AmeriSave Mortgage Review: 24,298 Loans in 2025, 70.0% Denied in Federal Data, 120 CFPB Complaints
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the amerisave numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick Answer
As of November 16, 2026: in the 2025 federal mortgage data (HMDA), AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation originated 24,298 loans for $3.53 billion and denied 58,518 applications, 70.0% of the applications it decided, against 30.1% for cash-out refinances and 13.9% for purchases across all lenders (our arithmetic). Nearly all of its loans (23,252, 95.7%) were cash-out refinances, and 11,923 (49.1%) were second-lien loans; only 736 (3.0%) were for buying a home. In 53.3% of its denials the first reason it gave was an incomplete application. On the 326 conventional and 244 FHA home-purchase loans in our 30-year, owner-occupied, one-unit filter, the median rate was 6.625% and 6.75% against 6.5% and 6.25% for all lenders, with median points of $4,063 and $4,211 against $2,483 and $2,938. The CFPB database lists 120 mortgage complaints naming AmeriSave in 2025 (4.94 per 1,000 loans) and 119 from January 1 to November 15, 2026. AmeriSave signed a CFPB consent order in August 2014 (the Bureau's matter is closed) and a New York consent order with a $56,000 penalty in April 2026. We found no SEC registrant under its name.
Key Takeaways
- Scale, HMDA 2025: AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation (LEI 549300YIQ7S7Z8PIHE53) has 107,056 records in the file. Of those, 24,298 were originated loans ($3.53 billion), 781 approved but not accepted, 58,518 denied, 7,807 withdrawn, 2,986 closed as incomplete, and 12,648 purchase pre-approval requests were decided (7,795 denied).
- What it lends for: 23,252 originated loans (95.7%) are cash-out refinances, 310 refinances and 736 (3.0%) purchases. 12,375 are first-lien and 11,923 (49.1%) second-lien loans. By type, 18,494 are conventional, 4,774 FHA and 1,030 VA.
- Denial rate (denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied, our arithmetic): 70.0% overall; 67.1% on purchase against 13.9% for all lenders, 85.0% on refinance against 20.4% and 69.7% on cash-out refinance against 30.1%. By loan type: conventional 65.4% against 23.4%, FHA 78.7% against 21.8%, VA 80.1% against 16.2%.
- Why denied: the first reason is an incomplete application in 31,200 of 58,518 denials (53.3%), then debt-to-income ratio in 8,363 (14.3%), collateral in 6,107 and credit history in 5,950. HMDA does not say whether an incomplete-application denial means a borrower who stopped sending documents; we do not know.
- Home-purchase loans, 30-year, owner-occupied, one unit, 2025: conventional median rate 6.625% on 326 loans (all lenders 6.5%), points $4,063 ($2,483) and total loan costs $7,249 ($5,592); FHA 6.75% on 244 loans (6.25%), points $4,211 ($2,938), costs $11,592 ($11,262); VA 6.375% on 39 loans (6.125%). All 701 purchase loans in our extract were applied for directly with AmeriSave.
- Second-lien closed-end loans (home equity loans, 11,708 refinance-purpose loans): median rate 9.125% against 8.75% for all lenders, median points $1,787 against $713, total costs $3,440 against $1,841, median term 360 months against 240, and a denial rate of 57.1% against 27.1% (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records).
- CFPB complaints, product Mortgage: 120 in 2025 (4.94 per 1,000 originated loans), of which 59 (49.2%) were about applying for a mortgage or refinancing and 28 about trouble during the payment process; 119 from January 1 to November 15, 2026, 60 of them about applying. 15 of the 2025 complaints were closed with monetary relief.
- Documents: a CFPB consent order filed August 12, 2014 ($14,892,234 in relief and a $4.5 million penalty on AmeriSave and its appraisal affiliate, without admitting or denying the findings; status Expired/Terminated/Dismissed); a July 31, 2013 settlement with state mortgage regulators ($2,250,000, AmeriSave admits no wrongdoing); a New York Department of State Do Not Call consent order of April 2026 ($56,000). EDGAR has no registrant named AmeriSave.
CSV · 159 rows
AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation: HMDA 2025 record by type, purpose and lien, denial reasons, purchase-loan costs, CFPB complaints and regulator orders
159 rows: loan counts, denial rates against the national rate, first denial reasons, rate, points and cost medians against all lenders, CFPB complaint counts and issues for 2025 and 2026, and the amounts in three regulator orders. One source per row.
What this page counts, and what it leaves out
Reviews of AmeriSave online lean on star averages and on the lender's own advertising. This page uses documents. The regulator's data for loans made in 2025 (the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act file, or HMDA) was released on March 31, 2026: the CFPB's announcement says the data for 2025 “are now available on the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council’s (FFIEC) HMDA Platform for approximately 4,768 HMDA filers.” We read AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation's file directly (one filer, one legal entity identifier), compared its counts with the national counts for the same year, and added the CFPB's complaint database, the orders of three regulators and AmeriSave's own state licensing page.
Three limits first. HMDA has no credit score, no first-time-buyer flag and no down payment, so it cannot say whether AmeriSave is the right lender for you. It records the rate at origination, so a higher median rate can mean weaker borrowers, a different loan size or more points paid, not a more expensive lender. And a denial in HMDA is the lender's coding of an application it decided: it is not a count of borrowers turned away for credit. For a reader who found AmeriSave through an online quote, one fact shapes everything below: in this data AmeriSave is mostly a cash-out refinance and home equity lender, not a home-purchase lender. Our ranked mortgage lenders page lists AmeriSave 39th of the large lenders with the same 24,298 loans.
What AmeriSave originated in 2025, and how often it said no
HMDA lists AmeriSave with 107,056 records in 2025. The counts below come straight from the data browser's aggregation for its legal entity identifier. We define the denial rate as loans denied divided by the sum of loans originated, approved but not accepted by the borrower, and denied; withdrawn applications and files closed as incomplete are not in the denominator. The last column is the same calculation for all lenders nationwide.
AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation: loans originated and denial rate by loan type, HMDA 2025
| Loan type | Originated | Denied | AmeriSave denial rate | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 18,494 | 36,109 | 65.37% | 23.40% |
| FHA | 4,774 | 18,056 | 78.70% | 21.84% |
| VA | 1,030 | 4,271 | 80.13% | 16.16% |
| USDA | 0 | 82 | 100.00% | 12.87% |
| All types | 24,298 | 58,518 | 70.00% | n/a |
The same file by what the loan is for tells more than the loan type does.
By loan purpose, HMDA 2025
| Purpose | Originated | Denied | AmeriSave denial rate | All lenders |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Home purchase | 736 | 1,530 | 67.13% | 13.94% |
| Refinance | 310 | 1,858 | 85.03% | 20.43% |
| Cash-out refinance | 23,252 | 55,130 | 69.67% | 30.12% |
Cash-out refinances are 95.7% of the loans AmeriSave originated (23,252 of 24,298) and purchases are 3.0% (our arithmetic). The lien position adds a second split: 12,375 originated loans were first-lien and 11,923 were second-lien loans, a home equity loan or line behind an existing mortgage. Of the second-lien loans, 11,708 were closed-end loans made for a refinance purpose and 212 were lines of credit and 3 were other closed-end loans (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records). Our pages on HELOC lenders ranked with HMDA 2025 and home equity loan lenders ranked with HMDA 2025 rank the whole market for those products.
Second-lien closed-end loans made for a refinance purpose: AmeriSave against all lenders, 2025
| Measure | AmeriSave | All lenders |
|---|---|---|
| Loans originated | 11,708 | 230,506 |
| Denial rate (denied divided by originated plus denied) | 57.09% | 27.09% |
| Median interest rate | 9.125% | 8.75% |
| Median loan amount | $65,000 | $75,000 |
| Median points paid (loans that report points) | $1,787 | $713 |
| Median total loan costs | $3,440 | $1,841 |
| Median loan term | 360 months | 240 months |
AmeriSave's median second-lien loan has a 30-year term where the national median is 20 years. A longer term lowers the monthly payment and raises total interest. A worked example (our arithmetic): $65,000 at 9.125% over 360 months costs $528.86 a month and $125,390 of interest over the term; at 8.75% over 240 months it costs $574.41 a month and $72,859 of interest. Points and costs also differ, and the data do not show your credit score or loan-to-value ratio, so these medians are a description of the market, not a quote.
Why its file says denied: a look at the reasons
HMDA lets a lender report up to four reasons for each denial. We counted the first one.
| First reason given | Purchase denials (1,530) | Cash-out refinance denials (55,130) | Refinance denials (1,858) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit application incomplete | 671 (43.9%) | 29,248 (53.1%) | 1,281 (68.9%) |
| Debt-to-income ratio | 158 (10.3%) | 8,053 (14.6%) | 152 (8.2%) |
| Collateral | 143 (9.3%) | 5,863 (10.6%) | 101 (5.4%) |
| Credit history | 104 (6.8%) | 5,736 (10.4%) | 110 (5.9%) |
| Unverifiable information | 299 (19.5%) | 3,939 (7.1%) | 82 (4.4%) |
| Insufficient cash | 79 (5.2%) | 1,118 (2.0%) | 91 (4.9%) |
| Other | 75 (4.9%) | 1,121 (2.0%) | 41 (2.2%) |
| Employment history | 1 (0.1%) | 52 (0.1%) | 0 |
An incomplete application is the first reason in 31,200 of the 58,518 denials (53.3%, our arithmetic). That is unusual enough to say plainly what we do and do not know. AmeriSave coded a further 2,986 applications as closed because they were incomplete and 7,807 as withdrawn, so the 31,200 are files it chose to mark as denied. The pattern fits a funnel that starts many more applications than it finishes: 107,056 records produced 24,298 loans. It also fits the “prescreened” offer notice on AmeriSave's licensing page. But the file does not say how the applications started, and we are not claiming that one lender's denial is another lender's non-start. The practical point for a reader is that a 70.0% denial rate does not mean seven in ten people who finished an application were turned down for their credit: more than half of the denials carry an incomplete-application code.
Pre-approval is the same story for buyers. Lenders that run a pre-approval program must report those requests too: AmeriSave decided 12,648, approving 4,853 that the borrower did not take up and denying 7,795 (61.6%, our arithmetic), against 736 purchase loans originated. These requests are not in the 58,518 above.
Home-purchase loans: rate, points and costs
For the cost comparison we used loans that look alike: originated in 2025 for a home purchase, first lien, closed-end, owner-occupied, one unit, 360-month term, not made for a business purpose, with a numeric rate. We took the median of all lenders in the same filter from the 2025 national home-purchase file. AmeriSave's samples are small (326, 244 and 39 loans), because purchases are 3.0% of its business, so read these as a description.
Median rate, points and total loan costs on 30-year purchase loans, AmeriSave against all lenders, 2025
| Loan type | AmeriSave loans in filter | AmeriSave median rate | All lenders median rate | AmeriSave median points paid | All lenders, points | AmeriSave median total loan costs | All lenders, total costs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 326 | 6.625% | 6.5% | $4,063 | $2,483 | $7,249 | $5,592 |
| FHA | 244 | 6.75% | 6.25% | $4,211 | $2,938 | $11,592 | $11,262 |
| VA | 39 | 6.375% | 6.125% | $4,235 | $2,743 | $8,922 | $6,585 |
Points are medians of the loans that report them (241 conventional, 225 FHA and 24 VA AmeriSave loans); 85, 19 and 15 loans in each group reported none. Median loan size also differs: $295,000 against $345,000 for conventional and $215,000 against $305,000 for FHA, so AmeriSave's purchase borrowers are not the national mix. Purchase denial rates in the same extract (denied divided by originated plus denied, no approved-not-accepted class in that file) are 66.4% for conventional (all lenders 15.3%), 63.0% for FHA (13.1%), 75.9% for VA (8.4%).
A worked example (our arithmetic). On a $300,000 30-year FHA loan, the monthly principal and interest is $1,945.79 at 6.75% and $1,847.15 at 6.25%: $98.64 a month, $35,511 over 360 payments, before the $1,273 difference in median points. On a conventional loan at 6.625% against 6.5% the gap is $24.73 a month, $8,902 over 360 payments. The rate that applies to you depends on your credit score, down payment, lock date and points, none of which HMDA shows. For comparison, our page on Better Mortgage and our Rocket Mortgage review use the same measures for two other online lenders.
What the CFPB complaint database shows
The CFPB's database is public and the Bureau does not verify the facts in a complaint. The company string is “AMERISAVE MORTGAGE CORPORATION”.
2025: 120 complaints, product Mortgage
| Issue (product Mortgage) | Complaints 2025 | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage | 59 | 49.2% |
| Trouble during payment process | 28 | 23.3% |
| Struggling to pay mortgage | 17 | 14.2% |
| Closing on a mortgage | 12 | 10.0% |
| Problem with a company's investigation into an existing problem | 2 | 1.7% |
| Improper use of your report | 1 | 0.8% |
| Incorrect information on your report | 1 | 0.8% |
The 120 complaints are 4.94 per 1,000 of the 24,298 loans AmeriSave originated in 2025 (our arithmetic). That ratio puts new loans in the denominator and counts complaints from borrowers whose application did not close, so it is a scale marker, not a failure rate. Complaints about applying or closing (59 and 12) are 2.92 per 1,000 originations. Of the 120, 105 were closed with an explanation and 15 with monetary relief; 9 company responses were not timely. Counting every product, the database lists 150 complaints for AmeriSave in 2025 and 95 in 2024 (76 of them about mortgages).
2026, January 1 to November 15: 119 complaints, product Mortgage
| Issue (product Mortgage) | Complaints Jan 1 to Nov 15, 2026 | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage | 60 | 50.4% |
| Trouble during payment process | 22 | 18.5% |
| Closing on a mortgage | 18 | 15.1% |
| Struggling to pay mortgage | 9 | 7.6% |
| Incorrect information on your report | 6 | 5.0% |
| Improper use of your report | 4 | 3.4% |
The 2026 count to mid-November is already almost the 2025 count (119 against 120), with half about applying for a loan again. 19 of the 2026 complaints were closed with monetary relief and one was still in progress when we pulled the data. HMDA for 2026 does not exist yet, so we cannot give a 2026 per-loan figure.
Enforcement and regulatory record
CFPB, August 12, 2014. The Bureau's docket lists a stipulation and consent order, File No. 2014-CFPB-0010, filed August 12, 2014 against AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation, its appraisal affiliate and the owner of both companies; its status is Expired/Terminated/Dismissed. The respondents consented “without admitting or denying any of the findings of fact or conclusions of law.” The findings say that “From mid-2011 until May 2013, a systemic problem caused Amerisave to list lower mortgage rates than it was willing to honor on the Rate Publisher's rate tables for ‘jumbo conforming’ loans,” and that “Since January 2011, Amerisave has generally required its customers to use Novo for their home appraisal services, referring more than 99% of its appraisal business to Novo.” The order entered a judgment of $14,892,234 for consumer redress against AmeriSave and a civil money penalty of $4.5 million on AmeriSave and its affiliate combined (plus $1.5 million on the owner), and says “This Consent Order shall terminate 5 years from the Effective Date.” The CFPB's enforcement search for “amerisave” returns this one action.
State mortgage regulators, July 31, 2013. AmeriSave signed a settlement agreement and order with state regulators from 35 states and the District of Columbia (our count of the states named). The regulators contend that certain unlicensed AmeriSave employees did mortgage loan origination work that required a license; AmeriSave contends that it intended to comply at all times and “admit no wrongdoing.” It agreed to a $2,250,000 payment to the participating states and to reimburse Pennsylvania $50,000 for investigative costs.
New York Department of State, April 2026. AmeriSave signed a consent order with the New York Department of State to settle alleged violations of the state's Do Not Call law, namely “having made or caused to be made unsolicited telemarketing sales calls to consumers who registered telephone” numbers on the national do-not-call registry. The parties “agree to a civil penalty of fifty-six thousand dollars ($56,000.00),” due by May 10, 2026; the order is a settlement of a disputed matter and no court found a violation. We did not see a record of payment. AmeriSave's own licensing page says it is “Not licensed to originate in NY.”
We did not read other state regulator orders (the Massachusetts and Pennsylvania regulators' sites list older ones) or private lawsuits, and NMLS Consumer Access, the official licence database, was blocked when we tried it. AmeriSave's licensing page, effective September 30, 2025, gives its NMLS ID as 1168 and lists state licences and a set of states where it “conducts business”.
AmeriSave's “Meet or Beat” offer. The same page says “AmeriSave will beat any competitor’s mortgage loan offer, and if it can’t it will pay you $1000,” with conditions: the comparison is by annual percentage rate on Loan Estimates dated the same day, your loan must close with the other lender within the terms, you must give notice with proof within 30 days, the maximum is $1000 per closed loan, and the offer “is not valid on jumbo loans or HELOC’s.” It is worth knowing the conditions before relying on it.
Is there an SEC filing to read?
No. We searched EDGAR's company list for “amerisave” and found no registrant, and a full-text search for the name returns only filings by other companies (the first page of results is asset-backed securities reports, form ABS-15G, and two 10-K exhibits from one insurer). AmeriSave is privately held, so there is no 10-Q, 10-K or loan-portfolio disclosure of its own to check against the HMDA figures. Everything above is regulator data and regulator documents.
What a reader can do with this
- Know which product you are buying. AmeriSave's file is a cash-out refinance and second-lien business. If you are buying a home, ask for a Loan Estimate and compare it with at least two other lenders for the same loan amount, lock date and points; the purchase medians above are above the national medians on small samples.
- Finish the application before you read a denial as a verdict. In AmeriSave's file the most common first reason is an incomplete application. Ask in writing what is missing and by when.
- If you want a home equity loan, compare total cost, not the monthly payment. A 30-year term lowers the payment and raises the interest; AmeriSave's median is 360 months against 240 nationally. Our home equity loan lender ranking shows the other lenders.
- Read the terms of any rate promise. The “Meet or Beat” offer compares annual percentage rates on Loan Estimates and is capped at $1000.
- Check the licence yourself. Search NMLS ID 1168 and your loan officer's own ID on NMLS Consumer Access, and your state regulator's page.
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources, read November 16, 2026: FFIEC HMDA 2025 data browser (aggregations for AmeriSave Mortgage Corporation, LEI 549300YIQ7S7Z8PIHE53, and nationwide aggregations; AmeriSave's filtered file and the national purchase and second-lien extracts streamed, raw files not kept) and the CFPB's March 31, 2026 announcement of the 2025 HMDA data; CFPB Consumer Complaint Database API (company AMERISAVE MORTGAGE CORPORATION, data as of November 15, 2026); CFPB consent order and docket, File No. 2014-CFPB-0010, and the CFPB enforcement actions search; Settlement Agreement and Order of July 31, 2013 between AmeriSave and state mortgage regulators (as published by the Alaska Department of Commerce, Community, and Economic Development); New York Department of State consent order of April 2026; AmeriSave state licensing and disclosures page (effective September 30, 2025); SEC EDGAR company and full-text search.
Keep reading.
- 0122 min read
Carrington Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Denials, Costs, CFPB Record
Carrington Mortgage made 15,089 loans in 2025; 74% of denials were incomplete files. FHA costs, 700 CFPB complaints, a 2022 CFPB order and HUD audit.
- 0222 min read
Guild Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA, Complaints and Bayview Sale
Guild made 86,111 loans in 2025, 82.4% for purchases, and denied 3.5% of purchase decisions. HMDA costs, CFPB complaints, 2020 DOJ deal, Bayview sale.
- 0320 min read
New American Funding Review 2026: HMDA Denials and CFPB Data
New American Funding's 2025 federal loan data: 57,460 loans, FHA and VA rates against the national median, 128 CFPB mortgage complaints and its enforcement record.