CrowdfundedWealth

Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing Review: 3,287 CFPB Complaints in 2025, 719 Late Answers in 2026

ReviewBy Jorge18 min read1 SEC filing cited

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the shellpoint mortgage servicing numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing is a name used by Newrez LLC, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Rithm Capital (NYSE: RITM); the CFPB database lists 3,287 mortgage complaints under “Shellpoint Partners, LLC” for 2025 and 3,293 for 2026 through November 20, 2026, and 719 of the 2026 complaints carry a “not timely” flag against 9 in 2025. Rithm's 10-Q for September 30, 2026 puts the servicing portfolio at $878.9 billion of unpaid principal balance, of which Newrez Servicing is $854.8 billion. In August 2026 state regulators announced a $15.5 million settlement with NewRez over lender-placed insurance, and on November 17, 2026 Washington announced a $3 million consent order. If your loan moved to Shellpoint, federal rules give you a 60-day period in which a payment sent to the old servicer cannot be treated as late.

Key takeaways

  • Who it is: Shellpoint's own legal page reads “Newrez LLC dba Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing” with NMLS ID 3013. Rithm Capital's 10-Q says its Origination and Servicing segment “operates through its wholly owned subsidiaries, Newrez LLC (“Newrez”) and New Residential Mortgage LLC (“NRM”)”. The 10-Q never uses the word Shellpoint.
  • Size at September 30, 2026 (Rithm 10-Q, accession 0001556593-26-000035): total servicing portfolio $878,919 million of UPB; Performing Servicing $554,276 million, Special Servicing $300,504 million (of which $266,452 million is for third parties), and $24,139 million serviced by others for Rithm. The 10-Q gives no loan count.
  • Complaints, CFPB database, product Mortgage, company Shellpoint Partners, LLC: 1,117 in 2022, 1,241 in 2023, 2,714 in 2024, 3,287 in 2025 and 3,293 in 2026 to November 20. In 2025, 2,121 were about trouble during the payment process and 720 about struggling to pay, together 86.4 percent (our arithmetic). Escrow, taxes or insurance alone was 692 in 2025 and 686 in 2026.
  • Money back: of 3,287 complaints in 2025, 9 ended with monetary relief and 7 with non-monetary relief; 3,271 ended with an explanation only. In 2022 the monetary count was 72 of 1,117.
  • The 2026 timeliness break: the database marks 719 of the 3,293 complaints of 2026 as not timely (21.8 percent, our arithmetic), peaking at 185 of 349 in June. In 2025 it was 9 of 3,287. Rocket Mortgage, Ocwen, LoanCare and Mr. Cooper show 0 in 2026 and Freedom Mortgage 6. Another 419 complaints were still marked “In progress”, 301 of them received in October.
  • Regulators: a multistate Settlement Agreement and Consent Order with NewRez LLC for $15,500,000 ($9,900,000 penalty, $1,088,757.84 of costs and a $4,511,242.16 credit for relief already paid), covering lender-placed insurance findings under 12 CFR 1024.37 from an examination of November 1, 2020 to October 31, 2021; and a Washington DFI consent order of $3 million announced November 17, 2026 after more than 125 complaints.
  • Transfers: under 12 CFR 1024.33(c)(1), for 60 days from the effective date of a servicing transfer a payment received by the old servicer on or before the due date, including any grace period, cannot be treated as late for any purpose.
  • Lender side, HMDA 2025: NEWREZ LLC originated 66,567 loans for $21.98 billion (41,729 conventional, 13,733 VA, 10,547 FHA, 558 USDA) and denied 36,587 applications of all purposes (our arithmetic from the backbone counts).

CSV · 194 rows

Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing (Newrez LLC): CFPB complaints, Rithm Capital servicing figures, 2026 orders and transfer rules

194 rows: CFPB complaints by year, issue, sub-issue, month and response, five peer servicers, Rithm's September 30, 2026 servicing balances and MSRs, Newrez HMDA 2025 counts, the 2019 and 2026 orders, NMLS IDs and the 12 CFR 1024.33 periods. One source per row.

Who owns Shellpoint

Shellpoint's legal disclosures page says: “Newrez LLC dba Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing is a debt collector.” It gives the NMLS ID as 3013 and lists a main office NMLS ID of 1105381 (Greenville, South Carolina) and branch offices in Houston, Tempe and Jacksonville. The 2019 Washington order and the 2026 multistate order both use NMLS 3013 for the same entity. The multistate order lists NewRez LLC's headquarters as Fort Washington, Pennsylvania.

Above Newrez sits Rithm Capital Corp. (CIK 1556593), whose Form 10-Q was filed on November 2, 2026. It describes servicing this way: “Our servicing operations are organized into performing and special servicing divisions. The performing servicing division services performing Agency and government-insured loans, while the special servicing division services delinquent Agency, government-insured and non-Agency loans on behalf of loan owners.” The 10-Q does not say which division carries the Shellpoint name, so we do not either.

Rithm Capital 10-Q: UPB in $ millionsSept 30, 2026June 30, 2026Sept 30, 2025
Performing Servicing554,276551,196530,709
Special Servicing (includes $266,452 million of third-party loans at Sept 30, 2026)300,504285,214291,354
Total Newrez Servicing854,780836,410822,063
Serviced by third parties for Rithm (owned MSRs)24,13928,81055,461
Total Servicing Portfolio878,919865,220877,524

The same 10-Q says that, as of June 30, 2026, Newrez “ranked among the top ten lenders in the U.S. based on total funded volume of originations and the top five servicers in the U.S. based on total unpaid principal balance (“UPB”) serviced, according to Inside Mortgage Finance.” Rithm owns the mortgage servicing rights on $596.2 billion of that (GSE $373.3 billion, Ginnie Mae $156.3 billion, non-agency $66.6 billion), carried at $12.2 billion. The rest is serviced for other owners, which matters to you: the owner of your loan, not Shellpoint, sets many of the rules.

Newrez also makes investor loans; we cover that product in our NewRez DSCR review.

What the complaints say

The CFPB publishes consumer complaints in a public database. A complaint is one person's account, not a finding, and the number says nothing on its own about how many loans a company services. In that database the Shellpoint complaints sit under a single company name, Shellpoint Partners, LLC. We searched “NewRez LLC”, “Newrez” and “New Penn Financial, LLC” as company names and each returned 0 mortgage complaints, so we count only the Shellpoint name and nothing is double counted. We pulled product Mortgage on November 20, 2026; the latest complaint received was on November 16, 2026.

Shellpoint Partners, LLC, mortgage complaints20222023202420252026 to Nov 20
All complaints1,1171,2412,7143,2873,293
Closed with monetary relief7249891
Closed with non-monetary relief7023270
Closed with explanation9751,1682,7043,2712,602
Marked not timely35329719

In 2022, 6.4 percent of complaints ended with money back (72 of 1,117, our arithmetic); in 2025 it was 0.3 percent (9 of 3,287). Whether that reflects fewer errors, a different mix of complaints or a different way of closing them is not something the database says.

What people complain about (2025 and 2026 to November 20)

Issue or sub-issue20252026 to Nov 20
Trouble during payment process2,1211,975
Struggling to pay mortgage720926
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing156132
Closing on a mortgage118120
Incorrect information on your report9378
Payment process: escrow, taxes, or insurance692686
Payment process: trying to communicate with the company555479
Payment process: payment process417331
Payment process: fees charged106131
Payment process: loan sold or transferred to another company102104
Struggling to pay: communicating about modification, forbearance, short sale, bankruptcy or foreclosure277445
Struggling to pay: foreclosure214177

Payments and hardship together are 86.4 percent of the 3,287 complaints of 2025 and 88.1 percent of the 3,293 of 2026 (our arithmetic). Escrow, taxes or insurance is 21.1 percent of 2025 and 20.8 percent of 2026. In 2026 the loss-mitigation conversations rise: complaints about communicating on a modification, forbearance or foreclosure went from 277 to 445 in a period that is shorter than the year before. For the escrow topic across servicers see our escrow shortage page. Of the 2025 complaints, 527 carry the Older American tag and 497 the Servicemember tag (102 carry both; our arithmetic).

The 2026 timeliness break

Companies must answer a complaint sent through the CFPB; the database records whether they did so on time. For Shellpoint the “not timely” count was in single digits in every month of 2025 (at most 4, in January). It then climbed: 15 in April 2026, 40 in May, 185 in June, 171 in July, 159 in August and 128 in September.

Month received (2026)ComplaintsNot timelyUntimely responseIn progress
March281710
April2541510
May2794000
June34918570
July370171541
August3491591087
September3831289666
October39594301
November 1 to 20500044

“Not timely” is the database's timely-response flag; “Untimely response” and “In progress” are values of the company-response field, and one complaint can carry both a flag and a status. Across 2026 the database shows 271 untimely responses and 419 still in progress. We do not know why: the database does not say. What we can say is that the pattern is specific to Shellpoint among the servicers we checked.

Mortgage complaints, CFPB database20252026 to Nov 20Not timely in 2026
Shellpoint Partners, LLC3,2873,293719
Mr. Cooper Group Inc. (merged into Rocket; last complaint under this name March 8, 2026)2,1674540
Freedom Mortgage Company1,1801,5266
Ocwen Financial Corporation1,1151,3460
Rocket Mortgage, LLC6543,5220
LoanCare, LLC4567990

These are counts of complaints, not rates. The servicers differ greatly in size and none of the counts is divided by a loan count, because Rithm's 10-Q gives balances and no loan count. On the balance, Shellpoint's 3,287 complaints in 2025 against $822,063 million of Newrez Servicing UPB at September 30, 2025 is about 4 complaints per $1 billion (our arithmetic), a rough scale only: we do not know how much of that balance sits under the Shellpoint name. Mr. Cooper's side is in our Mr. Cooper review.

What regulators did

DateRegulatorDocumentWhat it saysMoney
May 14, 2019Washington Department of Financial InstitutionsConsent Order C-18-2429-19-CO01 against NewRez LLC d/b/a Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing f/k/a New Penn Financial, LLCInaccurate annual assessment reports for 2015 and 2016 and underpaid assessments (RCW 31.04.155 and 31.04.085), found in a January 2018 examination. About reporting to the state, not borrowers.$20,000 assessments and $20,000 financial literacy, plus $1,456.11 investigation costs
Announced August 2026State mortgage regulators of 47 jurisdictions, through the CSBS/AARMR Multi-State Mortgage CommitteeSettlement Agreement and Consent Order, NewRez LLCExamination opened January 24, 2022 covering November 1, 2020 to October 31, 2021; Report of Examination of September 12, 2022 found noncompliance with 12 CFR 1024.37 on lender-placed insurance. NewRez neither admits nor denies.$15,500,000: $9,900,000 penalty, $1,088,757.84 costs, $4,511,242.16 credit for relief already paid
November 17, 2026Washington DFIConsent order with Newrez LLC resolving a March 2026 Statement of ChargesAfter more than 125 consumer complaints: incorrectly onboarded loans, incorrectly applied payments, escrow accounts, compliance management, written responses, statements. Corrective steps ordered.$3 million: $2,500,000 to DFI and $500,000 for system enhancements

For one year after an implementation date set 90 days after its effective date, the multistate order has NewRez test newly boarded loans with lender-placed insurance every month, and a loan fails if insurance was charged “when there was valid documentary evidence of a valid homeowners insurance policy in place”. If more than five percent of tested loans fail, NewRez is deemed to have failed that metric. A Maryland report says the company had already returned $4.5 million to more than 4,200 borrowers and that 109 Maryland borrowers share nearly $98,000 of restitution. We could not read the Washington order itself, only the department's press release, which says the issues “were resolved and associated costs were refunded to impacted consumers”. We did not search the CFPB's enforcement list for this page, so the table is not a complete list of actions.

When your loan is transferred to Shellpoint

Regulation X, 12 CFR 1024.33(b)(3), requires the transferor servicer to send the notice of transfer “not less than 15 days before the effective date of the transfer”, and the new servicer to send it “not more than 15 days after the effective date”; a single notice from both must come at least 15 days before. Under 1024.33(c)(1), during the 60 days from the effective date, a payment received by the old servicer on or before the due date, including any grace period, “may not be treated as late for any purpose”. The old servicer must promptly forward the payment or return it and say where to send it (1024.33(c)(2)).

Rule (12 CFR 1024.33)What it saysWhat to do
(b)(3) notice timingOld servicer at least 15 days before; new servicer within 15 days after; extended time up to 30 days after in the cases the rule listsKeep the letter and its date; confirm the new payment address and account number from the letter, not from a phone call
(c)(1) late payments60 days from the transfer date when a payment sent to the old servicer on time cannot be treated as lateIf you were charged a late fee in that window, say so in writing and cite the paragraph
(c)(2) misdirected paymentsThe old servicer must forward the payment or return it with the proper recipientPay on the date you always do and keep proof

What the documents cannot tell you

  • A complaint count is not a verdict. The database does not show which complaints were right, and the same name covers loans Shellpoint services for investors, loans Newrez originated and loans in default.
  • We do not know why 719 complaints of 2026 are flagged as not timely. The pattern could be a response-process problem, a data-reporting problem or a surge of complaints; the documents do not choose among them.
  • The Shellpoint name is not in Rithm's 10-Q, so we cannot give a loan count or a balance for Shellpoint alone.
  • The 2026 orders resolve allegations; the multistate order says NewRez neither admits nor denies them. Neither shows a single borrower's outcome.
  • We could not read NMLS Consumer Access, so we give no license count; Shellpoint's own page lists state-by-state disclosures.

What a reader can do with this

  • If your loan has just moved to Shellpoint, check the date on the transfer notice, keep your last statement from the old servicer and use the account number in the new letter. For 60 days after the transfer, a payment sent to the old servicer on time cannot be treated as late (12 CFR 1024.33(c)(1)).
  • If something is wrong with an escrow line, a fee or a payment, put it in writing and keep a dated copy; Regulation X also has notice-of-error and request-for-information rules, whose deadlines we set out in our Mr. Cooper review.
  • If you have lender-placed insurance you did not need and you had your own policy in force, send the servicer your policy declaration page and ask in writing for the charge to be removed; the 2026 multistate order is built on that exact situation.
  • If you file a CFPB complaint, note that the database in 2026 shows many Shellpoint complaints without a timely company response; keep the complaint number and follow up in writing with the servicer.
  • If you live in Washington, DFI takes complaints about mortgage servicing through its online form.

Frequently asked questions

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: CFPB Consumer Complaint Database (companies Shellpoint Partners, LLC, Mr. Cooper Group Inc., Freedom Mortgage Company, Ocwen Financial Corporation, Rocket Mortgage, LLC and LoanCare, LLC, product Mortgage, pulled November 20, 2026); Rithm Capital Corp. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (accession 0001556593-26-000035); the CSBS/AARMR Multi-State Settlement Agreement and Consent Order with NewRez LLC; Washington DFI consent order C-18-2429-19-CO01 and its November 17, 2026 press release; Shellpoint legal disclosures; a Southern Maryland Chronicle report of August 19, 2026; FFIEC and CFPB HMDA 2025 data; 12 CFR 1024.33 (eCFR, November 18, 2026).

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.