CrowdfundedWealth

Fay Servicing Review 2026: CFPB Orders, Complaints, Owner

ReviewBy Jorge24 min read2 SEC filings cited

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the fay servicing numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

The CFPB has issued two orders against Fay Servicing, LLC, and neither is in force today. The first was issued on June 7, 2017 (File No. 2017-CFPB-0014; up to $1.15 million of redress). The second, issued on August 21, 2024 (File No. 2024-CFPB-0007), found that Fay had violated the first and ordered $3 million of consumer redress, a $2 million civil money penalty and at least $2 million of investment in servicing technology and compliance; the Bureau terminated it on July 1, 2025. The CFPB database lists 434 mortgage complaints against Fay for 2025 and 304 for 2026 through November 22, 2026 (the latest was received November 7), and all but 4 were closed with an explanation. Fay's NMLS ID on its own licensing page is 88244.

Key takeaways

  • The 2024 order (File No. 2024-CFPB-0007, issued August 21, 2024): the Bureau found that from June 7, 2017 until early 2020 Fay did not protect borrowers from a first foreclosure filing from the day they sent a complete loss mitigation application, that its data did not always match its documents, that it did not tell borrowers that stating an interest in keeping the home could limit the options offered, and that it mishandled private mortgage insurance and late fees. Fay consented “without admitting or denying any of the findings of fact or conclusions of law”. Terms: $3,000,000 of redress, a $2,000,000 civil money penalty and at least $2 million invested in servicing technology and compliance.
  • The end of the order: on July 1, 2025 the CFPB's Acting Director signed an order that “terminates this Consent Order” and states “The Bureau waives any alleged noncompliance by Fay Servicing with the Consent Order.” The Bureau says Fay paid the $2 million penalty and the $3 million to the Bureau for redress; its payments page lists the redress distribution as ongoing from March 6, 2026. The 2017 order's status is also “Expired/Terminated/Dismissed”.
  • Massachusetts: on August 17, 2022 the Attorney General announced a settlement with Fay of $3.2 million in relief ($2.7 million of principal forgiveness for eligible loans plus $500,000 to the state), over allegations about loan modifications, debt collection calls and foreclosure fees.
  • CFPB mortgage complaints, company Fay Servicing, LLC: 241 (2019), 300 (2020), 329 (2021), 360 (2022), 324 (2023), 405 (2024), 434 (2025) and 304 from January 1 to November 22, 2026, a pace of about 340 for the year (our arithmetic). That is 1.8% of the 24,697 mortgage complaints of 2025 and 1.0% of the 31,037 of 2026 so far (our arithmetic). Of the 434 in 2025, 230 were about trouble during the payment process, 154 about struggling to pay, and all 434 were answered on time and closed with an explanation.
  • Who is behind it: the 2024 order says Fay Servicing “is a wholly owned subsidiary of Fay Financial, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company”, with its principal place of business in Tampa, Florida. Rithm Capital's 10-K for 2024 says that on December 31, 2024 “24% of our whole loan portfolio is serviced by Fay”. We found no document naming Fay Financial's owners, and no size figure for Fay's own servicing book.
  • If your loan is transferred to Fay (12 CFR 1024.33, eCFR of November 18, 2026): the old servicer's notice at least 15 days before the transfer date, the new servicer's no more than 15 days after, and for 60 days from the effective date a payment sent to the old servicer on or before the due date “may not be treated as late for any purpose”. Foreclosure protection while a loss mitigation application is pending is in 12 CFR 1024.41.

CSV · 122 rows

Fay Servicing: CFPB orders, Massachusetts settlement, complaints by year, issue and peer servicer, HMDA 2025 and transfer rules

122 rows: the two CFPB orders and their termination, the Massachusetts settlement, CFPB mortgage complaint counts for Fay Servicing, LLC from 2019 to 2026 by issue, sub-issue, outcome, tag and state, five peer servicers, owner and licence documents, HMDA 2025 applications and the 12 CFR 1024.33 and 1024.41 time limits. One source per row.

What the CFPB actually did to Fay Servicing

If you searched for a CFPB order against Fay, there are two, and both are closed. They are different cases: the first was about foreclosure protections, the second found that Fay had gone on breaking the first.

DateDocumentWhat it saysMoney and status
June 7, 2017 (the order text is dated June 6, 2017)CFPB consent order, File No. 2017-CFPB-0014The CFPB's page says the Bureau found Fay “failed to provide mortgage loan borrowers with the protections against foreclosure required by law”, kept borrowers in the dark about applying for foreclosure relief and moved forward with foreclosure while they were applyingUp to $1.15 million of redress (the order requires a deposit of $1,150,000); the CFPB lists the action as “Expired/Terminated/Dismissed”
August 21, 2024CFPB consent order, File No. 2024-CFPB-0007Findings that Fay violated the 2017 order, Regulation X (RESPA), the Homeowners Protection Act, Regulation Z (TILA) and the Consumer Financial Protection Act; Fay consented “without admitting or denying” the findings$3,000,000 of redress, a $2,000,000 civil money penalty, at least $2 million to update servicing technology and compliance systems
July 1, 2025CFPB Order Terminating the Consent Order, File No. 2024-CFPB-0007The Bureau, “Pursuant to its authority under 12 U.S.C. § 5563(b)(3)”, terminates the order and waives any alleged noncompliance; it says Fay had fulfilled several obligations, including the $2 million penalty and the $3 million paid to the Bureau for redressOrder ended; the redress is distributed by the Bureau through its administrator (payments page, last modified March 6, 2026: “Ongoing”)

What the 2024 order says went wrong, in its own paragraphs:

  • Foreclosure timing. From June 7, 2017 until early 2020 Fay's policy was to place a foreclosure hold only after reviewing the documents, which in some instances “took Respondent up to five days to review the documents and decide whether the documents made the application complete”; the hold was then dated back to when the documents arrived. The order says foreclosure activity that Regulation X prohibits happened in that gap, and in some instances after it.
  • Data. Since June 7, 2017 data in Fay's servicing system did not always match the underlying documents, which the order says violated the rule that servicers keep accurate information to answer borrowers.
  • Retention versus non-retention options. A borrower who said they wanted to keep the home, or said nothing, and qualified for a retention option was offered only that; the order says Fay “did not inform these borrowers” of this, and that if the borrower then declined the offer or did not perform, the foreclosure hold came off.
  • Mortgage insurance and late fees. The order says Fay failed to end borrower-paid private mortgage insurance on time, kept paying premiums from escrow, did not fully refund unearned premiums, and until August 2022 showed twelve months of PMI premiums in annual escrow statements even when the PMI should end inside that year. It also says Fay printed late fees on statements that were inconsistent with the promissory notes.

These are the Bureau's findings in a consent order; Fay did not admit or deny them. The order names the company's founder and chief executive only by role, and so do we. Our November 22, 2026 searches found no later CFPB action against Fay, but we searched titles and news, not every Bureau document.

Other regulators and what we could not read

DateAuthority and documentWhat it saysAmount
August 17, 2022Massachusetts Attorney General, press release “National Mortgage Servicer To Provide $3.2 Million in Relief to Massachusetts Homeowners in Settlement With AG’s Office”; assurance of discontinuance filed in Suffolk Superior CourtAlleges Fay offered loan modifications that required very large up-front “good faith down payments” with no affordability analysis, did not give the written assessment Massachusetts law requires, called borrowers more often than the state's two calls in seven days, did not send hundreds of borrowers debt validation notices and in some instances charged foreclosure-related fees before it had authority to foreclose$2.7 million of principal forgiveness on eligible loans plus $500,000 to the state
Not reachedNMLS Consumer Access (NMLS ID 88244) and other state regulator sitesBlocked automated access or not searched; the actions that state regulators have taken against Fay beyond Massachusetts are therefore not scoredUnknown

Fay's own licensing page (undated copy read on November 22, 2026) gives its address as 5426 Bay Center Drive, Suite 300, Tampa, Florida, NMLS ID 88244, and lists 97 lines of state licences, registrations and certificates (our count), including “Florida Mortgage Lender Servicer License #MLD702” and a Texas residential mortgage loan servicer registration. Check the current status in your own state's regulator or on NMLS Consumer Access, which we could not open. We did not read court dockets, so private lawsuits against Fay are not covered by this page.

Who owns Fay Servicing, and how big it is

The 2024 order says Fay Servicing, LLC is “a wholly owned subsidiary of Fay Financial, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company”, with a principal place of business in Tampa and branch offices in Illinois and Texas and an office in Zambia. Fay does not file with the SEC and we found no document naming the owners of Fay Financial. Two SEC filings of other companies show where Fay sits in the market:

DateDocumentWhat it says about Fay
December 31, 2024 (10-K filed February 18, 2025)Rithm Capital Corp. 10-K for 2024, accession 0001556593-25-000007Lists Fay Financial LLC among its third-party servicing partners and says that as of December 31, 2024 “24% of our whole loan portfolio is serviced by Fay and 15% is serviced by ServBank”
November 3, 2026 (8-K exhibit filed November 6, 2026)CNL Strategic Residential Credit, Inc. 8-K exhibit 10.1, master repurchase agreement with Goldman Sachs Bank USA, accession 0001437749-26-035428Defines “Fay Servicing Agreement” as “that certain Flow Special Servicing Agreement” with Fay, one of five named servicing agreements that govern the loans financed, next to those of Rushmore, SN, Selene and Shellpoint

Neither document gives Fay's unpaid principal balance, so we cannot say how many loans it services or compute a per-loan complaint rate. Rithm's 10-K for 2025 and its 10-Q for the third quarter of 2026 do not contain the name Fay (our text search of both), so the 24% figure is a 2024 snapshot. Fay's website also shows that it sells other services under the name Genstone (financing, realty and an insurance partner), so the company is more than a servicer; this page covers the servicing business.

Fay filed home loan application data under HMDA for 2025 (LEI 549300D0H09HSURFXA20): 613 records, of which 102 were originated for $29,760,000 (87 conventional, 11 FHA, 4 VA; 16 purchase, 23 refinance and 63 cash-out refinance), 158 were denied, 194 withdrawn, 142 closed as incomplete and 17 approved but not accepted. Denied divided by originated plus denied is 60.8% (our arithmetic), a figure that says little without the reasons, which we did not read. The lending side is small, and most complaints are about servicing: only 23 of the 434 complaints of 2025 are about closing a mortgage.

What the complaints say

The CFPB publishes consumer complaints in a public database. A complaint is a consumer's statement and not a finding, and a count says how many people complained, not how many were right. We counted complaints with product Mortgage under the company name “Fay Servicing, LLC” (found with the database's company search) from the API on November 22, 2026. The database's latest complaint received, across all companies, was dated November 20, 2026; the latest under Fay was November 7, 2026.

CFPB mortgage complaints against Fay Servicing, LLC by year

YearComplaints receivedChange from the year before (our arithmetic)
2019241Not computed
2020300+24.5%
2021329+9.7%
2022360+9.4%
2023324-10.0%
2024405+25.0%
2025434+7.2%
2026 to November 22304About 340 for the full year at this pace (304 over 324 days, our arithmetic)

The count rose in the year the second order was issued and again in 2025; we cannot tell from a count whether borrowers complained more, the book grew or the CFPB's order made complaining more visible. All years together, the database holds 3,740 mortgage complaints and 4,097 across all products for Fay since April 11, 2012.

By issue

Complaints received202420252026 to November 22
All mortgage complaints405434304
Trouble during payment process219230151
Struggling to pay mortgage161154112
Closing on a mortgage52316
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage10119
Incorrect information on your report479
Payments plus struggling to pay as a share of all (our arithmetic)93.8%88.5%86.5%

Inside the two biggest groups

Sub-issue20252026 to November 22
Payment process: trying to communicate with the company to fix an issue while managing or servicing your loan6250
Payment process: payment process4933
Payment process: escrow, taxes, or insurance4237
Payment process: loan sold or transferred to another company256
Payment process: fees charged229
Payment process: private mortgage insurance (PMI)43
Struggling to pay: trying to communicate about a modification, forbearance, short sale, deed-in-lieu, bankruptcy or foreclosure6540
Struggling to pay: applying for or obtaining a modification, forbearance plan, short sale or deed-in-lieu3632
Struggling to pay: foreclosure3527
Struggling to pay: an existing modification, forbearance plan, short sale or other loss mitigation relief1813

Two things stand out against the CFPB's findings. First, complaints about private mortgage insurance, the subject of a long section of the 2024 order, are tiny: 5 in 2024, 4 in 2025 and 3 in 2026 to date, out of 405, 434 and 304. Borrowers who pay PMI past its end date may not know to complain, which is our reading and not a statement in the database. Second, complaints about foreclosure and about applying for or keeping a modification, the subject of the 2017 order and of most of the 2024 one, are about a third of the total: 154 of 434 in 2025 and 112 of 304 in 2026 are in the struggling-to-pay group, 35.5% and 36.8% (our arithmetic). For the same escrow topics across servicers, see our page on escrow shortages and the CFPB counts by servicer; for how PMI is meant to end, see our page on private mortgage insurance.

How the complaints were closed

Outcome and profile20252026 to November 22All years since 2012
Closed with explanation4343003,733
Closed with monetary relief002
In progress044
Answered on time4343033,644
Not answered on time0196
Tagged Older American (alone or with Servicemember)6952Not computed
Tagged Servicemember (alone or with Older American)4833Not computed
Largest statesFlorida 62, California 43, New York 41California 34, Texas 33, Florida 30Not computed

Of the 434 complaints of 2025, 69 (15.9%) carry the Older American tag and 48 (11.1%) the Servicemember tag (our arithmetic). Two complaints in the whole history ended with monetary relief and none in 2025 or 2026 to date, which is the same pattern as the large servicers: the company's reply is almost always an explanation, and the database does not say whether the borrower agreed. Of the 96 complaints that were not answered on time since 2012, one is from 2026; all of the 2025 complaints were answered on time.

Peers in the same database (mortgage complaints, counts only)

Company name in the CFPB database20252026 to November 22
Shellpoint Partners, LLC3,2873,375
Mr. Cooper Group Inc. (new complaints go to Rocket from March 2026)2,167454
SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING, INC.8501,037
CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES, LLC5111,055
Fay Servicing, LLC434304
PLANET HOME LENDING, LLC286459
All companies24,69731,037

Fay is the smallest servicer in the table by complaints in 2026 and the second smallest in 2025 (our arithmetic), and its share of all mortgage complaints fell from 1.8% in 2025 to 1.0% in 2026. Counts are not rates: Fay services a different kind of book from Shellpoint or Mr. Cooper, we do not have loan counts for any of them, and a small number can come from a small number of loans. Compare the larger servicers in our Shellpoint review.

When your loan is moved to Fay: what the rule says

The rule is Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.33 (servicing transfers), in the eCFR version dated November 18, 2026, and 12 CFR 1024.41 (loss mitigation).

WhatRuleWhat it saysTime limit
Notice from the old servicer12 CFR 1024.33(b)(3)(i)The transferor servicer gives the borrower a notice of transfer; a single combined notice from both servicers is allowedAt least 15 days before the effective date of the transfer
Notice from the new servicer12 CFR 1024.33(b)(3)(i)The transferee servicer gives its notice, unless a combined notice was sent before the transferNo more than 15 days after the effective date
What the notice must say12 CFR 1024.33(b)(4)Effective date; name, address and a collect call or toll-free number of both servicers; the date the old servicer stops and the new one starts accepting payments (the same or consecutive days); the effect on optional insurance; and that the transfer does not affect any other term of the loanWith the notice
Payments sent to the old servicer12 CFR 1024.33(c)(1) and (c)(2)If the old servicer receives a payment on or before the due date (including any grace period) it “may not be treated as late for any purpose”; the old servicer must pass it on or return it60 days from the effective date of the transfer
First foreclosure filing12 CFR 1024.41(f)(1)(i) and (f)(2)A servicer may not make the first notice or filing for foreclosure unless the loan is more than 120 days delinquent (with exceptions), and not after a complete loss mitigation application unless one of the listed conditions is metDelinquency over 120 days
Judgment or sale after a late application12 CFR 1024.41(g)A complete application received after the first filing but more than 37 days before a foreclosure sale bars a motion for judgment, an order of sale or the sale itself until one of the listed conditions is metMore than 37 days before the sale

Worked example (our arithmetic, a made-up date): if a transfer to Fay takes effect on December 1, 2026, the old servicer's notice is due by November 16, 2026, the new servicer's by December 16, 2026, and a payment that reaches the old servicer on or before its due date cannot be treated as late through January 29, 2027, the 60th day counted from December 1. A payment you send in that window to the old address is not a late payment, but keep proof of the date.

The 2017 and 2024 orders are about the second line of that table: the CFPB found that Fay's foreclosure holds did not start on the day a complete application arrived. The orders are ended, the rule is not: 12 CFR 1024.41 applies to every servicer.

What the documents cannot tell you

  • Complaints are not verified findings, and the counts cover only people who filed with the CFPB. The company name Fay Servicing, LLC covers loans Fay services for investors and trusts, and the database does not say how many of its loans are in default.
  • We have no figure for the number of loans Fay services, so we cannot give a complaints-per-1,000-loans rate. The only size figure we found is Rithm's 24% of its own whole-loan portfolio at the end of 2024.
  • The consent orders are findings the Bureau made while Fay neither admitted nor denied them; the termination order does not say the findings were wrong, it ends the order and waives any alleged noncompliance.
  • We did not read NMLS Consumer Access, other states' regulator sites or court dockets; Fay's licence list is its own, and undated.
  • The owner of Fay Financial, LLC is not in any document we read.

What a reader can do with this

  • If a letter says your loan is moving to Fay, check the dates against the table above and pay by the method in the new notice. Keep proof of any payment made to the old servicer in the first 60 days.
  • If you want to know who owns your loan (Fay usually services for an owner and does not hold the loan itself), ask in writing; under 12 CFR 1024.36(d)(2)(i)(A) the servicer has 10 days, not counting weekends and legal holidays. The CFPB orders and Rithm's and CNL's documents tell you about Fay's customers, not about your loan.
  • If you have borrower-paid private mortgage insurance and a conventional loan, the 2024 order describes the termination rules the Bureau applied: termination when the loan is scheduled to reach 78% of the original value if you are current, with the date recalculated after a modification. Ask for your termination date in writing and compare it with your escrow statement.
  • If you are behind and applying for a modification, write down the date each document arrived and ask when the foreclosure hold took effect. That is the point on which the Bureau's two orders were written.
  • If you think you were harmed by what the 2024 order describes, the CFPB's payments page for the case lists the third-party administrator and a phone number and mailing address for questions.

Frequently asked questions

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: CFPB, consent order In the Matter of Fay Servicing, LLC, File No. 2017-CFPB-0014 (June 2017), and File No. 2024-CFPB-0007 (August 21, 2024), with its Order Terminating the Consent Order (July 1, 2025), the Bureau's enforcement pages for both and its payments page (last modified March 6, 2026), saved November 22, 2026; Massachusetts Attorney General, press release of August 17, 2022 (Internet Archive capture of November 9, 2026); CFPB Consumer Complaint Database API (company Fay Servicing, LLC and five peer servicers, product Mortgage, pulled November 22, 2026, database updated through November 20, 2026); FFIEC HMDA Data Browser aggregations API, 2025, LEI 549300D0H09HSURFXA20; Fay Servicing licensing and home pages (read November 22, 2026); Rithm Capital Corp. Forms 10-K for 2024 (accession 0001556593-25-000007) and 2025 and 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026; CNL Strategic Residential Credit, Inc. Form 8-K exhibit 10.1 (accession 0001437749-26-035428); 12 CFR 1024.33 and 1024.41 (eCFR, version of November 18, 2026).

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.