Guild Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA, Complaints and Bayview Sale
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the guild mortgage numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick Answer
Guild Mortgage Company originated 86,111 loans for $26.87 billion in the 2025 federal HMDA file, as of the data we read on November 16, 2026: 70,983 for home purchases (82.4%), 56,705 conventional, 20,919 FHA, 7,238 VA and 1,249 USDA. On first-lien home-purchase loans it ranked sixth of 4,460 lenders (59,915 loans) and denied 3.5% of decisions against 14.2% for the nation (our arithmetic). Its median 30-year purchase loan carried a 6.625% rate on conventional (national 6.5%), 6.375% on FHA (6.25%) and 6.25% on VA (6.125%), with median total loan costs of $9,094 on VA against $6,585 nationally. The CFPB database lists 100 complaints for 2025 and 221 for January 1 to November 7, 2026. The Justice Department announced a $24.9 million settlement in 2020 over FHA loans. The parent, Guild Holdings Company, was acquired by a fund managed by Bayview Asset Management for $20.00 a share in cash on November 28, 2025, and filed a Form 15 on December 8, 2025, so there is no 10-Q for 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Scale, from the 2025 HMDA file: 123,834 records reconcile to 86,111 originated loans ($26,867,785,000), 6,554 approved but not accepted, 4,586 denied, 22,782 withdrawn, 523 closed incomplete, 2,110 loans bought from others and 1,168 preapproval requests. Purposes: 70,983 purchase, 6,973 refinance, 7,904 cash-out refinance, 243 other and 8 home improvement.
- Denials (denied over originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied, our arithmetic, all purposes): 4.2% conventional, 6.6% FHA, 3.2% VA, 5.1% USDA and 4.7% overall. On first-lien purchase loans (denied over originated plus denied): 2.43% conventional against 15.34% nationally, 5.61% FHA against 13.07%, 2.74% VA against 8.38%.
- Cost of a 30-year purchase loan (first lien, owner-occupied, one unit): conventional median rate 6.625%, $3,001 of discount points and $6,165 of total loan costs on 31,947 loans; FHA 6.375%, $2,897 and $12,015 on 17,770; VA 6.25%, $3,466 and $9,094 on 6,001. National medians: conventional 6.5%, $2,483 and $5,592; FHA 6.25%, $2,938 and $11,262; VA 6.125%, $2,743 and $6,585.
- Channel and second liens: 58,624 of its 59,915 first-lien purchase loans (97.8%) were submitted directly to Guild, against 76.1% nationally. It also made 8,539 second-lien loans for home purchase, equal to 12.0% of its purchase loans.
- Complaints, CFPB database (company name Guild Holdings Company): 61 for 2024, 100 for 2025 (73 about mortgages, 1.16 per 1,000 originated loans) and 221 for 2026 to November 7. In 2026 so far, 51 name struggling to pay and 57 trouble during the payment process, against 18 and 26 in all of 2025.
- Documents: Justice Department release of October 28, 2020 ($24.9 million, allegations over FHA loans, case 16-2909 in the Southern District of California); California consent order of June 1, 2018 ($7,500 penalty over per diem interest); class action 3:25-cv-01140 filed October 3, 2025, which names Guild among 26 lenders. A title search of the CFPB's enforcement actions list for Guild returned no results on November 16, 2026.
- Ownership: merger agreement of June 17, 2025, closed November 28, 2025 at $20.00 a share (about $1.244 billion in all); Form 15 filed December 8, 2025 with one holder of record. The last 10-Q (September 30, 2025) shows a $98.3 billion servicing portfolio of 387 thousand loans, about 420 branches and $33.3 million of net income for the quarter.
CSV · 266 rows
Guild Mortgage: 2025 HMDA record, 30-year purchase costs against peers, CFPB complaints, SEC filings on the Bayview sale and three court or enforcement documents
266 rows: the 123,834 HMDA records reconciled by action, purpose, loan type and age, purchase denial rates and cost medians against the national file and five large lenders, second liens, channel, CFPB complaint counts by year, issue and month, the merger filings and the 2018, 2020 and 2025 documents. One source per row.
Which Guild is it: the lender, the holding company and the 2025 sale
The lender you apply to is Guild Mortgage Company, LLC, a subsidiary of Guild Holdings Company, which was listed on the New York Stock Exchange as GHLD. Guild Holdings signed a merger agreement on June 17, 2025 with Gulf MSR HoldCo, LLC, a company owned by a fund managed by Bayview Asset Management. On November 28, 2025 the merger closed: each share was converted into the right to receive $20.00 in cash, the aggregate consideration was approximately $1.244 billion, and the company became a wholly owned subsidiary of Gulf MSR HoldCo. The NYSE listing ended that day. On December 8, 2025 Guild Holdings filed a Form 15 to end its duty to file reports, stating one holder of record.
That means a search for "Guild Holdings 10-Q" will not find a quarter ended September 30, 2026: the last quarterly report is the one for September 30, 2025, filed on November 6, 2025. The filings we read say nothing about changes to servicing, branches or the Guild name. They do say that the directors resigned and the board of the company changed at closing, that all officers of the holding company ceased to hold office, and that three senior executives, including the chief executive, chief financial officer and president of Guild Mortgage, continue to serve as executives of Guild Mortgage under employment agreements. Everything below that is about borrowers comes from HMDA and the CFPB, which report under Guild's name and not under Bayview's.
What Guild lends: purchase loans, mostly conventional and FHA
The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) requires lenders to report every application and every loan they buy. The CFPB and FFIEC published the 2025 data on March 31, 2026. Guild filed 123,834 records; 86,111 are loans it made.
| 2025 HMDA action | Records | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Loan originated | 86,111 | Closed loans, $26,867,785,000 |
| Approved, not accepted | 6,554 | Offer made, borrower did not take it |
| Denied | 4,586 | Application refused |
| Withdrawn by applicant | 22,782 | Borrower walked away before a decision |
| Closed incomplete | 523 | File never completed |
| Purchased loan | 2,110 | Bought from another lender; not Guild's origination |
| Preapproval requests (denied 61, approved not accepted 1,107) | 1,168 | Preapproval stage only |
| All records | 123,834 | Sum of the eight lines |
Originated loans by type and by purpose, 2025
| Loan type | Originated | Dollars | Share of its loans | Denial rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 56,705 | $17.27 billion | 65.9% | 4.2% |
| FHA | 20,919 | $6.42 billion | 24.3% | 6.6% |
| VA | 7,238 | $2.92 billion | 8.4% | 3.2% |
| USDA | 1,249 | $257.5 million | 1.5% | 5.1% |
| All | 86,111 | $26.87 billion | 100% | 4.7% |
Denial rate here is denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied (our arithmetic), for all loan purposes. By purpose, 70,983 of the 86,111 originations (82.4%) were home purchases, 6,973 were refinances, 7,904 were cash-out refinances, 243 had another purpose and 8 were home improvement loans, so Guild's book is the opposite of a refinance lender's. In the same file 8,539 of its purchase loans (12.0%) are second liens, written next to a first mortgage, and 2,594 of its cash-out loans (32.8%) are second liens too. The ranked pages cover how it sits against others: top mortgage lenders of 2025 by volume and denials and first-time buyer lenders and borrowers under 35.
Of its 86,111 loans, 32,819 (38.1%) went to applicants under 35. Its denial rate for applicants under 35 was 4.0% against 5.7% for those 35 and older (denied over originated plus denied, our arithmetic). Its largest states for first-lien purchase loans were Texas (5,226), Missouri (3,859), Washington (3,615), Oregon (3,016) and Georgia (2,918).
Denials on home-purchase loans
For loans bought with a first mortgage the comparison file is clean: every first-lien, closed-end, non-reverse home-purchase application that ended in an origination or a denial in 2025, nationwide. Guild had 59,915 originations and 2,175 denials in it.
| First-lien purchase, 2025 | Guild originated | Guild denied | Guild denial rate | National denial rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 34,510 | 860 | 2.43% | 15.34% |
| FHA | 18,121 | 1,077 | 5.61% | 13.07% |
| VA | 6,043 | 170 | 2.74% | 8.38% |
| USDA | 1,241 | 68 | 5.19% | 13.57% |
| All | 59,915 | 2,175 | 3.50% | 14.20% |
Denial rate in this table is denied divided by originated plus denied (our arithmetic), because the extract has no approved-not-accepted records. A low rate does not by itself mean easy approval: HMDA contains no credit score and no information on applicants who never applied, and a lender whose loan officers pre-screen borrowers before an application, as a direct-to-consumer lender with many branches can, records fewer denials. The first reason entered on its 860 conventional denials was debt-to-income ratio in 314 (36.5%), collateral in 228 and credit history in 49; on its 1,077 FHA denials it was debt-to-income ratio in 407 (37.8%), credit history in 238 and collateral in 135. Our reading is that those two codes cover most of its refusals, but HMDA does not say why a lender chose a code.
Rate, points and total loan costs on a 30-year purchase loan
Rates exist in HMDA only for loans that closed, so we compare like with like: first-lien, owner-occupied, one-unit home-purchase loans with a 360-month term. We read Guild's loans in the national file and compared them with the same filter applied to all other lenders and, separately, to five other large lenders.
| 30-year purchase loans, 2025 | Guild conventional | National conventional | Guild FHA | National FHA | Guild VA | National VA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Loans in the filter | 31,947 | 1,709,795 | 17,770 | 600,894 | 6,001 | 317,166 |
| Median note rate | 6.625% | 6.5% | 6.375% | 6.25% | 6.25% | 6.125% |
| Median discount points paid | $3,001 | $2,483 | $2,897 | $2,938 | $3,466 | $2,743 |
| Median total loan costs | $6,165 | $5,592 | $12,015 | $11,262 | $9,094 | $6,585 |
| Median loan amount | $335,000 | $345,000 | $295,000 | $305,000 | $355,000 | $355,000 |
Discount points are reported for only part of the loans: 19,388 of Guild's 31,947 conventional loans (60.7%) carry a numeric value, against 824,123 of 1,709,795 nationally (48.2%), so its median covers more loans that paid points (our arithmetic). Guild's medians sit slightly above the national ones on rate and total costs in every type, and the gap is widest on VA, where its median total loan costs are $2,509 higher. HMDA's total loan costs mix lender charges and third-party charges and rise with loan size, and Guild's median VA loan is the same size as the national one.
Against five other large lenders (same filter, 2025)
| Lender | Conventional rate / points / total costs | FHA rate / points / total costs | VA rate / points / total costs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guild Mortgage | 6.625% / $3,001 / $6,165 | 6.375% / $2,897 / $12,015 | 6.25% / $3,466 / $9,094 |
| United Wholesale Mortgage | 6.624% / $2,329 / $7,223 | 6.125% / $2,330 / $13,222 | 6.125% / $2,654 / $5,865 |
| Rocket Mortgage | 6.625% / $2,813 / $5,951 | 6.25% / $2,393 / $11,151 | 6.125% / $2,999 / $8,557 |
| CrossCountry Mortgage | 6.75% / $3,160 / $6,892 | 6.575% / $3,310 / $12,568 | 6.25% / $3,350 / $6,728 |
| Fairway Independent Mortgage | 6.75% / $2,429 / $5,887 | 6.5% / $2,461 / $11,152 | 6.25% / $2,815 / $6,583 |
| CMG Mortgage | 6.625% / $2,769 / $6,616 | 6.125% / $3,137 / $12,761 | 6.0% / $3,288 / $10,371 |
Guild is not an outlier on conventional or FHA among these: its FHA median total costs ($12,015) sit between Rocket's ($11,151) and CMG's ($12,761). On VA only CMG shows a higher median total cost ($10,371) than Guild's $9,094. Its denial rates on purchase loans are close to CrossCountry's and CMG's (2.08% and 2.66% on VA, 4.64% and 5.66% on FHA) and far below Rocket's (10.97% VA, 19.64% FHA). Builders' lending arms (DHI Mortgage, Lennar Mortgage) were left out because their rates reflect builder buydowns.
What the rate gaps cost (our arithmetic)
| Comparison, 30 years | Rate | Monthly principal and interest | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| $335,000 conventional at Guild's median | 6.625% | $2,145 | n/a |
| $335,000 at the national median | 6.5% | $2,117 | $28 a month, $9,941 over 30 years |
| $295,000 FHA at Guild's median | 6.375% | $1,840 | n/a |
| $295,000 at the national median | 6.25% | $1,816 | $24 a month, $8,658 over 30 years |
A median rate describes a book of loans, not a quote for you: borrower mix, the day a rate was locked and points paid all differ. Only a Loan Estimate for your own file is a price.
How the loans arrive: almost all direct
HMDA records whether an application was submitted directly to the lender. For Guild's first-lien purchase loans, 58,624 of 59,915 (97.8%) were direct and 1,291 (2.2%) came from elsewhere, such as brokers (our arithmetic). Nationally 2,421,654 of 3,181,822 purchase loans (76.1%) were direct, 647,034 were not and 113,134 carry an exempt or not-applicable code. For a buyer the practical meaning is that you are dealing with a Guild loan officer and branch, not with a broker who can shop several lenders. We compare broker and retail lenders in our page on brokers against lenders.
What 100 complaints in 2025 say
The CFPB publishes the complaints consumers submit about financial companies and lists them under the name Guild Holdings Company, the only name its company search offered for Guild. The CFPB sends each complaint to the company and does not verify what the consumer says, so a count shows how many people complained, not how many were right.
CFPB complaints, by year received
| Measure | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 to November 7 |
|---|---|---|---|
| All complaints | 61 | 100 | 221 |
| About mortgages | 46 | 73 | 166 |
| About credit reporting | 15 | 25 | 46 |
| Issue: trouble during payment process | 24 | 26 | 57 |
| Issue: struggling to pay mortgage | 9 | 18 | 51 |
| Issue: closing on a mortgage | 6 | 16 | 21 |
| Issue: applying for a mortgage or refinancing | 1 | 9 | 25 |
Issue counts cover every product in the database for Guild, not only mortgages. In 2025, 100 complaints against 86,111 originated loans is 1.16 per 1,000, and 73 mortgage complaints is 0.85 per 1,000 (our arithmetic); 25 about applying or closing is 0.29 per 1,000. Those are low next to the size of its servicing book, 387 thousand loans at September 30, 2025, which is where most complaints about payments come from. Of the 100 complaints for 2025 the company closed 97 with an explanation, 2 with non-monetary relief and 1 with monetary relief, and all 100 were answered in time. The 2026 count is the number to watch: 221 complaints in about ten months is 2.2 times the whole of 2025 (our arithmetic), with 29 or more in each of March and May and 25 or more in September and October, and 41 still in progress. The database does not say why. The sale to Bayview closed on November 28, 2025, but the complaints do not mention it in any field we can read, so we cannot say the two are linked.
Court and enforcement documents
| Date | Document | What it covers | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|
| June 1, 2018 | California Department of Business Oversight consent order (license 413-0016) | Examinations found borrowers overcharged per diem interest in 2015 and 2017; Guild agreed to stop the violations | $7,500 penalty |
| October 28, 2020 | Justice Department press release; United States ex rel. v. Guild Mortgage Company, Civ. A. No. 16-2909 (S.D. Cal.) | Allegations that it knowingly approved ineligible FHA loans that later defaulted, failed to keep required quality control and failed to self-report deficient loans | $24.9 million |
| October 3, 2025 | Mendez v. Optimal Blue, LLC, case 3:25-cv-01140 (M.D. Tenn.), class action complaint | Alleges that 26 lenders including Guild Mortgage Company, LLC shared pricing data through Optimal Blue's software; claims under the Sherman Act; the complaint says Guild priced 145,938 mortgages from 2019 to 2024 | Damages sought; no finding |
On the 2020 settlement the Justice Department's release says the agreement "resolves allegations" brought by a former employee under the False Claims Act, that the government intervened in part, and that the claims "are allegations only." The release lists Guild's headquarters in San Diego, California, "with branches across the United States." The 2018 order records that the Department first examined Guild between February 3, 2014 and July 1, 2015, closed that examination after Guild said it had set up monitoring, and found overcharges again in a 2018 examination; it carries a $7,500 penalty and no admission of a wider pattern. The 2025 class action is a complaint, not a ruling: we read the complaint of October 3, 2025 and not later orders, so we do not know whether the claims against Guild were dismissed, stayed or settled.
A title search of the CFPB's enforcement actions list for "guild" returned no results on November 16, 2026, while the same search for "freedom" returned Freedom Mortgage's actions. We did not read state regulators other than California, and NMLS Consumer Access, which lists licenses and state actions, returned an access error to our request, so we give no license count and do not score state licensing. The 10-Q for September 30, 2025 says Guild operates about 420 branches with licenses in 49 states and the District of Columbia.
What the last SEC filings say
Guild Holdings Company (CIK 1821160) is the only SEC registrant behind the lender, and its filings stop with the sale. Its last 10-Q, for the quarter ended September 30, 2025, reports a servicing portfolio of $98.3 billion of unpaid principal balance (387 thousand loans), net income of $33.3 million for the quarter, and a purchase share of 85.9% of originations. It describes one lawsuit, the class action of October 3, 2025, which it said it believed was without merit and intended to defend vigorously, and says other lawsuits in the ordinary course are not expected to have a material adverse effect. The Form 8-K of the closing records the $20.00 per share and the $1.244 billion paid, funded by equity from Bayview MSR Opportunity (U.S.) Master Fund, L.P. Because the company deregistered on December 8, 2025, anything that has changed since, in profit, servicing portfolio or legal reserves, is no longer in a public filing, and HMDA and the CFPB are the only public records.
What HMDA cannot tell you about Guild
- It has no credit score, so a lender with low denial rates may simply see stronger applicants or pre-screen before an application.
- Rates and costs describe loans that closed in 2025 at 2025 prices. A 2026 quote can differ, and Guild's ownership changed after the data year.
- Our purchase comparison covers 59,915 of its 70,983 purchase loans: the other 11,068 are second liens (8,539) or loans outside the filter we used (our arithmetic).
- Discount points are missing for roughly 40% of its loans, which are probably loans with no points, but HMDA does not say so.
- Complaints measure servicing as much as origination, and the CFPB does not verify them.
What a reader can do with this
- If you are buying with a conventional or FHA loan, ask Guild and two other lenders for a Loan Estimate on the same day and compare total loan costs and points line by line; the medians above show where each lender's typical loan sits, not what you will pay.
- If you plan a VA purchase, check the total loan costs line closely: Guild's VA median was the second highest of the six lenders in our peer table.
- If a down payment program or second lien is part of your plan, ask what the second loan costs and when it is repaid: 12.0% of Guild's purchase loans in 2025 had one.
- If your loan is serviced by Guild, keep dated copies of what you send and what is posted, and note that complaints about payment problems doubled in 2026.
- For lenders that rank above or below Guild by loan type, see our ranked pages linked above and our review of loanDepot, which has a 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026.
Frequently asked questions
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: FFIEC and CFPB HMDA data for 2025 (data browser aggregations for Guild Mortgage Company, LEI 549300AQ3T62GXDU7D76, and nationwide home-purchase and subordinate-lien files), the CFPB's release of March 31, 2026, the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database (queried November 16, 2026), a title search of the CFPB enforcement actions list (November 16, 2026), SEC filings of Guild Holdings Company (Form 8-K for the closing, Form 15 of December 8, 2025, Form 10-Q for September 30, 2025 and the information statement of September 22, 2025), the Justice Department release of October 28, 2020, the California consent order of June 1, 2018 and the class action complaint in case 3:25-cv-01140 (M.D. Tenn.).
Keep reading.
- 0120 min read
AmeriSave Mortgage Review: 24,298 Loans in 2025, 70.0% Denied in Federal Data, 120 CFPB Complaints
AmeriSave's 2025 federal loan data: 24,298 loans, 70.0% of decisions denied, mostly cash-out refinances; purchase costs, 120 CFPB complaints, orders
- 0222 min read
Carrington Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Denials, Costs, CFPB Record
Carrington Mortgage made 15,089 loans in 2025; 74% of denials were incomplete files. FHA costs, 700 CFPB complaints, a 2022 CFPB order and HUD audit.
- 0320 min read
New American Funding Review 2026: HMDA Denials and CFPB Data
New American Funding's 2025 federal loan data: 57,460 loans, FHA and VA rates against the national median, 128 CFPB mortgage complaints and its enforcement record.