CrowdfundedWealth

PMI 2026: Six Insurers Hold $1.63 Trillion in Force; 45.8% of Buyers Owe Over 80%

ResearchBy Jorge19 min read6 SEC filings cited

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Quick answer

Private mortgage insurance (PMI) comes off by law when your balance is first scheduled to reach 78% of the home's original value, and you can ask for it to be cancelled at 80%; the six insurers that write it reported $1.63 trillion of insurance in force at September 30, 2026, and between 79.2% and 83.3% of it was still on their books a year later. Persistency of 79.2% to 83.3% means roughly one policy in five ended within twelve months (our arithmetic). In the 2025 federal mortgage data, 45.8% of conventional owner-occupied purchase loans had a combined loan-to-value ratio above 80%, the range where insurance is usually required. On October 22, 2026 an executive order told the housing agency to consider a pilot for cancelling PMI automatically, but only on mortgages made after the pilot starts. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Update alert · free

An email when the private mortgage insurance numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Key takeaways

  • The six U.S. private mortgage insurers reported primary insurance in force of $307.3 billion (MGIC), $285.7 billion (Radian), $285.5 billion (Arch, U.S. primary), $275.1 billion (Enact), $250.1 billion (Essent) and $229.7 billion (NMI) at September 30, 2026. The sum is $1,633 billion (our arithmetic; each company defines the line a little differently).
  • Persistency, the share of insurance still in force after twelve months, runs from 79.2% (Arch) to 83.3% (Essent). MGIC fell to 82.5% from 85.0% a year earlier and NMI to 80.8% from 83.9%: more policies are ending.
  • Insurers disclose premium rates on their whole book, not on one borrower: Essent 0.40% gross and 0.34% net, Enact 0.33% net, NMI 0.27% net, and direct yields of 37.9 basis points (MGIC) and 38.0 (Radian). Essent states that monthly premiums are based on the original mortgage amount, so the charge does not fall as you pay down the loan.
  • Three federal clocks and one agency test decide removal: request at 80% of original value, automatic termination at 78%, final termination at the midpoint of the loan term (12 U.S.C. 4902), and for Fannie Mae loans a current-value test of 75% or less after two to five years and 80% or less after five years (Servicing Guide B-8.1-04).
  • HMDA 2025 (our arithmetic): of 1,849,519 conventional, first-lien, owner-occupied purchase loans with a numeric combined loan-to-value ratio, 846,382 (45.8%) were above 80%. The median was exactly 80.0, and among loans above 80 the median was 95.0. By state the share runs from 32.6% in California to 60.1% in West Virginia.
  • The October 22, 2026 executive order's PMI pilot is limited by its own text to “mortgages made after the establishment of the pilot program”, and only if the FHFA Director finds it in the interest of the GSEs, the FHFA and the public. It does nothing for a loan you already have.

CSV · 135 rows

Private mortgage insurance, November 19, 2026: insurers' 10-Q figures, cancellation rules and 2025 HMDA loan-to-value shares

135 rows: six insurers' Q3 2026 10-Q figures with accession numbers, the Homeowners Protection Act and Fannie Mae thresholds, 2025 HMDA combined loan-to-value bands and state shares, and the worked cancellation example.

What the six insurers reported for the quarter ended September 30, 2026

Every private mortgage insurer in the country is a public company or a segment of one, so each files the same kind of quarterly numbers. We read all six Form 10-Q filings for the quarter ended September 30, 2026. The table puts the comparable lines side by side; the accession number under each name is the filing the row comes from.

Insurer (10-Q accession)Insurance in forceNew insurance written, Q312-month persistencyPremium rate or yieldDelinquency or default rate
MGIC Investment Corp (0000876437-26-000033)$307.3 billion (direct primary)$17.1 billion82.5% (85.0% a year earlier)37.9 bps direct; 31.2 bps net2.52% delinquent
Radian Group (0001193125-26-451985)$285.7 billion (primary)$14.7 billion81.2% (83.8% a year earlier)38.0 bps direct; 33.2 bps net2.7% default
Arch Capital, U.S. primary (0000947484-26-000152)$285.5 billion$13.6 billion79.2% (82.3% a year earlier)Not disclosed in the 10-Q2.20% in default
Enact Holdings (0001823529-26-000242)$275.1 billion (primary)$14.1 billion81% (83% a year earlier)0.33% net earned premium rate2.79% delinquent
Essent Group (0001448893-26-000032)$250.1 billion$12.1 billion (flow)83.3%0.40% gross; 0.34% net average premium rate2.75% default
NMI Holdings (0001547903-26-000045)$229.7 billion (primary)$13.6 billion80.8% (83.9% a year earlier)0.27% average net premium yield1.23% default

How to read it, with the limits stated:

  • Definitions differ. MGIC reports “direct primary” insurance in force, Arch reports its U.S. primary line, and the others report their primary portfolio. The $1,633 billion total and the $85.2 billion of Q3 new insurance written are sums of the six cells (our arithmetic); they are a size indicator, not an exact market total.
  • Premium figures are book averages. A yield in basis points is premiums earned divided by average insurance in force, so 37.9 bps is 0.379% a year. MGIC and Radian report direct (before reinsurance) and net figures; Essent, Enact and NMI report rates as a percentage. Your own rate depends on your credit score, down payment and the insurer's price card, none of which these filings publish.
  • Delinquency and default rates are not comparable one to one. NMI's 1.23% is 8,571 loans in default against 697,361 policies; Arch's 2.20% is the ending percentage of loans in default; MGIC calls its 2.52% the delinquency rate. They share a direction, and Enact's 2.79% and Essent's 2.75% are both above a year earlier (2.45% and 2.29%).
  • Arch gives no premium rate in the 10-Q we read, so that cell is empty rather than estimated.

The loan mix the insurers wrote this quarter shows who is buying PMI. At MGIC, 47.4% of Q3 primary new insurance written had a loan-to-value ratio of 90.01% to 95.00% and 15.0% was at 95.01% or above. At Arch the same two bands were 43.7% and 7.4%.

Why persistency fell

Persistency is the number that makes PMI a business: a policy that stays on the books pays a premium every month. Radian's 10-Q ties its decline from 83.8% to 81.2% to refinancing in early 2026, “particularly in the first quarter”, after mortgage rates fell. A refinance ends the old insurance policy, so for a borrower a drop in persistency is the same event as a payoff: the old PMI is gone, and a new loan with under 20% equity brings a new policy.

What a premium costs on a loan, and why it does not shrink

Essent's 10-Q explains the mechanics: “Monthly premium payments are based on the original mortgage amount rather than the amortized loan balance.” It also reports that monthly premium policies were 99% of its new insurance written in the first nine months of 2026. That has a practical meaning. If the premium is 0.40% of a $380,000 original loan, the charge is $1,520 a year, $126.67 a month, and it stays $126.67 in year ten when the balance has fallen to about $320,000 (our arithmetic, using Essent's gross average premium rate as an assumption, not a quote for any borrower).

The exception is lender-paid insurance. Freddie Mac's PMI handbook says “Lender-paid single premiums are not cancellable”; the cost sits in a higher rate or a fee and cannot be cancelled later. Check the Closing Disclosure to see which kind you have.

When PMI ends: the four rules, in order

RouteTriggerWhat you must doDocument
Automatic terminationBalance first scheduled to reach 78% of original value, if you are currentNothing; the servicer must end it, and Fannie Mae says the servicer must not charge a fee for processing an automatic termination12 U.S.C. 4902(b); Fannie Mae Servicing Guide B-8.1-04
Cancellation on request at 80%Balance first scheduled to reach 80% of original value, or actually reaches it by paymentsWritten request, good payment history, current payments, and evidence the value has not fallen below the original value and no subordinate lien12 U.S.C. 4902(a)
Final terminationMidpoint of the amortization period, if you are currentNothing12 U.S.C. 4902(c)
Current-value request (Fannie Mae loans)75% or less after two to five years; 80% or less after five years; 70% for investment propertyAsk the servicer; a property valuation (AVM, broker price opinion or appraisal) decides itFannie Mae Servicing Guide B-8.1-04

Three points that most guides skip:

  1. “Original value” is a defined term. The statute defines it as “the lesser of the sales price of the property securing the mortgage, as reflected in the contract, or the appraised value at the time at which the subject residential mortgage transaction was consummated.” A home that appraises above the price you paid does not help the schedule, and a home that goes up in price afterward does not change it either. Only the current-value route looks at today's price.
  2. “Good payment history” has two clocks. Under the statute you must not have a payment 30 days or more past due in the 12 months before the later of the cancellation date or your request, and none 60 days or more past due in the 12 months beginning 24 months before that date. Fannie Mae's servicing rule for a request states the same test as no payment 30 or more days past due in the last 12 months and none 60 or more days past due in the last 24 months.
  3. Servicers must stop charging within 30 days. The statute says no payments or premiums may be required “more than 30 days after the later of” the request or the date you meet the evidence requirements.

The current-value route in detail

Fannie Mae's Servicing Guide section B-8.1-04 (the section is dated May 15, 2019; the Guide was published as of October 14, 2026) sets this out for a one-unit principal residence or second home: the loan-to-value ratio must be “75% or less, if the seasoning of the mortgage loan is between two and five years” and “80% or less, if the seasoning of the mortgage loan is greater than five years.” For one- to four-unit investment properties and two- to four-unit principal residences the ratio must be 70% or less and the seasoning more than two years. If the two-year seasoning is waived because improvements raised the value, the ratio must be 80% or less. The servicer's decision rests on a valuation from Fannie Mae's servicing system, a broker price opinion or an appraisal.

Two more lines from the same section matter. The servicer “must not solicit a borrower for MI termination based on current value of the property”, so no one will remind you; you have to ask. And Fannie Mae's valuation in its system “will be updated after 120 days”.

Freddie Mac has parallel sections (8203.2 for loans under the Homeowners Protection Act and 8203.3 for the others), and its PMI handbook names section 8203.2(a) and (b) as the place for eligibility criteria. We could not retrieve the text of those sections, so we do not state Freddie Mac's current-value thresholds here. Ask your servicer which agency owns your loan.

Worked example: when does PMI come off a $380,000 loan? (our arithmetic)

Take a $400,000 home bought with 5% down: a $380,000 loan at an assumed 6.50% fixed for 30 years. Principal and interest is $2,401.86 a month. Original value is $400,000, so 80% is $320,000 and 78% is $312,000.

EventWhenBalancePMI paid to that point at 0.40%
Right to request cancellation (80% of $400,000 = $320,000)Month 124 (about ten years four months)$319,500$15,707
Automatic termination (78% = $312,000)Month 135 (about eleven years three months)$311,914$17,100
Midpoint of the 360-month termMonth 180Not reached; the 78% rule comes firstn/a

The schedule gives about eleven months between the day you may ask and the day it must happen, worth about $1,393 of premium at the assumed rate. Paying extra principal moves the dates: to be at $320,000 after month 24, when the balance is $371,221, would take a $51,221 lump sum.

The current-value route can be faster only if the home has risen enough. After 36 months the balance is $366,386; to reach the 75% test the value would have to be $488,514, 22.1% above the $400,000 price. After 60 months the balance is $355,722, and the 80% test needs $444,652, 11.2% above the price. If you are near one of those values, asking may save years of premium; if not, the schedule above wins. Ask the servicer what a valuation would cost you before you request one.

What 2025 mortgage data say about who carries PMI

The federal HMDA loan file has no field for mortgage insurance, so it cannot show who bought PMI. It does show combined loan-to-value (CLTV): the loan plus any second lien, divided by the property value. The 80% line is the usual dividing line, since Freddie Mac's handbook says its Charter “requires credit enhancement for any loans greater than 80% LTV”. We counted 2025 conventional, first-lien, owner-occupied, originated home-purchase loans (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records; data released by the CFPB on March 31, 2026; 134,899 loans with a CLTV of NA, Exempt or blank were set aside).

Combined loan-to-valueLoansShare of 1,849,519
80.00 or less1,003,13754.2%
80.01 to 85.0085,1244.6%
85.01 to 90.00211,77811.4%
90.01 to 95.00327,36517.7%
95.01 to 97.00133,3217.2%
Over 97.0088,7944.8%
Above 80 (all bands)846,38245.8%

The median CLTV was 80.0 and the median loan amount $345,000. The 25th percentile was 74.87 and the 75th 95.0; the 90th was 97.0. Among the 846,382 loans above 80, the median was 95.0. Another 407,101 loans (22.0%) sit at exactly 80, one dollar of equity from the line.

Two cautions. First, CLTV counts a second lien. A borrower who takes a first loan of 80% and a second of 10% shows a CLTV of 90 and may not carry PMI at all, so 45.8% is a ceiling on the share of loans that carried it, not a count of insured loans. Second, FHA, VA and USDA loans use their own insurance, fee or guarantee systems, not PMI: 96.5% of the FHA purchase loans in the same file, 89.4% of VA and 96.8% of USDA had a CLTV above 80, which is why we limited the count to conventional loans. For those programs see our page on FHA versus conventional loans.

By state

The share above 80% varies by market. The table lists the five states with the lowest and the highest shares among the 44 states with at least 5,000 loans in this filter, plus Florida and Texas.

StateConventional loansWith CLTV above 80Share
California151,05349,28432.6%
New Jersey50,22117,93635.7%
Montana5,6052,08337.2%
Washington51,59819,56037.9%
New York80,43430,53138.0%
Florida129,35355,02642.5%
Texas150,27570,92747.2%
Ohio76,41141,34654.1%
Indiana49,25626,97254.8%
Michigan67,74337,52155.4%
Iowa22,66512,90957.0%
West Virginia6,7424,05460.1%

HMDA does not say why the shares differ by state. For the down payment figures behind them, see our down payment calculator and state data.

The October 22, 2026 executive order

Three of the six insurers say in their Q3 10-Qs that the order “Decreasing Housing Costs for the American People” could change their business. The order itself says the FHFA Director, if the Director determines it to be in the best interests of the two housing finance companies, the agency and the public, shall direct them to set up a pilot that uses automated valuation models to find borrowers who appear to meet the requirements for cancelling mortgage insurance. Three limits are written into the text:

  • the pilot is “applicable only to mortgages made after the establishment of the pilot program”;
  • cancellation happens only if the borrower meets all other statutory, contractual and agency requirements;
  • servicers are to “notify borrowers promptly when mortgage insurance may be canceled under the pilot program”.

Essent calls it a provision directing the Director “to consider establishing a pilot program”, and Enact writes that the impact depends on the pilot's final design. As of November 19, 2026 we have found no FHFA announcement of the pilot's terms (our search, as of that date). Until there is one, nothing in the order changes the rules above for a loan you hold today.

What a reader can do with this

  • Find your dates. From your closing documents note the original value (the lesser of price and appraisal), your loan amount and term. Month 124 and month 135 in the example above are not general: your own 80% and 78% dates come from your amortization schedule,.
  • Ask in writing before the date. The right to cancel at 80% requires a written request; sending it a few months early is a way to be ready, since the statute lets cancellation happen on the cancellation date or any later date that you meet the conditions.
  • Run the current-value test once. If your home has risen sharply and you are two to five years in, compare your balance with the 75% line above before paying for a valuation.
  • Check whose loan it is. Whether Fannie Mae's or Freddie Mac's rules apply depends on who owns the loan; the servicer can tell you.
  • Do not pay a fee for automatic termination. Fannie Mae's guide says the servicer must not charge a fee for processing it.
  • If you itemize, the premium deduction has its own rules for 2026; see our page on the mortgage interest deduction and PMI.

FAQ

Sources, read November 19, 2026: Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 of MGIC Investment Corp (0000876437-26-000033), Radian Group (0001193125-26-451985), Essent Group (0001448893-26-000032), Enact Holdings (0001823529-26-000242), NMI Holdings (0001547903-26-000045) and Arch Capital Group (0000947484-26-000152); 12 U.S.C. 4901 and 4902 (Homeowners Protection Act of 1998); Fannie Mae Servicing Guide B-8.1-04, Termination of Conventional Mortgage Insurance; Freddie Mac Private Mortgage Insurance Handbook (September 2021); Executive Order "Decreasing Housing Costs for the American People" (October 22, 2026) and its White House fact sheet; CFPB, "2025 HMDA Data on Mortgage Lending Now Available" (March 31, 2026); FFIEC HMDA Data Browser, 2025 nationwide purchase-loan data (our arithmetic).

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.