Enron Scandal in Its Own Filings: Restatement, What Creditors Got
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the sec fraud cases and investor recoveries numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick answer
Enron's annual report for 2000 showed $979 million of net income on $100,789 million of revenue; on November 8, 2001 the company said its statements for 1997 through 2000 should not be relied upon, and by October 2011 its creditors had received 52.7 percent of their allowed claims. The 10-K was filed on April 2, 2001. In its own restatement table of November 8, 2001, net income for the four years fell from $2,680 million to $2,089 million (our sum of its four yearly columns), and debt for 2000 rose from $10,229 million to $10,857 million. Enron filed for Chapter 11 on December 2, 2001 (case 01-16034, Southern District of New York).
What came back, in the latest documents we read: the bankruptcy estate had distributed approximately $21,826,000,000 by October 14, 2011; the securities class action fund is $7,227,000,000 (order of September 8, 2008) against class losses that Lead Plaintiff put at approximately $44 billion; and 54.2 percent of the employees' Savings Plan was Enron common stock on December 31, 2000 (our arithmetic).
Key takeaways
- The audited 10-K for 2000 (filed April 2, 2001) reported net income of $979 million, total assets of $65,503 million and long-term debt of $8,550 million. Its Note 16 describes transactions with limited partnerships called the “Related Party” whose general partner's managing member is “a senior officer of Enron”, and does not use the name LJM. The 2001 proxy statement does name LJM2 and its managing member, then the Chief Financial Officer.
- Three documents give three restated totals for 1997-2000 net income: $2,089 million (8-K, November 8, 2001), $2,067 million (10-Q, November 19, 2001) and a $508 million cut from the LJM1 and Chewco items alone (Powers Report, February 1, 2002). The company's own 2000 figure moved from $979 million to $847 million, then $842 million (our arithmetic: reductions of $132 million and $137 million).
- Enron's table of LJM transactions puts their effect on 2000 pre-tax earnings at $604.5 million; 2000 pre-tax income in the 10-K was $1,413 million, so that is 42.8 percent of it (our arithmetic; the two figures come from different documents and bases).
- Creditors: the plan estimated 17.4 percent for Enron general unsecured creditors; by October 14, 2011 they had received 52.7 percent, and Enron North America creditors 52.4 percent against 20.1 percent estimated. Existing stock was cancelled on November 17, 2004, and the company had said in February 2002 that it believed existing equity would have no value.
- Investors in the class action: $7,227,000,000 from ten defendants, 91.3 percent of it from three banks (our arithmetic). Lead Plaintiff stated class losses of approximately $44 billion, so the fund is about 16.4 percent of that figure (our arithmetic).
- Employees: on December 31, 2000 the Enron Corp. Savings Plan held $1,157,515,958 of Enron common stock in $2,135,027,964 of net assets, 54.2 percent (our arithmetic). The Department of Labor announced settlements restoring at least $66.5 million to the Enron plans on May 12, 2004; a court order records a first tranche of about $89 million paid to Savings Plan claimants.
CSV · 138 rows
Enron: filings, restatement, bankruptcy, creditor, investor and employee recoveries and criminal outcomes, 2000-2026
138 rows: the 10-K, proxy and 10-Q figures as first filed, every restatement version, the Powers Report numbers, the plan, the creditor, class action and employee recoveries and the criminal outcomes. Source and document on every row.
The story, dated
The Department of Justice calls Enron once the nation's seventh largest company, and says its stock rose from approximately $30 a share in early 1998 to over $80 a share in January 2001. In the second quarter of 2001 it reported revenue of $50,060 million and net income of $404 million. After the third quarter announcement of October 16, 2001, its own 10-Q describes a loss of investor confidence that significantly affected its ability to raise capital. Everything below comes from documents filed by the company, the courts, the Department of Justice and the Department of Labor.
| Date | Event | Document |
|---|---|---|
| February 23, 2001 | Arthur Andersen LLP signs its audit report on the 2000 financial statements | Form 10-K for 2000 |
| March 27, 2001 | Proxy statement names LJM2 and its managing member, the Chief Financial Officer, under Certain Transactions | Schedule DEF 14A |
| April 2, 2001 | Form 10-K filed: revenue $100,789 million, net income $979 million | Form 10-K for 2000 |
| August 14, 2001 | Form 10-Q for the second quarter: net income $404 million, total assets $63,392 million | Form 10-Q, June 30, 2001 |
| October 16, 2001 | Third quarter results announced; Enron records a $544 million after-tax charge tied to LJM2 and a $1.2 billion reduction of equity | Powers Report; Form 10-Q for the third quarter |
| November 8, 2001 | Enron says it will restate 1997 through 2000 and the first two quarters of 2001 | Form 8-K, November 8, 2001 |
| November 19, 2001 | Third quarter 10-Q: net loss $644 million; going-concern warning; auditor has not finished its review | Form 10-Q, September 30, 2001 |
| December 2, 2001 | Enron and affiliates file Chapter 11 petitions; a $1.5 billion debtor-in-possession facility is committed | Form 8-K, event date December 2, 2001 |
| February 1, 2002 | Special Investigative Committee reports to the Board; filed as Exhibit 99.2 to an 8-K | Powers Report |
| February 12, 2002 | Enron says existing equity has and will have no value | Form 8-K, event date February 12, 2002 |
| January 14, 2004 | The former CFO pleads guilty to two conspiracy counts | Department of Justice |
| July 15, 2004 | Bankruptcy court confirms the plan; it takes effect on November 17, 2004 | Findings and conclusions; Form 8-K |
| May 25, 2006 | Federal jury convicts the former CEO; the former chairman was convicted with him and died on July 5, 2006 | Department of Justice |
| September 8, 2008 | Court approves the plan of allocation of the $7,227,000,000 class action fund | Order, H-01-3624 |
| October 14, 2011 | Post-confirmation report: $21,826,000,000 distributed; 52.7 percent to Enron general unsecured creditors | Twenty-Eighth Post-Confirmation Status Report |
What the documents show that the headlines don't
Look for the October 16 filing: there is none
The October 16, 2001 announcement is not in a stand-alone Form 8-K. The EDGAR filing list for Enron (CIK 1024401) shows no Form 8-K between February 28, 2001 and November 8, 2001. What exists is the Form 10-Q filed on November 19, 2001, which refers to the October 16 announcement, a significant fall in the share price and credit ratings cut to BBB- and Baa3, the lowest investment grade level, and the Form 8-K of November 8, 2001, which carries the restatement and explains the equity reduction. A reader looking for the first filing that explains the $1.2 billion will find it in those two documents.
What the 10-K said, and what the proxy said
The audited 10-K does not use the word LJM. Its Note 16, titled Related Party Transactions, describes “limited partnerships (the Related Party) whose general partner's managing member is a senior officer of Enron”, says the limited partners are unrelated to Enron, and adds that management believes the terms “were reasonable compared to those which could have been negotiated with unrelated third parties.” The note gives sizeable numbers: Enron contributed assets valued at approximately $1.2 billion to the Entities, entered into derivative transactions with a combined notional amount of approximately $2.1 billion, and recognized revenues of approximately $500 million from the subsequent change in the market value of those derivatives.
Item 13 of the 10-K sends the reader to the proxy statement. There, under Certain Transactions, the company names LJM2 and writes that Andrew S. Fastow, Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, “is the managing member of LJM2's general partner”. It lists eleven transactions in which LJM2 bought from Enron, for approximately $213 million, and sales of merchant investments by LJM2 to Enron for approximately $76 million, and says the transactions were “negotiated on an arm's length basis with senior officers of Enron other than Mr. Fastow.” The two documents together contained the facts; the 10-K, the one most investors read, did not put the name beside them.
Three restatements, three sets of numbers
The company's restated figures moved within eleven days, and the special committee gave a third view of the same items. We show all three, not one.
| Net income, USD millions | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000 | Four years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| As reported (10-K and earlier filings) | 105 | 703 | 893 | 979 | 2,680 |
| Restated, 8-K of November 8, 2001 | 9 | 590 | 643 | 847 | 2,089 |
| Restated, 10-Q of November 19, 2001 | 26 | 564 | 635 | 842 | 2,067 |
| Reduction, 8-K basis (our arithmetic) | 96 | 113 | 250 | 132 | 591 |
| Reduction, 10-Q basis (our arithmetic) | 79 | 139 | 258 | 137 | 613 |
| Powers Report: cut from the LJM1 and Chewco items alone | 28 | 133 | 248 | 99 | 508 |
The 10-Q says that some amounts in its table “differ from those included in Enron's November 8, 2001 Form 8-K due to further refinement of the identified restatement items.” The 8-K says the figures are unaudited. The 1997 figure is after a $463 million after-tax restructuring charge. In dollars, the four years lost roughly 22 percent of reported net income on either basis (our arithmetic: 591 and 613 over 2,680).
The balance sheet moved the same way. Debt was restated up in every year and equity down, as the table from the 8-K and 10-Q shows.
| December 31, 2000, USD millions | As reported (10-K) | Restated, 8-K of November 8, 2001 | Restated, 10-Q of November 19, 2001 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Debt | 10,229 | 10,857 | 10,857 |
| Shareholders' equity | 11,470 | 10,306 | 10,289 |
| Total assets | 65,503 | 64,775 | 64,926 |
| Net income | 979 | 847 | 842 |
For 1997 the debt restatement was larger in proportion: $6,254 million became $6,965 million, an increase of $711 million, 11.4 percent (our arithmetic), the dollar figure the Powers Report also gives. For 2000 the increase was $628 million, 6.1 percent (our arithmetic).
How much of 2000's profit came through the related parties
Enron's own Table 2 in the November 8, 2001 8-K sums the effect of the LJM transactions on pre-tax earnings. For 2000 it was $604.5 million; for 1999 it was $138.8 million; for the first nine months of 2001 it was negative $165.5 million, so that the total over the whole period is $577.8 million. Net income before the cumulative effect of accounting changes for 2000 was $979 million after $434 million of income tax, which is pre-tax income of $1,413 million (our arithmetic). The LJM effect for the year is 42.8 percent of that figure (our arithmetic). The 8-K table is unaudited and covers items the company itself had not yet fully reviewed, so treat it as an upper-level indicator of dependence, not as an audited percentage.
The 8-K also says that Enron believed the initial capital commitments to LJM1 were $16 million and to LJM2 $394 million, that 24 business relationships involved LJM1 or LJM2 between June 1999 and September 2001, and that its former CFO had received “in excess of $30 million” from his LJM management and investment activities. The Powers Report later wrote that the CFO was enriched by at least $30 million and another employee by at least $10 million.
The Raptors and the $1.2 billion
The $1.2 billion reduction of equity announced on October 16, 2001 is explained in the 8-K of November 8, 2001. Four special purpose entities known as Raptor I to IV were created in 2000 to hedge Enron's investments; Enron had recorded notes receivable as an increase in equity, and “now believes” they should have been recorded as a reduction in equity. That error overstated equity by approximately $172 million in 2000 and by a further $828 million in the first quarter of 2001. In the third quarter of 2001 Enron bought LJM2's interests in the Raptors for about $35 million and, per the 10-Q, recorded charges of $710 million ($462 million after tax) on the acquisition and a charge of $48 million to write down warrants. The Powers Report concluded that these hedging transactions let Enron report earnings from the third quarter of 2000 through the third quarter of 2001 that were “almost $1 billion higher than should have been reported.”
The Special Investigative Committee, chaired by William Powers, found that the partnerships were used by management to enter into transactions that “it could not, or would not, do with unrelated commercial entities.” It wrote: “Many of the most significant transactions apparently were designed to accomplish favorable financial statement results, not to achieve bona fide economic objectives or to transfer risk.” It added that some transactions were designed so that, had they followed the accounting rules, Enron could have kept assets and liabilities, especially debt, off its balance sheet, “but the transactions did not follow those rules.” The report adds that three former employees named in it declined to be interviewed on most issues and that the Committee had only limited access to Andersen's workpapers.
The auditor
Arthur Andersen LLP signed the audit report on the 2000 financial statements on February 23, 2001. The Powers Report says that in “virtually all of the transactions” Enron's accounting treatment was determined with “extensive participation and structuring advice from Andersen”, and that Enron's records show Andersen billed $5.7 million for advice on the LJM and Chewco transactions alone, above and beyond its regular audit fees. It also records Andersen's CEO telling Congress that the firm had “simply been wrong in 1999” about the LJM1 structure.
Arthur Andersen was indicted in March 2002 on one count of violating 18 U.S.C. §1512(b)(2)(A) and (B), corruptly persuading its employees to withhold or alter documents; a jury found it guilty. On May 31, 2005 the Supreme Court reversed and remanded (No. 04-368), holding that the jury instructions failed to convey the elements of a corrupt persuasion conviction. The opinion concerns the jury instructions. The class action fund described below includes $72,500,000 from Arthur Andersen and $33,330,000 from Andersen Worldwide.
The creditors: 17.4 percent forecast, 52.7 percent paid
The bankruptcy court confirmed the plan on July 15, 2004, after finding that more than 24,500 proofs of claim had been filed; it became effective on November 17, 2004. The company's disclosure statement had estimated what each class would get. The court's findings quote an Enron North America creditor recovery of 20.1 percent under the plan and 17.4 percent in a stand-alone scenario. The estate's own 28th status report, filed October 14, 2011, gives the outcome:
| Measure | Estimate in the disclosure statement | Paid, as reported on October 14, 2011 |
|---|---|---|
| Enron general unsecured creditors, return on allowed claims | 17.4% | 52.7% |
| Enron North America creditors, return on allowed claims | 20.1% | 52.4% |
| ENA creditors who also hold an Enron guaranty claim, combined | Not stated in the report | 94.8%, excluding gains, interest and dividends |
| Total distributed in cash, PGE stock and cash equivalents | Not stated in the report | Approximately $21,826,000,000, of which $267,000,000 is interest, capital gains and dividends |
| Distributed by April 2, 2007 (press release) | Not applicable | Approximately $11,479,000,000 |
The report also says all disputed claims had been resolved and that of more than 25,000 proofs of claim filed, approximately 5,653 were ordered allowed and approximately 2,333 allowed as filed. On November 17, 2004 all of the company's outstanding stock was cancelled and replaced by non-transferable trust interests, with distributions to them to be made only “in the highly unlikely event” that assets exceeded allowed claims.
The investors: a fund of $7.227 billion against a stated $44 billion of losses
In the securities class action, In re Enron Corporation Securities, Derivative and “ERISA” Litigation (H-01-3624, S.D. Tex.), the court's order of September 8, 2008 on the plan of allocation lists the settlement fund by source.
| Settling defendant | Amount | Share of the $7,227,000,000 (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|
| CIBC | $2,400,000,000 | 33.2% |
| JPMorgan Chase | $2,200,000,000 | 30.4% |
| Citigroup | $2,000,000,000 | 27.7% |
| Lehman Brothers | $222,500,000 | 3.1% |
| Outside Directors | $168,000,000 | 2.3% |
| Arthur Andersen | $72,500,000 | 1.0% |
| Bank of America | $69,000,000 | 1.0% |
| LJM2 | $51,900,000 | 0.7% |
| Andersen Worldwide | $33,330,000 | 0.5% |
| Kirkland & Ellis | $10,160,000 | 0.1% |
The order quotes Lead Plaintiff that the class members' losses are “approximately $44 billion” and the settlement fund “approximately $7.2 billion”, with more than one million class members who may make claims. The fund is about 16.4 percent of the stated losses (our arithmetic). The nine items above add to $7,227,390,000, the order's rounded total of $7,227,000,000. Three banks provided $6,600,000,000, 91.3 percent of it (our arithmetic). That is a different pattern from the bankruptcy: the people paying were lenders, advisers and directors, not the company.
The employees: the 401(k) held the stock
The Form 11-K for the Enron Corp. Savings Plan for 2000, filed June 27, 2001, shows net assets available for benefits of $2,135,027,964 at December 31, 2000, up from $1,623,350,881. Enron common stock was $1,157,515,958 of that, and Enron Cumulative Second Preferred Convertible Stock, held in the same stock fund, $158,875,150 more.
| Savings Plan, December 31 | Enron common stock | Net assets | Share (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1999 | $662,118,399 | $1,623,350,881 | 40.8% |
| 2000, common stock only | $1,157,515,958 | $2,135,027,964 | 54.2% |
| 2000, common plus preferred | $1,316,391,108 | $2,135,027,964 | 61.7% |
What employees got back comes from two documents. On May 12, 2004 the Department of Labor announced the filing of settlements “to restore at least $66.5 million to the Enron 401(k) and employee stock ownership plans”; the proposed settlements were subject to court approval, and the release says neither applied to Enron or to the former executives Kenneth L. Lay and Jeffrey K. Skilling. A 2008 court order in the ERISA litigation describes a first tranche of settlement funds of approximately $89 million distributed to Savings Plan claimants. We did not find a document giving the total ERISA settlement or a per-participant figure, so we do not give one.
What happened to the executives named by the Department of Justice
| Person (role at Enron) | Outcome as the Department of Justice records it | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Jeffrey K. Skilling (former CEO) | Convicted by a federal jury in Houston on 19 counts: one of conspiracy, 12 of securities fraud, one of insider trading and five of making false statements to auditors | May 25, 2006 |
| Jeffrey K. Skilling | Sentenced to 292 months (24 years and four months); ordered to forfeit approximately $45 million toward restitution | October 23, 2006 |
| Jeffrey K. Skilling | Fifth Circuit upheld the convictions and vacated the sentence; resentenced to 168 months with approximately $42 million of forfeiture (Department of Justice case page; press release of June 21, 2013) | January 6, 2009; June 2013 |
| Jeffrey K. Skilling | Bureau of Prisons locator lists an actual release date of February 21, 2019 | Checked November 19, 2026 |
| Kenneth Lay (former CEO) | Convicted with Skilling; died on July 5, 2006; his conviction was voided by a federal judge | October 2006 |
| Andrew S. Fastow (former CFO) | Pleaded guilty to two conspiracy counts on January 14, 2004 and agreed to forfeit more than $20 million; sentenced to six years in prison | January 14, 2004; September 26, 2006 |
| Timothy Despain and David Delainey (former executives) | Despain: four years of probation and a $10,000 fine; Delainey: 30 months in prison on one count of insider trading | September 15 and 18, 2006 |
| Arthur Andersen LLP (auditor) | Jury verdict on one count; reversed and remanded by the Supreme Court, No. 04-368 | May 31, 2005 |
The table nobody has: the money, by document
| What | Amount | Document and date |
|---|---|---|
| Net income reported for 1997-2000 | $2,680 million | Form 8-K, November 8, 2001, Table 1 |
| Net income restated for 1997-2000 | $2,089 million (8-K); $2,067 million (10-Q) | Form 8-K, November 8, 2001; Form 10-Q, November 19, 2001 |
| Debt added for 2000 by consolidating entities | $628 million ($10,229 million to $10,857 million) | Form 8-K, November 8, 2001; Powers Report, February 1, 2002 |
| Equity removed in the Raptor correction | $1.2 billion | Form 8-K, November 8, 2001 |
| Third quarter 2001 net loss | $644 million | Form 10-Q, November 19, 2001 |
| Paid to creditors by October 14, 2011 | $21,826,000,000; 52.7% for Enron general unsecured creditors | Twenty-Eighth Post-Confirmation Status Report |
| Class action fund approved for allocation | $7,227,000,000 | Order of September 8, 2008, H-01-3624 |
| Enron stock in the employees' Savings Plan | 54.2% of net assets (common stock only) | Form 11-K, filed June 27, 2001, our arithmetic |
| Employee plan settlements announced by the Department of Labor | At least $66.5 million, proposed | Department of Labor release, May 12, 2004 |
| Forfeiture ordered against the former CEO at resentencing | Approximately $42 million | Department of Justice case page, 2013 |
What this means for your money
The Enron file is old, but the checks it teaches apply to anything with an offering document, a holder vote or a bankruptcy plan.
- Read the note, then the proxy. The 10-K's related-party note described the partnerships without naming them; the proxy statement named LJM2 and its managing member. When a fund or company reports transactions with an insider's entity, find where the name, the amounts and the approval process are written. See the same question on a company that filed an S-1 in what WeWork's S-1 showed before its IPO collapsed.
- Expect the first restatement not to be the last. The company's own 8-K and 10-Q, eleven days apart, differ by $22 million on four years of net income. A restatement announcement is a first version; the numbers can move again.
- Consolidation is where debt hides. Debt for 2000 was $628 million higher once the entities were consolidated. For a non-traded REIT or fund, check which affiliates and joint ventures are in the debt line and which are in notes.
- Know your place in the queue. Enron general unsecured creditors recovered 52.7 percent from the estate, while stockholders were left with trust interests that pay only if assets exceed claims; the investors' separate recovery came from lenders, advisers and directors. In a bankruptcy, the plan's class table, not the headline loss, tells you what a holder of that instrument was owed. A comparison of what a trustee and a receiver actually distributed in fraud cases is in how much investors recover in real estate Ponzi receiverships.
- Concentration is a fact in the plan's 11-K. More than half of the Savings Plan's net assets was one company's stock a year before it filed for bankruptcy. If a large share of your own retirement account, your income and your housing wealth depends on one employer or one sector, that is the exposure to read.
- Related cases. Compare how a court later measured an investor loss in a private company: Theranos and Elizabeth Holmes: SEC complaint, restitution, sentence; and how an examiner described repo transactions and creditor recoveries in the Lehman Brothers collapse.
Do not read this as a verdict on anyone beyond the court records quoted. Executives are named only for what the Department of Justice, the SEC filings and the Powers Report record.
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
FAQ
Sources, read on November 19, 2026: Enron Corp. (CIK 1024401) Form 10-K for 2000 (accession 0001024401-01-500010); Schedule DEF 14A (0000950129-01-001669); Forms 10-Q for the quarters ended June 30 and September 30, 2001 (0001024401-01-500028 and 0000950129-01-504218); Forms 8-K of November 8, 2001 (0000950129-01-503835), December 2, 2001 (0001024401-01-500046), January 29, 2002 with the Report of Investigation by the Special Investigative Committee as Exhibit 99.2 (0000909518-02-000089), February 12, 2002 (0000909518-02-000098) and November 17, 2004 (0000950129-04-009127); Form 11-K for the Enron Corp. Savings Plan, plan year 2000 (0001024401-01-500018); United States Bankruptcy Court, S.D.N.Y., Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law confirming the plan, July 15, 2004 (Case No. 01-16034); Enron Creditors Recovery Corp. Twenty-Eighth Post-Confirmation Status Report, October 14, 2011, and its press release of April 2, 2007, both through the Internet Archive; In re Enron Corp. Securities, Derivative and ERISA Litigation, Order re Final Approval of Plan of Allocation, H-01-3624 (S.D. Tex. September 8, 2008) and the order of August 29, 2008 in H-01-3913 (govinfo.gov); U.S. Department of Labor release of May 12, 2004; U.S. Department of Justice press releases 06-723 and 06-647 and the Criminal Division case page for United States v. Skilling; Arthur Andersen LLP v. United States, No. 04-368 (U.S. May 31, 2005); Federal Bureau of Prisons inmate locator, November 19, 2026. Court records through PACER and CourtListener were not available to us on November 19, 2026, so the dockets themselves were not scored.