CrowdfundedWealth

APR vs Interest Rate: 2025 HMDA Rate Spread and HPML by Lender

ResearchBy Jorge24 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Quick answer

As of November 22, 2026, the 2025 federal mortgage data (HMDA) show that the middle 30-year fixed-rate home-purchase loan on a principal residence had a rate spread of 0.164 percentage points over the average prime offer rate (APOR), and 60,682 of 2,491,580 classified loans (2.44%) were higher-priced mortgage loans (HPML) under 12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1). The interest rate sets your monthly principal and interest; the APR adds finance charges such as points and origination fees; and the spread HMDA records is the APR minus the APOR, not the APR minus your rate. By loan type the HPML share was 4.35% for FHA, 2.18% for conventional and 0.20% for VA, where 76.56% of loans had a negative spread. The share was 6.49% on loans under $100,000 and 1.63% on loans of $750,000 or more. Among 333 lenders with 1,000 or more such loans the median lender share was 1.22%, and 24 lenders were at 10% or more. On a $350,000 loan at 6.5% for 30 years, the APR is 6.5494% with the $1,790.72 median conventional origination charges and 6.738% with two points and $1,500 of other fees (our arithmetic). This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal, tax or lending advice.

Update alert · free

An email when the apr vs interest rate numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Key takeaways

  • The APR is a cost measure, not a second interest rate: the Loan Estimate says of it “Your costs over the loan term expressed as a rate. This is not your interest rate.” Points, loan fees and broker fees are in it; title insurance, appraisal and credit-report fees are out if bona fide and reasonable (12 CFR 1026.22, 1026.4, 1026.37(l)(2)).
  • HMDA rate_spread is the APR minus the average prime offer rate for a comparable loan on the day the rate was set (12 CFR 1003.4(a)(12)). In 2025 the median spread of 2,491,598 30-year fixed purchase loans was 0.164 points, the quartiles -0.187 and 0.532, and 37.31% of loans were below zero.
  • A loan is higher-priced when the spread reaches 1.5 points (first lien at or under the Freddie Mac limit), 2.5 points (above it) or 3.5 points (subordinate lien). In our 2025 file 60,682 loans (2.44%) cross that line: FHA 4.35%, conventional 2.18%, USDA 0.83%, VA 0.20% (our arithmetic).
  • Loan size matters: 6.49% of loans under $100,000 were HPML against 1.76% at $350,000 to under $500,000, because fixed fees weigh more on a small balance; our rough floor for the APR gap on conventional loans is 0.17 points under $100,000 and 0.048 points at $350,000 to under $500,000.
  • Paying points lowers the spread rather than raising it: conventional loans with 2 or more points had a median spread of -0.28 and a median rate of 5.998%, against 0.174 and 6.625% with none.
  • By lender the HPML share runs from zero (19 lenders) to 98.94% at First National Bank of America; the top of the list is made of lenders with median rates of 6.75% to 8.875% (our reading: non-QM, portfolio and manufactured-home lending), while the two largest lenders sit at 0.76% (Rocket Mortgage) and 1.77% (United Wholesale Mortgage).
  • On $350,000 at 6.5% the monthly payment is $2,212.24 whatever the fees; two points plus $1,500 push the APR to 6.738%. Fees alone cannot make this loan HPML: with an assumed APOR of 6.30% it would take $42,689 of finance charges (our arithmetic).

CSV · 289 rows

APR vs interest rate: 2025 HMDA rate spread and higher-priced mortgage loan share by loan type, loan size, lender and state

Median rate spread, interest rate, points and HPML share of 2.5 million 30-year fixed purchase loans by loan type, loan amount, points paid, 30 lenders and 12 states, the Regulation Z thresholds and the $350,000 worked example.

Interest rate and APR: two different questions

The interest rate answers “what does the lender charge on the balance each year?” It sets the monthly principal and interest. The APR answers “what do all the credit costs add up to, as a yearly rate?” Regulation Z defines it in 12 CFR 1026.22(a)(1) as “a measure of the cost of credit, expressed as a yearly rate, that relates the amount and timing of value received by the consumer to the amount and timing of payments made.” The Loan Estimate puts the two side by side and warns that the APR is not the rate: under 12 CFR 1026.37(l)(2) the form must say “Your costs over the loan term expressed as a rate. This is not your interest rate.”

The money that moves the APR above the note rate is the finance charge, which 12 CFR 1026.4(a) defines as “the cost of consumer credit as a dollar amount.” Not every closing cost is in it:

ChargeIn the finance charge, and so in the APR?Where the rule is
Discount points, loan fees and similar chargesYes12 CFR 1026.4(b)(3)
Mortgage broker feesYes, even if you chose the broker12 CFR 1026.4(a)(3)
Insurance or a guarantee that protects the lender against your default (for example FHA or private mortgage insurance premiums)Yes12 CFR 1026.4(b)(5)
Title examination, title insurance, property surveyNo, if bona fide and reasonable in amount12 CFR 1026.4(c)(7)(i)
Notary and credit-report feesNo, same condition12 CFR 1026.4(c)(7)(iii)
Appraisal and pre-closing inspectionsNo, same condition12 CFR 1026.4(c)(7)(iv)
Application fees charged to every applicantNo12 CFR 1026.4(c)(1)
Seller pointsNo12 CFR 1026.4(c)(5)

Because the APR treats those charges as if they were paid out of the amount you borrow, a loan with fees has an APR above its note rate and a loan with no finance charges has the same APR and rate. The disclosed APR is allowed some slack: 12 CFR 1026.22(a)(2) considers it accurate if it is within 1/8 of 1 percentage point of the correct figure. Two caveats from our own numbers further down: the APR gap is small on a large loan, and it says nothing about how long you will keep the loan, because the APR assumes you hold it for the full term.

From the APR to HMDA rate spread

HMDA does not publish the APR. It publishes the rate spread, defined in 12 CFR 1003.4(a)(12)(i) as “the difference between the covered loan's annual percentage rate and the average prime offer rate for a comparable transaction as of the date the interest rate is set.” The average prime offer rate (APOR) is, under 12 CFR 1026.35(a)(2), “an annual percentage rate that is derived from average interest rates, points, and other loan pricing terms currently offered to consumers by a representative sample of creditors for mortgage transactions that have low-risk pricing characteristics,” and the Bureau publishes it in a table “updated at least weekly.” In plain words: the spread is how far this borrower's APR sits above (or below) the going APR for a comparable, low-risk loan on the day the rate was locked. It is not the gap between your APR and your own interest rate.

That is why the spread can be negative. 37.31% of the 2,491,598 loans in our file are below zero, including 76.56% of VA loans: their APR was lower than the APOR for a comparable loan. A rate bought down with points shows it clearly:

Conventional loans, points paidLoansMedian rate spreadMedian interest rateHPML share
no points reported or zero754,6620.1746.625%2.21%
under 1 point469,3360.2056.625%1.90%
1 to under 2 points199,0280.1636.5%2.78%
2 or more points118,512-0.285.998%2.08%

Conventional loans where the borrower paid 2 or more points (of the loan amount, our arithmetic from the discount points field) had a median interest rate of 5.998% and a median spread of -0.28: the lower rate pulled the APR below the APOR even after the points were counted. Discount points were reported on 1,342,932 of the 2,502,066 loans, so the points columns describe only the loans that reported them.

What 2.5 million 2025 loans show: rate spread by loan type

We read every originated 30-year fixed-rate home-purchase loan on a principal residence in the 2025 HMDA data (first lien, closed-end, not reverse, not business purpose): 2,502,066 loans, of which 2,491,598 report a numeric rate spread; the other 10,468 report NA or exempt and are left out. HMDA 2025 data were released on March 31, 2026. The HPML test below is our arithmetic: spread of 1.5 or more for loans HMDA flags as conforming, 2.5 or more for nonconforming, and 18 loans with an undetermined limit left out.

Loan typeLoans keptMedian rate spread (points over APOR)Share with negative spreadHPML loansHPML shareMedian interest rateMedian discount points paid
All loan types2,502,0660.16437.31%60,6822.44%6.5%$2,599
Conventional1,547,6390.16134.89%33,6422.18%6.625%$2,467
FHA605,0350.45123.28%26,1324.35%6.25%$2,912
VA316,433-0.3576.56%6390.20%6.125%$2,722
USDA32,9590.21530.67%2690.83%6.25%$1,585

FHA loans carry the largest spreads (median 0.451) and the largest HPML share (4.35%); the FHA insurance premium is part of the finance charge and the APOR it is compared with is for a low-risk loan, so an FHA loan can sit above the benchmark with an ordinary note rate (our reading; HMDA does not show the cause). VA loans sit below it: a median of -0.35 and 0.20% higher-priced. The whole distribution:

Rate spread (points over APOR)All loan typesConventionalFHAVA
below 037.31%34.89%23.28%76.56%
0 to under 0.535.86%41.55%30.13%18.31%
0.5 to under 1.018.39%16.81%29.91%3.91%
1.0 to under 1.55.94%4.48%12.34%1.02%
1.5 to under 2.52.12%1.71%4.23%0.20%
2.5 or more0.38%0.56%0.12%0.00%

Only 2.12% of all loans fall in the band 1.5 to under 2.5 and 0.38% reach 2.5 or more; 91.56% sit below 1.0 (our arithmetic).

What makes a loan higher-priced, and what it triggers

The line is drawn by 12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1), and crossing it changes what the lender must do for a loan on your principal dwelling:

Test or dutyWhat the regulation saysWhere
Higher-priced line, first lien at or under the Freddie Mac limitAPR exceeds the average prime offer rate by 1.5 or more percentage points12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1)(i)
Higher-priced line, first lien above that limit (jumbo)2.5 or more percentage points12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1)(ii)
Higher-priced line, subordinate lien3.5 or more percentage points12 CFR 1026.35(a)(1)(iii)
Escrow accountA first-lien higher-priced loan needs an escrow account for property taxes and required insurance before closing; the consumer can ask to cancel it no earlier than five years after closing12 CFR 1026.35(b)(1) and (b)(3)(i)(B)
AppraisalA written appraisal from a certified or licensed appraiser who makes a physical visit of the interior12 CFR 1026.35(c)(3)(i)
Second appraisalTwo appraisals on a purchase if the seller acquired the home 90 or fewer days earlier and the price rose by more than 10 percent, or 91 to 180 days earlier and by more than 20 percent12 CFR 1026.35(c)(4)(i)
Notice and copiesA written statement at application about the appraisal, and a copy of any appraisal12 CFR 1026.35(c)(5) and (c)(6)

The rule applies to closed-end loans secured by a principal dwelling; investor and second-home loans are outside it, which is why our file keeps principal residences only. Our reading of what it means for a borrower: an HPML is a loan the regulation considers expensive enough to require an escrow account and a closer look at the property value, not a loan the regulation forbids.

Why small loans cross the line more often

Fees are mostly fixed dollars, so they weigh more on a small loan. The same pattern shows up in the 2025 file:

Loan amountLoans with a rate spreadMedian rate spreadHPML share, all loan typesHPML share, conventional onlyEstimated APR minus note rate, conventional (our floor)
under $100,00050,2640.3936.49%4.63%0.17 points
$100,000 to under $200,000380,3890.2854.00%2.97%0.101 points
$200,000 to under $350,000964,6320.1852.41%2.08%0.068 points
$350,000 to under $500,000597,2020.1141.76%1.83%0.048 points
$500,000 to under $750,000361,6310.081.74%1.96%0.031 points
$750,000 and over137,4800.0651.63%1.74%not estimated

The last column is our own rough estimate: for conventional loans that report origination charges, we treat origination charges minus lender credits as the finance charge and solve for the APR of a 30-year loan at the reported rate (blank lender credits count as zero). It leaves out mortgage insurance, prepaid interest and other finance charges, so it is a floor, not the disclosed APR. Across 1,539,431 conventional loans the median estimated gap is 0.062 points, from 0.025 at the lower quartile to 0.135 at the upper quartile, on a median proxy finance charge of $1,791. In the top band the share with a spread of 1.5 or more is larger than the HPML share because jumbo loans need 2.5 to be higher-priced.

HPML share by lender

We rank no one. The table gives the share of each lender's own 2025 loans in our filter that were higher-priced, next to the lender's median rate and points, because the share mostly tracks what the lender sells. A lender qualifies with 1,000 or more of these loans and a numeric rate spread on at least 90% of them: 333 of 335 do. Two lenders with 1,000 or more loans are left out for reporting the spread on fewer loans: Click n' Close (413 of 3,495 loans) and Directions Equity (1,189 of 1,503). We checked the first against a lender-level download from the Data Browser and got the same counts, so the gap is in what the lender reported, not in our extract. The median lender share is 1.22%; 46 of the 333 are at 5% or more, 24 at 10% or more, 146 under 1% and 19 have none.

The 20 largest lenders in the filter:

Lender (name as filed, short form)30-year fixed purchase loans keptHPML shareMedian rate spreadMedian interest rateMedian discount pointsFHA or VA share of these loans
United Wholesale Mortgage204,3901.77%0.2066.5%$2,34636.2%
Rocket Mortgage115,9090.76%0.2026.5%$2,72827.5%
CrossCountry Mortgage79,7303.46%0.4216.625%$3,17535.5%
Mortgage Research Center66,5190.35%-0.1856.25%$1,17896.5%
DHI Mortgage Company60,6980.03%-1.3474.99%$3,52771.6%
Guild Mortgage57,2442.94%0.3156.5%$2,97542.0%
Fairway Independent Mortgage52,4572.65%0.376.625%$2,45837.5%
CMG Mortgage44,3031.90%0.1666.5%$2,94941.9%
Guaranteed Rate42,1181.66%0.2266.575%$2,23032.1%
Lennar Mortgage41,8850.11%-1.4444.75%$5,72357.1%
JPMorgan Chase Bank40,5660.35%-0.0426.49%$2,1205.2%
Movement Mortgage35,9321.41%0.2666.562%$2,38140.7%
loanDepot.com32,0081.61%0.0296.25%$3,61949.1%
Broker Solutions30,3045.21%0.5436.625%$2,89346.4%
PennyMac Loan Services27,8270.57%0.1796.499%$1,97636.1%
Navy Federal Credit Union25,8370.64%-0.4126.125%$2,94455.2%
Union Home Mortgage22,6972.36%0.3866.625%$1,68833.1%
NewRez21,1822.07%0.2016.5%$1,92244.8%
U.S. Bank19,4490.48%0.0516.5%$1,09013.8%
American Pacific Mortgage18,2765.02%0.486.625%$3,38345.1%

The builder affiliates (DHI Mortgage Company, Lennar Mortgage, Pulte Mortgage) combine low median rates (4.99%, 4.75% and 5.5%) with high median points ($3,527, $5,723 and $8,633) and near-zero HPML shares; that fits a builder paying to buy rates down, but HMDA does not say who paid (our reading). Rocket Mortgage has 0.76% and CrossCountry Mortgage 3.46% with median interest rates of 6.5% and 6.625%, so the difference is in the spread over the APOR, which also reflects the day each rate was set and the borrower mix.

The ten highest shares among the 333 qualifying lenders:

Lender (name as filed, short form)30-year fixed purchase loans keptHPML shareMedian rate spreadMedian interest rateMedian discount pointsFHA or VA share of these loans
First National Bank of America1,88898.94%2.688.875%not reported0.0%
21st Mortgage Corporation1,67498.69%2.1518.56%not reported0.0%
Champions Funding2,24270.03%2.2218.375%$3,3610.0%
Commerce Home Mortgage4,19435.15%0.9327.25%$3,40019.7%
Citadel Servicing1,67431.36%1.0247.375%$2,5970.0%
Deephaven Mortgage1,34330.45%1.0337.5%$4,0000.0%
HomeXpress Mortgage1,02727.65%1.0357.375%$2,06010.9%
LendSure Mortgage1,05827.13%1.187.5%$4,2690.0%
Cake Mortgage1,18826.35%1.1337.49%$3,6622.0%
OCMBC6,55522.68%0.6586.75%$2,24142.9%

These are lenders whose median interest rates are 6.75% to 8.875%, and seven of the ten make 2% or less of these loans as FHA or VA: loans priced far above what the APOR measures for low-risk borrowers, which is what non-QM, bank-portfolio and manufactured-home lending look like (our reading; see our non-QM lenders ranked page for that market). A high share describes a product mix, not a judgment: HMDA has no credit score, so it cannot show whether the price matches the risk. The rate is not the whole story either: Vanderbilt Mortgage and Finance has a median rate of 6.125% and an HPML share of 12.68%.

By state

Loan size, loan type and lender mix change by place, so the share does too. States and territories with 5,000 or more loans in the filter, six highest and six lowest:

State or territoryLoans keptHPML shareMedian rate spreadMedian interest rate
Puerto Rico10,0386.27%0.026%
Ohio93,5653.79%0.296.625%
New Mexico14,9313.61%0.2056.5%
Louisiana28,6533.47%0.2516.5%
West Virginia10,8273.35%0.3096.5%
Nevada29,1953.35%0.1046.375%
Nebraska16,1861.03%0.1136.5%
Colorado59,0900.95%0.036.375%
Montana7,8450.88%0.0816.375%
Alaska5,9740.82%0.0026.25%
Idaho20,3260.76%0.0496.25%
South Dakota6,9080.71%-0.0236.25%

Puerto Rico, Ohio, New Mexico and Louisiana are at the top; South Dakota, Idaho, Alaska and Montana at the bottom. The state table describes where loans were priced above the benchmark in 2025, not where borrowers paid more: a state with small loans and many FHA loans will show a higher share for that reason alone. Our mortgage rates by state page gives the median rate and points by state.

A worked example: how fees push the APR above the rate (our arithmetic)

Take a $350,000 30-year fixed loan at 6.5%. The monthly principal and interest is $2,212.24 in every row of the table, because the note rate fixes it: 350,000 × (0.065 ÷ 12) ÷ (1 − (1 + 0.065 ÷ 12) to the power of −360). The APR is the rate that makes the present value of those 360 payments equal the amount actually financed, which is the loan minus the prepaid finance charges (the actuarial method of 12 CFR 1026.22(a)(1) and Appendix J).

Finance charges paid at closing (our arithmetic)Amount financedMonthly principal and interestAPRAPR minus note rate
None$350,000$2,212.246.5%0
$1,790.72 (HMDA 2025 median for conventional loans, origination charges less lender credits)$348,209.28$2,212.246.5494%0.0494 points
$5,000 (1 point plus $1,500 of other lender fees)$345,000$2,212.246.6389%0.1389 points
$8,500 (2 points plus $1,500)$341,500$2,212.246.738%0.238 points
$12,000 (3 points plus $1,500)$338,000$2,212.246.8387%0.3387 points

The second row uses the HMDA median for conventional loans, $1,790.72 of origination charges net of lender credits. Each additional point ($3,500) adds roughly 0.1 percentage point to the APR on a 30-year loan held to term. Now the link to the HPML line, with an invented APOR of 6.30% for the day the rate was set (an assumption for illustration, not a published figure): the threshold of 1.5 points means an APR of 7.80%. At a 6.5% rate, that would take $42,689 of finance charges, 12.2% of the loan. With $5,000 of fees, it takes a note rate of 7.6511% (payment $2,483.55). Fees alone rarely make a loan higher-priced (in our file, conventional loans with 2 or more points were HPML at 2.08% against 2.21% with none); a note rate well above the going rate does, which is why the lenders at the top of the table above price at 6.75% to 8.875%.

What HMDA can and cannot tell you about APR and rate spread

  • No APR. HMDA publishes the spread over APOR, not the APR or the APOR. Our APR-gap estimate in the loan-size table is a floor built from two fields; the disclosed APR on your Loan Estimate is the figure that counts.
  • The benchmark moves. APOR is set weekly for comparable loans. A spread of 0.2 in January and 0.2 in June are not the same rate; HMDA records the spread, and 2025 loans were priced in a year when rates moved.
  • Points are inside the spread. A bought-down rate can show a negative spread. Compare rate and points together, as in our discount points and lender credits page.
  • Our HPML count is an approximation. We apply the thresholds to HMDA rate_spread and to the conforming flag in the file; a lender runs its own higher-priced test at the time of the loan under 12 CFR 1026.35, so our share is a description of the data, not a compliance finding about any lender.
  • No credit score and no borrower choice. A higher share can reflect riskier borrowers, a product the lender specializes in, or a state; it cannot show whether you would have been quoted less elsewhere.
  • Only 30-year fixed purchase loans on principal residences. Refinances, other terms, adjustable-rate loans and second homes are outside this page; 2,502,066 loans passed the term and rate-type filters out of 2,984,324 originated principal-residence purchase loans in the extract.
  • Rate spread is blank on some loans. 10,468 loans in our filter report NA or exempt; a lender with many blanks can have a share that rests on few loans, as the two excluded lenders show.

What a reader can do with this

  1. Read page 3 of the Loan Estimate. Compare the interest rate (page 1) with the APR (page 3) on every offer; for the same loan type and term the APR is the fairer yardstick, as long as you expect to keep the loan for its full term.
  2. Ask for points and fees in dollars. In our $350,000 example a point costs $3,500 and moves the APR about 0.1 point; whether the lower rate is worth it depends on how long you will stay (see our closing cost calculator for loan costs by state).
  3. Check whether your loan is higher-priced. The test is APR against the APOR on the day the rate was set; if the loan is a first lien on your home, the lender should tell you about the escrow account and the appraisal. If you see an escrow requirement you did not expect, ask whether the loan crossed the line.
  4. Do not compare the APR of a fixed loan with the APR of an adjustable one without asking what rate the lender assumed after the fixed period.
  5. If your loan is small, expect a wider gap. Under $100,000, our floor for the APR gap is 0.17 points; at $350,000 to under $500,000 it is 0.048 points.

FAQ

Sources, read November 22, 2026: FFIEC and CFPB, 2025 HMDA data (Modified Loan Application Register released March 31, 2026): HMDA Data Browser home-purchase records (loan purpose 1, originated and denied) filtered by our script to first lien, closed-end, not reverse and not business purpose, then to originated, principal residence, 360-month, fixed-rate loans (aggregates in sources/); Data Browser aggregations API and a lender-level CSV used as checks; eCFR, 12 CFR 1003.4(a)(12), 12 CFR 1026.4, 1026.22, 1026.35 and 1026.37, current to November 18, 2026. Medians, shares, HPML classification, the APR-gap estimate and the worked example are our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records; the APOR of 6.30% in the example is an assumption. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal, tax or lending advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.