CrowdfundedWealth
Articles · Research note

FHA vs Conventional Loans: What 2025 Home Buyers Really Paid

By Jorge··20 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Quick Answer

As of November 15, 2026, in the 2025 federal mortgage data (HMDA) for California and Georgia, FHA home-purchase loans had a lower median rate than conventional ones (6.125% against 6.5%) but higher median total loan costs ($14,766 against $7,507) and a higher denial rate (12.3% against 8.2%). The sample is owner-occupied, first-lien, 30-year, site-built one-unit purchases: 64,983 FHA and 197,397 conventional loans originated, and 9,104 and 17,554 applications denied. FHA borrowers had a median income of $115,000 against $178,000, and 37.4% of originated FHA loans had a debt-to-income ratio of 50% to 60%, against 1.0% of conventional loans. On a $350,000 house, 3.5% down with an FHA loan costs $2,245.63 a month in the first month with the annual premium, and the FHA mortgage insurance totals $42,553 over 30 years; 5% down conventional at a 6.625% rate costs $2,295.28 a month with PMI at an assumed 0.60% a year, and PMI that ends at month 137 totals $22,776 (our arithmetic). This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal, tax or lending advice.

Update alert · free

An email when the first-time home buyer numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Key Takeaways

  • In 2025 HMDA data for California and Georgia, FHA purchase loans had a median interest rate of 6.125% and conventional ones 6.5%; among loans at 95% loan-to-value or more the gap was wider, 6.125% against 6.625%, yet the median rate spread (APR minus the average prime offer rate) was 0.383 for FHA and 0.361 for conventional.
  • Median total loan costs were $14,766 for FHA and $7,507 for conventional. 99.6% of FHA loans in the sample reported total loan costs of at least 1.75% of the loan amount, against 42.6% of conventional loans, which is what the FHA upfront premium would produce (our inference).
  • FHA denial rate in the sample was 12.3% (13.7% in Georgia, 11.2% in California) against 8.2% for conventional; the debt-to-income ratio was the first listed reason in 44.0% of FHA denials and 38.9% of conventional ones, and collateral in 10.1% and 20.8%.
  • Of originated FHA loans, 37.4% had a debt-to-income ratio of 50% to 60%; of originated conventional loans, 1.0% did. Fannie Mae's maximum for DU casefiles is 50% (Selling Guide B3-6-02).
  • HUD's annual premium for a 30-year FHA loan with a base loan up to $726,200 and loan-to-value above 95% is 0.55% a year for the whole mortgage term, plus 1.75% upfront (Mortgagee Letter 2023-05); PMI must end automatically when the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original value (12 U.S.C. 4902(b)).
  • On a $350,000 house the FHA loan (3.5% down, $343,660 with the financed premium, 6.125%) pays $18,525 of mortgage insurance in 7 years and $42,553 in 30; the 5% down conventional loan (6.625%) pays $8,146 to $20,948 of PMI in 7 years and $13,286 to $34,164 in total at assumed PMI rates of 0.35% to 0.90% (our arithmetic).
  • At the rates we assumed, 7-year PMI equals FHA's insurance cost only at about 0.80% a year; lifetime PMI never reaches FHA's 30-year cost unless the rate is above about 1.12% (our arithmetic).

CSV · 210 rows

FHA vs conventional home-purchase loans in 2025 HMDA data for California and Georgia, 2026 rules and a $350,000 worked example

Row-level 2025 HMDA medians, shares and counts for FHA and conventional purchase loans in California and Georgia (rate, spread, total loan costs, points, debt-to-income, denial reasons), HUD, Fannie Mae, FHFA and Homeowners Protection Act rules, and the arithmetic behind a $350,000 example.

The sample: California and Georgia, one filter for both loan types

We pulled the row-level 2025 HMDA files from the CFPB's HMDA Data Browser (the Bureau announced the 2025 data on March 31, 2026), one state and one loan type at a time: California and Georgia, FHA (loan_type 2) and conventional (loan_type 1), originated and denied applications. We kept owner-occupied (principal residence), first-lien, 30-year (360-month), site-built, one-unit home purchases, and dropped reverse mortgages, open-end lines of credit and business-purpose loans. That left 64,983 FHA and 197,397 conventional originations and 9,104 and 17,554 denials. Our debt-to-income page uses Texas and Florida; these two states are different ones, and Georgia (median FHA loan $305,000) and California ($485,000) show how much the answer moves with house prices. The check we ran: the file row counts matched the Data Browser's own aggregation counts in each state before filtering.

Two details matter for reading everything below. First, we pulled only originated and denied applications, so the denial rate is denied divided by originated plus denied (our arithmetic); applications approved but not accepted by the borrower are not in it. Second, the conventional group is every conventional loan, jumbo included: 15.3% of California conventional loans in the sample were flagged nonconforming (above the conforming limit), 5.4% in Georgia.

FHA vs conventional, side by side

2025, California + GeorgiaFHAConventional
Loans originated64,983197,397
Applications denied9,10417,554
Denial rate (denied / originated + denied)12.3%8.2%
Median loan amount$405,000$535,000
Median property value$415,000$705,000
Median loan-to-value ratio96.5%80%
Share of loans at exactly 96.5%61.8%0.1%
Share of loans at 95% or more85.4%19.2%
Median gross income relied on$115,000$178,000
Median interest rate6.125%6.5%
Median rate spread (APR minus APOR)0.3490.099
Median total loan costs$14,766$7,507
Median discount points (loans reporting)$3,424 (58.6% report)$3,317 (47.1% report)
Median lender credits (loans reporting)$777$1,000
Share submitted through third parties38.5%35.9%

The two groups are not the same borrowers buying the same houses: the median conventional loan is $130,000 larger, the median property $290,000 more expensive and the median income $63,000 higher. That is why the like-for-like table below matters. Discount points are reported in dollars and only some loans report a figure (we do not read a blank as zero), so the medians describe loans that paid points.

By state, 2025FHA GeorgiaConventional GeorgiaFHA CaliforniaConventional California
Loans originated27,52652,59237,457144,805
Denial rate13.7%8.1%11.2%8.2%
Median loan amount$305,000$355,000$485,000$615,000
Median loan-to-value96.5%80%96.5%80%
Median income$93,000$129,000$133,000$198,000
Median interest rate6.125%6.5%6.125%6.5%
Median total loan costs$11,942$6,363$17,191$7,928
Share through third parties23.2%27.2%49.7%39.1%

Like-for-like: loans with a 95% or higher loan-to-value ratio

A conventional loan at 80% loan-to-value is not what an FHA borrower with 3.5% down gets. The nearest comparison is the 37,431 conventional loans and the 55,289 FHA loans in the sample with a loan-to-value ratio of 95% or more.

Loans at 95% LTV or more, 2025FHAConventional
Loans originated55,28937,431
Median loan amount$395,000$435,000
Median income$115,000$135,000
Median interest rate6.125%6.625%
Median rate spread0.3830.361
Median total loan costs$14,676$7,085
Median discount points (loans reporting)$3,329$3,026

Among these high-loan-to-value loans the FHA median rate was half a point lower, but the median total loan costs were $7,591 higher, and the rate spread, which compares the APR with the average prime offer rate, was about the same (0.383 against 0.361). The APR includes mortgage insurance, so the nearly equal spread says that in this sample the cheaper FHA rate was paid for by insurance. The conventional loans at 95% or more were larger ($435,000 against $395,000) and their borrowers had $20,000 more median income, a reminder that these are not matched pairs.

What “total loan costs” contains. Regulation C requires the lender to report the “total loan costs” shown on the Closing Disclosure (12 CFR 1003.4(a)(17)(i), pointing to 12 CFR 1026.38(f)(4)), which is the sum of the amounts disclosed as borrower-paid in the loan-cost sections of that form. None of the documents we saved says in plain words whether the FHA upfront premium is inside that figure. The data say it is: 99.6% of the FHA loans in the sample reported total loan costs of at least 1.75% of the loan amount, and half of them 3.7% or more; for conventional loans the median was 1.5% and 42.6% were at or above 1.75% (our arithmetic). A 1.75% premium on the $405,000 median FHA loan is $7,088, close to the $7,259 gap between the two medians of $14,766 and $7,507 (our arithmetic). Treat that as an inference from the data, not a statement of the rule.

Who gets approved: debt-to-income and denial reasons

HMDA reports the debt-to-income ratio the lender relied on in bands (under 20%, 20% to under 30%, 30% to under 36%, then each whole percent from 36% to 49%, 50% to 60%, over 60%). We grouped them.

Debt-to-income band, 2025FHA originatedConventional originatedFHA deniedConventional denied
36% or lower12.5%34.4%8.9%21.3%
37% to 43%20.1%29.5%11.5%15.7%
44% to 49%28.4%33.2%16.8%21.4%
50% to 60%37.4%1.0%31.4%16.9%
Over 60%0.0%0.2%29.1%21.6%
Not available1.5%1.9%2.3%3.1%

Shares are of 64,983 FHA and 197,397 conventional originations and of 9,104 and 17,554 denials. More than a third of the FHA loans that closed had a ratio of 50% to 60%; the conventional loans that closed almost all sat at 49% or below, in line with the 50% ceiling Fannie Mae applies to DU casefiles. Among denials the ratio was often above 50% in both groups, but 60.5% of denied FHA applications were above 50%, against 38.6% of conventional ones.

First denial reason listed, 2025FHA denialsConventional denials
Debt-to-income ratio44.0%38.9%
Credit history13.5%6.3%
Collateral10.1%20.8%
Unverifiable information8.1%7.7%
Insufficient cash (down payment, closing costs)7.8%7.2%
Other7.8%7.8%
Credit application incomplete5.6%9.5%
Employment history3.1%1.7%
Any of the four reasons is debt-to-income48.8%42.3%

Debt-to-income is the most common first reason for both, and credit history appears twice as often among FHA denials. Collateral is twice as common as a first reason among conventional denials. Our debt-to-income calculator page shows how each program counts the ratio.

The rules, side by side

Rule (2026)FHAConventional (Fannie Mae)
Smallest down payment3.5% of adjusted value, credit score 580 or above; maximum loan-to-value 96.5% on a purchase (HUD Handbook 4000.1)3% down: 97% loan-to-value on a one-unit principal residence, fixed rate, DU (Eligibility Matrix, August 5, 2026); for non-HomeReady purchases at least one borrower must be a first-time home buyer
Credit score 500 to 579Maximum loan-to-value 90% (HUD Handbook 4000.1)Credit score minimums for manually underwritten loans are in the Eligibility Matrix
Mortgage insurance, upfront1.75% of the base loan amount, may be financed (Mortgagee Letter 2023-05; Handbook 4000.1)No government premium; any private insurance is priced by the insurer
Mortgage insurance, ongoing0.55% a year for the mortgage term at over 95% loan-to-value; 0.50% a year for the term at over 90% up to 95%; 0.50% a year for 11 years at 90% or less (30-year loan, base loan up to $726,200)Private mortgage insurance priced by the insurer; borrower may ask to cancel at 80% of original value and it ends automatically at 78% (12 U.S.C. 4902)
Loan limit, one unit, 2026$541,287 in low-cost areas; $1,249,125 in high-cost areas (Mortgagee Letter 2025-23)$832,750 baseline conforming limit (FHFA, November 25, 2025); higher in high-cost counties
Debt-to-incomeManual underwriting, credit score 580 or above: 31/43, up to 40/50 with compensating factors (Handbook 4000.1)DU casefiles 50%; manual 36%, up to 45% with credit score and reserves (Selling Guide B3-6-02)

FHA's 96.5% limit is a 3.5% down payment and the 3.5% is of the “Adjusted Value”; Handbook 4000.1 describes it as the borrower's Minimum Required Investment. For the two-to-four-unit and investor versions of both loans see our pages on an FHA loan for an investment property and the conforming loan limits by county. For the lender ranking behind the FHA numbers, see FHA lenders ranked with HMDA 2025.

Worked example: a $350,000 house (our arithmetic)

Assumptions, all ours: a $350,000 price; a 30-year fixed loan; the FHA loan at 3.5% down ($12,250), base loan $337,750 plus the financed 1.75% premium ($5,910.63), rounded down to $343,660 as the Handbook requires, at 6.125% (the FHA median at 95% loan-to-value or more); annual premium 0.55%, charged each month as one twelfth of 0.55% of that month's starting balance. The conventional loan at 5% down ($17,500), loan $332,500, at 6.625% (the conventional median at 95% or more). PMI at an annual rate of 0.35%, 0.60% or 0.90% of the original loan, paid monthly, ending at the month the balance is first scheduled to reach 78% of the $350,000 original value. We do not have a source for PMI rates: they depend on credit score, loan-to-value and the insurer, so read the three columns as a range, not a quote. Taxes, insurance, HOA and closing costs are left out.

$350,000 house, 30-year loanFHA, 3.5% downConventional, PMI 0.35%Conventional, PMI 0.60%Conventional, PMI 0.90%
Down payment$12,250$17,500$17,500$17,500
Loan amount$343,660 (with $5,911 premium)$332,500$332,500$332,500
Rate6.125%6.625%6.625%6.625%
Principal and interest$2,088.11$2,129.03$2,129.03$2,129.03
Mortgage insurance, month 1$157.51$96.98$166.25$249.38
Payment in month 1$2,245.63$2,226.01$2,295.28$2,378.41
Insurance paid in 7 years$18,525 (with upfront)$8,146$13,965$20,948
Insurance paid in total$42,553 (with upfront)$13,286$22,776$34,164
Month the insurance endsNever (mortgage term)137137137
Balance after 7 years$308,737$301,256$301,256$301,256

Three things follow. First, in the first month the FHA loan is cheaper than conventional at 0.60% or 0.90% PMI and about $20 dearer at 0.35%, because FHA's rate in this sample is half a point lower. Second, the FHA cost is front-loaded and permanent: $5,911 financed at closing, then a premium that falls only as the balance falls and runs the full 30 years ($36,642 of annual premium over the term), while PMI stops at month 137, about 11.4 years in. Third, whether FHA insurance is the more expensive depends on the PMI rate the conventional borrower is actually quoted: 7-year PMI equals FHA's $18,525 at about 0.80% a year ($18,525 divided by $332,500 for seven years), and lifetime PMI would equal FHA's $42,553 only at about 1.12% a year.

If both loans carried the same 6.125% rate, the conventional payment at 0.60% PMI would be $2,186.56 in month 1, $59.07 below the FHA loan's $2,245.63, and PMI would total $21,779; the FHA advantage in the example comes entirely from the lower assumed rate. The FHA borrower also needed $5,250 less cash for the down payment. Putting 10% down on an FHA loan would shorten the premium to 11 years under the schedule in Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 (0.50% a year at 90% loan-to-value or less); we did not run that case.

What HMDA cannot tell you about this comparison

  • No credit score, no first-time-buyer flag. The two groups differ in credit, in down payment and in house price. A lower or higher median reflects who borrowed, not what a lender would quote you. The conventional group is mostly 80% loan-to-value borrowers with no mortgage insurance at all.
  • Rates are at origination, for 2025. A median of 6.125% describes loans closed in 2025, not this week's quotes. Rate-lock timing, points and lender credits are all in or around the number; only about half of loans report a points figure.
  • Total loan costs are a closing-date total, not a monthly cost. They include the financed FHA upfront premium (by our inference above) but not the annual premium or PMI, so they understate what mortgage insurance costs over time.
  • Two states, not the nation. California's FHA and conventional medians sit far above Georgia's. The pooled numbers are pulled toward California because it has more loans; each state is shown separately above.
  • Denials are not verdicts. Denial rates differ because applicants, properties and lender channels differ. HMDA shows the reasons lenders listed, not whether a different lender would have approved the same file.
  • What the filter leaves out. Manufactured homes, two-to-four-unit buildings, refinances, second homes and investor loans are not in the sample.

What a reader can do with this

  1. Run your own break-even. Ask for a quote for each program from the same lender, with the mortgage insurance line in dollars on the Loan Estimate. Compare the total insurance over the 7 years you expect to hold the loan, not just the monthly figure; the example above shows both views can disagree.
  2. Check your ratio against the bands. If your debt-to-income ratio is above 50%, 37.4% of the originated FHA loans in this sample were in that range and almost no conventional ones were; if it is under 36%, a third of conventional loans were.
  3. Ask when the insurance ends. For FHA at over 90% loan-to-value the answer under Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 is the end of the mortgage term; for PMI the answer is a date on the schedule, and the law lets you ask earlier at 80%.
  4. Check the limit for your county before you shop: the 2026 FHA one-unit range is $541,287 to $1,249,125 and the baseline conforming limit is $832,750. The 2026 limits were announced on November 25, 2025 (FHFA) and December 11, 2025 (HUD), so the 2027 ones should arrive around the same time (our expectation).
  5. Use the lender data as a yardstick. A conventional loan quoted above the sample's 6.625% for 95% loan-to-value, or an FHA one above 6.125%, is above the 2025 median for that group; that tells you where you stand, not that the lender is wrong.

FAQ

Sources, read November 15, 2026: CFPB and FFIEC, 2025 HMDA data (Modified Loan Application Register announced March 31, 2026): CFPB HMDA Data Browser CSV files for California and Georgia, FHA and conventional loans, originated and denied applications, filtered and summarized by our script (reduced rows and summary saved), and Data Browser aggregation counts used to check the files; FFIEC LAR data fields documentation; 12 CFR 1003.4 and 12 CFR 1026.37 and 1026.38 (eCFR, November 10, 2026); HUD Mortgagee Letter 2023-05 (February 22, 2023) and Mortgagee Letter 2025-23 (December 11, 2025); HUD Handbook 4000.1; Fannie Mae Eligibility Matrix (August 5, 2026) and Selling Guide B3-6-02; FHFA, conforming loan limits for 2026 (November 25, 2025); 12 U.S.C. 4901 and 4902. Shares, medians of derived ratios, denial rates and every worked-example figure are our arithmetic, and the PMI rates are our assumption. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal, tax or lending advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.