Rental Junk Fees 2026: Greystar, Invitation Homes and State Law
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the rental junk fee rules numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick answer
As of November 17, 2026, no federal rule bans hidden fees in a long-term lease: the FTC's Rule on Unfair or Deceptive Fees (16 CFR Part 464) covers only “Live-event tickets” and “Short-term lodging,” and the FTC itself wrote in March 2026 that it “determined, in its discretion, to proceed incrementally and not include rental housing as part of that rulemaking.” What the agency has done instead is sue the largest landlords one at a time. Invitation Homes agreed to a $48,000,000 judgment (No. 1:24-cv-04280-SEG, N.D. Ga., September 2024); Greystar agreed to $23 million to the FTC and $1 million to Colorado (No. 1:25-cv-00165, D. Colo., order entered December 12, 2025); and on November 6, 2026 the FTC and four states announced $49.75 million with Progress Residential and its owner Pretium Partners, a proposed order the FTC calls the largest enforcement matter against a landlord in its history. The three add to $121.75 million (our arithmetic). All three orders say the companies neither admit nor deny the allegations, and they bind only the companies named. For a small landlord the binding rules today are state rules: Colorado (from January 1, 2026) requires the total price as a single number, Minnesota (leases signed from January 1, 2024) requires a Total Monthly Payment on page one of the lease and the fees in the ad, Massachusetts (from September 2, 2025) treats a dwelling unit as a product under its junk-fee regulation, and New York caps the screening fee at $20.
Key takeaways
- Federal rule scope: 16 CFR 464.1 defines a covered good or service as live-event tickets or short-term lodging, “including temporary sleeping accommodations at a hotel, motel, inn, short-term rental, vacation rental, or other place of lodging.” A 12-month lease is not in it; a vacation or short-term rental is. Section 464.4 leaves state rules in place and says a state law giving greater protection is not inconsistent.
- The rental-housing step is only a notice: the FTC published an advance notice of proposed rulemaking at 91 FR 12325 on March 13, 2026, with comments due April 13, 2026. A search of the Federal Register on November 17, 2026 found no proposed rule after it. The agency's own reason for wanting a rule: a rule “would allow for civil penalties to be sought against violators,” while its “current remedial authority is limited.”
- Invitation Homes: complaint filed September 24, 2024 alleging mandatory fees outside the advertised rent, a bundle that “can add $60 per month” ($720 over a one-year lease), and a deposit return rate of 39.2% against a 63.9% national figure it cites. Order: $48,000,000. In March 2026 the FTC said it was sending checks totaling more than $47.2 million to 444,131 consumers.
- Greystar: complaint filed January 16, 2025 alleging hidden fees collected from tenants in California, Colorado, Nevada and Utah alone of “more than $100 million” between August 2019 and August 2022. Order: $23,000,000 to the FTC and $1,000,000 to Colorado, entered December 12, 2025 according to the FTC's own Federal Register notice. We did not find an FTC refund page or administrator for the $23 million by November 17, 2026.
- Progress Residential: complaint and proposed stipulated order filed November 6, 2026 (No. 1:26-cv-06782-VMC, N.D. Ga.) by the FTC with Arizona, Colorado, Indiana and Utah; $48,500,000 to the FTC and $1,250,000 to Arizona. The FTC release says such an order has the force of law only “when approved and signed by the District Court judge”; we did not confirm a signature.
- State rules a small landlord can check against: Colorado HB25-1090 (new C.R.S. 6-1-737, effective January 1, 2026) bans a fee “for the maintenance of common areas” and, after a written demand, a landlord that does not refund within 14 days owes actual damages plus 18% a year; Minnesota 504B.120 makes a violator liable for treble damages; California SB 611 (Civil Code 1947.3, effective January 1, 2025) bars a fee for paying rent or deposit by check.
- Our arithmetic for a 4-unit owner in Colorado who still bills a $20-a-month common-area fee: $960 a year, $1,132.80 after a year of 18% interest if tenants demand it back and the landlord does not refund within 14 days.
CSV · 61 rows
Rental junk fees: FTC and state enforcement record, the federal fees rule's coverage, penalty amounts and state rental fee rules
61 rows: the Invitation Homes, Greystar and Progress Residential complaints and orders, 16 CFR Part 464 coverage, the 2026 rental-housing notice and penalty amount, and six states' rental fee rules, each with its source.
This is a summary of public rules and enforcement records, not legal advice. Cities and counties can add rules; talk to a licensed attorney in your state before changing a lease or a listing. The orders below are allegations resolved by settlement: each order says the defendant neither admits nor denies them.
The enforcement record: three landlords, three orders
The table lists every FTC action against a landlord over rental fees that we found on ftc.gov. All three were filed as a complaint plus a stipulated order, so the order carries the terms the company agreed to. The amounts are monetary judgments entered in the stipulated orders; the FTC releases say the Invitation Homes, Greystar and Progress money is to be used to refund or compensate consumers, apart from the amounts that go to Colorado and Arizona.
| Case | Agency and court | Date | Amount | What the complaint alleges | Docket or release |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FTC v. Invitation Homes Inc. | FTC, N.D. Ga. (Atlanta) | Complaint September 24, 2024; order filed September 27, 2024 | $48,000,000 judgment; checks of more than $47.2 million sent March 2026 to 444,131 consumers | Mandatory monthly fees left out of the advertised rent (Lease Easy bundle of utility management, air filter and smart-home fees, “$60 per month”; an $85 internet package fee added in November 2023); application fees up to $55 and holding fees up to $500 paid before the total was shown; deposit return rate of 39.2% against 63.9% | No. 1:24-cv-04280-SEG, Doc. 1 and Doc. 21; FTC release of September 24, 2024; refund release of March 11, 2026 |
| FTC and State of Colorado v. Greystar Real Estate Partners, LLC and affiliates | FTC and Colorado Attorney General, D. Colo. | Complaint January 16, 2025; settlement announced December 2, 2025; order entered December 12, 2025 | $23,000,000 to the FTC and $1,000,000 to Colorado, jointly and severally | “Hidden Fees”: valet trash ($25-35 a month), package concierge ($15-20), media or smart-home package ($75-175), common-area charges ($15-25), utility billing, pest control ($2-5), shown after the applicant had applied or paid; more than $100 million collected in four states between August 2019 and August 2022 | No. 1:25-cv-00165-CNS; FTC releases of January 16, 2025 and December 2, 2025 |
| FTC, Arizona, Colorado, Indiana and Utah v. Progress Residential, LLC and Pretium Partners, LLC | FTC and four states, N.D. Ga. (Atlanta) | Complaint and proposed order filed November 6, 2026 | $49,750,000: $48,500,000 to the FTC and $1,250,000 to Arizona | Advertised rent without mandatory monthly fees (smart-home and utility-management fees), an inadequately disclosed renter's insurance exemption fee, deposits withheld for normal wear and tear, and form contracts with nondisparagement clauses; hidden fees “since at least 2021” | No. 1:26-cv-06782-VMC, Doc. 2-1; FTC release of November 6, 2026 |
What the three orders have in common. Each defines a monthly price that includes every mandatory recurring fee (Invitation Homes: “Total Monthly Leasing Price”; Greystar: “Total Monthly Leasing Price,” excluding variable utility costs and optional fees; Progress: “Total Monthly Rental Price”). Each then requires that number to be shown clearly and conspicuously and more prominently than other pricing information (the FTC's notice describes Greystar's order as requiring the company “to most prominently advertise the total rent including all mandatory fees”). Greystar must, before it takes any payment such as a nonrefundable application fee, give the details of all fees and the total monthly price. Greystar's order starts to bind 90 days after the defendants sign it (its Compliance Date). The Progress order, per the FTC release, also requires an itemized statement of deductions no later than 30 days after move-out and bars deductions for normal wear and tear, and the Invitation Homes order has its own security deposit provisions.
What the documents show that the headlines do not. The Invitation Homes complaint did not allege one hidden fee but a sequence: advertised price, application fee up to $55, holding fee up to $500, then a lease that shows a total “as much as $1,740 higher per year.” The Greystar complaint describes the same sequence: in what it calls the most egregious examples, Greystar “did not disclose any of the Hidden Fees it charges until after prospective tenants paid to apply” and, if approved, a forty- to sixty-page lease package arrived. And the Progress release says the complaint attributes “the majority of the conduct” to prior management, which new management has moved to remedy; the settlement is still $49.75 million. On who pays: Greystar's complaint says the company collected the fees “for itself and its landlord clients,” which is the point for a small owner who hires a manager: the advertising is the manager's, but the owner is the one whose building carries the fee.
Other actions the FTC cites. In its March 2026 notice the FTC lists state and local cases as examples of rental fee enforcement. We have not read these filings; the table repeats the FTC's own citations.
| Case as the FTC cites it | Forum and status | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Commonwealth v. Creshem Valley Realty Co. | Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, No. 230701198, complaint | July 13, 2023 |
| State v. Populum Real Estate Holdings, LLC | Colorado District Court, No. 2024CV30023, stipulated final consent judgment | January 8, 2024 |
| Office of the Attorney General v. 786 Property Management, Inc. | Maryland, assurance of discontinuance | August 31, 2023 |
| State v. Berrada Properties Management Inc. | Wisconsin, No. 2023AP1031-LV, consent judgment | December 18, 2024 |
| City of Cincinnati v. VineBrook Homes, LLC | Complaint | January 18, 2023 |
For the listed company behind the first order, see our Invitation Homes stock and dividend page and the refund and INVH versus AMH page.
Does the FTC's “junk fees” rule cover rent? No, and here is the text
The rule everyone calls the junk fees rule is 16 CFR Part 464, published January 10, 2025. Section 464.2(a) says it is an unfair and deceptive practice for any business “to offer, display, or advertise any price of a covered good or service without clearly and conspicuously disclosing the total price.” Section 464.1 then defines a covered good or service in two items: live-event tickets, or short-term lodging, “including temporary sleeping accommodations at a hotel, motel, inn, short-term rental, vacation rental, or other place of lodging.” That has two consequences for a landlord.
- Long-term lease: outside the rule. In the FTC's March 2026 notice (91 FR 12325), the agency states that in the 2025 rulemaking it “determined, in its discretion, to proceed incrementally and not include rental housing as part of that rulemaking.”
- Short-term or vacation rental: inside the rule. An owner who lists a unit as a short-term or vacation rental is renting “temporary sleeping accommodations,” and Part 464 applies to the price shown for it. The rule's text does not define how many nights make a rental short-term; we did not find a number in it.
Why it matters: the penalty. A knowing violation of an FTC rule can carry a civil penalty. The table in 16 CFR 1.98(d) lists the amount for section 5(m)(1)(A) of the FTC Act at $53,088 per violation, and the FTC's September 15, 2026 Federal Register notice (91 FR 58446) says its penalty amounts “will remain unchanged during 2026,” so the 2025 amounts apply. Because Part 464 does not reach leases, that route is not open for rent today; the FTC's notice says a rental rule “would allow for civil penalties to be sought against violators,” and that without one its “current remedial authority is limited.” In the three cases above the money came as redress inside a settlement.
Where the rental rule stands. The March 13, 2026 notice (RIN 3084-AB88) asks about advertised rent that leaves out mandatory fees, fees charged without informed consent and fees misdescribed, across “a lease lifecycle, from application to move out.” It cites a 2025 report finding that “more than 70% of renters reported having to pay at least one mandatory fee or charge aside from the monthly rent.” It is a request for comment, not a proposal: a proposed rule would be a separate Federal Register document, and a search of the Federal Register for FTC documents on rental housing fees on November 17, 2026 returned only this notice. FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson's statement on the Greystar order, as the notice quotes it, said “the problem involving misleading pricing representations in America's rental markets is not limited to Greystar, and today's order will not fully resolve this problem.”
State rules on rental fees: what is in force
State law is where a small landlord is bound today. Part 464 says it does not supersede a state rule that gives “greater” protection. The six rules below were read on the official legislature, revisor, attorney general or code site; the effective date is the one in the enacting text. Other states have acts or bills we did not read (the FTC's notice lists enacted or pending bills in several, including Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Nevada, Oregon and Virginia), and cities can add rules.
| State | Rule | Section | Effective date | What a landlord must do or may not do |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colorado | HB25-1090, Protections Against Deceptive Pricing Practices | C.R.S. 6-1-737 (new) and 38-12-801(3)(a)(VI) | January 1, 2026; applies to conduct on or after that date | Show the total price “as a single number without separating the total price into separate fees,” most prominently; no landlord fee for maintenance of common areas, property taxes, goods or services not provided, or processing rent when a free payment method is not reasonably accessible; a fee may not rise more than 2% over a lease of a year or less (utilities excepted); written demand then 14 days, then actual damages plus 18% a year compounded |
| Colorado | HB23-1099, portable screening report | C.R.S. 38-12-903 and 38-12-904 | Takes effect 12:01 a.m. on the day after the 90-day period following the 2023 session's adjournment | No application fee if the applicant provides a portable screening report completed within the previous 30 days; $2,500 plus costs and fees per violation, or $50 if cured within 7 days of notice |
| Minnesota | Prohibited fees | Minn. Stat. 504B.120 | January 1, 2024, for leases signed on or after that date (2023 c. 52, art. 19, sec. 90) | All nonoptional fees disclosed in the lease; “Total Monthly Payment” on the first page; nonoptional fees in any advertisement or posting; say whether utilities are included; violation means treble damages and possible attorney fees |
| Massachusetts | Unfair and deceptive fees (Attorney General regulation) | 940 CMR 38.03, 38.04 and 38.09 | Applies to acts and practices in force as of September 2, 2025 | A dwelling unit for rent or lease is a covered Product; the total price must be disclosed before personal information is collected (with an underwriting exception) and shown most prominently; rent may be advertised as a monthly amount if the period covered is also disclosed |
| New York | Limitation on fees | Real Property Law 238-a | In force; effective date not shown on the page we read | Screening fee no more than the actual cost or $20, whichever is less, waived if the applicant supplies a report from the past 30 days; late fee only after 5 days and no more than $50 or 5% of monthly rent, whichever is less |
| California | SB 611 (Stats. 2024, ch. 287) | Civil Code 1947.3 | January 1, 2025 | Allow payment of rent and deposit by at least one form that is neither cash nor electronic funds transfer; “shall not charge a tenant any fee for payment by check” |
| Virginia | Fee disclosure statement | Code of Virginia 55.1-1204.1 | Code history: 2024, cc. 788, 826; 2025, c. 567; effective date not read | Itemize the security deposit, rent per period and one-time charges due before commencement on the first page of the written rental agreement, under a prescribed statement |
Some states pair these rules with caps on deposits and late fees; see our pages on the Massachusetts security deposit law, the New York security deposit law, Colorado landlord-tenant law and eviction, California landlord-tenant laws, Virginia and Illinois, where Public Act 104-479, a 2026 act on junk fees and application fees, is covered with its effective-date question.
What changed between 2023 and 2026
| Date | Event | Rule or case | Why it matters to a landlord |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Colorado portable screening report act | HB23-1099 | A tenant with a recent screening report cannot be charged an application fee |
| January 1, 2024 | Minnesota fee disclosure applies to new leases | Minn. Stat. 504B.120 | Total Monthly Payment on page one; fees in the ad; treble damages |
| September 24, 2024 | Invitation Homes complaint and order | No. 1:24-cv-04280-SEG | First FTC order against a landlord's advertised rent: $48,000,000 |
| January 1, 2025 | California bars check-payment fees | Civil Code 1947.3 (SB 611) | No fee for paying by check |
| January 10, 2025 | FTC fees rule published | 16 CFR Part 464 | Covers tickets and short-term lodging, not leases |
| January 16, 2025 | Greystar complaint | No. 1:25-cv-00165 | Hidden fees in apartment advertising: $100 million in four states alone |
| September 2, 2025 | Massachusetts junk-fee regulation applies | 940 CMR 38.00 | Dwelling units for rent are covered Products |
| December 12, 2025 | Greystar order entered | No. 1:25-cv-00165-CNS | $23,000,000 and $1,000,000; total monthly price must be shown |
| January 1, 2026 | Colorado deceptive pricing act | HB25-1090 | Single-number total price; list of fees a landlord may not charge |
| March 13, 2026 | FTC notice on rental housing fees | 91 FR 12325 | Starts the process for a federal rule; comments closed April 13, 2026 |
| November 6, 2026 | Progress Residential and Pretium proposed order | No. 1:26-cv-06782-VMC | $49,750,000, the largest landlord matter in the FTC's history |
What a small landlord must change in a listing and a lease
None of the three orders binds a small owner, and no federal rule requires a listing format for a 12-month lease. What the documents do show is where the agencies drew the line, and each state rule above applies only in its state. Read the table as a checklist of what the sources require or bar, not as a safe harbor.
| Item | In the listing or ad | In the lease or at application | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent plus mandatory fees | Colorado: total price as a single number, most prominent. Minnesota: nonoptional fees disclosed with the rent. Massachusetts: total price shown most prominently, monthly allowed. The three FTC orders: total monthly price shown most prominently | Minnesota: Total Monthly Payment on page one. Virginia: itemization on page one | C.R.S. 6-1-737; Minn. Stat. 504B.120; 940 CMR 38.04; Code of Virginia 55.1-1204.1 |
| Utilities | Minnesota: say whether utilities are included. Colorado: the actual utility-provider cost need not be in the total price | Colorado: no utility fee above what the provider charges the unit | Minn. Stat. 504B.120; C.R.S. 6-1-737(2)(d) and (4)(a) |
| Fees tied to the building | Colorado: no fee for maintenance of common areas | Colorado: no fee for property taxes, for goods or services not provided or for processing rent without a free payment method | C.R.S. 6-1-737(4) |
| Application and screening fee | New York: $20 or actual cost; Colorado: none if the applicant brings a recent portable report | Colorado: the fee may not differ from what another applicant for the same unit is charged (section 38-12-903) | N.Y. RPL 238-a; C.R.S. 38-12-903 as amended |
| Payment method fees | California: no fee for payment by check; offer a form that is neither cash nor electronic transfer | Colorado: no processing fee if no free method is reasonably accessible | Civil Code 1947.3; C.R.S. 6-1-737(4)(d) |
| Fee increases during a lease | Colorado: no more than 2% over a lease of a year or less, utilities excepted | C.R.S. 6-1-737(4)(b) |
Worked example (our arithmetic): a 4-unit owner and one fee that is now off the table
Assume a Colorado owner of four units whose leases carry a $20-a-month “common area” charge. We picked $20 as the middle of the “generally $15-25 per month” the Greystar complaint gives for fixed common-area charges; it is not a figure from Colorado law or from this landlord's market.
- Collected from tenants: $20 × 12 months × 4 units = $960 a year.
- Colorado C.R.S. 6-1-737(4)(i) bars a fee “for the maintenance of common areas,” effective January 1, 2026. A tenant (or group of tenants) can send a written demand; if the landlord does not refund within 14 days, the statute makes the landlord liable for actual damages plus 18% a year compounded annually. If the damages equal one year of the fee and a full year of interest accrues: $960 × 1.18 = $1,132.80, or $172.80 of interest on top of the refund (our arithmetic).
- Minnesota version: a $25-a-month nonoptional fee not disclosed in the ad or on page one of the lease is $25 × 12 × 4 = $1,200 a year. Minn. Stat. 504B.120 subd. 2 makes the landlord liable for treble damages; if a court measured damages as the fees collected, that is $3,600 (our arithmetic; the statute does not say how damages are measured, and a court may award attorney fees on top).
- Against the rent roll: on rent of $2,000 a unit ($96,000 a year for four units, an assumption), $960 is 1.0% of it. If a lender's cash-flow test counted the fee as income, taking it out lowers that income by the same $960.
If the building is financed or about to be, the three lenders below make business-purpose investor loans; the cash flow a lender counts is the lease rent, so a fee that must be refunded is not income to underwrite. Our page on landlord insurance and the property management fee page cover two other lines a manager can add to a lease.
What a reader can do with this
- Check who writes your ad. The Greystar complaint says the manager collected fees “for itself and its landlord clients,” and the orders bind the manager, not the owner. If a manager or a listing platform builds your ad, read the price line: does it show rent plus every mandatory recurring fee as one number?
- List every mandatory charge in one place before you list the unit. Colorado, Minnesota and Massachusetts all ask for the total; the FTC orders define the total as including “all recurring mandatory fees.”
- Treat a fee a tenant cannot avoid as rent. Each order separates optional fees from mandatory ones; the mandatory ones go in the monthly price.
- Read your state's section, not a blog's summary. The table above gives the section and the effective date for six states. If your state is not there, the FTC's March 2026 notice lists others that have enacted or are considering rules; open the statute and check its effective date.
- Watch two federal dates. Whether the judge signs the Progress order, and whether the FTC issues a proposed rental fee rule after the March 2026 notice. Both change what “federal law” means for rent.
- A short-term rental is different. If you list a unit on a short-term platform, 16 CFR 464.2 applies to the price you show.
FAQ
Sources, read November 17, 2026: FTC complaint and stipulated order in FTC v. Invitation Homes Inc., No. 1:24-cv-04280-SEG (N.D. Ga.), and FTC press releases of September 24, 2024 and March 11, 2026; FTC and State of Colorado complaint and stipulated order in No. 1:25-cv-00165 (D. Colo.), and FTC press releases of January 16, 2025 and December 2, 2025; FTC press release, consumer alert and proposed stipulated order of November 6, 2026 in No. 1:26-cv-06782-VMC (N.D. Ga.); eCFR, 16 CFR Part 464 and 16 CFR 1.98 (up to date as of November 13, 2026); Federal Register 91 FR 12325 (March 13, 2026) and 91 FR 58446 (September 15, 2026); Colorado House Bills 25-1090 and 23-1099 (leg.colorado.gov); Minnesota Statutes 504B.120 and 2023 Minnesota Laws chapter 52 (revisor.mn.gov); 940 CMR 38.00 (mass.gov); New York Real Property Law 238-a (nysenate.gov) and the Attorney General's 2019 guide; California Civil Code 1947.3 (leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, archived copy); Code of Virginia 55.1-1204.1 (law.lis.virginia.gov). Court dockets were not opened (CourtListener unavailable on November 17, 2026); the orders were read as filed. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.