Navy Federal Mortgage Review 2026: 12.9% of Conventional Purchase Applications Denied in 2025
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the navy federal mortgage numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick Answer
As of November 15, 2026, Navy Federal Credit Union's 2025 federal HMDA record shows 61,447 conventional and 19,100 VA mortgage loans originated ($11.05 billion and $7.49 billion), the 8th and 5th largest in the country by count, and a 12.9% denial rate on conventional first-lien home-purchase applications (1,967 denied against 13,295 originated, our arithmetic) compared with 9.0% pooled for the ten largest other conventional lenders. On 30-year purchase loans its median rate was 6.625% conventional and 6.0% VA, with median total loan costs of $4,104 and $4,975, below the medians of those ten lenders ($6,210 and $7,882). Its conventional purchase denial rate was 7.9% for White applicants who are not Hispanic or Latino and 26.9% for Black or African American applicants who are not Hispanic or Latino; the pooled figures for the ten others are 7.1% and 15.8%. A class action over this pattern, filed on December 17, 2023, ended with a notice of dismissal with prejudice that the court so ordered on August 25, 2026; the docket shows no public terms. HMDA has no credit scores. The CFPB database lists 230 mortgage complaints about Navy Federal for 2025 and 270 for 2026 through November 14. Membership is required.
Key Takeaways
- Scale: in 2025 Navy Federal originated 61,447 conventional loans ($11,053,555,000) and 19,100 VA loans ($7,489,250,000), 8th and 5th by count among lenders in the federal file; it originated no FHA or USDA loans in the data we read. Its HMDA file has 180,596 records in all.
- Denial rate by loan type (all purposes; denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied): 36.8% conventional (36,657 denied) and 16.1% VA (3,703 denied). These figures include refinances, home improvement and other purposes, so for a home buyer the purchase-only figures below are the relevant ones.
- Home purchase, first lien, owner-occupied: 12.9% of conventional applications denied (1,967 of 15,262 decided) and 8.8% of VA (1,467 of 16,748). The first reason listed in 905 of the 1,967 conventional denials was debt-to-income ratio and in 382 credit history.
- Cost: median note rate on 30-year purchase loans 6.625% conventional and 6.0% VA; median total loan costs $4,104 and $4,975. The medians of ten other large lenders are 6.495% and 6.1875% for rate and $6,210 and $7,882 for costs. On a $300,000 loan, the gap between the lowest and highest of those lenders' conventional median rates (6.0% and 6.825%) is $162 a month (our arithmetic).
- Applicant groups, conventional purchase: denial rate 7.9% White (not Hispanic or Latino), 26.9% Black or African American (not Hispanic or Latino), 17.5% Hispanic or Latino, 12.3% Asian (not Hispanic or Latino). For the ten other lenders pooled: 7.1%, 15.8%, 12.8% and 10.4%. HMDA does not include credit scores, so these differences do not by themselves show a cause.
- Court: the consolidated case 1:23-cv-01731 (Eastern District of Virginia) was revived in part by the Fourth Circuit on February 9, 2026, went through settlement-status reports in March and April 2026, and ended with a notice of dismissal with prejudice (docket entry 164) that the court so ordered on August 25, 2026.
- Complaints and regulators: 230 CFPB mortgage complaints received in 2025 (2.86 per 1,000 loans originated, our arithmetic; the count includes 62 home-equity complaints) and 270 from January 1 to November 14, 2026. The CFPB's November 7, 2024 order against Navy Federal (File No. 2024-CFPB-0014) concerned overdraft fees on deposit accounts, not mortgages, and the CFPB terminated it on July 1, 2025.
CSV · 260 rows
Navy Federal Credit Union mortgages: HMDA 2025 volume and denials, purchase-loan rates and costs against ten lenders, denial rates by applicant group, CFPB complaints, court docket and regulator records
261 rows: Navy Federal's 2025 HMDA record by loan type and purpose, its 30-year purchase loans against ten other lenders, denial rates by applicant group, CFPB mortgage complaints, the court docket and regulator records.
What Navy Federal is, who can apply and what it advertises
Navy Federal Credit Union is a member-owned credit union headquartered in Vienna, Virginia; its mortgage page carries “NMLS ID 399807”, the notice that it is “insured by NCUA” and the Equal Housing Lender mark (read November 15, 2026). You cannot apply for a mortgage without being a member. Its membership page says: “Our field of membership goes beyond current and retired members of the military to include their families and household members, Department of Defense personnel and more.” It lists active duty, veterans and retirees, immediate family (parents, grandparents, spouses, siblings, children and grandchildren), household members and Department of Defense civilians and contractors, and says “A Membership Savings Account with a $5 minimum balance is required to establish and maintain membership.”
On November 15, 2026 its mortgage page advertised a VA rate “as low as” 5.750% (APR 6.492%) and a conventional fixed rate “as low as” 6.250% (APR 6.448%); the conventional example “assumes the 15-year fixed mortgage, purchase of a single-family primary residence, 720 FICO, down payment of 20% up to the conforming loan amount limit.” An advertised rate is a best case for a stated borrower. The record of what it charged people in 2025 is the HMDA file below. For how VA lenders compare on the same data see our ranking of VA lenders by 2025 HMDA volume and the Veterans United review.
What 2025 HMDA shows: volume and denials by loan type
The federal HMDA file (FFIEC data browser; the CFPB announced the 2025 data on March 31, 2026) lists Navy Federal under LEI 5493003GQDUH26DNNH17 with 180,596 records, every action and every product, including home equity lines. In this table the denial rate is denied divided by originated plus approved-but-not-accepted plus denied, for all loan purposes together.
| Loan type | Originated | Dollars originated | Approved, not accepted | Denied | Denial rate (all purposes) | Rank by originations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 61,447 | $11,053,555,000 | 1,397 | 36,657 | 36.8% | 8th |
| VA | 19,100 | $7,489,250,000 | 230 | 3,703 | 16.1% | 5th |
Both rows include purchases, refinances, cash-out refinances, home improvement and other purposes. The 80,547 loans it originated in 2025 by purpose were: 30,361 home purchase, 20,002 home improvement, 17,293 coded as other purpose, 9,749 cash-out refinance and 3,142 refinance (HMDA purpose codes 1, 2, 4, 32 and 31). A 36.8% conventional denial rate across all purposes is not what a home buyer faces; the buyer-relevant figure is the purchase-only rate in the next sections.
Home-purchase loans: rate, points and closing costs against ten other lenders
To compare like with like we downloaded the row-level 2025 file for Navy Federal and for the ten largest other lenders of each loan type and kept first-lien, owner-occupied, home-purchase loans that were originated with a 360-month term, leaving out loans flagged as business purpose, reverse mortgages and open-end lines. “Ten largest other” means the ten largest by originations of that loan type in the federal file, excluding Navy Federal. Points and total loan costs are in dollars as HMDA reports them; the points column counts only loans that report a figure.
Conventional 30-year purchase loans.
| Lender | Loans | Median rate | Loans reporting points | Median points | Median total loan costs | Median loan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Navy Federal Credit Union | 12,206 | 6.625% | 1,829 | $2,580 | $4,104 | $335,000 |
| Rocket Mortgage | 86,076 | 6.625% | 53,429 | $2,818 | $5,969 | $325,000 |
| United Wholesale Mortgage | 131,038 | 6.624% | 71,920 | $2,340 | $7,256 | $355,000 |
| JPMorgan Chase Bank | 43,846 | 6.375% | 26,476 | $2,167 | $4,742 | $375,000 |
| Bank of America | 18,619 | 6.0% | 10,946 | $2,839 | $5,088 | $415,000 |
| CrossCountry Mortgage | 52,535 | 6.825% | 33,166 | $3,176 | $6,913 | $365,000 |
| U.S. Bank | 22,195 | 6.49% | 9,707 | $1,099 | $5,261 | $435,000 |
| Citizens Bank | 6,149 | 6.375% | 2,788 | $1,988 | $7,636 | $485,000 |
| PNC Bank | 7,638 | 6.375% | 3,903 | $798 | $4,818 | $295,000 |
| loanDepot | 16,843 | 6.5% | 10,932 | $3,045 | $6,451 | $355,000 |
| PennyMac | 18,249 | 6.624% | 8,023 | $2,088 | $7,470 | $465,000 |
Across the ten other lenders the median of their medians is 6.495% for the rate (range 6.0% to 6.825%), $2,254 for points among loans that report them (range $798 to $3,176) and $6,210 for total loan costs (range $4,742 to $7,636). Navy Federal's median rate of 6.625% is 0.13 of a point above that figure, while its total loan costs are $2,106 lower (our arithmetic). Its middle half of rates ran from 6.25% to 7.0%.
VA 30-year purchase loans.
| Lender | Loans | Median rate | Loans reporting points | Median points | Median total loan costs | Median loan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Navy Federal Credit Union | 14,261 | 6.0% | 1,377 | $3,409 | $4,975 | $355,000 |
| Mortgage Research Center (Veterans United) | 61,650 | 6.25% | 37,226 | $1,175 | $4,755 | $305,000 |
| United Wholesale Mortgage | 21,252 | 6.125% | 13,808 | $2,654 | $5,880 | $415,000 |
| Freedom Mortgage | 3,827 | 6.25% | 2,331 | $2,800 | $9,999 | $395,000 |
| Rocket Mortgage | 8,596 | 6.125% | 5,809 | $2,998 | $8,559 | $385,000 |
| PennyMac | 3,858 | 5.999% | 2,002 | $2,431 | $9,638 | $455,000 |
| NewRez | 5,210 | 6.25% | 2,549 | $1,908 | $8,315 | $395,000 |
| DHI Mortgage | 11,909 | 4.875% | 5,657 | $3,548 | $5,178 | $345,000 |
| CrossCountry Mortgage | 8,288 | 6.25% | 5,776 | $3,354 | $6,741 | $385,000 |
| loanDepot | 4,130 | 5.625% | 2,828 | $5,582 | $9,424 | $375,000 |
| New Day Financial | 472 | 6.375% | 230 | $4,610 | $7,449 | $285,000 |
The median of the ten others' medians is 6.1875% for the rate (range 4.875%, a builder-affiliated lender, to 6.375%), $2,899 for points and $7,882 for total loan costs (range $4,755 to $9,999). Navy Federal's 6.0% is 0.19 of a point below that figure and its costs are $2,907 lower (our arithmetic). Its middle half of VA rates ran from 5.75% to 6.125%.
Worked example (our arithmetic). On a $300,000 30-year conventional loan, the payment at 6.0% (the lowest median among the ten others, Bank of America) is $1,798.65 a month, at Navy Federal's 6.625% $1,920.93 and at 6.825% (the highest, CrossCountry) $1,960.77. The gap between the lowest and the highest is $162.12 a month, or $58,364 over 360 payments. The gap between Navy Federal and the ten-lender median of 6.495% is $25.72 a month.
A lower or higher median is not a price list. HMDA gives the rate at origination, not the rate you would have been quoted, and borrower mix differs by lender: a lender with stronger borrowers can show lower rates, and a lender that sells points can show a lower rate with higher points. Navy Federal's low total loan costs may also reflect how a credit union charges fees, or which borrowers it lends to; the file cannot say. All 13,295 conventional and 15,281 VA purchase originations in our subset were submitted directly to Navy Federal, none through a broker.
Denial rates by applicant group, and the 2023 reports and litigation
HMDA lets anyone compute denial rates by the race and ethnicity applicants report. The table is built from the row-level 2025 file: conventional, first-lien, owner-occupied, home-purchase applications that ended in an origination or a denial (denied divided by originated plus denied), for Navy Federal and for the same ten other lenders as above. Race categories are single-race groups among applicants who are not Hispanic or Latino; the Hispanic or Latino column covers any race. Applicants with joint, unavailable or other entries appear only in the last column.
| Lender | White (not Hispanic or Latino) | Black or African American (not Hispanic or Latino) | Hispanic or Latino (any race) | Asian (not Hispanic or Latino) | All applicants |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Navy Federal Credit Union | 7.9% (611 of 7,692) | 26.9% (569 of 2,113) | 17.5% (225 of 1,289) | 12.3% (80 of 649) | 12.9% (1,967 of 15,262) |
| Rocket Mortgage | 10.7% (5,887 of 55,174) | 19.4% (974 of 5,014) | 16.1% (1,787 of 11,100) | 12.5% (1,244 of 9,976) | 12.2% (12,646 of 103,912) |
| United Wholesale Mortgage | 5.5% (3,978 of 72,644) | 15.7% (931 of 5,916) | 11.7% (3,233 of 27,527) | 9.8% (1,504 of 15,365) | 8.0% (11,885 of 149,471) |
| JPMorgan Chase Bank | 8.6% (2,392 of 27,743) | 17.0% (537 of 3,167) | 13.4% (942 of 7,012) | 11.1% (879 of 7,893) | 10.3% (5,461 of 53,029) |
| Bank of America | 10.2% (991 of 9,747) | 14.6% (384 of 2,626) | 20.9% (636 of 3,040) | 12.0% (442 of 3,669) | 12.8% (2,990 of 23,294) |
| CrossCountry Mortgage | 1.4% (474 of 33,255) | 4.8% (94 of 1,963) | 4.2% (251 of 5,946) | 2.5% (76 of 3,092) | 2.0% (1,140 of 55,736) |
| U.S. Bank | 7.6% (1,103 of 14,577) | 18.2% (138 of 759) | 13.9% (298 of 2,149) | 7.3% (266 of 3,657) | 8.7% (2,256 of 25,938) |
| Citizens Bank | 8.8% (374 of 4,261) | 19.1% (52 of 272) | 15.9% (69 of 435) | 11.2% (95 of 845) | 10.2% (731 of 7,151) |
| PNC Bank | 10.1% (638 of 6,326) | 20.3% (92 of 454) | 22.1% (136 of 616) | 15.5% (159 of 1,026) | 12.3% (1,206 of 9,778) |
| loanDepot | 4.3% (375 of 8,710) | 11.9% (110 of 922) | 11.0% (296 of 2,698) | 7.9% (145 of 1,836) | 6.7% (1,259 of 18,701) |
| PennyMac | 10.2% (1,197 of 11,725) | 20.3% (128 of 629) | 18.2% (407 of 2,238) | 15.3% (336 of 2,189) | 12.0% (2,614 of 21,740) |
| Ten others pooled | 7.1% (17,409 of 244,162) | 15.8% (3,440 of 21,722) | 12.8% (8,055 of 62,761) | 10.4% (5,146 of 49,548) | 9.0% (42,188 of 468,750) |
For Navy Federal the White (not Hispanic or Latino) rate is 7.9% and the Black or African American (not Hispanic or Latino) rate is 26.9%, a difference of 19.0 percentage points; pooled for the ten other lenders the figures are 7.1% and 15.8%, a difference of 8.7 points (our arithmetic). Navy Federal's 26.9% is higher than the figure for each of the ten lenders listed. HMDA does not include credit scores or full credit files, so differences in denial rates do not by themselves show the cause.
In December 2023 a CNN analysis of 2022 HMDA data on these applications was published (the complaint cites it, dated December 14, 2023), and on December 17, 2023 a lawsuit by mortgage applicants followed in the Eastern District of Virginia (case 1:23-cv-01731). The first complaint states: “a White person in 2022 who applied for a conventional home loan purchase with Navy Federal had a 75% chance of being approved for the mortgage, while Black borrowers had less than a 50% chance of success.” That is the plaintiffs' allegation in their pleading, not a court finding. The docket and the Fourth Circuit opinion show how the case went:
| Date | Event | Source |
|---|---|---|
| December 17, 2023 | First complaint filed in the Eastern District of Virginia, case 1:23-cv-01731 | Complaint; CourtListener docket |
| May 30, 2024 | Court dismissed the disparate-treatment theory and struck the class allegations; claims on a disparate-impact theory continued | CourtListener docket, entry 92 |
| February 9, 2026 | Fourth Circuit (No. 24-1656, published, one judge concurring in part and dissenting in part) affirmed the order striking the Rule 23(b)(3) damages class and vacated it as to the Rule 23(b)(2) injunctive class | Fourth Circuit opinion |
| March 3, 2026 | Mandate issued | CourtListener docket, entry 154 |
| April 3 to April 21, 2026 | Parties report on settlement progress; court stays the matter for 45 days | CourtListener docket, entries 158 to 160 |
| August 25, 2026 | Plaintiffs file a notice of dismissal with prejudice (entry 164); court so orders; docket shows the case terminated | CourtListener docket, entries 164 to 166 |
The Fourth Circuit opinion describes the complaint as alleging that Navy Federal uses a “semi‑automated underwriting process” that discriminates; the opinion decided a procedural question about striking class allegations before discovery and made no finding about whether Navy Federal discriminated. The docket on CourtListener does not show the terms, if any, behind the dismissal with prejudice, and we found no public settlement document. We did not find a Navy Federal statement about the dismissal that we could save, so we do not quote one. Nothing on this page concludes anything about intent.
Complaints, the CFPB order and the NCUA
The CFPB Consumer Complaint Database lists complaints under the company name “NAVY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION” in the product category Mortgage. It received 230 in 2025 and 270 from January 1 to November 14, 2026. The CFPB does not verify the facts in complaints and they include servicing and home-equity issues, so this is a record of what people reported, not a count of errors.
| Measure | 2025 (January 1 to December 31) | 2026 (January 1 to November 14) |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage complaints received | 230 | 270 |
| Applying for a mortgage or refinancing | 75 | 104 |
| Trouble during payment process | 61 | 74 |
| Closing on a mortgage | 45 | 41 |
| Struggling to pay mortgage | 34 | 41 |
| Sub-product: conventional home mortgage | 90 | 126 |
| Sub-product: VA mortgage | 62 | 77 |
| Sub-product: home equity loan or line of credit | 62 | 55 |
| Closed with monetary relief | 29 | 20 |
| In progress | 0 | 39 |
Per 1,000 loans originated (80,547 conventional and VA loans in the 2025 HMDA file) 2025's 230 complaints are 2.86 (our arithmetic); the ratio mixes complaints about existing loans with an origination count, so read it as a scale, not a rate. All 230 complaints in 2025 and all 270 in 2026 are marked as answered by the company on time; in 2025 the company closed 166 with explanation, 35 with non-monetary relief and 29 with monetary relief.
The 2024 CFPB order was about overdrafts, not mortgages. On November 7, 2024 the CFPB issued a consent order against Navy Federal (File No. 2024-CFPB-0014) over overdraft fee practices on deposit accounts; it required a civil money penalty of $15,000,000 and found about $80.2 million in harm to consumers. The CFPB's enforcement page lists the product as Deposits, and says that on July 1, 2025 the Bureau “terminated the order and waived any alleged non-compliance therewith.” Nothing in that order concerns mortgage lending.
NCUA. In the NCUA's administrative-orders list as we saved it on November 15, 2026 (the first 100 of 1,426 results, which the NCUA says are “not guaranteed to be comprehensive”), we found no order in which the credit union itself is the respondent.
What HMDA cannot tell you about a Navy Federal loan
- No credit scores and no full credit files. An applicant with a 780 score and one with a 620 look the same except for the fields HMDA collects. Denial rates compare who applied, not who was equally qualified.
- Application counts depend on who applies. A lender that pre-screens heavily shows fewer denials; one that takes applications from anyone shows more. Navy Federal's members are a defined group, so its applicant pool is not the pool of a national retail lender.
- Conventional here means conforming, jumbo and portfolio loans together. HMDA does not label them, so the 6.625% median mixes products with different pricing.
- 2025 is not 2026. The rates are those at closing during 2025; today's quotes differ.
- Servicing is outside the file. Most 2025 complaints were about payments, closing and applications, which no loan-level field records.
What a reader can do with this
- If you are a member, get a Loan Estimate from Navy Federal and from two other lenders on the same day, with the same assumptions, and compare rate, points and the total in the Loan Estimate, not the advertised rate.
- If you are denied, ask for the adverse-action notice and the reasons listed; in Navy Federal's 2025 file the first reason was debt-to-income ratio in 905 of 1,967 conventional purchase denials, which you can test against your own numbers before reapplying.
- For a VA purchase, compare its 6.0% median and $4,975 median costs with the other large VA lenders in our VA lender ranking and read how VA loans work on rental property if you plan to rent the home later.
- Check your eligibility on its membership page before you plan around it.
FAQ
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: FFIEC HMDA Data Browser, 2025 loan-level and aggregation data (Navy Federal LEI 5493003GQDUH26DNNH17 and ten other lenders per loan type), and the CFPB's announcement of the 2025 data (March 31, 2026); CFPB Consumer Complaint Database, company NAVY FEDERAL CREDIT UNION, product Mortgage (complaints received through November 14, 2026); United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, No. 24-1656 (decided February 9, 2026); CourtListener docket, Eastern District of Virginia, 1:23-cv-01731 (read November 15, 2026) and the complaint filed December 17, 2023; CFPB File No. 2024-CFPB-0014 and enforcement page; NCUA administrative-orders list; Navy Federal membership and mortgage pages (November 15, 2026).
Keep reading.
- 0120 min read
AmeriSave Mortgage Review: 24,298 Loans in 2025, 70.0% Denied in Federal Data, 120 CFPB Complaints
AmeriSave's 2025 federal loan data: 24,298 loans, 70.0% of decisions denied, mostly cash-out refinances; purchase costs, 120 CFPB complaints, orders
- 0222 min read
Carrington Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Denials, Costs, CFPB Record
Carrington Mortgage made 15,089 loans in 2025; 74% of denials were incomplete files. FHA costs, 700 CFPB complaints, a 2022 CFPB order and HUD audit.
- 0322 min read
Guild Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA, Complaints and Bayview Sale
Guild made 86,111 loans in 2025, 82.4% for purchases, and denied 3.5% of purchase decisions. HMDA costs, CFPB complaints, 2020 DOJ deal, Bayview sale.