% error rate “is unsupported by the facts and the law”.

We did not find a CFPB, state attorney general or federal court action brought by a government agency against Carrington that is still open. We did not read state regulator orders: NMLS Consumer Access, where state actions are listed, could not be reached by us. Private lawsuits exist and are not covered here.

Licences and where it lends

The licensing page on Carrington's own site, as captured by the Internet Archive on March 24, 2026, gives NMLS ID 2600 and lists licence entries under 55 headings: the 50 states, the District of Columbia, Guam, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Its notes say the company is licensed only to service loans in Guam, Massachusetts, the Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands, and that its correspondent lending in Massachusetts is exempt from licensing. The HUD inspector general report describes Carrington as headquartered in California, servicing loans in all 50 states and Puerto Rico and licensed to lend in 48 states. We could not check these lists against NMLS Consumer Access, so confirm the licence for your state there before you apply.

Is there an SEC filing to read

Not for Carrington Mortgage Services. An EDGAR company search for the name on November 16, 2026 returns no registrant of that name, so there is no 10-K or 10-Q with its profit, servicing portfolio or legal reserves. The HUD report says Carrington is a subsidiary of Carrington Holding Company, LLC, which filed a Form D on March 10, 2021 for an offering of 8.00% Senior Secured Notes: $180,000,000 sold to 49 investors, first sale February 26, 2021, with an amendment on July 13, 2021 as its last filing. That is a private placement to investors and has nothing in it for a borrower. EDGAR also lists 19 asset-backed issuers named Carrington Mortgage Loan Trust, with series dated 2004 to 2007: securitization trusts from that period, not the company that services your loan today.

What HMDA cannot tell you about Carrington

  • It has no credit score, so a lender with a high denial rate may simply see weaker applicants. Carrington's FHA and VA lending is aimed at borrowers who qualify for government-insured loans.
  • A denial for an incomplete application is a record of a file, not a verdict on the borrower, and Carrington's denials are dominated by them.
  • Rate and cost figures describe loans that closed in 2025 at 2025 prices, and the Carrington samples are 145 to 540 loans. A 2026 quote can differ.
  • HMDA shows the rate at origination, not what a borrower paid over time or how the loan was serviced.
  • The CFPB does not verify complaints, and servicing complaints depend on a portfolio we cannot size for 2025.

What a reader can do with this

  • If you are buying with FHA or VA, ask Carrington and at least two other lenders for a Loan Estimate on the same day and compare the rate, the points and the total loan costs line by line. Our page on FHA vs conventional loans by 2025 borrowers and costs shows what a typical FHA buyer paid.
  • If Carrington sent you a cash-out or second-lien offer on a loan it services, expect the application to need full documents: in 2025, 73.9% of its denials were files recorded as incomplete.
  • If Carrington already services your loan, keep dated copies of what you send and what is posted. Most CFPB complaints concern payments, and you can file a complaint with the CFPB; the company answered all but two of the 700 complaints of 2025 in time.
  • If you had a forbearance with Carrington between March 27, 2020 and November 17, 2022, that is the period the CFPB order covered.
  • Compare with another servicer-lender, Freedom Mortgage, also an FHA and VA lender with a large servicing book.

Frequently asked questions

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: FFIEC and CFPB HMDA data for 2025 (Data Browser aggregations and loan-level records for Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC, LEI 549300R9S3MVDV4MGF56, and the nationwide home-purchase extract), the CFPB release of March 31, 2026, the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database as queried on November 16, 2026, CFPB consent order 2022-CFPB-0010 of November 17, 2022 and the order terminating it of July 21, 2025, the HUD Mortgagee Review Board notice in the Federal Register of April 13, 2020 (85 FR 20510), HUD Office of Inspector General audit report 2025-KC-1002 of January 30, 2025, the Carrington state licensing page as captured on March 24, 2026, SEC Form D accession 0001850480-21-000001 and an EDGAR company search of November 16, 2026.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.