New American Funding Review 2026: HMDA Denials and CFPB Data
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the new american funding numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick Answer
As of November 16, 2026: in the 2025 federal mortgage data (HMDA), New American Funding, which files under the name Broker Solutions, Inc., originated 57,460 conventional, FHA, VA and USDA loans for $16.53 billion and denied 18.32% of the applications it decided (our arithmetic). That blends two different businesses: on home-purchase loans it denied 5.13% of decided files against 14.20% for all lenders, while on cash-out refinances it denied 35.71% (all lenders 31.41%) and on loans for other purposes 53.89% (40.59%). For 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans its median note rate was 6.75% conventional, 6.625% FHA and 6.5% VA, against national medians of 6.5%, 6.25% and 6.125%. The CFPB database lists 128 mortgage complaints naming the company in 2025 (2.23 per 1,000 loans originated) and 149 from January 1 to November 15, 2026. We found no CFPB enforcement action. Dated settlements we did find: a $367,000 California penalty (July 2015) and a $702,000 payment to FHA in a False Claims Act settlement (February 2022), neither an admission of fault.
Key Takeaways
- Scale, HMDA 2025: Broker Solutions, Inc. (LEI 549300E2UX99HKDBR481, 140,816 records in the file) originated 34,151 conventional loans ($9.59 billion), 18,653 FHA loans ($5.19 billion), 4,328 VA loans ($1.68 billion) and 328 USDA loans, 57,460 in all. That ranks 21st of 2,046 lenders by originations of these four loan types (our arithmetic).
- Purchase is the business: 40,029 of the 57,460 originated loans (69.7%) were for buying a home. On first-lien purchase loans it denied 5.13% of decided applications against 14.20% for all lenders. On cash-out refinances it denied 35.71% against 31.41%, and on home-improvement loans 38.88% against 36.64% (our arithmetic).
- FHA is unusually large: 32.5% of its originations were FHA loans, against 13.3% for all lenders. Across all purposes its FHA denial rate was 26.70% against 22.67% nationally (our arithmetic).
- Rate and cost, 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans: median note rate 6.75% conventional, 6.625% FHA, 6.5% VA and 6.625% USDA, each above the all-lender median (6.5%, 6.25%, 6.125%, 6.25%). Median total loan costs were $6,320 conventional (all lenders $5,592), $11,997 FHA ($11,262) and $9,229 VA ($6,585). Borrower mix differs, so this is not a measure of savings.
- Channel: all 34,679 first-lien purchase loans it originated were reported as submitted directly to New American Funding, none through a broker or other third party. A reader comparing it with a broker is comparing a direct lender with a different door.
- Complaints: 128 about mortgages in 2025, of which 47 were trouble during the payment process, 32 applying for or refinancing a mortgage, 24 struggling to pay and 21 closing; 149 in 2026 through November 15. The company's response was Closed with explanation on all 128 of the 2025 mortgage complaints, and one was untimely.
- Record: no CFPB enforcement action under either name. HUD's notice lists a February 24, 2022 False Claims Act settlement with a $702,000 payment to FHA; California's 2015 settlement carried a $367,000 penalty over per diem interest charges; the company filed a vendor data-breach notice with California's Attorney General on July 11, 2025.
CSV · 160 rows
New American Funding (Broker Solutions, Inc.): HMDA 2025 originations and denials, purchase-loan rates and costs, CFPB complaints and the settlement and breach record
160 rows: counts, denial rates by loan type and purpose against all lenders, 30-year purchase medians for rate, points and total loan costs, first denial reasons, top states, CFPB complaint counts and issues for 2025 and 2026, the HUD and California settlements and two California breach notices. One source per row.
What this page counts, and what it leaves out
Reviews of New American Funding on Google are star averages and borrower stories. This page uses documents. The regulator's data on loans made in 2025 (the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act file, or HMDA) was released on March 31, 2026: the CFPB's announcement says the 2025 data “are now available on the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council’s (FFIEC) HMDA Platform for approximately 4,768 HMDA filers.” We read the file of one filer, LEI 549300E2UX99HKDBR481.
A naming point first, because it trips up searches. The HMDA file lists that LEI as Broker Solutions, Inc. The Global LEI Foundation record for the same LEI gives the legal name as New American Funding, LLC, and a 2015 California settlement describes “Broker Solutions, Inc. also doing business as New American Funding.” The CFPB complaint database lists the company under BROKER SOLUTIONS, INC.; a search for “New American Funding” in its company list returns nothing. Every figure below is for that one LEI. The company is privately held: an EDGAR company search for either name returns no filer, so there is no 10-K or 10-Q to read and no audited financial statement we can quote.
Three limits. HMDA has no credit score, so it cannot say whether this lender suits a particular borrower. It records the rate at origination, so a lower median rate can mean stronger borrowers or more points paid. And our denial rate (denied divided by originated plus denied) leaves out withdrawn applications and files closed as incomplete. Our page on Rocket Mortgage's 2025 HMDA record uses the same definitions for a larger lender.
What it originated in 2025, and how often it said no
HMDA lists 140,816 records for this LEI in 2025, including withdrawn and closed files and loan types we do not count here. The table counts the four loan types the regulator's aggregation publishes, across every loan purpose, occupancy and lien. The all-lender column uses the same four-type aggregation for the whole country.
Broker Solutions, Inc. (New American Funding): loans originated and denial rate by loan type, HMDA 2025, all purposes
| Loan type | Originated | Dollars originated | Denied | Denial rate | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 34,151 | $9.59 billion | 5,356 | 13.56% | 24.52% |
| FHA | 18,653 | $5.19 billion | 6,796 | 26.70% | 22.67% |
| VA | 4,328 | $1.68 billion | 700 | 13.92% | 17.00% |
| USDA | 328 | $0.06 billion | 33 | 9.14% | 13.35% |
| All four | 57,460 | $16.53 billion | 12,885 | 18.32% | not computed |
Against the national rates, it denied fewer conventional, VA and USDA applications and more FHA applications. The FHA gap is 4.03 percentage points (26.70% against 22.67%). FHA is also a large share of what it does: 32.5% of its originations (18,653 of 57,460) against 13.3% for all lenders, while VA is 7.5% against 8.2%. Our page on FHA lenders ranked by originations and denial rate shows the whole FHA market with the same measure.
Why the purpose matters more than the loan type
The loan-type table mixes buying and refinancing. Split by purpose, the picture changes.
Originated loans and denial rate by loan purpose, HMDA 2025 (all four loan types, any lien)
| Purpose | Originated | Denied | Denial rate | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Home purchase | 40,029 | 2,274 | 5.38% | 14.47% |
| Refinance | 4,416 | 1,181 | 21.10% | 21.65% |
| Cash-out refinance | 7,925 | 4,401 | 35.71% | 31.41% |
| Home improvement | 1,728 | 1,099 | 38.88% | 36.64% |
| Other purpose | 3,362 | 3,930 | 53.89% | 40.59% |
Home purchase is 69.7% of what it originated, and on purchase it denied about a third as often as the national average. The weight of its denials sits elsewhere: 4,401 cash-out refinance and 3,930 other-purpose denials outnumber its 2,274 purchase denials, on far fewer applications. A reader who is buying a house is looking at the first row of this table; a homeowner asking about cash-out is looking at a denial rate above the national one.
Purchase loans only: first lien, closed-end
For buyers, we narrowed to the loan-level file of first-lien, closed-end home-purchase applications that were originated or denied (reverse mortgages and business-purpose loans excluded). That file leaves out second-lien piggyback loans, which is why its counts are lower than the 40,029 above.
| Loan type | Originated | Denied | Denial rate | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 18,969 | 657 | 3.35% | 15.34% |
| FHA | 12,406 | 1,060 | 7.87% | 13.07% |
| VA | 2,980 | 127 | 4.09% | 8.38% |
| USDA | 324 | 30 | 8.47% | 13.57% |
| All four | 34,679 | 1,874 | 5.13% | 14.20% |
A purchase denial rate this low can reflect borrowers who were already pre-qualified or screening before an application is formally taken. HMDA cannot show screening that happens before a file exists, so we do not read the low number as a statement about who gets approved.
Why it denies, by its own first reason
HMDA lets a lender report up to four denial reasons. We use the first one, on purchase denials.
| First reason given | New American Funding | Share | All lenders | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credit history | 744 | 39.7% | 155,480 | 29.5% |
| Collateral (the property) | 336 | 17.9% | 51,681 | 9.8% |
| Other | 239 | 12.8% | 33,603 | 6.4% |
| Unverifiable information | 187 | 10.0% | 35,983 | 6.8% |
| Debt-to-income ratio | 167 | 8.9% | 176,386 | 33.5% |
| Insufficient cash | 109 | 5.8% | 22,601 | 4.3% |
| Credit application incomplete | 57 | 3.0% | 32,699 | 6.2% |
| Employment history | 35 | 1.9% | 10,076 | 1.9% |
Credit history leads its list, 39.7% of 1,874 purchase denials, and debt-to-income is first only 8.9% of the time, against 33.5% nationally (our arithmetic; the all-lender column also holds a small number of other codes, so its shares add to slightly under 100%). The reasons are what the lender chose to report and say nothing about individual applicants.
Rates, points and total loan costs on 30-year purchase loans
For owner-occupied, one-unit, 30-year purchase loans that closed, we took the median of each field. Points are reported on 61% to 68% of its loans by type (the rest are blank or not applicable), so that median is for loans that report points.
Median 30-year purchase loan, New American Funding against all lenders, HMDA 2025 (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records)
| Loan type | Loans in the median | Note rate | All lenders | Points paid | All lenders | Total loan costs | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 16,036 | 6.75% | 6.5% | $2,699 | $2,483 | $6,320 | $5,592 |
| FHA | 11,041 | 6.625% | 6.25% | $3,101 | $2,938 | $11,997 | $11,262 |
| VA | 2,918 | 6.5% | 6.125% | $3,257 | $2,743 | $9,229 | $6,585 |
| USDA | 324 | 6.625% | 6.25% | $1,699 | $1,585 | $7,111 | $6,549 |
Its medians are above the national ones on every line, and the gap in total loan costs on VA loans is $2,644. The median loan amount tells part of the story: $315,000 conventional against $345,000 nationally, $275,000 FHA against $305,000 and $345,000 VA against $355,000. The median borrower income on its purchase loans was $104,000 against $116,000 for all lenders. Higher points paid next to a higher rate, as on VA, means the points did not buy the rate down, so points do not explain the gap.
A worked example (our arithmetic). Take a $300,000 conventional purchase loan over 30 years. At this lender's 6.75% median the principal-and-interest payment is $1,945.79 a month; at the national 6.5% median it is $1,896.20. The $49.59 difference is $17,852 over 360 payments. On the FHA median loan amount of $275,000, 6.625% against 6.25% is $1,760.86 against $1,693.22, a $67.63 monthly gap and $24,348 over the full term. These are medians of different borrower pools, not quotes: your own rate depends on your credit, down payment, points and lock date.
Where its purchase loans are
Texas had 3,739 of its 34,679 originated first-lien purchase loans (10.8%), California 2,602 (7.5%), Georgia 2,513 (7.2%), Florida 2,472 (7.1%), Illinois 2,402 (6.9%), Missouri 1,643 (4.7%), Pennsylvania 1,426 (4.1%) and Minnesota 1,366 (3.9%). Borrowers under 35 were 39.0% of its purchase originations, against 37.9% for all lenders. Our page on first-time buyer lenders and borrowers under 35 ranks lenders on that measure, and the page on mortgage brokers against lenders compares the two doors in the data.
What the CFPB complaint database shows
We pulled the database on November 16, 2026 for the company name BROKER SOLUTIONS, INC. The complaints are unverified accounts by consumers; the Bureau does not check them.
CFPB complaints naming the company, product Mortgage, top issues
| Issue | 2025 | 2026 through Nov 15 |
|---|---|---|
| Trouble during payment process | 47 | 44 |
| Struggling to pay mortgage | 24 | 45 |
| Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage | 32 | 24 |
| Closing on a mortgage | 21 | 32 |
| All Mortgage complaints | 128 | 149 |
| All products, including credit reporting | 169 | 181 |
In 2025 the 128 mortgage complaints are 2.23 per 1,000 loans originated (128 divided by 57,460, our arithmetic); complaints can concern loans the company also services from earlier years, so the ratio is a rough scale and not a rate. In 2026 the mix has moved toward payment problems: struggling to pay and trouble during the payment process together are 89 of 149 (59.7%), against 71 of 128 (55.5%) in 2025. One 2025 mortgage complaint was untimely, and in 2026 two were untimely and one was closed with monetary relief. The database holds 785 mortgage complaints for the company across all years; the most recent received before our pull was dated November 5, 2026.
The enforcement, settlement and breach record
We searched the CFPB's enforcement actions page for “new american funding” and for “broker solutions”; both searches returned no actions. That is a search of one regulator's list, not a clean bill of health. The documents we did find:
Actions and notices found, with their documents
| Date | Source | What it says | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 21, 2015 | California Department of Business Oversight, file 413-1117 | Per diem interest charged beyond the one-day grace period; 678 overcharged loans in the company's self-audit of 2,632 | Settlement without admitting or denying the findings; $367,000 penalty, refunds with 10% interest, third-party audits |
| February 24, 2022 | HUD Mortgagee Review Board notice, 88 FR 17591 (March 23, 2023) | Settlement of a False Claims Act lawsuit brought by a relator, over alleged FHA underwriting violations | $702,000 paid to FHA; not an admission of liability or fault |
| July 11, 2025 | California Attorney General breach list | Notice filed by New American Funding, LLC after a notary vendor reported suspicious activity on June 6, 2025 | Notices sent to consumers; the vendor's services were terminated |
| February 27, 2026 | California Attorney General breach list | Listing for New American Funding, LLC with a breach date of January 28, 2026 | Attached sample notice is a Figure Lending letter; connection unclear |
The 2015 California agreement records that the Department's 2012 examination found per diem interest overcharges in 46% of the funded loan files it reviewed, that the Department's own check of 100 files found 56 more overcharged loans ($6,005.63 in all), and that the company “enters into this Settlement Agreement without admitting or denying any of the findings contained in the Administrative Action.” It is more than ten years old and about California loans from 2011 to 2013.
HUD's notice says the Board “voted to concur on a settlement of a False Claims Act lawsuit initiated by a relator against Broker Solutions, Inc. d/b/a New American Funding” with a payment of $702,000 to FHA, and that the settlement “did not constitute an admission of liability or fault.” The notice lists what the lawsuit alleged, including that the company improperly compensated employees performing underwriting activities on a commission basis and authorized certain managers or salespersons to override FHA and other government underwriting requirements. The alleged conduct was not found by a court. We did not find the underlying court complaint or a Justice Department release, so we describe only what HUD's notice says.
The July 2025 notice to California says: “On June 6, 2025, we learned about suspicious activity associated with information provided to one of our vendors” that provided notary services, and that “All services provided by MNZ were immediately terminated upon discovery of this incident.” We did not find a count of people affected in a primary document. The February 2026 listing carries only a breach date of January 28, 2026 and a sample letter from a different company, Figure Lending Corp, which says data was obtained “on January 28, 2026” through queries of its databases; we cannot say from these documents how that incident relates to this lender's borrowers.
We did not read NMLS Consumer Access (which lists state licenses and any regulatory actions a state has reported), other states' regulator orders, or court dockets for consumer lawsuits. If you are about to apply, those are the next places to check.
What HMDA cannot tell you about this lender
- Credit scores. HMDA does not carry one, so a denial rate cannot show whether it is stricter or only served a different mix.
- Closing costs you will pay. Total loan costs are reported only on loans that closed, and lender credits and points move them in opposite directions.
- Servicing. The 2025 file is about origination. The most common 2025 and 2026 complaints are about payments after closing, and HMDA is silent on who services the loan.
- Pre-application screening. A lender that sorts borrowers before taking an application will show a low denial rate; a lender that takes every application will not.
What a reader can do with this
- Get a second Loan Estimate for the same loan. Ask this lender and one other for the same loan amount, rate lock date and points. This lender's purchase medians sit above the national ones; your quote may not.
- If you are on FHA, compare total loan costs and points, not only the rate. FHA is a third of its business, and its median FHA purchase rate and costs sit above the national medians.
- If you plan a cash-out refinance, expect more scrutiny. Its cash-out denial rate of 35.71% is above the 31.41% national figure; a home-purchase borrower sees a very different picture.
- Ask who will service the loan. Most complaints are about payments after closing. Ask whether it keeps servicing and how a transfer works.
- Check NMLS Consumer Access and your state regulator. Those records were outside what we could read.
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources, read November 16, 2026: FFIEC HMDA 2025 data browser (aggregations for LEI 549300E2UX99HKDBR481 and nationwide; the nationwide first-lien home-purchase file of originated and denied applications, streamed, raw file not kept) and the CFPB's March 31, 2026 announcement of the 2025 data; FFIEC LAR data fields; CFPB Consumer Complaint Database API (company BROKER SOLUTIONS, INC.); CFPB enforcement actions search; HUD, Mortgagee Review Board: Administrative Actions, 88 FR 17591 (March 23, 2023); California Department of Business Oversight, settlement agreement, file 413-1117 (July 2015); California Attorney General data security breach list and sample notices (July 11, 2025 and February 27, 2026 filings); GLEIF record for LEI 549300E2UX99HKDBR481; SEC EDGAR company search.
Keep reading.
- 0120 min read
AmeriSave Mortgage Review: 24,298 Loans in 2025, 70.0% Denied in Federal Data, 120 CFPB Complaints
AmeriSave's 2025 federal loan data: 24,298 loans, 70.0% of decisions denied, mostly cash-out refinances; purchase costs, 120 CFPB complaints, orders
- 0222 min read
Carrington Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Denials, Costs, CFPB Record
Carrington Mortgage made 15,089 loans in 2025; 74% of denials were incomplete files. FHA costs, 700 CFPB complaints, a 2022 CFPB order and HUD audit.
- 0322 min read
Guild Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA, Complaints and Bayview Sale
Guild made 86,111 loans in 2025, 82.4% for purchases, and denied 3.5% of purchase decisions. HMDA costs, CFPB complaints, 2020 DOJ deal, Bayview sale.