CrowdfundedWealth
Reviews · Platform teardown

PennyMac Loan Services Review 2026: HMDA Rates, Complaints, 10-Q

By Jorge··24 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Filing alert · free

An email when PennyMac Financial Services files with the SEC

An email the day PennyMac Financial Services files something new, with the link to the document on the SEC site.

Quick Answer

As of November 15, 2026: PennyMac Loan Services, LLC filed 490,614 records in the 2025 federal mortgage-lending file (HMDA, released in 2026), but only 100,816 were loans it made ($35.4 billion); 293,228 (59.8%) were loans it bought from other lenders, worth $107.9 billion. On 30-year, first-lien, owner-occupied purchase loans its median rate was 6.624% conventional, 6.125% FHA and 5.999% VA, against 6.625%, 6.25% and 6.15% for the median of 13 to 15 other large lenders, with lower median discount points on all three ($2,088, $1,739 and $2,431). It denied 12.1% of conventional, 18.6% of FHA and 13.8% of VA purchase applications (our arithmetic). The CFPB database lists 686 mortgage complaints for 2025, 6.8 per 1,000 loans it made (our arithmetic), 521 of them about payments or trouble paying. Its parent, PennyMac Financial Services, Inc. (NYSE: PFSI), reported in its November 3, 2026 10-Q third-quarter net income of $28.7 million (down from $181.5 million) and a servicing portfolio of $736.7 billion.

Key Takeaways

  • The lender is not what the name suggests. In 2025 PennyMac Loan Services, LLC reported 490,614 HMDA records: 100,816 originated, 293,228 purchased from other lenders (action code 6), 47,737 files closed for incompleteness, 23,771 denials, 17,520 withdrawals. Purchased loans were 59.8% of records and $107.9 billion against $35.4 billion originated (our arithmetic), because it is the buyer in a large correspondent channel.
  • What it made itself: 60,054 conventional loans ($21.0 billion), 24,044 FHA ($7.4 billion), 16,581 VA ($6.9 billion) and 137 USDA. Of the 100,816, 36,527 were home purchases; 46,092 were refinances or cash-out refinances; 18,196 were home-improvement loans, 17,530 of them second liens with a median size of $55,000.
  • Channel: 41.1% of the loans it made came to it not submitted directly by the borrower (brokers and other third parties), but the split is by purpose: 84.9% of its purchase loans were not direct, while 78.6% of refinances and 97.3% of home-improvement loans were direct (our arithmetic). On conventional purchase loans only 8.5% were direct.
  • Price, 30-year purchase loans: FHA median 6.125% with $1,739 in points (peer median 6.25% and $2,473), VA 5.999% with $2,431 (6.15% and $2,915), conventional 6.624% with $2,088 (6.625% and $2,786). Total loan costs were above the peer median on conventional ($7,470 against $5,969) and VA ($9,638 against $6,576) and below it on FHA ($11,631 against $12,031).
  • Denials: all purposes, 18.5% of decided applications were denied (17.7% conventional, 22.9% FHA, 14.1% VA). On purchase loans its denial rate was 12.1% conventional (peer median 10.3%), 18.6% FHA (19.2%) and 13.8% VA (8.6%). Debt-to-income was the first reason on 35.9% of purchase denials.
  • CFPB complaints, 2025: 686 mortgage complaints, 338 about trouble during the payment process and 183 about struggling to pay, 51 about applying and 29 about closing. For January 1 to November 15, 2026 the count is already 1,040, with hardship complaints up from 183 to 403. All 686 were closed, 25 with monetary relief.
  • Parent company, 10-Q for September 30, 2026: loan locks of $25.3 billion in the quarter (down 34.8%), of which 60.3% correspondent; net income $28.7 million (against $181.5 million); servicing portfolio $736.7 billion, 4.82% of it delinquent (our arithmetic). It agreed on October 20, 2026 to sell conventional servicing rights on $28.9 billion of loans.
  • No CFPB enforcement action against the company appears on the CFPB's list, and its 10-Q describes one open matter: a putative class action over fees of up to $6.75 for payments by debit card in North Carolina, in discovery with no class certified.

CSV · 287 rows

PennyMac Loan Services: 2025 HMDA record, rates and points against 15 large lenders, CFPB complaints, 10-Q and litigation

287 rows: actions by code, purchased loans, denials by loan type and purpose, medians of rate, points and total loan costs by loan type and channel, peer medians, CFPB complaint counts, and PennyMac Financial Services' production, servicing and legal figures. One source per row.

Who files what: three names, one business

The lender is PennyMac Loan Services, LLC, the company that reports to the federal mortgage-lending file (HMDA, legal entity identifier RVDPPPGHCGZ40J4VQ731) and that the CFPB's complaint database lists as PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES, LLC. It is the mortgage-banking subsidiary of PennyMac Financial Services, Inc. (CIK 1745916, NYSE: PFSI), whose 10-Q describes it as “a non-bank producer and servicer of mortgage loans in the United States.” The parent's latest periodic filing is the 10-Q filed November 3, 2026, after an 8-K with earnings on October 29, 2026.

A third company, PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust (NYSE: PMT), is separately listed and is not the lender. PFSI services the trust's loans and was subserving $209.8 billion for it on September 30, 2026. The trust is a real estate investment trust whose dividend and book value we read in our PMT page; this page is about the company that makes, buys and collects on home loans.

Reviews that rank for “pennymac mortgage reviews” lean on star averages from review sites. None we found puts the lender's own 2025 lending file next to its complaint record and the parent's filings, which is what follows. For how the largest FHA lenders compare on one measure after another, see FHA lenders ranked with 2025 HMDA data.

Half a point of rate on a $300,000 30-year loan is about $100 a month for 30 years, and a late denial costs weeks and a hard credit pull. PennyMac also collects the payments on millions of loans it did not make, so a reader searching “pennymac loan services” may be a borrower in servicing rather than a buyer, and the complaint section is written for both.

Most of its HMDA records are loans it bought

PennyMac runs a large correspondent channel: a smaller lender or bank closes a loan, then sells it to PennyMac, which reports it as a purchased loan. Those loans appear in PennyMac's file with an action code of 6, and the lender that made them reports the origination in its own file.

PennyMac Loan Services, LLC, HMDA 2025, all records by action taken

Action taken (HMDA code)RecordsAmountShare of records (our arithmetic)
Purchased loan (6)293,228$107.9 billion59.8%
Loan originated (1)100,816$35.4 billion20.5%
File closed for incompleteness (5)47,737$13.3 billion9.7%
Application denied (3)23,771$7.3 billion4.8%
Application withdrawn (4)17,520$5.9 billion3.6%
Approved but not accepted (2)3,963$1.3 billion0.8%
Preapproval approved, not accepted (8)3,558$1.3 billion0.7%
Preapproval denied (7)21$5.8 millionunder 0.1%
All records490,614100%

The 293,228 purchased loans were 132,389 conventional, 101,392 FHA, 49,172 VA and 10,275 USDA, and 253,871 of them (86.6%) were for buying a home. Everything below about denials, rates and complaints per loan concerns the 100,816 loans PennyMac made itself, because HMDA records a purchase only after the loan exists: a denial or a rate quote at the lender who closed it is in that lender's file.

HMDA is published by the FFIEC; the CFPB announced on March 31, 2026 that the 2025 modified loan-level data were available, and the FFIEC announced the national snapshot on June 23, 2026.

What PennyMac made in 2025

Loans PennyMac Loan Services, LLC originated or denied, 2025, all loan purposes

Loan typeOriginatedAmount originatedDeniedDenial rate (our arithmetic)
Conventional60,054$21.04 billion13,27917.7%
FHA24,044$7.41 billion7,44422.9%
VA16,581$6.91 billion2,93414.1%
USDA137$31.5 million11444.4%
All four100,816$35.39 billion23,77118.5%

The denial rate is denied applications divided by originated loans plus approved-but-not-accepted plus denied applications. HMDA does not count withdrawn or incomplete files in that rate, and the USDA line rests on 257 decisions. The all-purpose rates blend very different products, so here is the same record by what the loan was for:

The same decisions split by purpose (closed-end loans)

PurposeOriginatedDeniedDenial rate (our arithmetic)Conventional / FHA / VA
Home purchase36,5275,83513.7%12.1% / 18.6% / 13.8%
Refinance and cash-out refinance46,09212,32220.1%19.9% / 24.0% / 13.8%
Home improvement18,1965,61322.9%22.3% / 69.6% / 38.0%

Home-improvement is the line that surprises. Of 18,195 home-improvement loans with a loan-purpose code of 4, 17,530 were second liens with a median amount of $55,000, and 97.3% came direct from borrowers. The 10-Q names the product: “Closed-end second lien” locks were $1.84 billion in the first nine months of 2026. The FHA and VA home-improvement rows rest on very few originated loans (79 and 124).

The channel: who sends PennyMac its loans

HMDA's submission-of-application field says whether the borrower applied directly to the institution (code 1) or the file came through someone else (code 2), which includes mortgage brokers but is not limited to them.

Loans PennyMac originated in 2025 by who submitted the application

PurposeSubmitted directlyNot submitted directlyNot direct share (our arithmetic)
Home purchase5,50031,02784.9%
Refinance and cash-out refinance36,2279,86521.4%
Home improvement17,7024932.7%
All originated59,43041,38641.1%

A buyer applying to PennyMac for a purchase loan is, in most cases, being brought to it by a broker: only 15.1% of its originated purchase loans were applied for directly, against 78.6% of refinances. The parent's 10-Q uses the matching names for its three channels, correspondent, broker direct and consumer direct, and the mix moved in 2026 (see the 10-Q section). For how not-direct loans compare with direct ones across the market, see mortgage broker vs lender: 2025 HMDA rates and costs.

Rates, points and costs on 30-year purchase loans

We pulled every originated 2025 home-purchase loan of PennyMac and of the 15 largest other lenders by 2025 originations, and kept only 30-year (360-month), first-lien, owner-occupied, closed-end loans that are not reverse mortgages or business-purpose loans. Medians are ours. Lenders with fewer than 500 loans of a type are left out of the peer median (Bank of America and Navy Federal on FHA, Bank of America on VA), so the conventional comparison has 15 peers, FHA has 13 and VA has 14.

PennyMac against the median of the other large lenders (each lender counts once)

Loan typePennyMac loansMedian rate: PennyMac vs peersMedian discount pointsMedian total loan costs
Conventional18,2496.624% vs 6.625% (tied 6th lowest of 16)$2,088 vs $2,786 (3rd fewest of 16)$7,470 vs $5,969 (2nd highest of 16)
FHA6,7236.125% vs 6.25% (tied 3rd lowest of 14)$1,739 vs $2,473 (3rd fewest of 14)$11,631 vs $12,031 (7th lowest of 14)
VA3,8585.999% vs 6.15% (3rd lowest of 15)$2,431 vs $2,915 (3rd fewest of 15)$9,638 vs $6,576 (3rd highest of 15)

The peers are loanDepot, Rocket Mortgage, United Wholesale Mortgage, CrossCountry Mortgage, JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, Guild, Mortgage Research Center, Navy Federal, U.S. Bank, Fairway, Guaranteed Rate, CMG, Freedom Mortgage and DHI Mortgage. DHI is a homebuilder's mortgage arm whose low rates (5.5% conventional, 4.5% FHA, 4.875% VA) fit builder-paid rate buy-downs; it sets the low end of every range.

Spread of median rates among the same lenders, and what it is worth on $300,000 (our arithmetic)

Loan typeLowest median rateHighest median rateMonthly payment gapGap over 30 years
Conventional5.5% (DHI Mortgage)6.825% (CrossCountry Mortgage)$257.41$92,667
FHA4.5% (DHI Mortgage)6.625% (Mortgage Research Center)$400.88$144,316
VA4.875% (DHI Mortgage)6.25% (six lenders)$259.53$93,430

What PennyMac's gap is worth (our arithmetic)

On a $300,000 30-year loan, 6.125% costs $1,822.83 a month against $1,847.15 at 6.25%: $24.32 less, about $8,755 over 30 years, before taxes, insurance and mortgage insurance. On VA, 5.999% against 6.15% saves $29.23 a month, about $10,500 over 30 years. On conventional the gap is 20 cents a month (6.624% against 6.625%). The median points were also lower: $734 below the peer median on FHA, $485 on VA and $698 on conventional. These are median-to-median figures for different borrowers, not a quote.

Total loan costs deserve a second look because PennyMac's loans are large: its median conventional loan was $465,000 against $355,000 for the median peer, and its median VA loan $455,000 against $380,000. Divided by loan size, its median conventional costs were 1.61% of the loan against 1.72% for the peers (the median of each lender's cost divided by its median loan), FHA 3.58% against 3.95%, and VA 2.12% against 1.73% (our arithmetic). So the conventional and FHA cost gaps shrink or reverse once size is counted, and VA stays higher.

Direct and not direct, inside PennyMac (30-year purchase loans)

Loan type and channelLoansMedian rateMedian total loan costsMedian origination chargesMedian loan
Conventional, direct1,5476.499%$6,318$2,744$385,000
Conventional, not direct16,7026.624%$7,649$2,987$475,000
FHA, direct7445.99%$10,796$2,167$295,000
FHA, not direct5,9796.25%$11,793$1,507$335,000
VA, direct9175.75%$10,406$4,549$425,000
VA, not direct2,9416.124%$9,209$1,743$465,000

Read the tables together. The direct loans have lower median rates on every type, but they are different borrowers and smaller loans, and there are far fewer of them. HMDA does not say whether a borrower chose to buy down the rate or was quoted that way, and it holds no credit scores, so a lower median rate can reflect stronger borrowers as well as pricing.

Who it denies, and why

Purchase applications only, 2025, closed-end loans: denial rate (our arithmetic)

Loan typePennyMacMedian of other large lendersPeers with a lower denial rate
Conventional12.1%10.3%9 of 15
FHA18.6%19.2%6 of 13
VA13.8%8.6%12 of 14

On VA purchase loans 12 of the 14 peers denied a smaller share; only loanDepot (14.2%) and JPMorgan Chase (16.2%) denied more. Denial rates mix credit, income, debt, property and who applies to each lender, so a higher rate is not evidence of unfair treatment. The first denial reason recorded on all 5,835 of its purchase denials:

First denial reason (HMDA code)Purchase denialsShare (our arithmetic)
Debt-to-income ratio2,09535.9%
Credit application incomplete1,13519.5%
Insufficient cash70612.1%
Collateral61510.5%
Unverifiable information4958.5%
Credit history4668.0%
Other, employment history, mortgage insurance3235.5%

Debt-to-income and an incomplete application together were 55% of purchase denials, both things a buyer can partly control with documents ready. Across all 23,771 denials of every purpose, debt-to-income was first on 7,431 (31.3%), collateral on 4,862 (20.5%) and credit history on 3,919 (16.5%).

CFPB complaints: 686 in 2025

The CFPB complaint database, pulled November 15, 2026, lists 686 mortgage complaints received in 2025 under the company name PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES, LLC. and 1,040 from January 1 to November 15, 2026. That is 6.8 complaints per 1,000 loans it originated (686 over 100,816; our arithmetic), or 1.7 per 1,000 counting the loans it bought as well. The figure overstates lending trouble, because PennyMac also collects payments on a servicing book of $736.7 billion that includes loans it did not make.

Mortgage complaints about PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES, LLC., by issue

Issue20252026 to November 15
Trouble during payment process338406
Struggling to pay mortgage183403
Incorrect information on your report5460
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage5173
Closing on a mortgage2968
Problem with a company's investigation into an existing problem2726
All mortgage complaints6861,040

Payment and hardship issues were 521 of the 686 complaints in 2025 (76%) and 809 of 1,040 in 2026 (78%), while applying and closing were 80 (12%) and 141 (14%) (our arithmetic). The company closed all 686 with a response: 586 with explanation, 75 with non-monetary relief and 25 with monetary relief; all were marked timely. With six weeks of 2026 left, the hardship count is already more than double the full-year 2025 figure, a rise the database does not explain.

Complaint counts are not comparable across companies without care. The same database lists 654 for Rocket Mortgage, LLC (1.5 per 1,000 loans it originated), 202 for LD Holdings Group, LLC, loanDepot's complaint name (2.2), and 1,180 for Freedom Mortgage Company (16.9), each over its own HMDA 2025 originations of the four federal types and each with a different servicing book (our arithmetic). Separately, 254 credit-reporting complaints and 83 debt-collection complaints in 2025 name PennyMac, which are not counted above; the CFPB does not verify complaints and they show what people report, not what a regulator found.

What the 10-Q says (quarter ended September 30, 2026)

PennyMac Financial Services, Inc., filed November 3, 2026 (dollars in thousands except per share)

MeasureQ3 2026Q3 2025Nine months 2026Nine months 2025
Loan production revenues$240,359$382,313$1,018,387$954,815
Net loan servicing fees$261,855$241,238$560,506$555,919
Total net revenues$468,775$632,898$1,510,724$1,508,531
Income before income taxes$42,547$236,374$178,763$417,012
Net income$28,654$181,503$132,702$394,246
Diluted earnings per share$0.54$3.37$2.48$7.34
Production segment, income before taxes($7,406)$122,882$164,608$242,613
Servicing segment, income before taxes$98,882$157,401$133,259$287,554

The production business lost money in the quarter. The 10-Q gives the reasons: “income before income taxes decreased $193.8 million compared to the same quarter in 2025,” mainly from “a $142.0 million decrease in loan production revenue due to lower volume across all production channels” and a $42.3 million rise in net interest expense. It also says it “implemented cost reduction measures in the third quarter of 2026” and expects to keep cutting “through early 2027.”

Interest rate locks by production channel (dollars in thousands)

ChannelQ3 2026Q3 2025Nine months 2026Nine months 2025Change, nine months (our arithmetic)
Correspondent$15,255,493$24,901,402$56,257,275$75,654,691down 25.6%
Broker direct$6,128,859$7,967,470$24,187,435$20,597,288up 17.4%
Consumer direct$3,909,742$5,951,735$19,249,482$13,623,032up 41.3%
All channels$25,294,094$38,820,607$99,694,192$109,875,011down 9.3%

Correspondent was 56.4% of nine-month locks in 2026 against 68.9% in 2025 (our arithmetic). The 10-Q adds that “We expect to sell all of our non-agency correspondent production and none of our conventional conforming correspondent production to PMT in the fourth quarter of 2026.”

The servicing book is what most borrowers deal with after closing. On September 30, 2026 PennyMac serviced loans with an unpaid balance of $736.7 billion: $503.4 billion that it owns (servicing rights and loans held for sale) and $233.3 billion subserviced for others, mostly the trust. Loans 30 or more days past due were $35.5 billion, 4.82% of the total (our arithmetic), including $12.5 billion 90 days or more past due and not in foreclosure and $2.2 billion in foreclosure; the same share on December 31, 2025 was 4.89%. The 10-Q also says: “On October 20, 2026, we entered into an agreement to sell a portfolio of conventional MSRs with an aggregate UPB of approximately $28.9 billion,” expected to close in the fourth quarter, and that it “may sell additional MSR portfolios in future periods.” MSRs are the right to service loans; when they are sold, the borrower's payments go to another company.

Regulators and courts

CFPB. The CFPB's public list of enforcement actions returned no result for a title search of “pennymac” on November 15, 2026; a control search the same day for “freedom mortgage” returned that company's actions. That is an absence on one list, not proof that no examination or investigation ever took place.

SEC filings. The 10-Q describes legal and regulatory matters as arising “in the ordinary course of its business” and says management believes no outcome will have a material adverse effect; Item 3 of the 10-K for 2025 uses similar wording and describes no consent order. The 10-Q describes one case: a putative class action filed April 9, 2025 against PennyMac Loan Services in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina (Civil Action No. 1:24-cv-00276), alleging that fees of up to $6.75 for payments by debit card or through an automated clearing house were not authorized by borrowers' mortgage agreements and violate North Carolina law. The plaintiff seeks statutory penalties of $500 to $4,000 per violation and treble damages. The court denied the company's motion to dismiss on December 1, 2025, discovery is under way and no class has been certified. The company says it “believes it has meritorious defenses” and cannot estimate a loss. These are allegations, not findings.

We did not search state regulators' orders or NMLS Consumer Access, which would show licensing actions state by state, and we did not read court dockets other than the one the 10-Q describes.

What a reader can do with this

  1. If you are buying a home through a broker, know that 84.9% of PennyMac's purchase loans arrive that way: ask the broker for the lender's Loan Estimate and compare total loan costs and points from at least one direct lender, not only the rate.
  2. Ask for the rate and the points as two numbers. Its median points were below the peer median on all three types, but a median is not your loan: get a quote at the lowest rate and one at zero points and compare what the points cost against what they save.
  3. On a VA loan, compare total loan costs, not just the rate. Its median VA rate was lower than most peers, its median VA total loan costs were among the highest of 15, and its VA purchase denial rate was above the peer median.
  4. Have income and debt records ready before you apply. Debt-to-income and an incomplete application led its purchase denials, so a preapproval with documents is worth more than a quick estimate.
  5. If you are a borrower in servicing, most complaints concern payments and hardship (76%). Keep a record of payments and messages, and use the CFPB complaint form if a problem is unresolved.
  6. If your loan is sold or transferred, the 10-Q describes a $28.9 billion servicing sale expected in the fourth quarter of 2026; the filing does not say which loans are in it, so watch for a transfer notice and keep paying the company the notice names.
  7. To check the licence record yourself, search NMLS Consumer Access and your state regulator for PennyMac Loan Services, LLC; we could not.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: CFPB HMDA Data Browser, 2025 aggregate and loan-level data for PennyMac Loan Services, LLC and 15 other lenders (pulled November 15, 2026), the CFPB announcement of March 31, 2026 and the FFIEC announcement of June 23, 2026; CFPB Consumer Complaint Database, companies PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES, LLC., Rocket Mortgage, LLC, LD Holdings Group, LLC and Freedom Mortgage Company (pulled November 15, 2026); CFPB enforcement actions list (searched November 15, 2026); PennyMac Financial Services, Inc. (CIK 1745916) Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (accession 0001104659-26-121982), Form 10-Q for June 30, 2026, Form 10-K for 2025 (0001104659-26-018142) and Form 8-K of October 29, 2026 (0001104659-26-120224).

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.