CrowdfundedWealth

Down Payment Assistance in 2025 Federal Data: 103,306 Small Second Mortgages, 53% at 0% or No Rate

ResearchBy Jorge22 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Quick answer

As of November 18, 2026, the 2025 federal mortgage file (HMDA) holds 140,582 originated second mortgages on owner-occupied home purchases, and 103,306 of them look like down payment help: closed-end loans under $50,000, with a median of $15,000 (the $10,000 to $19,999 band) and a median combined loan-to-value of 100.2%. Of those 103,306, 44.2% report a 0% rate and 8.9% report no rate at all (53.1% together, our arithmetic), which is how deferred and forgivable seconds usually appear; 46.9% carry a rate, with a median of 7.625% and a median term of 120 months. In the same data 10.4% of the applications for these small seconds were denied (11,963 denied, our arithmetic), against 14.4% for first-lien purchase loans. The lenders that report them are mostly mortgage companies, not state agencies: no name in the 2025 HMDA filer list contains “housing finance agency” or a similar term. HUD’s handbook sets no maximum combined loan-to-value for a second lien from a governmental entity; Fannie Mae’s Community Seconds allow up to 105%. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Update alert · free

An email when the down payment assistance numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Key takeaways

  • HMDA has no field for down payment assistance, so the closest public screen is the owner-occupied purchase second lien: 140,582 originated in 2025, of which 112,493 were closed-end and 25,943 were open-end lines of credit (HELOC type), plus 2,146 where the open-end flag was reported as exempt (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records).
  • Closed-end seconds under $50,000 number 103,306 and look like assistance: 85.4% have a combined loan-to-value of 96.5% or more, 33.3% are in the under-$10,000 band and 54.4% in the $10,000 to $19,999 band (HMDA publishes loan amounts as the midpoint of a $10,000 band, so the median of $15,000 is a band, not an exact amount).
  • 53.1% of those small seconds report a 0% rate or no rate; the other 46.9% have a median rate of 7.625% and a median term of 120 months, against 360 months for the 0% and no-rate group. A 0% second carries no monthly payment but is still a lien that is repaid when you sell or refinance, unless the program forgives it.
  • Of 4,778 institution names in the 2025 HMDA filer list, none contains “housing”, “finance agency”, “development authority”, “HFA” or similar. The 10 largest reporters, all lenders, account for 39.5% of the 103,306 loans (our arithmetic), and in Iowa one credit union reports 29.2% of the state’s small seconds.
  • Seconds per 1,000 first-lien owner-occupied purchases run from 4.9 in New York and 18.5 in Michigan to 90.7 in Connecticut and 165.1 in New Mexico (our arithmetic; the nationwide figure is 34.6), so where you buy changes how common the product is.
  • HUD Handbook 4000.1 (transmittal August 13, 2025) says there is “no maximum Combined Loan-to-Value (CLTV)” for secondary financing from a governmental entity, but no balloon payment inside 10 years; Fannie Mae’s Community Seconds guide (B5-5.1-01, 11/04/2026) caps combined loan-to-value at 105% and the second’s rate at 2 points above the first mortgage.

CSV · 124 rows

Down payment assistance in 2025 HMDA: second liens on home purchases by amount, rate, combined LTV, lender and state, with HUD and Fannie Mae rules

Counts and denial rates for 2025 owner-occupied purchase second liens, amount bands, interest-rate classes, terms, the 20 largest reporting lenders, 25 states, a first-lien comparison, and the HUD and Fannie Mae rule values.

What a “second lien for a home purchase” in HMDA can and cannot tell you

HMDA is the federal file in which mortgage lenders report each application and loan. The CFPB said on March 31, 2026 that the 2025 loan-level data were available on the FFIEC platform for about 4,768 filers. It records the lien status, the amount, the rate, the combined loan-to-value ratio and the lender, but it has no field that says “down payment assistance”, and it does not link a second lien to its first. Everything below is therefore a screen, and we say where it can mislead.

Our filter: loan purpose “home purchase”, occupancy “principal residence”, lien status “subordinate lien”, action “loan originated” or “application denied”. The denial rate is denied divided by originated plus denied (our arithmetic); the extract has no withdrawn or incomplete files. As a check, the Data Browser’s own count for all originated second liens of every purpose and occupancy was 1,558,203, the same number our stream of the file produced.

That leaves 140,582 originated loans, and they are not all assistance. About 18% (25,943) are lines of credit that a buyer opens at closing next to the first mortgage; their median amount is $175,000 and their median combined loan-to-value is 75.0%, which is a different product. The closed-end loans (112,493) include conventional “piggyback” seconds (a bank lends 10% behind an 80% first mortgage), seller-financed seconds and genuine assistance. Cutting to closed-end loans under $50,000 gives 103,306 loans, 73.5% of all purchase seconds, and a profile that fits assistance: 95.5% are reported with loan type conventional and 4.3% as USDA. Only 182 are reported as FHA and 2 as VA, because HMDA’s loan type describes the second lien itself, not the FHA or VA first mortgage it sits behind. The piggyback seconds that remain in the group are the main reason the figures below are a ceiling for assistance, not a count of it.

Cut of 2025 owner-occupied purchase second liensOriginatedDeniedDenial rateMedian amountMedian combined LTV
All purchase seconds140,58229,88217.53%$15,000100.0% closed-end, 75.0% open-end
Open-end (line of credit)25,943not split outnot split out$175,00075.0%
Closed-end, any amount112,493not split outnot split out$15,000100.0%
Closed-end under $50,000 (our screen for assistance)103,30611,96310.38%$15,000100.2%

Loan amounts in the public file are reported at the midpoint of a $10,000 band: in our 103,306 loans every amount ends in 5,000. So “$15,000” means a loan between $10,000 and $19,999, and the real median could be anywhere in that range. Combined loan-to-value is as the lender reported it; two large reporters have a median of 5.00 in the field, which cannot be right for a $15,000 second on a typical home, so we do not rely on the ratio for individual lenders.

How big the seconds are, and what rate they carry

The amount bands show how small these loans are. One in three is under $10,000 and nearly nine in ten are under $20,000. Compare that with the larger sums state programs advertise (our Florida page lists up to $35,000): amounts of $30,000 or more are 3.0% of what lenders report.

Amount band (HMDA midpoint)LoansShare of 103,306 (our arithmetic)
$5,000 (under $10,000)34,37133.3%
$15,000 ($10,000 to $19,999)56,18754.4%
$25,000 ($20,000 to $29,999)9,6269.3%
$35,000 ($30,000 to $39,999)2,0842.0%
$45,000 ($40,000 to $49,999)1,0381.0%

The interest-rate field splits the group in two. A 0% rate or no rate is typical of the deferred or forgivable second that a state or city program funds. A positive rate is typical of an amortizing second or a piggyback.

Rate fieldLoansShare (our arithmetic)Median termMedian combined LTV
Reported as 0%45,70444.2%360 months100.4%
Rate not applicable (NA)9,1558.9%360 months100.8%
Positive rate (median 7.625%, middle half 6.125% to 8.875%)48,44746.9%120 months100.0%

Terms back this up. 43,075 of the 103,306 loans (41.7%) have a 360-month term, the usual length of a deferred second that runs alongside the first mortgage, and 35,559 (34.4%) have a 120-month term, the usual length of an amortizing second. Only 7.4% have a combined loan-to-value under 50%, so almost all of these loans sit on top of a first mortgage that already covers most of the price. In that group 85.4% have a combined loan-to-value of at least 96.5% and 72.0% are at 100% or more (our arithmetic). Compare the first liens: the median combined loan-to-value of all owner-occupied first-lien purchases was 90.0%, and for FHA first liens it was 96.5%, with 78.9% of FHA loans at 96.5% or more. A combined ratio above 100% means the loans together exceed the reported value, which happens when closing costs are rolled in. Our average down payment page shows what first-lien buyers put down at the median.

Who reports these loans: mortgage companies, not agencies

State housing finance agencies, cities and nonprofits fund much of the assistance, and a reader would expect to find them in this file. We did not. We searched the 4,778 institution names in the 2025 HMDA filer list for “housing”, “finance agency”, “development authority”, “HFA”, “redevelopment”, “habitat”, “homeownership” and “DCA” and found no match. The lenders that report the seconds are the lenders that close the first mortgage. That fits how the programs are described: the buyer applies through a participating lender, which originates the first loan and records the assistance. HMDA does not say who funded a second lien, so we cannot tell which of these seconds came from an agency and which from the lender itself.

819 lenders reported at least one small closed-end purchase second, 146 reported 100 or more and 70 reported 300 or more. The 10 largest account for 39.5% of the loans.

Lender (HMDA 2025 name)Small closed-end seconds originatedDenial rate on its secondsShare with 0% or no rateStates
Guild Mortgage Company8,3446.0%65.2%49
Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation5,8538.0%61.1%44
Broker Solutions, Inc.5,2045.6%53.3%50
Movement Mortgage, LLC5,0486.4%40.5%46
CMG Mortgage, Inc.4,8497.9%70.2%49
Click n’ Close, Inc.2,7507.1%31.1%46
Guaranteed Rate, Inc.2,5069.8%68.5%45
loanDepot.com, LLC2,47016.1%24.9%48
PrimeLending, a PlainsCapital Company2,14710.3%78.1%44
Everett Financial, Inc.1,6677.8%67.8%36
DHI Mortgage Company, Ltd.1,30424.5%96.5%29
Neighborhood Loans, Inc.1,13212.2%92.5%20
GreenState Credit Union1,0672.3%0.0%6

These are counts of reported loans, not an endorsement and not a measure of quality: HMDA does not show which of these seconds belonged to an assistance program, whether the lender funded them, or what the buyer paid. The share with a 0% or no rate varies a lot, from 0.0% at the credit union to 96.5% at DHI Mortgage, so the same label “second mortgage” covers very different products. A lender’s denial rate on seconds also reflects who applies and which programs it offers, so a high figure is not a verdict. For the first mortgage that goes with the assistance, see our FHA versus conventional page.

By state: where these seconds are common

The biggest states by count are Texas, Florida and California, but the density per 1,000 first-lien purchases tells a different story. New Mexico had 165.1 small seconds per 1,000 owner-occupied first-lien purchases and Connecticut 90.7, against 4.9 in New York and 18.5 in Michigan. Utah’s seconds are almost all positive-rate loans (1.6% report 0% or no rate); Colorado’s are almost all deferred (95.6%). Seconds per 1,000 first-lien purchases are our arithmetic from the two HMDA 2025 extracts; the first-lien counts are all originated owner-occupied purchase loans, not only first-time buyers.

StateSmall seconds originatedPer 1,000 first-lien purchases0% or no rateMedian combined LTVDenial rateLargest reporter (share of the state)
Texas7,88925.568.8%100.15%12.1%CMG Mortgage (14.3%)
Florida7,07030.067.0%100.00%15.3%Click n’ Close (10.3%)
California5,77627.215.7%100.00%9.8%Golden Empire Mortgage (9.4%)
North Carolina4,89039.878.2%101.26%9.9%Atlantic Bay Mortgage Group (17.0%)
Georgia4,88745.168.8%100.00%12.0%Ameris Bank (10.9%)
Illinois4,60543.575.1%99.73%11.3%Neighborhood Loans (17.0%)
Washington3,68251.084.4%100.43%6.6%Guild Mortgage (14.7%)
Colorado3,68053.995.6%100.43%5.8%Guild Mortgage (18.1%)
Ohio2,97226.456.3%100.00%11.5%First Financial Bank (9.6%)
Virginia2,96133.37.0%100.00%9.9%Movement Mortgage (13.1%)
New Mexico2,943165.138.9%101.68%8.4%Guild Mortgage (22.0%)
Alabama2,83354.318.7%100.49%11.7%Guild Mortgage (9.2%)
Connecticut2,56190.771.8%100.50%9.5%Total Mortgage Services (24.9%)
Iowa2,44074.033.7%100.00%4.7%GreenState Credit Union (29.2%)
Utah2,39265.71.6%102.09%6.0%InterCap Lending (16.1%)
Michigan1,70918.557.5%100.18%12.2%Union Home Mortgage (12.3%)
New York4804.988.3%98.99%22.2%M&T Bank (37.9%)

New York is the outlier worth reading with care: only 480 small closed-end seconds appear in these records, 4.9 per 1,000 first-lien purchases, with 37.9% from one bank. Assistance there may be recorded in another way or with a different lien or amount, and HMDA does not let us say which. Do not read a low count as “no help in your state”. For program rules in one state, see our Florida first-time buyer page, which sets Florida’s four options against the same federal file.

What the 2025 denials say

11,963 applications for these small seconds were denied, 10.4% of 115,269 decisions (our arithmetic), lower than the 14.4% for first-lien owner-occupied purchase loans in the same year (502,661 denied against 2,984,324 originated) and the 13.1% for FHA first liens. The principal denial reason on the application was the debt-to-income ratio for 3,887 of them (32.5%), then “other” for 2,181, credit history for 1,865, collateral for 1,427 and unverifiable information for 850. The lower rate is not evidence that the seconds are easy to get: a buyer whose first mortgage is declined never reaches the second, so many failures show up in the first-lien count, and a lender can pre-screen before taking an application. What the denial reasons do show is that a debt-to-income ratio that is too high is the most common stated cause, even when the assistance itself carries no payment.

HUD’s rules for assistance behind an FHA loan

Assistance paired with an FHA first mortgage is typically a second lien held by a government body or a nonprofit. HUD Handbook 4000.1 (transmittal of August 13, 2025) says that financing is “not considered a Gift or a grant even if it does not require regular payments or has other features forgiving the debt.” That wording applies to any financing that creates a lien on the property, so a silent second is secondary financing in HUD’s terms, not a gift.

For a second lien made or held by a governmental entity, the handbook says FHA will insure the first mortgage provided that, among other conditions:

  • the secondary financing is disclosed at the time of application;
  • the payments on the second are included in the total mortgage payment;
  • the insured first mortgage does not exceed the FHA nationwide limit for the area;
  • the second does not result in cash back to the borrower except for a refund of earnest money or costs paid outside closing; and
  • the second lien does not provide for a balloon payment within 10 years from the date of execution.

The handbook adds: “There is no maximum Combined Loan-to-Value (CLTV) for secondary financing loans provided by Governmental Entities or HOPE grantees.” It also says assistance from a governmental entity may be used to meet the borrower’s minimum required investment (3.5 percent of the adjusted value), whereas for a HUD-approved nonprofit’s second the secondary financing “may not be used to meet the Borrower’s MRI”. That difference is why a reader should ask who holds the second lien, not only how large it is. HMDA’s 85.4% of loans at 96.5% or higher combined loan-to-value matches an FHA first mortgage plus a second.

Fannie Mae’s Community Seconds for conventional loans

For conventional loans, Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (B5-5.1-01, version of 11/04/2026) says “Fannie Mae does not purchase Community Seconds loans; however, first lien mortgages that are originated with this type of subordinate financing are eligible for purchase.” The guide’s conditions on the second include these:

  • the provider must be one of a short list: a federal agency; a state, county or similar political subdivision (including a housing finance agency) or local government; a 501(c)(3) nonprofit; a regional Federal Home Loan Bank under an affordable housing program; an employer; or a federally recognized tribe or its designated housing entity;
  • it must fund only the down payment, closing costs, renovations or a permanent rate buydown, and the guide says the loan may not be funded in any way through the first lien “such as premium pricing”;
  • “The maximum CLTV is 105% with a Community Seconds loan, unless the first lien mortgage has an independent CLTV cap”;
  • the mortgage must be a one- to four-unit principal residence, and for a one-unit home with a loan-to-value above 80% no minimum contribution from the borrower’s own funds is required, while for a two- to four-unit home the guide asks for 5% of the borrower’s own funds;
  • “The Community Seconds loan must be a fixed-rate loan and the interest rate may not be more than 2% (200 basis points) higher than the initial note rate of the first lien mortgage”;
  • when repayment is deferred for five years or more, the lender does not have to count a monthly payment in the debt-to-income ratio, and when deferred for less than five years it must count the payment due after the deferral ends.

Repayment “may be structured at the provider’s discretion”, and the guide lists forgiving all or part of the debt over time as one permitted example. The guide also states that a Community Seconds provider “must not be the property seller or other interested party in the transaction”. Median combined loan-to-value in our screen is 100.2% and 72.0% of loans are at 100% or more, inside both the 105% conventional cap and HUD’s no-maximum rule.

A worked example (our arithmetic)

Take a $300,000 purchase with an FHA first mortgage. HUD’s minimum required investment of 3.5% is $10,500, and the first mortgage is $289,500. Suppose a program lends $15,000 behind it, to cover the $10,500 and $4,500 of costs, where the program allows closing costs.

  • If the second is 0% and deferred (the 53.1% case): no monthly payment, and $15,000 is due when you sell, refinance, or stop living there, unless the program forgives part of it each year.
  • If the second is amortizing at HMDA’s median positive rate of 7.625% over 120 months: the payment is $179.03 a month, you repay $21,484, and $6,484 of that is interest. HUD’s handbook says the payment goes into the total mortgage payment and Fannie Mae’s guide has the lender count it, so it also reduces how much first mortgage you qualify for.
  • Fannie Mae’s rate cap: with a first mortgage at 6.5%, a Community Seconds loan could not exceed 8.5%.

The 0% deferred second looks free, but it is a lien: it comes out of the proceeds when you sell, and refinancing the first mortgage normally needs the second lienholder to agree to stay behind it (Fannie Mae’s guide calls this a resubordination agreement for limited cash-out refinances). If your first-year plan includes a quick sale, add the second to the cost of leaving.

What a reader can do with this

  1. Ask which second lien you are being offered. Ask whether it is 0% deferred, forgivable over time or amortizing, who holds it (a government body or a nonprofit), and what triggers repayment. Our data say 46.9% of small seconds carry a rate and a median term of 120 months, so “assistance” does not always mean “no payment”.
  2. Use the lender list as a starting point, not a recommendation. In your state a handful of lenders report a large share of these loans. Ask the lender whether the program you want requires its participation, and compare the first-mortgage rate and costs, not only the assistance.
  3. Check the total, not only the second. A combined loan-to-value of 100% means almost no cash of your own; the first mortgage’s insurance and rate still apply. Our FHA versus conventional page compares the two first-mortgage types.
  4. Ask for the repayment terms in writing before the appraisal: recapture on sale in the first years, the due date, and what happens if you rent the home out.
  5. Do not read the absence of a state agency in this file as a gap in your state’s help. Agency programs are visible in the lender’s records, not under the agency’s name.

FAQ

Sources, read November 18, 2026: FFIEC HMDA Data Browser, 2025 nationwide loan-level data (lien status 2, home purchase, principal residence, actions 1 and 3; aggregation API cross-check for lien status 2, action 1; data fields documentation) and the 2025 HMDA filer list; CFPB announcement of March 31, 2026, “2025 HMDA Data on Mortgage Lending Now Available”; HUD, FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook 4000.1 (transmittal of August 13, 2025), section II.A on secondary financing and the minimum required investment; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B5-5.1-01, Community Seconds (11/04/2026). All shares, medians, per-1,000 figures and the payment example are our arithmetic from those records.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.