CrowdfundedWealth

Fyre Festival: What the SEC and Court Records Say About the Money

ResearchBy Jorge21 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the sec fraud cases and investor recoveries numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

A founder who sold a Bahamas music festival that never happened raised money from more than 100 investors on documents that showed millions of dollars of bookings; the company's real income from bookings was $57,443. The SEC's complaint of July 24, 2018 (case 18-cv-6634, S.D.N.Y.) alleges that William "Billy" McFarland fraudulently induced over 100 investors to put more than $27.4 million into Fyre Media, Fyre Festival LLC and Magnises, Inc. On March 6, 2018 he pleaded guilty to two counts of wire fraud, and prosecutors put the losses at more than $24 million from at least 80 investors plus $2 million from a ticket vendor; he consented to forfeit $26,040,099.48, and on October 11, 2018 he was sentenced to six years in prison. The SEC settlement set disgorgement at $27.4 million, "to be deemed satisfied" by that forfeiture order. In the Fyre Festival LLC chapter 7 case, the bankruptcy court entered default judgments on February 11, 2020 of $10,993,267.51 and $3,422,079.12. How much of any of this reached victims is not in a court record we could read: the criminal judgment and the trustee's final report are not among our sources. Records as of November 19, 2026.

Key takeaways

  • Alleged, ordered and returned are three different numbers. The SEC alleged more than $27.4 million raised from over 100 investors (complaint, paragraph 1). Prosecutors put investor losses at more than $24 million from at least 80 victim-investors, plus $2 million from a ticket vendor (U.S. Attorney press release of March 6, 2018). The forfeiture the founder consented to is $26,040,099.48 at the first plea and $151,206.80 more at the second, $26,191,306.28 together (our arithmetic).
  • The company's real revenue was tiny. The SEC complaint says only 60 talent bookings were confirmed and paid between May 2016 and April 2017, and the fees paid to Fyre Media for them totaled $57,443. That is about 0.24% of the $24.4 million the complaint says was raised from 102 investors in the Fyre Media and Fyre Festival offerings (our arithmetic).
  • The investor documents were built from the real ones. The complaint says a January 2017 offer report from the booking platform showed $1.459 million of offers and the version sent to investors showed $34.79 million, about 24 times as much (our arithmetic). It also says a brokerage statement showing $2.56 million of Facebook shares was backed by $1,499 of actual shares.
  • The SEC case ended in a consent judgment on August 1, 2018: a permanent injunction against violating Securities Act Sections 5 and 17(a) and Exchange Act Sections 10(b) and 15(a), and, on August 3, 2018, an SEC order barring him from associating with any broker, dealer or investment adviser and from penny stock offerings. The disgorgement of $27.4 million was tied to the criminal forfeiture, which is about $1.2 million smaller (our arithmetic).
  • In bankruptcy court, the trustee showed that at least $14,415,346 of festival money was moved into Fyre Media accounts, and at least $10,993,267.51 from there to the founder between January and April 2017. The court entered default judgments for those amounts on February 11, 2020. A judgment is a claim, not cash.
  • What came back, per press reports of court papers: about $1.4 million collected by the trustee and about $300,000 left for creditors after costs (Fox Business, July 7, 2021); a $2 million claim for 277 ticket holders at $7,220 each (NPR, April 16, 2021); and a $245,300 eBay sale of the Fyre brand (Yahoo News, July 16, 2025). The FBI wrote in November 2018 that forfeited money would be returned to victims if possible but would likely be a small portion of what was lost.

CSV · 65 rows

Fyre Festival: SEC complaint, SEC judgment, criminal pleas, forfeiture, bankruptcy judgment and recoveries, 2017-2025

65 rows: what the SEC complaint alleges about each offering, the SEC settlement and judgment, the two criminal pleas and forfeiture amounts, the bankruptcy court's default judgments and the press-reported recoveries. Source and URL on every row.

The story in dated documents

Fyre Media was meant to be an app for booking artists. Fyre Festival, a subsidiary, was meant to advertise it with a luxury festival in the Bahamas. The festival collapsed in April 2017 and the paper trail starts there. Each row below points to a document we saved and read.

DateEventDocument
April 2017Advance-ticket buyer pays $2 million on a Fyre Media income statement that the U.S. Attorney says grossly inflated revenue and incomeU.S. Attorney (S.D.N.Y.) press release 18-067, March 6, 2018
July 7, 2017Involuntary chapter 7 petition filed against Fyre Festival LLC, case 17-11883 (MG)SEC complaint, paragraph 14; bankruptcy court opinion
August 29, 2017Bankruptcy court enters the order for reliefBankruptcy court opinion, Adv. 19-01340
March 6, 2018Guilty plea to two counts of wire fraud, case 17 Cr. 600; consent to forfeit $26,040,099.48U.S. Attorney press release 18-067
July 24, 2018SEC files its complaint and announces settlements with the founder, two companies, a former executive and a former contractorSEC litigation release 24213; press release 2018-141
July 26, 2018Second plea (ticket scheme, bank fraud, false statements) while awaiting sentencing; additional forfeiture of $151,206.80U.S. Attorney press release 18-259
August 1, 2018Final judgment entered by consent in the SEC caseSEC order, Release No. 34-83773
August 3, 2018SEC follow-on order bars the founder from the securities industry and penny stock offeringsSEC order, Release No. 34-83773, File No. 3-18622
October 11, 2018Sentenced to six years in prisonFBI news story, November 5, 2018
February 11, 2020Bankruptcy court grants default judgments of $10,993,267.51 and $3,422,079.12Bankruptcy court opinion, Adv. 19-01340

What the documents show that the headlines don't

Alleged versus ordered versus recovered

The same story carries four different dollar figures depending on which document you read. This is the table nobody else puts in one place:

LayerDocument and dateAmountWhat it isWhat it is not
SEC allegationComplaint, July 24, 2018More than $27.4 million from over 100 investorsThe amount the SEC alleges was raised across Fyre Media, Fyre Festival and MagnisesA finding of loss; it includes $3 million raised for Magnises
Criminal lossU.S. Attorney release, March 6, 2018More than $24 million from at least 80 investors, plus $2 million from a ticket vendorThe losses prosecutors tied to the two wire fraud countsA restitution order
ForfeiturePlea releases, March 6 and July 26, 2018$26,040,099.48 plus $151,206.80, or $26,191,306.28 (our arithmetic)Money and property the founder consented to forfeit to the governmentCash in hand: the FBI wrote it would likely be a small portion of what was lost
SEC disgorgementLitigation release, July 24, 2018$27.4 millionAgreed amount, to be deemed satisfied by the criminal forfeiture orderA separate payment on top of the forfeiture
Bankruptcy judgmentOpinion, February 11, 2020$10,993,267.51 joint; $3,422,079.12 against Fyre MediaDefault judgments for money moved out of the festival's estateA recovery: they are claims against defendants that did not respond
RecoveredTrustee's final report; criminal judgment and forfeiture accountingNot in our sourcesThe amount actually paid to victimsAvailable only as press reports of court papers, labelled as such in the section below

Two gaps in the table are worth stating plainly. The SEC's $27.4 million is about $1.2 million larger than the $26,191,306.28 forfeited in total (our arithmetic), and the SEC release says the disgorgement is "to be deemed satisfied" by the forfeiture order without saying how that gap is treated. And the criminal judgment itself, which would give the restitution order, is not in our sources: court records not scored (CourtListener unavailable on November 19, 2026). NPR wrote in August 2023 and again in April 2025 that he "still owes $26 million in restitution"; we report that as NPR's statement, not as a reading of the judgment.

What investors were shown and what the company recorded

The SEC complaint is specific about the gap between the documents and the business. Everything in this table is an allegation in the complaint unless it is marked as the U.S. Attorney's statement.

ItemWhat investors were shownWhat the complaint says was realParagraph
Fyre Media bookings"thousands of offers representing tens of millions of dollars" in the January 2017 memorandum60 confirmed and paid bookings, $57,443 in fees (May 2016 to April 2017)30-31
September 2016 offer report42 accepted offers totaling $5.6 millionThe platform's own report: 33 accepted offers, $275,800 in total, under $8,400 each24
January 2017 offer report$34.79 million of offers for the month$1.459 million on the report generated by the platform38
Bookings forecastOn track to achieve $160M of completed bookings by Q4 2017A colleague asked whether it was a typo; the next investor email raised the goal from $50 million to $150 million26-28
Founder's collateralA statement showing $2.56 million of Facebook shares$1,499 of Facebook shares44
Event cancellation insuranceInvestors would have rights to payouts if the festival was cancelledNo event cancellation policy was ever executed; investors lost their investments in full51
Bahamas landReal estate worth about $8 million acquired for the siteFyre Media never acquired any real estate in the Bahamas32
Magnises membership7,000 to 40,000 members and $2.5 million of revenue from March 2014 to August 2015Never more than 4,000 to 5,000 members; peak monthly revenue about $100,000 (former employees)67-68
Magnises saleA $35 to 40 million sale to a third-party buyerThe buyer was invented; the SEC says the address given was Magnises's own55-59

The SEC also alleges that the offerings were not registered and not exempt, that many buyers were not accredited investors and that no audited financial statements were distributed before the sale (paragraphs 81 to 83). That is the part that matters for anyone who is asked to invest in a private company: the documents you are handed are the only evidence you get.

Who was charged, and with what

The SEC complaint names five defendants: the founder, Fyre Media, Magnises, a former chief marketing officer and a former contractor. The founder, Fyre Media and Magnises settled by consent; the former executive and the contractor settled without admitting or denying. The litigation release gives a 7-year director-and-officer bar and a $35,000 civil penalty for the executive, and a 3-year bar and over $15,000 in disgorgement and penalty for the contractor. The complaint describes their role as negligent assistance, charged under Securities Act Section 17(a)(3) only. The founder admitted the SEC's allegations against him, according to the release.

The criminal cases: two pleas, one sentence

The first case, 17 Cr. 600 (NRB), covers the investors and the ticket vendor. On March 6, 2018 the founder pleaded guilty to two counts of wire fraud. The U.S. Attorney's release says prosecutors tied the scheme to "at least 80 victim-investors, totaling more than $24 million" and to a $2 million payment from a ticket vendor. It also says Fyre Media's income from talent bookings from approximately May 2016 to April 2017 "was only $57,443", the same figure as the SEC complaint, and that falsified documents showed over 2,500 confirmed talent bookings in a single month when there were only 60 in the entire year.

The SEC counts "at least 102 investors" for $24.4 million in the Fyre Media and Fyre Festival offerings; the U.S. Attorney counts "at least 80" for more than $24 million. Both are lower bounds from different documents, and we do not reconcile them.

The second case was filed while he awaited sentencing. On July 26, 2018 he pleaded guilty to wire fraud for a ticket scheme run through a company called NYC VIP Access, to bank fraud for writing a check in an employee's name without authorization, and to making false statements to a federal agent. The U.S. Attorney's release says he obtained approximately $150,000 in fraudulent ticket sales from at least 30 customer-victims, and that the events advertised, such as the 2018 Met Gala and Coachella 2018, had no tickets behind them. He consented to forfeit an additional $151,206.80.

On October 11, 2018 he was sentenced to six years in prison, according to the FBI. NPR reported in August 2023 that the sentence included three years of supervised release and that he was released in March 2022. The FBI also wrote that money recovered through forfeiture would be returned to victims "if possible, though that will likely be a small portion of what was lost."

The bankruptcy: where the festival's money went

The bankruptcy court's opinion says Fyre Festival LLC maintained only two financial accounts, both escrow accounts for an air travel vendor, and that all other festival money went into and out of accounts of Fyre Media and the founder. The trustee's accounting, which the court deemed admitted when the defendants did not answer the complaint, is in the next table.

ItemAmountSource in the opinion
Festival money moved into Fyre Media accounts, at least$14,415,346Background, paragraph 26 of the motion
Of which: investors in and lenders to Fyre Festival$10,471,000Complaint paragraph 61
Of which: revenue from ticket purchasers$1,404,531.86Complaint paragraph 61
Of which: company that paid for advance ticket sales$1,500,000Complaint paragraph 61
Of which: prepaid wristband balances$1,039,814.77Complaint paragraph 61
Moved from Fyre Media to the founder, January 1 to April 30, 2017, at least$10,993,267.51Motion paragraph 27
Founder's personal expenses in that period, at least$315,645.87Motion paragraph 31
Default judgment, Fyre Media and the founder jointly and severally$10,993,267.51Conclusion
Default judgment, Fyre Media only$3,422,079.12Conclusion

The two judgments add up to $14,415,346.63, the full amount moved into Fyre Media (our arithmetic). The court granted them "without prejudice to additional judgments on unliquidated claims", and noted that the founder had not filed bankruptcy schedules or testified at a meeting of creditors. In a letter of September 14, 2019, quoted in the opinion, he "accepted responsibility for repaying 'every dollar owed to investors and ticket holders.'"

What creditors got, as reported

We could not retrieve the trustee's final report from the court. The recovery figures below come from press reports of court papers and are labelled that way.

Fox Business reported on July 7, 2021 that the trustee had told the court he had "collected a measly $1.4 million", that "there will be just $300,000 left for creditors" after about $1.1 million of costs, and that this would leave "less than 4 cents on the dollar" for unsecured creditors, who claimed they were owed "more than $7 million." NPR reported on April 16, 2021 that a settlement with 277 ticket holders would give each a claim of $7,220, a $2 million total (277 times $7,220 is $1,999,940, our arithmetic), and that the final amount could be lower depending on the bankruptcy. A claim of $2 million against a pool of about $300,000 is not a $2 million payment.

Set against the judgments (our arithmetic), the $1.4 million reported as collected is about 10% of the $14,415,346.63 awarded by default.

After prison: Fyre Festival 2 and the brand sale

Dated press reports, one sentence each. CNN reported on February 24, 2025 that Fyre Festival 2 was "set to be held on Mexico's Isla Mujeres between May 30 and June 2." NPR reported on April 24, 2025 that the founder had put the brand up for sale and that the sequel "will not take place on May 30 in Mexico as planned", and that he "still owes $26 million in restitution." Yahoo News reported on July 16, 2025 that the brand "sold its intellectual property for $245,300 on eBay" after 175 bids from 42 bidders. In our search on November 19, 2026 we found no dated report of a Fyre Festival 2 event taking place, and no document showing where the eBay proceeds went.

What this means for your money

This is our reading of the documents, not advice.

  • A forfeiture order is not a refund. It transfers assets to the government. The FBI itself wrote that what is recovered would likely be a small portion of what was lost, and the press reports put the bankruptcy payout at a few cents on the dollar. Compare the recoveries on our page about what investors got back in 12 real-estate and private-fund fraud cases.
  • Unregistered private offerings come with no filing to read. The SEC alleges no registration statement was filed and no audited financial statements were given. In a registered or exempt-and-filed offering, the SEC's EDGAR system holds a document you can check; in this one the only evidence was the investor deck and the offer reports.
  • Check the number against a second source before the cheque. The complaint's own pattern is one document (a booking report, a brokerage statement) standing in for a record that a third party could have confirmed: the platform's own report, a brokerage's confirmation, a bank's loan letter.
  • Ticket buyers stood in line behind the costs. In the chapter 7 case, the press reported about $1.1 million of costs taken out of about $1.4 million collected, leaving about $300,000 against more than $7 million of unsecured claims.
  • A founder's own filings are the starting point, not the end. Our page on what the WeWork S-1 showed reads a company that did file. The same method on a company that does not file is only possible when a regulator or court later publishes the record, as it did here. For the same kind of records in a health-technology case, see our page on the Theranos SEC complaint and restitution.

What a reader can do with this

  1. Ask for the filing before the pitch. If the company has registered with the SEC, search EDGAR; if it relies on an exemption, look for a Form D on EDGAR for that offering.
  2. Ask which numbers a third party can confirm. Revenue should reconcile to a bank statement or an audit; "offers" or "interest" should reconcile to a platform export you can see.
  3. Treat a quoted collateral value as a claim. Ask for the custodian's confirmation sent directly, not a screenshot.
  4. If you are already in a failed private deal, read the court docket and any trustee reports for the amount actually collected, the costs and the claims pool. Those three numbers decide the recovery, and they are rarely in the headline.

Get an email when new SEC fraud cases and investor recoveries are added to this series: the box at the top of this page.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 19, 2026: SEC, "Securities and Exchange Commission v. William Z. ('Billy') McFarland et al.," complaint, Case 1:18-cv-06634, S.D.N.Y., filed July 24, 2018 (sec.gov/files/litigation/complaints/2018/comp24213.pdf); SEC Litigation Release No. 24213 and press release 2018-141, July 24, 2018; SEC, In the Matter of William Z. McFarland, Release No. 34-83773, File No. 3-18622, August 3, 2018; SEC Division of Enforcement remarks, October 3, 2018, citing the final judgment of August 1, 2018; U.S. Attorney's Office, S.D.N.Y., press releases 18-067 (March 6, 2018) and 18-259 (July 26, 2018); FBI, "Fyre Festival Founder Sentenced," November 5, 2018; U.S. Bankruptcy Court, S.D.N.Y., memorandum opinion in Adv. Pro. 19-01340 (MG), February 11, 2020; Fox Business (July 7, 2021); NPR (April 16, 2021, August 24, 2023 and April 24, 2025); CNN (February 24, 2025); Yahoo News (July 16, 2025). Press reports are cited only as those outlets' reports. Court records not scored (CourtListener unavailable on November 19, 2026).

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.