CrowdfundedWealth
Articles · Research note

WeWork's S-1: What the Filing Showed Before the IPO Collapsed

By Jorge··20 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the related-party fees in real estate offerings numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick Answer

On August 14, 2019 The We Company, the parent of WeWork, filed a Form S-1 to sell shares to the public; 47 days later, on September 30, 2019, it asked the SEC to withdraw it, saying it “no longer wishes to conduct a public offering of securities at this time.” The prospectus put on the record what investors in the private rounds had not been shown in one place: $1,927.4 million of net loss in 2018 on $1,821.8 million of revenue, non-cancelable operating leases of $33.95 billion plus $13.1 billion of signed leases not yet started (about $47.1 billion, our arithmetic), Class B and C shares with 20 votes each against one for the public's Class A, and a related-party section covering four leases with landlords in which co-founder Adam Neumann held an interest, $25.4 million (our sum of two loans) and $7.0 million of past company loans to his holding entity and to him, a $362.1 million note for exercising options, and a $380 million personal credit line secured by pledged shares. The paradox is in the numbers: cash paid to the Neumann-linked landlords was $8.0 million in 2018, 0.4% of that year's net loss (our arithmetic). Within 30 days the S-1/A cut the votes to 10 per share. After a 2021 SPAC listing at a pre-transaction equity value of $6.553 billion, WeWork Inc. filed Chapter 11 on November 6, 2023, and on June 11, 2024 its existing stock was cancelled without consideration.

Key Takeaways

  • The S-1 (August 14, 2019, accession 0001193125-19-220499) reports net losses of $429.7 million (2016), $933.5 million (2017) and $1,927.4 million (2018), and $904.7 million for the first six months of 2019, on revenue of $436.1 million, $886.0 million, $1,821.8 million and $1,535.4 million. Cumulative net loss over the four periods is $4.2 billion (our sum).
  • Lease commitments: $33,953 million of non-cancelable operating leases at June 30, 2019, plus $13.1 billion of executed leases that had not yet started. Together about $47.1 billion (our arithmetic), against $2,473 million of cash. The S-1 itself says that future minimum payments of $236.6 million under the four related-party leases are 0.5% of total lease commitments.
  • Related-party items are all in one section that begins on page 197: four leases with landlord entities in which Adam Neumann had an ownership interest (cash paid $3.1 million, $5.6 million and $8.0 million in 2016-2018, $4.2 million in the first half of 2019), loans of $10.4 million, $15.0 million and $7.0 million, a $362.1 million option-exercise note, and a $380 million bank credit line secured by his pledged Class B shares.
  • The “we” trademark: the original S-1 says WE Holdings LLC assigned rights to the company in July 2019 and received partnership interests worth about $5.9 million “in lieu of paying cash.” Amendment No. 1 (September 4, 2019) says the issuance was unwound and returned.
  • Votes: 20 per share for Class B and C against one for Class A in the original; Amendment No. 2 (September 13, 2019) cut it to 10. The filing left the percentage of votes the CEO would hold blank in all three versions. In 2021 the multi-class structure was eliminated; on June 11, 2024 the existing common stock was cancelled and about 100% of the voting securities went to creditor classes.
  • No document gives The We Company a value in the S-1. The documents that do: $6.553 billion pre-transaction equity value in the 2021 BowX merger (deemed $10.00 a share) and “no value” for existing equity at the 2024 plan date. The $47 billion figure is a press-reported private valuation (CNBC, October 22, 2019), not a filing.

CSV · 115 rows

WeWork's 2019 S-1: financials, lease commitments, related-party items, votes, the amendments, and what the later filings say

115 rows from The We Company's S-1 and two S-1/A amendments, its withdrawal request, the BowX S-4/A, WeWork Inc.'s 2022 10-K, the Chapter 11 and plan 8-Ks, the monthly operating report and one dated press report, each with its source and accession.

The story in dates

DateEventDocument
Aug 14, 2019The We Company files its S-1 for an IPO. The price range, number of shares and the CEO's share of the votes are blankS-1, accession 0001193125-19-220499
Sep 4, 2019Amendment No. 1: the trademark partnership interests are unwound; the CEO's credit line secured by shares is also mentioned in the “Sales of Shares” paragraphS-1/A, accession 0001193125-19-236798
Sep 13, 2019Amendment No. 2: high-vote stock cut from 20 to 10 votes per share, a lead independent director, no family member on the board, real estate profits to go to the companyS-1/A, accession 0001193125-19-244329
Sep 24, 2019Adam Neumann resigns as chief executive officerBowX S-4/A (2021), accession 0001193125-21-274442
Sep 30, 2019The We Company requests withdrawal of the S-1; no securities had been soldForm RW, accession 0001193125-19-258913
Feb 25-26, 2021Settlement of the tender-offer litigation; the Class B stock converts to Class A and multi-class voting endsBowX S-4/A
Oct 20, 2021Business combination with BowX Acquisition Corp. closes; the stock lists as WEForm 10-K FY2022, accession 0001813756-23-000016
Nov 6, 2023WeWork Inc. and 516 affiliates file Chapter 11 petitions in the District of New Jersey (Case No. 23-19865)Form 8-K, accession 0001193125-23-271902; monthly operating report, accession 0001813756-24-000006
Jun 11, 2024Plan becomes effective; existing equity is cancelled; WeWork Inc. files Form 15-12G the same dayForm 8-K, accession 0001193125-24-159419; EDGAR filing list

Nothing in this timeline is an allegation: each row is the company's own filing or a court-captioned exhibit to one.

The S-1 numbers

All figures are from the S-1's summary financial data and contractual-obligations table (WeWork Companies Inc., the predecessor of The We Company), amounts in millions of US dollars unless stated.

FigureFY2016FY2017FY2018H1 2019Section of the S-1
Revenue436.1886.01,821.81,535.4Summary consolidated financial data
Loss from operations(396.3)(931.8)(1,691.0)(1,369.5)Summary consolidated financial data
Net loss(429.7)(933.5)(1,927.4)(904.7)Summary consolidated financial data
Net loss attributable to WeWork Companies Inc.(429.7)(884.0)(1,610.8)(689.7)Summary consolidated financial data
Memberships (thousands, period end)87186401527Key performance indicators
Lease and cash figure at June 30, 2019AmountSection of the S-1
Non-cancelable operating lease commitments, total$33,953.4 millionContractual obligations
Of which due in 2024 and beyond$23,787.2 millionContractual obligations
Executed non-cancelable leases not yet commenced (excluded from the line above)$13.1 billionFootnote to the contractual-obligations table
Operating leases plus leases not yet commenced (our arithmetic)about $47.1 billionOur sum of the two lines above
Total contractual obligations in the table$39,378.9 millionContractual obligations
Cash and cash equivalents$2,473.1 millionCondensed consolidated balance sheet
Committed revenue backlog$4.0 billionKey performance indicators
Locations (June 1, 2019)528Related-party section

The S-1 states the loss in the plain terms of its own table: the 2018 net loss was 1.06 times revenue (our arithmetic: 1,927.4 / 1,821.8). Revenue roughly doubled in each of 2017 and 2018, and so did the loss.

The section is titled “Certain Relationships and Related Party Transactions” and covers every transaction since January 1, 2016 above $120,000 involving a director, an executive officer or a holder of more than 5% of any class, or their family. It opens by promising “clarity and transparency on the history of these relationships and transactions.”

ItemAmount disclosedWhat the S-1 says
Leases with four landlord entities in which Adam Neumann has an ownership interestCash paid: $3.1 million (2016), $5.6 million (2017), $8.0 million (2018), $4.2 million (first half of 2019)Four of 528 locations. Tenant improvement reimbursements received from those landlords in 2018: $11.6 million. Future minimum payments of $236.6 million, 0.5% of total lease commitments
Ten commercial properties managed by the ARK managerTen properties, including the four leased onesManagement agreement of August 2019; ARK has a one-year option to buy at cost plus a pre-set annual cost of capital, subject to approval of disinterested directors
Loans to WE Holdings LLC (2013 and 2014)$10.4 million and $15.0 million at 0.2% a yearCollateralized by shares; settled in May 2016 when the company bought and retired 8,398,670 shares
Loan to Adam Neumann (June 2016)$7.0 million at 0.64% a yearRepaid in cash in November 2017
Promissory note for exercising a time-based option (2019)$362.1 million at 2.89%, maturity April 11, 2029Full recourse; repaid in August 2019 by surrendering the shares received
Stock options granted in the first half of 201942,473,167 optionsFive tranches; three vest only at a public market capitalization of $50 billion, $72 billion and $90 billion
The “we” trademark rightsPartnership interests worth about $5.9 millionIssued “in lieu of paying cash” on a third-party appraisal; unwound in Amendment No. 1
Personal line of credit of the CEOUp to $500 million; about $380 million outstanding on July 31, 2019Secured by a pledge of Class B common stock he owns beneficially; the company is not the borrower
Other bank credit to the CEO$97.5 million from JPMorgan Chase BankPer the S-1, not secured by company shares
Family membersUnder $200,000 for hosting eight events in 2018; under $200,000 a year for a wellness roleIndividuals are not named in the S-1
SalaryNone in 2018; $1 in 2017No employment agreement; no severance
Charitable pledge$1 billion by the tenth anniversaryIf not met, high-vote shares fall from 20 to 10 votes

The S-1 separately lists $10.65 billion that SoftBank entities had invested or committed to invest since January 1, 2017, with tender offers, a convertible note, warrants and regional joint ventures. At June 30, 2019 the contractual-obligations table also carried $2,945.0 million of convertible related-party liabilities due in the remainder of 2019.

Worked example: how big were the Neumann-linked leases? (our arithmetic)

Cash paid to the four landlord entities was $3.1 + $5.6 + $8.0 + $4.2 = $20.9 million over 2016 through June 2019. Net losses over the same periods added up to $4,195.3 million. The ratio is 0.5%. In 2018 alone it was $8.0 million against a $1,927.4 million net loss: 0.4%. The amounts disclosed were small next to the loss. The money at risk sat in the leases the company signed with everyone else and in how the business spent cash.

Who held the votes

ItemOriginal S-1 (Aug 14, 2019)Amendment No. 2 (Sep 13, 2019)After the 2021 settlement
Votes per Class A share111
Votes per Class B or C share2010Class B converted to Class A on February 26, 2021; Class C adjusted from three votes to one
CEO's share of total votesBlank (“approximately %”)Blank (“approximately %”)Not applicable after conversion
Condition that lowers the votesFalls to 10 votes if the $1 billion charitable pledge is not met by the tenth anniversaryAlso falls to one vote on the CEO's death or permanent incapacity, and below 5% ownershipNot applicable
SuccessionA committee including the CEO's spouse picks a successorA successor is selected by the board “acting as a group”Not applicable

The S-1 beneficial-ownership table lists 112,507,371 Class B shares for Adam Neumann and 113,988,653 Class A shares for the SoftBank entities, before the offering. At 20 votes against one that is 2.25 billion votes against 114.0 million (our arithmetic: 112,507,371 × 20 and 113,988,653 × 1; share counts before the offering and before the stock split the S-1 describes). Amendment No. 2 opens its governance list with the sentence “We are making a number of changes to our proposed governance structure in response to market feedback.”

What the amendments changed

TopicOriginal S-1 (Aug 14)Amendment No. 1 (Sep 4)Amendment No. 2 (Sep 13)
High-vote shares20 votes20 votes10 votes
“we” trademark interests (about $5.9 million)Issued to WE Holdings LLCUnwound; company keeps the rightsRepeated as already unwound
Credit line secured by pledged sharesIn “Personal Loans”Also pointed to from “Sales of Shares”Same
Real estate profits from deals with the companyNot in the filingNot in the filingTo be given to the company
Sales by the CEO after the IPOAbout one-year lock-up; no sales in the offeringSameAlso limited to no more than 10% of his shareholdings in each of years two and three
BoardNo lead independent director mentionedNo lead independent director mentionedLead independent director by year end; no family member on the board; majority-independent committees

What the documents show that the headlines don't

  • The trademark was not a cash payment in the S-1. The original says the company issued partnership interests valued at about $5.9 million “in lieu of paying cash,” on a third-party appraisal. Amendment No. 1 says the issuance was unwound “at Adam’s direction.” The page does not rely on press accounts of the amount.
  • The related-party leases were small by the filing's own arithmetic. $236.6 million is 0.5% of lease commitments. The related-party section discloses these items; the larger exposure sits in other parts of the filing, in the lease and loss tables above.
  • A line was left blank that mattered. Percentage of votes held by the CEO, price range and shares offered are empty in the original and in both amendments. A reader of the August 14 document could see 20 votes a share and could not compute who decided.
  • The CEO's borrowing was against company stock. About $380 million of a $500 million credit line was outstanding on July 31, 2019, secured by Class B shares. Amendment No. 1 added a reference to it in the paragraph on share sales.
  • Governance moved in 30 days. High-vote stock went from 20 to 10 votes between August 14 and September 13, and the CEO's real estate profits and sale limits were added. The original S-1 was a draft of the terms, not the terms.
  • The later filings are the ones that state value. The 2021 S-4/A states a pre-transaction equity value of $6.553 billion at a deemed $10.00 a share and an anticipated enterprise value of $8.8 billion. The 2023 and 2024 8-Ks state that existing equity was cancelled.

What the company was worth, where a document says

DateValue statedKind of source
Aug 14, 2019 (S-1)None. Price range and shares offered are blankSEC filing
Oct 22, 2019CNBC reported that SoftBank's investments pushed the valuation “from about $17 billion to $47 billion” and that SoftBank was “setting a value for WeWork, at a post-money valuation of about $12 billion”Press report, quoted as CNBC's report
Sep 16, 2021 (BowX S-4/A, for the merger agreement of March 25, 2021)Pre-transaction equity value of about $6.553 billion at a deemed $10.00 a share; anticipated enterprise value $8.8 billionSEC filing
Nov 6, 2023 (8-K)Equity interests to be cancelled with no distributionSEC filing
Jun 11, 2024 (8-K)Existing equity cancelled “without consideration and has no value”; about 100% of voting securities issued to creditor classes (up to 71,246,391 shares)SEC filing

The figures are not comparable: a private-round valuation is a price set by one investor, a SPAC value is a deemed $10.00 share price on a negotiated deal, and the 2024 line is a legal cancellation. Net loss ran from $3,774.9 million (2019) to $3,833.9 million (2020) and $2,295 million (2022) in the later filings, on revenue of $3,458.6 million, $3,415.9 million and $3,245 million. At December 31, 2022 the 10-K showed $16,534 million of lease obligations at present value and $27,490 million of undiscounted fixed minimum lease payments, and said losses and projected cash needs had “initially raised substantial doubt” about continuing as a going concern.

What this means for your money

The related-party section was the part of the S-1 where a reader could see who was on both sides of a contract. It is the first place to read in any offering, and non-traded REITs, interval funds and crowdfunding offerings disclose the same things under other names: advisor and asset-management fees, acquisition fees, property bought from or sold to the sponsor, affiliate loans, and lease or management contracts with sponsor-owned companies.

  1. Read the related-party section before the business section. The S-1's own threshold was $120,000. Count the items, add the amounts, and ask what each costs the holder. The disclosure in WeWork's case was complete; the lesson is that completeness does not tell you which item matters.
  2. Compare the related-party amount with the loss or the distribution. Here it was 0.4% of a year's net loss. In a fund, divide affiliate fees by the income the fund distributes: our pages on real estate crowdfunding fees, the Sterling Real Estate Trust 10-Q with its affiliate loans, and Roots' purchase of houses from its own sponsor show how that looks in filings.
  3. Find who controls the votes and what they borrowed against. 20 votes against 1 decides every election. A pledge of the controlling holder's shares is a second thing to read: if the loan is not repaid, the lender can end up holding those shares. Non-traded REITs that could not reach a quorum show the other side, where small holders do not vote at all.
  4. Check what happens in a liquidation. The 8-Ks of 2023 and 2024 show the order of payment in practice: the old stock was cancelled without consideration and the creditor classes received the new stock. Our real estate crowdfunding failures page covers what happened to holders of smaller vehicles.
  5. Do not rely on a value that comes from one buyer. The private valuation came from a financing, and the SPAC figure from a deemed share price.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 14, 2026: The We Company (CIK 1533523) on SEC EDGAR: Form S-1 filed August 14, 2019 (accession 0001193125-19-220499, File No. 333-233259), Form S-1/A Amendment No. 1 of September 4, 2019 (0001193125-19-236798), Amendment No. 2 of September 13, 2019 (0001193125-19-244329) and the Form RW withdrawal request of September 30, 2019 (0001193125-19-258913); WeWork Inc. (CIK 1813756): Form S-4/A of September 16, 2021 for the BowX Acquisition Corp. merger (0001193125-21-274442), Form 10-K for 2022 filed March 29, 2023 (0001813756-23-000016), Form 8-K of November 7, 2023 on the Chapter 11 filing (0001193125-23-271902), the Form 8-K filed March 7, 2024 with the monthly operating report in the District of New Jersey, Case No. 23-19865 (Exhibit 99.1, accession 0001813756-24-000006) and the Form 8-K of June 12, 2024 on the plan's effective date (0001193125-24-159419); the EDGAR filing lists of both CIKs; and CNBC, “WeWork's $47 billion valuation was always a fiction created by SoftBank,” October 22, 2019, quoted only as that outlet's report. The sum of $47.1 billion, the 47-day count, the ratios of 0.4% and 0.5%, the cumulative loss of $4.2 billion and the vote counts are our arithmetic. Share counts and amounts are those the filings state; the S-1 leaves the offering terms blank. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.