CrowdfundedWealth

Piggyback Loan Lenders in 2025 Data: Who Makes 80/10/10 Seconds

ResearchBy Jorge25 min read1 SEC filing cited

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Quick answer

As of November 22, 2026, the 2025 federal mortgage file (HMDA) holds 140,582 originated second mortgages on home purchases of principal residences, and only 3,938 of them (2.8%) look like a piggyback loan: a second lien worth at least 5% of the home's value, carrying a rate above 0%, behind a first lien of about 80% of value. Most purchase seconds are something else. Of 111,231 closed-end ones with usable figures, 86,152 (77.5%) sit behind a first lien of 90% of value or more, with a median amount of $15,000, which is the shape of down payment help. The piggyback-type seconds are concentrated: GreenState Credit Union, Veridian Credit Union and Fulton Bank made 1,918 of the 3,177 closed-end ones (60.4%, our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records). Their median rate above 0% was 7.125%, against 6.5% for conventional first liens at about 80% with a second behind them (6,652 of 1,810,369, or 0.4%).

Update alert · free

An email when the piggyback loan numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Key takeaways

  • HMDA 2025 lists 140,582 originated purchase second liens on principal residences: 112,493 closed-end loans, 25,943 open-end lines and 2,146 open-end records marked exempt. Only 3,938 (2.8%) fit the piggyback screen (first lien about 80%, second at least 5% of value, rate above 0%): 3,177 closed-end loans and 761 lines.
  • The classic 80/10/10 shape (second 7.5% to 12.5% of value behind an about-80% first lien) is rarer still: 900 closed-end loans (701 with a rate above 0%, median $35,000, median rate 7.0%) and 567 open-end lines (median limit $95,000, median rate 8.25%).
  • Most purchase seconds are not piggybacks. 77.5% of the 111,231 closed-end ones with usable figures sit behind a first lien of 90% or more; their median is $15,000 and 45.7% of closed-end seconds carry a 0% rate, which fits assistance programs (see our page on down payment assistance).
  • Three lenders, GreenState Credit Union, Veridian Credit Union and Fulton Bank, made 1,918 of the 3,177 closed-end piggyback-type seconds (60.4%). Large mortgage companies write many purchase seconds, but at a median of $15,000, so they rarely fit the screen. Iowa leads by state: 1,243 of its 3,290 closed-end seconds (38.1%) sit behind an about-80% first lien.
  • Seen from the first lien: of 1,810,369 conventional purchase loans on principal residences, 60,180 (3.3%) report a combined loan-to-value ratio at least 5 points above their own loan-to-value, and 6,652 (0.4%) are first liens at about 80% with a second behind them. Their median 30-year rate is 6.5%, the same as first liens at 80% or less with no second.
  • Regulation Z treats a closed-end second lien as a higher-priced mortgage loan at 3.5 points or more over the average prime offer rate; 5,589 of 91,480 closed-end purchase seconds with a rate spread (6.1%) are at or above that line. HMDA does not link a second lien to its first, so every figure here is a screen, not a count of 80/10/10 loans.

CSV · 204 rows

Piggyback loans in 2025 HMDA: purchase second liens by segment, profile, lender and state, with the first-lien view, the rules and a worked example

Second liens on 2025 home purchases by segment (closed-end and open-end, principal residence and other), the piggyback-type screen, ten lenders by volume and ten by piggyback-type loans, ten states, the first liens that have a second behind them, the Regulation Z, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac rules and a worked 80/10/10 against mortgage-insurance example.

What a piggyback loan is, and what HMDA can and cannot show

A piggyback loan is a second mortgage taken at the same time as the first, so the first lien stays at about 80% of the home's value. The usual shapes are 80/10/10 (a first lien for 80%, a second for 10%, 10% in cash) and 80/20 (a first lien for 80%, a second for 20%, nothing down). The data below say how many 2025 loans have that shape, who made them and at what rate.

The data are the 2025 loan application registers that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said on March 31, 2026 were available on the FFIEC platform for about 4,768 filers. We streamed the Data Browser file of every 2025 record with a subordinate lien that was originated or denied (2,351,450 records) and kept the 178,196 whose loan purpose is a home purchase. To check the file, we asked the Data Browser's own aggregation for all originated and denied second liens: 1,558,203 originated and 793,247 denied, the same 2,351,450 our stream read.

Four limits shape every number on this page.

  • HMDA does not link a second lien to its first. Each record is one loan. Our piggyback screen therefore uses the combined loan-to-value ratio (CLTV) and the property value on the second lien's own record: the second as a share of the value is the loan amount divided by the property value, and the implied first lien is the CLTV minus that share (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records). Property values are rounded in the public file, so the implied first lien is accurate to a point or two, not exactly. We call a second a piggyback type when the implied first lien is between 77.5% and 82.5%, the second is at least 5% of value and the rate is above 0%.
  • CLTV is “the ratio of the total amount of debt secured by the property to the value of the property relied on in making the credit decision” (12 CFR 1003.4(a)(24)). Some lenders appear to report only their own lien: 7,410 closed-end seconds (6.7%) have a reported CLTV close to the second's own share of value (a median of 4.0%). We set those aside because their first lien cannot be inferred.
  • Open-end lines are reported at their limit. For a line of credit HMDA records “the amount of credit available to the borrower under the terms of the plan” (12 CFR 1003.4(a)(7)(ii)), not what was drawn.
  • The file has originated and denied applications only. Our denial rate is denied divided by originated plus denied (our arithmetic); withdrawn and incomplete files are not in it. There is no credit score, no margin over an index and no mortgage-insurance field.

What the 140,582 purchase second liens are

Lenders made 140,582 second liens on home purchases of principal residences in 2025. Another 4,312 were on second homes or investment properties (2,414 closed-end loans and 1,898 open-end lines), which we show separately. A closed-end second is a lump sum at a fixed payment schedule; an open-end line is a credit limit the buyer draws on. They are different products and we keep them apart.

2025 purchase second liensOriginatedDeniedDenial rateMedian amount or limitMedian rateMedian CLTVMedian term
Closed-end, principal residence112,49315,79712.3%$15,0007.55% for the 55,989 above 0%; 47,129 of 103,118 at 0%100.0%180 months
Open-end line, principal residence25,94313,73934.6%$175,0007.4%75.0%300 months
Open-end, principal residence, status exempt2,14634613.9%$105,000Not reportedNot reportedNot reported
Closed-end, second home or investment2,41464921.2%$15,000Not computedNot computedNot computed
Open-end, second home or investment1,8982,16153.2%$155,000Not computedNot computedNot computed

The closed-end group is where the money is by count, and it is not what people usually mean by a piggyback. Its median is $15,000, its median CLTV is 100.0% and 75,961 of 111,866 loans with a CLTV (67.9%) are at 100% or more. Its loan types (the type of the second lien itself, not of the first) are 107,745 conventional, 4,534 USDA, 199 FHA and 15 VA. The terms are 360 months for 46,148 loans and 120 months for 36,494.

The rate field splits the group. In 103,118 closed-end loans with a numeric rate, 47,129 (45.7%) report 0%, which fits a deferred or forgivable second funded by a program. The other 55,989 have a median rate of 7.55%. Across all 103,118: 11.2% are between 0% and 5.99%, 20.1% between 6% and 7.99%, 22.3% between 8% and 9.99%, 0.6% between 10% and 11.99% and 0.1% at 12% or more.

Open-end lines are a different group: a median limit of $175,000 (a median 27.8% of the home's value), a median CLTV of 75.0% (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records) and 34.6% denied. They look like home equity lines opened at the purchase, not like a piggyback second.

Only a few look like a piggyback loan

For each closed-end second with an amount, a property value and a CLTV (111,231 of 112,493; 1,262 lack one) we computed the second as a share of the value and the implied first lien. The groups below do not overlap.

Profile of the second lien (implied first lien, second as a share of value)LoansShare of 111,231Median amountLoans with a rate above 0%Median rate above 0%Median CLTV
First lien 90% or more of value (down payment or closing-cost help shape)86,15277.5%$15,00039,1657.625%100.5%
First lien under 77.5% of value8,0257.2%$105,0006,5987.65%75.0%
Reported CLTV looks like the second lien alone7,4106.7%$15,0004,8078.625%4.0%
First lien 82.5% to 90%3,8813.5%$15,0001,3336.625%95.0%
First lien about 80%, second 7.5% to 12.5% of value (80/10/10 shape)9000.8%$35,0007017.0%90.0%
First lien about 80%, second 17.5% to 22.5% of value (80/20 shape)2,1241.9%$65,0001,4457.125%100.0%
First lien about 80%, second 5% of value or more, other sizes1,8981.7%$45,0001,0317.25%95.0%
First lien about 80%, second under 5% of value8410.8%$15,0002265.0%83.1%

The three rows for a first lien of about 80% with a second of 5% of value or more add up to 4,922 closed-end seconds (4.4%), and 3,177 of them carry a rate above 0%. The other 1,745 carry 0% or no rate, which looks more like a program second than a bank loan. On open-end lines, 762 of 25,703 (3.0%) have an implied first lien of about 80% and a second of at least 5% of value (761 with a rate above 0%); 567 of them are 80/10/10 shaped, with a median limit of $95,000 and a median rate of 8.25%. 24,124 lines (93.9%) have an implied first lien under 77.5%, which is a buyer with a larger down payment opening a line.

Together that is 3,938 piggyback-type loans of 140,582 originated purchase seconds (2.8%, our arithmetic). Our page on down payment assistance in 2025 data covers the large group at the top of the table; of the 103,306 closed-end seconds under $50,000 that it screens as possible assistance, 2,392 have the piggyback profile (our arithmetic).

The rate of the piggyback-type closed-end seconds is higher than that of the first lien: a median of 7.125% above 0%, against 6.5% for the first liens next to them (next section), about 0.6 points more. The median amount of the 4,922 seconds with an about-80% first lien (all rates) is $55,000 and their median term is 180 months.

Seen from the first lien: how many carry a second behind them

A first-lien record also carries a CLTV. When the CLTV is at least 5 points above the loan's own loan-to-value (amount divided by property value), the lender knew of other debt on the home. We streamed all 2025 conventional, site-built, first-lien home-purchase loans on principal residences that were originated (1,893,011) and kept the 1,810,369 with an amount, a property value and a CLTV (82,642 lack one).

Conventional purchase first liens, principal residenceLoansMedian rate, 30-yearMedian discount points paid (loans that report them)Median total loan costsJumbo share
No second, CLTV 80.5% or less955,4196.5%$2,492$5,6697.9%
First lien at about 80% with a second behind (5 points or more)6,6526.5%$2,617$5,1514.1%
No second, CLTV 80.5% to 90.5%265,6226.625%$3,175$6,0074.8%
No second, CLTV 90.5% to 95.5%282,3816.625%$2,565$5,7590.9%
No second, CLTV 95.5% to 97.5%106,3066.625%$1,931$5,1190.2%
Any second of 5 points or more60,1806.625%$1,990$4,7451.7%

The picture matches the second-lien side. 60,180 first liens (3.3%) have a second of at least 5 points behind them; 6,652 (0.4%) are at about 80% (1,748 with a second near 10 points, 2,178 near 20 points). The 6,652 first-lien records and the 5,684 closed-end and open-end second-lien records with the same profile are of the same order, as two views of one population should be (our arithmetic).

Two things stand out. First, first liens with a second behind them are not priced higher than plain 80% loans: the median 30-year rate is 6.5% for both, and 6.625% for loans at 90.5% to 95.5% with no second, a gap of 0.125 points between those medians. Second, only 275 of the 6,652 first liens at about 80% with a second (4.1%) are jumbo, with a median loan of $275,000, so in 2025 data the piggyback is not mainly a jumbo tool.

Who makes piggyback-type seconds

HMDA names the lender of each loan. 159 of the 1,179 lenders with at least one closed-end purchase second on a principal residence made 100 or more, together 100,688 of the 112,493 loans. The five largest made 26.7% of the loans and the ten largest 37.3%. The volume leaders are mortgage companies, and their seconds are mostly the small, 0%-rate kind. The table shows each lender's closed-end seconds, how many report a rate, the share of those at 0%, the median rate above 0%, the median CLTV as the lender reports it and the share that sit behind an about-80% first lien.

Lender (name as filed, short form)Closed-end seconds originatedWith a rate reportedOf those, at 0%Median rate above 0%Median CLTV as reportedBehind an about-80% first lien
Guild Mortgage Company8,5388,53865.6%7.625%100.4%1.6%
Fairway Independent Mortgage5,9382,3230.0%6.875%100.4%1.1%
Movement Mortgage5,3275,32743.6%8.625%101.0%5.2%
Broker Solutions, Inc.5,2615,26153.8%8.5%100.0%0.9%
CMG Mortgage4,9521,4570.0%6.875%102.0%2.3%
Click n' Close, Inc.2,7512,75131.1%9.99%5.0%0.0%
Guaranteed Rate2,5682,56869.3%6.375%100.4%1.9%
loanDepot.com2,4712,47124.8%8.625%5.0%0.0%
PrimeLending, a PlainsCapital Company2,2102,21078.3%6.75%100.4%2.0%
GreenState Credit Union1,9041,9040.0%7.25%97.0%69.4%

Two reading notes. Fairway Independent Mortgage and CMG Mortgage report a rate on only some of their seconds (2,323 of 5,938 and 1,457 of 4,952); the rest have none in the public file, so the share at 0% means little for them. Click n' Close and loanDepot report a median CLTV of 5.0%, which is not a combined ratio: it looks like their own lien only, and their seconds cannot be placed behind a first lien.

Ranked instead by how many seconds fit the piggyback screen (first lien about 80%, second at least 5% of value, rate above 0%), the list changes completely. Only lenders with at least 100 closed-end purchase seconds are ranked.

Lender (name as filed, short form)Closed-end seconds originatedPiggyback-type seconds (rate above 0%)Share of its secondsMedian amountMedian rateMedian CLTVMedian term (months)Its denial rate on closed-end seconds
GreenState Credit Union1,9041,32169.4%$45,0007.25%97.0%1202.3%
Veridian Credit Union42331975.4%$45,0007.125%100.0%847.0%
Fulton Bank51227854.3%$55,0006.625%100.0%36015.2%
First Financial Bank90212614.0%$45,0006.5%89.9%36010.6%
The Washington Trust Company of Westerly1069387.7%$95,0004.75%97.0%3604.5%
Certified Funding2818028.5%$115,0007.5%95.0%18037.6%
The Park National Bank1287961.7%$35,0006.375%100.0%36011.7%
International Bank of Commerce1404532.1%$115,0008.5%94.4%18015.7%
Arvest Bank2142210.7%$40,0007.12%100.0%18017.1%

The first three, GreenState Credit Union, Veridian Credit Union and Fulton Bank, made 1,918 of the 3,177 closed-end piggyback-type seconds in the whole country (60.4%, our arithmetic). They are the same names that lead the first-lien view: of 5,983 conventional purchase first liens at GreenState Credit Union, 875 (14.6%) are at about 80% with a second behind; Fulton Bank has 221 of 2,206 (10.0%), Veridian Credit Union 199 of 2,212 (9.0%) and First Financial Bank 133 of 1,823 (7.3%). At the largest first-lien lenders the share is under 1%: Guild Mortgage Company 120 of 32,422 (0.4%), Movement Mortgage 119 of 22,130 (0.5%), CrossCountry Mortgage 114 of 53,940 (0.2%). In this data the piggyback is a product of a few lenders, mostly credit unions and regional banks, that write the first and the second together.

These tables rank by a stated count. They do not say who is cheapest or best for a borrower: median rates mix terms from 84 to 360 months, and HMDA has no credit score, no fees on the second and no information on how many borrowers were turned away before applying.

By state: where the screen finds them

The table ranks states by the number of closed-end purchase seconds that sit behind an about-80% first lien (any rate), and puts the first-lien view next to it.

StateClosed-end seconds originatedBehind an about-80% first lienShare of the state's closed-end secondsConventional purchase first liensFirst liens at about 80% with a second behindShare of first liens
IA3,2901,24338.1%22,3888523.81%
WA4,51659313.1%49,7923630.73%
CA7,0725648.1%148,7089640.65%
IL4,9724529.1%76,2084420.58%
TX8,9252402.7%147,2492550.17%
OH3,2972066.3%75,2532870.38%
PA2,9331986.9%71,2892710.38%
CT2,6231606.1%22,2052120.95%
MA1,7391398.1%39,7651920.48%
NC5,0371162.3%74,5421660.22%

Iowa is the outlier: 3.81% of its conventional purchase first liens have a second behind them, against 0.17% in Texas. A state's count reflects which lenders operate there more than what its borrowers prefer, and it includes seconds with a 0% rate. Texas has the most closed-end seconds of any state (8,925) with a median of $5,000, far from a piggyback.

The rules: Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac and Regulation Z

Fannie Mae. Selling Guide section B2-1.2-04, Subordinate Financing (page dated 08/06/2025 as we read it on November 22, 2026), says that “Subordinate liens must be evidenced by a promissory note; reflected in a recorded mortgage, deed of trust, or other security instrument; and clearly subordinate to Fannie Mae’s first mortgage loan or co-op share loan.” Lenders “must disclose the existence of subordinate financing and the subordinate financing repayment terms to Fannie Mae, the appraiser, and the mortgage insurer.” The same section lists terms that are not acceptable on a second behind a Fannie Mae first lien: negative amortization, and a balloon or maturity less than five years after the note date of the new first mortgage, with exceptions for employer financing and for a second that is small relative to the borrower's assets or credit profile. If a property seller finances the second at a rate more than 2% below current standard rates for second mortgages, the section treats the difference as a sales concession.

Section B2-1.2-02 (12/04/2018) says that “The CLTV ratio is determined by dividing the sum of the items listed below by the lesser of the sales price or the appraised value of the property,” and that the lender “must calculate the LTV ratio and the CLTV ratio” for a first mortgage subject to subordinate financing. It refers the allowable CLTV to Fannie Mae's Eligibility Matrix, which we did not retrieve, so we state no limit.

Freddie Mac. The Home Possible fact sheet of February 2026 says: “Any secondary financing that meets Freddie Mac requirements is allowed,” and “TLTV allowed up to 105% with eligible Affordable Seconds when the first lien is a fixed-rate mortgage,” the latter provided by an agency or similar program under Guide Section 4204.2. We could not retrieve the Guide sections themselves, so we do not state Freddie Mac's general limit for a piggyback.

Mortgage insurance starts above 80%. Fannie Mae's mortgage insurance table (B7-1-02, 08/07/2019) covers first liens with an LTV from 80.01% up: for a fixed-rate loan with a term over 20 years it shows standard coverage of 12% for an LTV of 80.01% to 85%, 25% for 85.01% to 90%, 30% for 90.01% to 95% and 35% for 95.01% to 97%, with lower minimum levels (6%, 12%, 16% and 18%) available with a price adjustment. The table is keyed to the first lien's LTV, and a piggyback keeps that first lien at about 80%.

Regulation Z. A higher-priced mortgage loan is “a closed-end consumer credit transaction secured by the consumer's principal dwelling” with an annual percentage rate above the average prime offer rate by “1.5 or more percentage points” for a conforming first lien, “2.5 or more percentage points” for a jumbo first lien or, in paragraph (a)(1)(iii), “3.5 or more percentage points for loans secured by a subordinate lien” (12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1), eCFR version current to November 19, 2026). The escrow requirement in 1026.35(b) applies to first liens. Under 1026.35(c)(3)(i), “a creditor shall not extend a higher-priced mortgage loan to a consumer without obtaining, prior to consummation, a written appraisal of the property to be mortgaged,” subject to the exemptions in (c)(2). HMDA's rate spread is the difference between the loan's APR and the average prime offer rate (12 CFR 1003.4(a)(12)). In the 91,480 closed-end purchase seconds on principal residences with a rate spread, 5,589 (6.1%) are at 3.5 points or more. Because the HPML definition covers closed-end loans only, open-end lines are outside it; 395 of 23,798 lines with a spread are at 3.5 or more, which we show only for scale.

Piggyback against mortgage insurance: a worked example (our arithmetic)

Take a $500,000 purchase with $50,000 down. Two ways to get there:

  • 80/10/10: a $400,000 first lien at 6.5% for 30 years (the 2025 median for first liens at about 80% with a second behind), and a $50,000 second at 7.00% (the median above 0% of the 80/10/10-shaped seconds, rounded).
  • 90% first lien: a $450,000 loan at 6.625% for 30 years (the 2025 median for first liens at 90.5% to 95.5% with no second), plus mortgage insurance at 0.34% a year of the original amount. Enact Holdings' 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 says: “The net earned premium rate was 0.34% for the nine months ended September 30, 2026.” That is an average across its whole book and net of ceded premium, not a quote; your price depends on your credit score and the insurer's rate card. For how insurers report it, see our page on private mortgage insurance and its cancellation.
StructureFirst lien payment (principal and interest)Second lien paymentMortgage insuranceTotal per month
80/10/10, second for 15 years$2,528.27$449.41$0$2,977.69
80/10/10, second for 30 years$2,528.27$332.65$0$2,860.92
90% first lien with mortgage insurance$2,881.40None$127.50$3,008.90

With the 15-year second the 80/10/10 is $31.21 a month below the insured loan; with the 30-year second it is $147.98 below, but the second then costs $69,754.45 in interest over 30 years against $30,894.54 over 15. If the second were 9.00% for 15 years (the 8% to 9.99% band holds 22.3% of closed-end seconds), its payment would be $507.13, the total $3,035.41 and the insured loan would be $26.51 cheaper. Mortgage insurance is charged until it is cancelled or the loan ends (see the page linked above), and Enact reports a primary persistency rate of 81% for the third quarter of 2026. So the comparison turns on the second's rate and term, the insurance quote and how long you keep the loan. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

What a reader can do with this

  1. Ask for both structures in writing on the same day: a first lien at 80% with a named second, and a 90% first lien with the mortgage insurance quote. The Loan Estimates show the second lien's rate, term and costs, which HMDA does not.
  2. Check who makes the second. In 2025 data, piggyback-type seconds are concentrated in a few credit unions and regional banks; the large mortgage companies' purchase seconds are mostly small (a median of $15,000). If the first-lien lender does not make the second, two lenders must approve you.
  3. Read the second's terms against the rules above: a balloon inside five years or negative amortization is not acceptable behind a Fannie Mae first lien, and a seller-financed second well below market rates can be treated as a sales concession.
  4. Test the payment at a higher rate for the second. The closed-end median above 0% is 7.55%, and 22.3% of closed-end seconds are between 8% and 9.99%; an open-end line floats, with a median starting rate of 7.4%.
  5. Compare with assistance if you qualify: a second behind a first lien of 90% or more with a 0% rate is a different product, covered on our page on down payment assistance. For a line of credit opened after closing, see HELOC lenders ranked and the home equity loan page.

FAQ

Sources, read November 22, 2026: FFIEC and CFPB, 2025 HMDA data (Modified Loan Application Register, announced by the CFPB on March 31, 2026): HMDA Data Browser nationwide CSV (2025, subordinate liens, originated and denied; 2025 purchase first liens) and aggregation API; Regulation C, 12 CFR 1003.4 (eCFR, current to November 19, 2026); Regulation Z, 12 CFR 1026.35 (eCFR, current to November 19, 2026); Fannie Mae Selling Guide B2-1.2-02 (12/04/2018), B2-1.2-04 (08/06/2025) and B7-1-02 (08/07/2019); Freddie Mac, Home Possible Mortgage fact sheet (February 2026); Enact Holdings Corp., Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (accession 0001823529-26-000242). Medians, shares, implied first liens, denial rates and payments are our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.