Elon Musk, PayPal and eBay in 2002: What the SEC Filings Show
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Filing alert · free
An email when PayPal files with the SEC
An email the day PayPal files something new, with the link to the document on the SEC site.
Quick answer
Elon Musk founded X.com in March 1999, merged it with Confinity on March 30, 2000, ran PayPal as CEO from May to September 2000, and was still its largest individual shareholder when eBay agreed to buy it: 6,514,156 shares, 10.6% of PayPal, on August 23, 2002. PayPal's own filings show his stake at 14.2% (September 21, 2001), 13.0% (December 31, 2001) and 11.7% (May 31, 2002), after he offered 600,000 shares in a June 2002 secondary at $19.00. The IPO priced at $13.00 in February 2002, when PayPal said it had “never achieved a profitable quarter” and had lost $107.8 million in 2001 on $104.8 million of revenue. eBay's merger turned each PayPal share into 0.39 eBay share: on the 6,501,656 shares the proxy statement says he voted with eBay, about 2.54 million eBay shares, or $140 million to $154 million at the prices printed in the document (our arithmetic). No SEC document states what he actually received.
Key takeaways
- The filings name the roles and dates: Musk was CEO of X.com from March 1999 to December 1999 and CEO of PayPal from May 2000 to September 2000. Peter Thiel has been CEO since September 2000. The X.com and Confinity merger closed on March 30, 2000, and X.com became PayPal, Inc. in February 2001 (PayPal's February 2002 prospectus and June 2002 prospectus).
- His stake, filing by filing: 28,406,630 shares or 14.2% before the December 2001 one-for-four reverse split (S-1, September 28, 2001), 7,101,656 shares or 13.0% (prospectus, February 14, 2002), 7,109,989 shares or 11.7% (June 28, 2002), and 6,514,156 shares or 10.6% (eBay proxy statement-prospectus, August 28, 2002). He is the largest holder in each table, apart from eBay's own line in the August 2002 table.
- He paid $0.0132 a share for 1,350,000 shares in March 1999 and $0.132 for 150,000 in May 1999. The IPO price of $13.00 is 985 times the first price (our arithmetic). In May 2001, PayPal repurchased shares from him at what he had paid, including 90,909 Series C shares for $250,000 and 166,667 Series D shares for $500,000.
- The IPO (prospectus dated February 14, 2002): 5,400,000 shares at $13.00, $70,200,000 before the $4,914,000 underwriting discount, Nasdaq symbol PYPL. With the over-allotment, 6,210,000 shares and about $69.9 million net cash. PayPal itself was the seller of the 5,400,000 shares.
- What the IPO prospectus said about money: net loss of $281.9 million since March 8, 1999 (10-K405 for 2001), provision for transaction losses from fraud and non-performance of $14.8 million in 2001 (0.42% of $3.52 billion of payment volume, down from 0.87% in 2000), and a small profit, net income of $1.2 million, in the first quarter of 2002 after a net loss of $18.5 million in the fourth quarter of 2001.
- The merger agreement is dated July 7, 2002: 0.39 eBay share per PayPal share, about 24.0 million eBay shares to PayPal holders, a deal PayPal's own filing says was “valued at approximately $1.5 billion” on eBay's July 5, 2002 price, completed October 3, 2002. Holders of 27.7% of PayPal had agreed to vote for it and gave eBay an irrevocable proxy.
CSV · 127 rows
Elon Musk and PayPal, 2001-2002: ownership tables, the February 2002 IPO, losses, the June 2002 secondary and the eBay merger terms
127 rows from PayPal, Inc.'s S-1, IPO prospectus, 10-K405, two 10-Qs, secondary prospectus, 8-K and Form 15, and eBay's merger 8-Ks and S-4/A, each with its accession number; our own arithmetic rows are labelled.
The story in dates
The company that eBay bought in 2002 began as two companies. PayPal's own filings give the sequence, and they are specific about who held the chief executive job at each point.
| Date | What the filings say happened | Document |
|---|---|---|
| December 1998 | Confinity, Inc. incorporated in California; its product let users send money to an email address | 424B4, February 2002 |
| March 1999 | X.com Corporation incorporated, intending to offer Internet banking. Musk bought 1,350,000 shares at $0.0132 and, in May, 150,000 more at $0.132 (after the later reverse split) | 424B4 |
| March to December 1999 | Musk is CEO of X.com | 424B1, June 2002 |
| October 1999 | The PayPal product launched | 424B4 |
| December 1999 to May 2000 | Bill Harris is CEO, as the later filings state it | S-4/A, August 2002 |
| March 30, 2000 | X.com merges with Confinity. Former Confinity holders own about 46.5% of the voting interest afterwards; Confinity had lost $18.3 million since its start | 424B4 |
| May to September 2000 | Musk is CEO of PayPal | 424B1 |
| September 2000 | Peter Thiel becomes CEO and President | 424B4 |
| December 2000 | Company decides to focus on the PayPal product and drop Internet banking | 424B4 |
| February 2001 | X.com formally renamed PayPal, Inc. | 424B4 |
| May 2001 | Separation agreement with Musk, described as the company's “former President and Chief Executive Officer” | 424B4 |
| September 28, 2001 | First S-1 filed | S-1 |
| February 14 to 21, 2002 | Prospectus dated February 14; shares sold at $13.00; delivery on or about February 21 | 424B4 |
| June 28 to July 2, 2002 | Secondary of existing holders' shares at $19.00 (Musk offers 600,000); completed July 2, 2002 at $131.1 million for 6.9 million shares | 424B1, S-4/A |
| July 7, 2002 | Merger agreement with eBay and Vaquita Acquisition Corp. | eBay 8-K, July 8, 2002 |
| October 3, 2002 | Stockholders approve; merger completed. October 4: PayPal files Form 15 to end its reporting | eBay 8-K, PayPal Form 15-12G |
The prospectus uses plain language for the founding: “Mr. Musk founded X.com Corporation in March 1999, which merged with Confinity, Inc. in March 2000.” It does not say why the chief executive changed twice in 2000, and neither does any other filing we read. The only place the filings touch it is the repurchase paragraph below.
Musk's stake, filing by filing
Every PayPal prospectus has a table of beneficial owners. Put side by side, the four tables we read show one pattern: the number of shares barely moves, and the percentage falls as the company issues stock.
| Share count as of | Musk's shares | Percent of shares outstanding | Document | Note |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 21, 2001 | 28,406,630 | 14.2% | S-1, September 28, 2001 | Before the December 2001 one-for-four reverse split; divided by four it matches the next row (our arithmetic) |
| December 31, 2001 | 7,101,656 | 13.0% before the IPO, 11.9% after | 424B4, February 15, 2002 | A footnote to the related-party section of the same prospectus says 13.2% |
| May 31, 2002 | 7,109,989 | 11.7% before the secondary, 10.7% after | 424B1, June 28, 2002 | 600,000 shares offered; the total includes 8,333 option shares exercisable within 60 days |
| August 23, 2002 | 6,514,156 | 10.6% | eBay S-4/A, August 28, 2002 | Includes 12,500 option shares; 6,501,656 shares carry shared voting with eBay under the Stockholders Agreement |
In the August 2002 table the next-largest listed holders are eBay itself at 17,051,187 shares (27.7%, through the voting agreements it signed with PayPal's directors and large holders), Sequoia Capital entities at 5,340,908 shares (8.7%) and Nokia Ventures at 4,807,491 shares (7.8%). The same kind of table for other founders is on our Nvidia CEO shares and pay page, and the voting side of a founder's stake is on our Anthropic S-1 share classes and votes page.
What Musk paid, and what the company took back
Founder shares in a venture-backed company usually come with a repurchase right. PayPal's prospectus shows how it worked in practice.
| Item | Figure | Document |
|---|---|---|
| Common stock bought, March 1999 | 1,350,000 shares at $0.0132 (the first S-1 wrote it as 5,400,000 shares at $0.0033, before the reverse split) | 424B4; S-1 |
| Common stock bought, May 1999 | 150,000 shares at $0.132 | 424B4 |
| Cost of the 1,500,000 shares | $37,620 (our arithmetic) | 424B4 |
| August 1999 | Sequoia Capital entities bought 15,000,000 shares of Series A preferred (pre-split) from Musk for $5 million | S-1 |
| May 2001, separation agreement | Company repurchased common stock from him for a total of $12,666, 90,909 Series C shares for $250,000 and 166,667 Series D shares for $500,000, each at the price he paid | 424B4 |
| Repurchase right | “In connection with Mr. Musk's termination of employment as our CEO, we exercised our right to repurchase any unvested shares” | 424B4 |
| Note owed to the company | About $389,000, issued in July 2000 to buy Series B shares assigned to him; the company agreed to forgive it on completion of the IPO | 424B4 |
| 2000 salary column | $163,825 (summary compensation table, former Chief Executive Officer) | 424B1 |
| January 18, 2002 director option | 50,000 shares at $12.00, vesting monthly over three years | 424B4 |
Two details matter for anyone reading a founder's stake. First, the percentage in a prospectus counts shares that are still subject to a company repurchase right; the 424B4 says its share count “includes 3,683,562 shares of common stock outstanding that are subject to repurchase by us.” Second, where the company bought shares back in May 2001, it paid the founder's own cost.
The IPO as the prospectus shows it
| Term | Figure | Document |
|---|---|---|
| Shares offered by PayPal | 5,400,000 (plus an option for 810,000 more) | 424B4 |
| Price to the public | $13.00 a share, $70,200,000 in total | 424B4 |
| Underwriting discount | $0.91 a share, $4,914,000 | 424B4 |
| Proceeds to PayPal before expenses | $12.09 a share, $65,286,000 | 424B4 |
| Shares actually issued, over-allotment included | 6,210,000 | 10-Q, June 30, 2002 |
| Net cash received | About $69.9 million | 10-Q, March 31, 2002 |
| Ticker and market | PYPL, Nasdaq National Market | 424B4 |
| Risks the prospectus summary lists | A patent suit by CertCo filed February 4, 2002; contacts between PayPal's communications director and the author of a research note published two days before pricing, which the company said could lead to a requirement to repurchase the IPO shares | 424B4 |
The cover says “We are selling 5,400,000 shares of our common stock.” The proceeds went to PayPal, not to its holders; holders' shares came to market later, in the June 2002 secondary.
What PayPal looked like when it priced
The company's own numbers, including the fraud-related line, frame the IPO. “Transaction losses” in PayPal's filings are losses “due to fraud and non-performance of third parties and customers.”
| Period | Revenue | Net result | Transaction losses | Document |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 2000 | $14.5 million | Net loss $169.5 million | $11.0 million, 0.87% of payment volume | 10-K405 for 2001 |
| Year 2001 | $104.8 million | Net loss $107.8 million ($15.9 million excluding non-cash items) | $14.8 million, 0.42% of $3.52 billion | 10-K405 for 2001 |
| March 8, 1999 to December 31, 2001 | Not stated as one figure | Net loss $281.9 million | Not stated | 10-K405 for 2001 |
| Third quarter 2001 | $30.2 million | Net loss $32.4 million | Not stated in the summary | 424B4 |
| First quarter 2002 | Not stated in this table | Net income $1,231 thousand | Not stated in this table | 10-Q, Q1 2002 |
| Second quarter 2002 | $53.8 million | Net income $529 thousand ($9.2 million excluding non-cash and non-recurring items) | 0.38% of $1.62 billion | 10-Q, Q2 2002 |
| First half 2002 | $102.5 million | Net income $1.8 million | 0.43% of payment volume | 10-Q, Q2 2002 |
The prospectus risk summary says it plainly: “we have never achieved a profitable quarter.” Net loss was $18.5 million in the fourth quarter of 2001; the first quarter of 2002 shows a small profit, and the second quarter another.
The eBay merger terms
| Term | What the filings say | Document |
|---|---|---|
| Agreement date | July 7, 2002; announced July 8 | eBay 8-K, July 8, 2002 |
| Exchange ratio | 0.39 of an eBay share for each PayPal share; PayPal options assumed at the same ratio | eBay 8-K; S-4/A |
| eBay shares to PayPal holders | About 24.0 million, leaving them with about 8.5% of eBay | S-4/A |
| Shares issued or reserved, including options | About 26.5 million | eBay 8-K, October 4, 2002 |
| Value | PayPal's own note says the acquisition “is valued at approximately $1.5 billion” on eBay's July 5, 2002 price; eBay's pro forma shows an aggregate purchase price of $1,541,485 thousand | S-4/A |
| eBay price points in the document | $60.55 close on July 5, 2002; $59.50 five-day average to July 5; $55.37 close on August 28, 2002 | S-4/A |
| PayPal's price before the deal | $20.00 close on July 5, 2002, an implied premium of 18.1% at 0.39 times $60.55 | S-4/A |
| Vote needed | A majority of PayPal's outstanding common stock; special meeting October 3, 2002 | S-4/A |
| Committed votes | Directors and large holders, including Musk, agreed to vote about 27.7% of PayPal's stock for the deal and gave eBay an irrevocable proxy | S-4/A |
| If the deal failed | PayPal could owe $5,000,000 or $45,000,000 plus eBay's expenses | S-4/A |
| Transfer lock | Musk and five other named holders could not transfer subject shares from July 7, 2002 until 30 days after the effective time | S-4/A |
| Completion | October 3, 2002; PayPal became a wholly owned subsidiary of eBay | eBay 8-K, October 4, 2002 |
What 6.5 million shares became (our arithmetic)
The filings give the ratio, the share count and several eBay prices. They do not give a payout for Musk, so the figures below are our arithmetic from those inputs, not a statement of what he received or kept.
| Step | Arithmetic | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Shares carrying shared voting with eBay (August 23, 2002) | From the S-4/A footnote | 6,501,656 shares |
| eBay shares at 0.39 | 6,501,656 x 0.39 | 2,535,646 eBay shares |
| At $55.37 (August 28, 2002 close in the proxy statement) | 2,535,646 x 55.37 | about $140.4 million |
| At $59.50 (five-day average used in eBay's pro forma) | 2,535,646 x 59.50 | about $150.9 million |
| At $60.55 (July 5, 2002 close in the fairness analysis) | 2,535,646 x 60.55 | about $153.5 million |
| One PayPal share, July 5, 2002 prices | 0.39 x 60.55 | $23.61, against $13.00 in the IPO and $19.00 in the secondary |
| June 2002 secondary, 600,000 shares at $19.00 | 600,000 x 19.00, and x 18.05 after the underwriting discount | $11.4 million; $10.83 million before expenses |
Three limits. The 6,501,656 shares exclude the 600,000 he offered in the secondary, which the 424B1 table already subtracts. The prices are from the documents' dates, not the October 3, 2002 closing date, because no filing we read gives eBay's price that day. And taxes, any shares transferred after August 23, 2002, and the over-allotment in the secondary are outside these documents.
What the documents show that the headlines don't
- The filings contain no payout figure. The proxy statement lists his shares, the ratio and the prices, and stops there. Figures you see online for what he made come from press and web accounts, not from a filing in this set.
- He was a 10% holder, not an officer. The February 2002 prospectus lists him as a director who sat on the audit committee; his CEO job had ended in September 2000, and the May 2001 separation agreement calls him the company's “former President and Chief Executive Officer.”
- The company bought some of his shares back at his own cost. The filings show a founder's equity as shares bought for almost nothing, plus repurchase rights the company could use when the founder left.
- He sold some before the deal. In the June 2002 secondary he offered 600,000 shares at $19.00. Nine days after that prospectus the merger agreement was signed, and at July 5, 2002 prices its ratio valued a PayPal share at $23.61, about 24% above $19.00 (our arithmetic).
- The IPO money went to the company. PayPal sold the 5,400,000 shares itself, at a time when its own risk summary said it had never had a profitable quarter. Holders sold in June.
- The ratio was fixed. The proxy statement has a risk factor titled so that the exchange ratio holds “Despite Changes in the Market Value of PayPal Common Stock or eBay Common Stock.” The value moved with eBay's stock between July and October 2002; the shares did not.
What this means for your money
Read the founder's table, not the founder's story. The same documents that explain a famous exit tell an investor in any private company or non-traded vehicle what to look for.
- Who controls the votes. In PayPal's case 27.7% of the stock was committed to the merger by agreement and an irrevocable proxy before the stockholder meeting. When insiders and large holders have already signed, a large part of the vote is decided before the meeting. See the same issue in WeWork's S-1 and its 20-vote shares.
- Repurchase rights. Check which shares the company can buy back if a holder leaves, and at what price. In PayPal's filings the price was the holder's cost.
- Lock-ups and transfer limits. The signing holders could not transfer shares for the period the merger agreement set, and those shares were also under a lock-up from the June 2002 secondary. If you hold a private stake, the transfer clause decides when you can sell.
- Fixed ratios and who bears price moves. A stock-for-stock deal at 0.39 passes the market risk of the buyer's stock to you until closing. Pay attention to the ratio and the dates of the prices in the filing.
- Who gets paid first. In PayPal's merger every common share got the same 0.39 ratio; in a vehicle with senior or preferred classes, read the charter before the headline value. If most of your own wealth sits in one stock, see the exchange fund and concentrated stock page.
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. PayPal, Inc. stopped filing in October 2002; the company that files today, PayPal Holdings, Inc., is a different registrant (CIK 1633917) and its filings are the ones the alert above follows.
FAQ
Sources, read on November 17, 2026: PayPal, Inc. (CIK 1103415) on SEC EDGAR: Form S-1 filed September 28, 2001 (accession 0000912057-01-533855), Form 424B4 prospectus of February 15, 2002 (0000912057-02-006471), Form 10-K405 for 2001 filed March 13, 2002 (0000912057-02-009834), Forms 10-Q filed May 15, 2002 (0000912057-02-020678) and August 6, 2002 (0000912057-02-030120), Form 424B1 prospectus of June 28, 2002 (0000912057-02-025671), Form 8-K of October 4, 2002 (0000912057-02-037693) and Form 15-12G of October 4, 2002 (0000912057-02-037694); eBay Inc. (CIK 1065088): Form 8-K of July 8, 2002 (0000891618-02-003151), Form S-4/A, the proxy statement-prospectus, filed August 28, 2002 (0000891618-02-004121) and Form 8-K of October 4, 2002 (0000891618-02-004533); and the EDGAR filing lists of PayPal Holdings, Inc. (CIK 1633917) and PayPal, Inc. The products of share counts and prices (2,535,646 eBay shares, $140.4 million, $150.9 million, $153.5 million, $23.61, $11.4 million, $10.83 million, $37,620 and the factor of 985) are our arithmetic from the figures the filings state. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.