CrowdfundedWealth

PNC Mortgage Review 2026: 12.13% Denied on Conventional Purchases

ReviewBy Jorge31 min read1 SEC filing cited

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the pnc mortgage numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

As of November 21, 2026: in the 2025 federal mortgage data (HMDA), PNC Bank originated 61,280 conventional, FHA, VA and USDA loans for $18.88 billion and denied 34.62% of the applications it decided, against 23.65% for all lenders. Part of that gap is one product: 56.4% of its originations were second liens (our arithmetic). On first-lien, owner-occupied, one-unit home-purchase loans PNC denied 12.13% of conventional applications (all lenders 15.79%), 27.04% of FHA (12.89%) and 12.57% of VA (8.29%). Its median rate on 30-year conventional purchase loans was 6.375% (all lenders 6.5%) with a median $795 of points, the lowest of 12 large banks (all lenders $2,483). The CFPB database lists 311 mortgage complaints naming PNC Bank N.A. in 2025 (5.08 per 1,000 loans originated) and 377 in 2026 as counted on November 21, 2026. Its parent's September 30, 2026 Form 10-Q reports a $207 billion mortgage servicing portfolio and $48.0 billion of residential real estate loans on the balance sheet, up from $43.8 billion after the January 5, 2026 purchase of FirstBank. The mortgage enforcement record is dated: a $35 million consent order of December 23, 2013 over National City Bank loans from 2002 to 2008, 2011 servicing and foreclosure orders ended by the OCC in 2015, and a $3.5 million Federal Reserve penalty in 2018.

Key takeaways

  • Scale, HMDA 2025: PNC Bank, National Association (LEI AD6GFRVSDT01YPT1CS68, 132,736 records in the file) originated 60,515 conventional loans ($18.60 billion), 528 FHA, 228 VA and 9 USDA loans, 61,280 in all for $18.88 billion. 34,580 of them (56.4%) were second liens, against 22.8% for all lenders (our arithmetic).
  • Two different denial pictures: on first-lien owner-occupied one-unit purchase loans PNC denied 12.13% of conventional applications (all lenders 15.79%), the ninth lowest of 12 large banks; on home improvement, refinancing and other-purpose loans its denial rates were 42.33%, 27.38% and 41.79%, against 36.64%, 21.65% and 40.59% for all lenders. Cash-out refinancing was lower than the national rate: 28.09% against 31.41%.
  • Rate and cost, 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans: PNC's median conventional rate was 6.375% (all lenders 6.5%, 12-bank range 6.0% to 6.625%), median points paid $795 (all lenders $2,483, the lowest of the 12) and median total loan costs $4,816 (all lenders $5,592). Its median conventional loan, $295,000, was $50,000 below the national median.
  • Government-backed loans: PNC made only 765 FHA, VA and USDA loans in 2025 (1.2% of its originations). Its FHA purchase denial rate was 27.04% against 12.89% nationally and its median FHA rate 6.375% against 6.25%.
  • Channel: all 9,513 of PNC's originated home-purchase loans in the file (100.0%) were applied for directly with the bank; 69.2% were sold to Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac or Ginnie Mae, 3.1% to other buyers and 27.7% show no purchaser in the 2025 file. 8.8% were above the conforming loan limit. The first denial reason on conventional purchase denials was an incomplete credit application (32.5%), ahead of debt-to-income ratio (29.4%).
  • CFPB complaints: 311 about mortgages in 2025 (324 in 2024), of which 181 were trouble during the payment process; 377 were received in 2026 as counted on November 21, 2026 (latest on November 17), already 21.2% above all of 2025. At 5.08 complaints per 1,000 loans originated, 2025 was the fifth lowest of 12 banks (1.33 to 29.76). Fifteen were closed with monetary relief in 2025 and six in 2026.
  • 10-Q, quarter ended September 30, 2026: serviced portfolio balance $207 billion (up from $199 billion a year earlier), residential mortgage servicing rights $2,908 million, residential real estate loans $48,026 million (December 31, 2025: $43,760 million) and home equity loans $26,280 million. Colorado went from 2% to 14% of the residential book after FirstBank.
  • Enforcement: December 23, 2013, CFPB and Justice Department consent order with PNC Bank as successor to National City Bank, a $35 million settlement fund over alleged higher mortgage prices to African-American and Hispanic borrowers on 2002 to 2008 loans; April 13, 2011 OCC and Federal Reserve orders on servicing and foreclosure, terminated by the OCC on June 16, 2015; a $3.5 million Federal Reserve penalty on January 12, 2018. The CFPB enforcement list has no action with PNC in the title.

CSV · 348 rows

PNC Bank, N.A.: HMDA 2025 originations, denials, rates and costs against 11 banks, CFPB complaints, the September 30, 2026 10-Q and the mortgage enforcement record

348 rows: counts by loan type, purpose and lien, denial rates, median rate, points and total loan costs, a 12-bank comparison, channels, states, denial reasons, CFPB complaint counts and issues for 2024 to 2026 with eleven peers, 10-Q figures and the dated enforcement record. One source per row.

What this page counts, and what it leaves out

The pages that rank for “pnc mortgage review” (NerdWallet, Forbes, U.S. News, ConsumerAffairs and similar sites) lean on star ratings, customer comments and the bank's product list. This page reads documents. The regulator's data for loans made in 2025 (the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act file, or HMDA) was released on March 31, 2026; the CFPB's announcement says the data for 2025 “are now available on the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council’s (FFIEC) HMDA Platform for approximately 4,768 HMDA filers.” PNC reports under one lender identifier, PNC Bank, National Association (LEI AD6GFRVSDT01YPT1CS68), and we found no other 2025 filer with PNC in its name; we counted its loans by loan type, purpose and lien position using the Data Browser's counts, read its home-purchase loans one by one in the loan-level file, and set them beside 11 other large banks. We then add the CFPB complaint database, the 10-Q of the parent company, The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc., and the enforcement record.

Three limits first. HMDA has no credit score, no down payment and no first-time-buyer flag, so it cannot say whether PNC is right for a particular borrower. It records the rate at origination, so a lower median rate can mean stronger borrowers or more points paid, not a cheaper lender. And these are 2025 loans: the 2026 file does not exist yet. Denial rate throughout is our arithmetic: denied divided by originated plus denied, which leaves out applications withdrawn by the borrower, files closed as incomplete and approvals the borrower did not accept. Our page on Truist's mortgage business uses the same federal data for another large regional bank, and the one on Chase for the largest.

What PNC originated in 2025, and how often it said no

HMDA lists PNC Bank with 132,736 records in 2025, which include purchased loans, withdrawn and closed applications and loan types we do not count here. The first table uses the counts the regulator publishes for the four loan types. These counts cover every purpose (purchase, refinancing, home improvement and others) and both lien positions, so they describe the whole mortgage and home equity business, not only buying a house.

PNC Bank: loans originated and denial rate by loan type, HMDA 2025 (all purposes and lien positions)

Loan typeOriginatedDollars originatedDeniedPNC denial rateAll lenders
Conventional60,515$18.60 billion32,07134.64%24.52%
FHA528$204.2 million30936.92%22.67%
VA228$70.5 million6221.38%17.00%
USDA9$1.9 million743.75%13.35%
All four61,280$18.88 billion32,44934.62%23.65%

PNC is almost entirely a conventional lender: 98.8% of its originations are conventional, and FHA, VA and USDA loans together are 765. A denial rate of 34.64% on conventional loans looks alarming next to the national 24.52%, and it should not be read as how PNC treats home buyers. The next table splits the same counts by what the loan was for.

PNC Bank against all lenders by loan purpose, HMDA 2025 (all loan types and lien positions)

PurposePNC originatedPNC deniedPNC denial rateAll lenders originatedAll lenders deniedAll lenders denial rate
Home purchase11,1762,40617.71%3,592,033607,81814.47%
Home improvement16,97812,46142.33%613,448354,76136.64%
Refinancing (no cash out)17,0696,43427.38%1,042,078288,00021.65%
Cash-out refinancing1,16545528.09%953,349436,54231.41%
Other purpose14,89210,69341.79%624,151426,48340.59%

Home purchase is 18.2% of PNC's originations (11,176 of 61,280); home improvement is 27.7%, refinancing without cash out 27.9% and other purposes 24.3%. Cash-out refinancing is 1.9%, so PNC is not a cash-out lender in this data. Its denial rate on purchase loans, 17.71%, is above the national 14.47% once second liens and all occupancies are included, while on refinancing it is 27.38% against 21.65%. The lien split shows where the gap sits.

First and second liens, PNC against all lenders, HMDA 2025 (all purposes and loan types)

Lien positionPNC originatedPNC deniedPNC denial rateAll lenders denial rate
First lien26,70011,75130.56%20.05%
Second lien34,58020,69837.44%33.73%

Second liens were 56.4% of PNC's originations (34,580 of 61,280) against 22.8% for all lenders (1,558,203 of 6,827,891), and 37.44% of the second-lien applications it decided were denied. First-lien denial, 30.56%, is also above the national 20.05%, so the gap does not come only from home equity. The data cannot say why: a lender that takes many applications for lines of credit, screens less before the application, or applies stricter limits will show a higher rate. Our page on HELOC lenders ranked by 2025 originations lays out the open-end lines separately, with PNC third by number of owner-occupied lines (34,152), and our ranking of the largest mortgage lenders by 2025 volume puts PNC at 19. For a reader choosing a home purchase loan, the next section is the relevant one.

Home-purchase loans: denial rates by loan type

To compare like with like, we read PNC's purchase loans one by one and kept only first-lien, owner-occupied, one-unit loans (any term), not for a business purpose and not reverse mortgages. The denial rate is denied divided by originated plus denied. The national figure uses the same filter.

Denial rate on first-lien, owner-occupied, one-unit home-purchase applications, HMDA 2025 (our arithmetic)

Loan typePNC originatedPNC deniedPNC denial rateAll lenders denial rate
Conventional8,5171,17612.13%15.79%
FHA37513927.04%12.89%
VA1532212.57%8.29%
USDA9535.71%13.56%
All four9,0541,34212.91%14.38%

On conventional purchase loans, which are 94.1% of PNC's purchase originations in this filter, PNC denied about three-quarters of the national share. On government-backed loans the picture reverses: its FHA denial rate is more than double the national rate and its VA rate about 4 points higher, though on small numbers (514 FHA and 175 VA decided applications; 14 USDA). A buyer with a lower credit score or higher debt who is steered by a lender toward FHA, or who applies only where approval is likely, will change these rates; HMDA does not show that. For lenders that specialize in FHA loans, see our FHA lender ranking.

Rates, points and costs on 30-year purchase loans

For the rate comparison we used only loans that look alike: originated in 2025 for a home purchase, first lien, owner-occupied, one unit, 360-month term and not for a business purpose. For each lender we took the median interest rate, the median discount points paid in dollars (only loans that report points above zero) and the median total loan costs.

Median rate, points and total loan costs on 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans, PNC against all lenders, 2025

Loan typePNC loans in filterPNC median rateAll lendersPNC median pointsAll lendersPNC median total loan costsAll lendersPNC median loanAll lenders
Conventional7,5866.375%6.5%$795$2,483$4,816$5,592$295,000$345,000
FHA3646.375%6.25%$840$2,938$8,535$11,262$225,000$305,000
VA1466.375%6.125%$879$2,743$3,960$6,585$320,000$355,000
USDA96.625%6.25%$432$1,585$4,866$6,549$195,000$205,000

PNC's median conventional rate sits 0.125 points under the national median, with far fewer points and lower total costs, while its FHA and VA medians are 0.125 and 0.25 points above the national ones. About half of its conventional loans report points (3,880 of 7,586, 51.1%), as nationally (824,123 of 1,709,795, 48.2%). The USDA row is nine loans and is shown only for completeness. Read this as a description, not a price list: the rate that applies to you depends on your credit score, down payment, lock date and whether you buy points, none of which HMDA shows.

PNC next to 11 other large banks

We applied the same filter to 11 other large banks: the national and regional banks with the biggest 2025 mortgage books that are not mortgage companies or credit unions. The list is a ranking by public metrics, not a ranking of quality. Conventional loans only.

Conventional, 30-year, owner-occupied, one-unit purchase loans, 12 banks, HMDA 2025 (sorted by loans in the filter)

BankLoans in filterMedian rateMedian points paidMedian total loan costsMedian loanDenial rate, conventional purchase
JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.43,0726.375%$2,146$4,722$375,00010.13%
U.S. Bank N.A.21,9876.49%$1,099$5,253$435,0008.56%
Wells Fargo Bank, N.A.19,3146.125%$1,769$6,284$505,00014.38%
Bank of America, N.A.18,3016.0%$2,808$5,095$415,00012.67%
The Huntington National Bank10,5716.625%$945$4,647$275,0005.86%
Truist Bank8,9976.375%$1,145$5,460$415,0006.74%
PNC Bank, N.A.7,5866.375%$795$4,816$295,00012.13%
Fifth Third Bank, N.A.6,2786.5%$866$4,282$305,0008.53%
Citizens Bank, N.A.5,9496.375%$1,947$7,536$485,00010.03%
Regions Bank4,8126.5%$1,838$5,277$325,00013.73%
Manufacturers and Traders Trust Company (M&T)4,4796.0%$993$5,411$415,0005.06%
TD Bank, N.A.3,5046.25%$1,446$5,594$675,00011.31%

PNC has the lowest median points of the 12 ($795) and the fourth lowest median total loan costs, behind Fifth Third, Huntington and Chase. Its median rate ties with Chase, Truist and Citizens at 6.375%: four banks are lower (6.0%, 6.0%, 6.125% and 6.25%) and four are higher. Its denial rate is the fourth highest of the 12, after Wells Fargo (14.38%), Regions (13.73%) and Bank of America (12.67%). Medians of different banks' loans are not like-for-like: median loan amounts range from $275,000 to $675,000, and PNC's $295,000 is the second lowest.

A worked example (our arithmetic). On a $295,000 30-year fixed loan, PNC's median loan amount, principal and interest is $1,840.42 a month at 6.375% and $1,864.60 at 6.5%, the national median: $24.18 a month, $8,706 over 360 payments. Between the lowest and highest median rates of the 12 banks, 6.0% ($1,768.67) and 6.625% ($1,888.92), the gap is $120.25 a month, $43,288 over 360 payments. Points paid at closing change the comparison, which is why the table shows them: PNC's median reported points are $795 against $2,483 for all lenders.

Who gets a PNC purchase loan: channel, buyer of the loan, size and states

How PNC's 9,513 originated home-purchase loans reached the bank and where they went, HMDA 2025 (all occupancies, all terms)

MeasureLoansShare
Applied for directly with PNC9,513100.0%
Sold in 2025 to Fannie Mae3,35835.3%
Sold in 2025 to Freddie Mac2,81629.6%
Sold in 2025 to Ginnie Mae4084.3%
Sold to other buyers (commercial banks and other purchaser codes)2993.1%
No purchaser reported (not sold in the year)2,63227.7%
Above the conforming loan limit (jumbo)8368.8%

PNC sells most of its purchase loans to the agencies and keeps a little over a quarter without a purchaser in the 2025 file; HMDA does not say whether those are held on its balance sheet or sold after year end. Every one of its purchase loans was applied for directly, so no broker channel shows up in this data. The median income of its principal-residence purchase borrowers who reported income was $116,000, and the median loan across all 9,513 was $285,000.

PNC Bank home-purchase loans by state, top eight, HMDA 2025 (all occupancies, all terms)

StateLoans originatedShare of PNC purchase loansApplications deniedDenial rate
Pennsylvania1,85719.5%1949.46%
Ohio98610.4%12611.33%
California7748.1%9110.52%
Illinois6336.7%9913.52%
Florida5285.6%14020.96%
Indiana5045.3%6411.27%
Michigan4294.5%6112.45%
Texas4224.4%11120.83%

Eight states hold 64.5% of its purchase loans (our arithmetic), Pennsylvania alone 19.5%; its denial rate runs from 9.46% in Pennsylvania to 20.96% in Florida and 20.83% in Texas, two states where it makes far fewer loans.

Why PNC denies a purchase application, by its own first reason

HMDA lets a lender report up to four reasons for each denial. We counted the first one on PNC's home-purchase denials (all occupancies).

First reason givenConventional denials (1,288)FHA denials (145)VA denials (22)
Credit application incomplete419 (32.5%)22 (15.2%)9 (40.9%)
Debt-to-income ratio379 (29.4%)59 (40.7%)5 (22.7%)
Collateral281 (21.8%)9 (6.2%)0
Other83 (6.4%)12 (8.3%)3 (13.6%)
Credit history53 (4.1%)19 (13.1%)4 (18.2%)
Unverifiable information38 (3.0%)1 (0.7%)1 (4.5%)
Employment history18 (1.4%)10 (6.9%)0
Insufficient cash17 (1.3%)13 (9.0%)0

At PNC an incomplete credit application is the most common first reason on conventional and VA purchase denials (32.5% and 40.9%), and the debt-to-income ratio leads on FHA (40.7%). On conventional loans only 4.1% of first reasons were credit history. For a buyer the practical point is that missing documents decided about one denial in three, which a complete file at the start can avoid; the lender codes the reason and HMDA does not publish the underlying numbers.

What the CFPB complaint database shows

The CFPB's database is public and the Bureau does not verify the facts in a complaint. The company string is “PNC Bank N.A.”, the only one the database's company search returns for “pnc”, so it names the bank, not the holding company. The latest PNC mortgage complaint in the database on November 21, 2026 was received on November 17, 2026. Mortgage is a small part of what customers complain about at PNC: 311 of the 3,198 complaints naming PNC Bank N.A. in 2025 (9.7%, our arithmetic), against 1,638 about checking or savings accounts.

PNC Bank N.A.: mortgage complaints by issue, 2024 to 2026

Issue (product Mortgage)2025Share of 20252026 (to Nov 21)Share of 2026
Trouble during payment process18158.2%20153.3%
Struggling to pay mortgage5818.6%9023.9%
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing an existing mortgage3310.6%4812.7%
Closing on a mortgage206.4%174.5%
Incorrect information on your report113.5%133.4%
Problem with a company's investigation into an existing problem82.6%71.9%
Improper use of your report00%10.3%
Total311100%377100%

The total was 324 in 2024, 311 in 2025 and is 377 in the 325 days of 2026 to November 21, 2026 (our arithmetic: 21.2% above all of 2025, or 1.16 complaints a day against 0.85 in 2025). Complaints from borrowers struggling to pay rose from 18.6% to 23.9% of the total. Of the 311 complaints in 2025, 295 were closed with an explanation, 15 with monetary relief and one with non-monetary relief; all 311 got a timely response. In 2026, 303 were closed with an explanation, 8 with non-monetary relief and 6 with monetary relief, and 60 were still in progress; all 377 were timely so far. The database does not say why the count is rising, and complaint counts follow a bank's servicing book as much as its new lending.

Mortgage complaints in 2025 against the originations of the matching bank in HMDA, 12 banks

Company in CFPB databaseMortgage complaints 2025Mortgage complaints 2026 (to Nov 21)HMDA 2025 originations (all purposes)Complaints per 1,000 originated
WELLS FARGO & COMPANY1,2371,06341,56229.76
M&T BANK CORPORATION36853023,44615.70
TRUIST FINANCIAL CORPORATION29341241,0597.14
BANK OF AMERICA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION53452188,5306.03
JPMORGAN CHASE & CO.54965294,2435.83
FIFTH THIRD FINANCIAL CORPORATION21838539,5345.51
U.S. BANCORP39962174,6355.35
PNC Bank N.A.31137761,2805.08
TD BANK US HOLDING COMPANY10113023,4994.30
CITIZENS FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.23220068,9023.37
REGIONS FINANCIAL CORPORATION7810130,2692.58
HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK, THE6813751,2031.33

This ratio puts new loans in the denominator and counts complaints on loans made years earlier, and for most banks the complaint company is a holding company while the loan count is one bank, so it is a scale marker, not a failure rate. It shows where PNC sits: in the middle, with four banks lower and seven higher, and far below Wells Fargo, whose servicing book is much larger. PNC's 2026 count, 377, is the eighth highest of the 12 companies.

What The PNC Financial Services Group 10-Q says

The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (CIK 713676) filed its Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 on November 3, 2026 (accession 0001628280-26-069377). PNC Bank, N.A. is its banking subsidiary. For a borrower, four things in it matter.

ItemSep 30, 2026 (or nine months 2026)Comparison periodWhat it means for a borrower
Mortgage loan servicing balances for third parties (Retail Banking table)$207 billion$199 billion at Sep 30, 2025 (up 4%)PNC services about $207 billion of home loans for other owners
Residential mortgage servicing rights, asset value$2,908 million$2,622 million at Sep 30, 2025 (up 11%)The value of the right to collect payments on loans PNC services for others
Servicing fees, net, nine months$187 million$191 million (down 2%)Net fee income from servicing fell slightly while the balance grew
Mortgage servicing rights valuation, net of economic hedge, nine months$(28) million$16 millionA small loss in 2026 against a small gain in 2025
Residential real estate loans on the balance sheet$48,026 million$43,760 million at Dec 31, 2025 (up 10%)Loans PNC keeps ($44.7 billion of them originated nonconforming loans); the increase follows the FirstBank purchase
Residential real estate loans past due 30 days or more, still accruing$608 million (1.27% of the book)$553 million at Dec 31, 2025 (1.26%)$278 million 30 to 59 days, $98 million 60 to 89 days and $232 million 90 days or more (our arithmetic)
Residential real estate loans nonperforming$319 million (0.66%)$320 million at Dec 31, 2025 (0.73%)Plus $174 million of nonaccrual loans on the fair value option, down from $200 million
Home equity loans on the balance sheet$26,280 million$25,941 million at Dec 31, 2025$22.8 billion of lines of credit and $3.5 billion of closed-end loans

The filing describes how PNC lends: “We originate residential mortgage loans nationwide through our national mortgage business as well as within our branch network.” It says conforming loans are sold, “Residential mortgage loans underwritten to agency standards, including conforming loan amount limits, are typically sold with servicing retained by us,” and nonconforming loans are kept, with “$44.7 billion at September 30, 2026, with 39% located in California” (December 31, 2025: $39.5 billion and 46%). The weighted-average FICO score of its residential originations was 774 and the loan-to-value ratio 71%. For a borrower this means a nonconforming PNC loan is generally kept by PNC itself, while a conforming loan is often serviced by PNC but owned by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac.

The acquisition matters if your loan came from Colorado or Arizona. On January 5, 2026, PNC acquired FirstBank Holding Company and its banking subsidiary, FirstBank, for $4.2 billion of cash and PNC stock to the common and Series A preferred shareholders, and in June 2026 it converted “approximately 780,000 customers, more than 1,620 employees and 95 branches across Colorado and Arizona,” merging FirstBank into PNC Bank. Colorado went from $1,069 million (2%) to $6,730 million (14%) of PNC's residential real estate loans in nine months. The 10-Q also reports $35,851 million of residential mortgages that PNC services for securitizations it sold, of which $251 million were delinquent (90 days or more past due or in foreclosure), and $27 million of repurchases of previously transferred residential loans in the third quarter. Its origination volume line in the Retail Banking table, $4.6 billion for nine months, is a different measure from the $18.88 billion of HMDA 2025 loans above, which covers a full year and every purpose including home equity.

Enforcement and regulatory record

The mortgage record we found is dated, and none of it concerns loans made in 2025. The first matter involves a bank PNC bought. National City Bank originated more than 1 million mortgage loans through its retail channel and over 600,000 through brokers between 2002 and 2008, and “PNC acquired National City at the end of 2008,” in the CFPB's words. On December 23, 2013, the CFPB and the Justice Department filed a joint complaint and a consent order in the Western District of Pennsylvania (civil action 2:13-cv-01817) against National City Bank through its successor in interest, PNC Bank. The agencies alleged the bank charged African-American and Hispanic borrowers higher prices on mortgage loans than similarly creditworthy white borrowers between 2002 and 2008, through discretionary pricing and broker compensation. The order set up a $35 million settlement fund; the consent order states that “There has been no factual finding or adjudication with respect to any matter alleged by the Plaintiffs,” and that PNC no longer uses third-party brokers for a wholesale channel. The CFPB lists the action as “Expired/Terminated/Dismissed.”

The second matter is servicing. On April 13, 2011, the OCC issued a consent order against PNC Bank, N.A. (AA-EC-11-17) after an interagency review of large mortgage servicers, finding that the bank serviced a portfolio of 1,000,000 residential mortgage loans as of December 2010, that employee affidavits filed in state-court foreclosures were in many cases not based on personal knowledge or a review of the records, and that some filed documents were not properly notarized. The bank neither admitted nor denied the findings. The Federal Reserve issued a parallel order the same day against The PNC Financial Services Group (docket 11-026-B-HC). The OCC's release of June 17, 2015 says it terminated the orders against Bank of America, Citibank and PNC “because it determined that these institutions have complied with the orders issued in April 2011 and amendments issued in February 2013.” On January 12, 2018, the Federal Reserve assessed a $3,500,000 civil money penalty against the holding company in connection with the conduct that was the subject of its 2011 order, alleging that PNC “failed to provide effective oversight with respect to the residential mortgage loan servicing, Loss Mitigation, foreclosure activities, and related functions of the Bank.”

DateMatterAgencyAbout mortgages?Status found
April 13, 2011PNC Bank, N.A.: consent order AA-EC-11-17 (residential mortgage servicing and foreclosure)OCCYesTerminated June 16, 2015 (per the Federal Reserve's 2018 order; OCC release dated June 17, 2015)
April 13, 2011The PNC Financial Services Group: consent order 11-026-B-HC, amended February 28, 2013Federal Reserve BoardYes$3.5 million civil money penalty on January 12, 2018; we did not find the date the Board order ended
December 23, 2013National City Bank through its successor PNC Bank: $35 million settlement fund (alleged discriminatory mortgage pricing, 2002 to 2008 loans)CFPB and Department of JusticeYesConsent order filed with the court; CFPB lists status Expired/Terminated/Dismissed
January 12, 2018The PNC Financial Services Group: order 17-049-CMP-HC, $3,500,000 penaltyFederal Reserve BoardYesPaid on execution of the order
Searched November 21, 2026CFPB enforcement actions with pnc in the titleCFPBn/aNo results (the National City Bank action is listed under that name)

We did not read the OCC's enforcement database for later orders, state regulator actions or the NMLS Consumer Access license list, which are not scored on this page, so the table is what we found, not proof that nothing else exists. The PNC 10-Q says it is a party to disclosed legal matters and estimates reasonably possible losses above its accruals of less than $300 million in aggregate; it does not break that figure out by mortgage matters.

What a reader can do with this

  • If you are buying and have a conventional loan in mind, price PNC next to a bank and a broker. The data show a conventional denial rate below the national one, a median rate in the middle of 12 large banks and the lowest median points of the 12. A Loan Estimate for the same loan amount, lock date and points from PNC and one other lender is the only way to compare the loan you would get.
  • If you plan an FHA or VA loan, look at who it works with. PNC originated 528 FHA and 228 VA loans in 2025, and its FHA purchase denial rate was more than double the national one. These are small numbers, and a specialist government lender may be a better comparison.
  • Send a complete file. The first denial reason on about one in three conventional purchase denials at PNC was an incomplete application. Have pay stubs, tax returns and asset statements ready before you apply.
  • If you want a home equity line or loan, ask about approval before you apply. More than a third of the second-lien applications PNC decided in 2025 were denied.
  • If your loan is already with PNC, know who owns it. The 10-Q says conforming loans are typically sold with servicing retained; the owner, not the servicer, sets many rules. The CFPB's complaints are mostly about payments on existing loans.
  • Check the current numbers before you rely on them. Everything above is 2025 loans, complaints through November 17, 2026 and a quarter that ended September 30, 2026.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Sources, read November 21, 2026: FFIEC HMDA 2025 Data Browser (loan-level home-purchase file for PNC Bank, National Association, LEI AD6GFRVSDT01YPT1CS68, and 11 other banks; aggregation counts by loan type, purpose and lien position; raw files not kept) and the CFPB's March 31, 2026 announcement of the 2025 HMDA data; CFPB Consumer Complaint Database API (companies PNC Bank N.A. and eleven peer holding companies, product Mortgage); The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (accession 0001628280-26-069377); OCC consent order AA-EC-11-17 and Federal Reserve consent order 11-026-B-HC (April 13, 2011); OCC news release 2015-85 (June 17, 2015); Federal Reserve order 17-049-CMP-HC (January 12, 2018); CFPB enforcement page, consent order and press release for National City Bank (December 23, 2013); CFPB enforcement actions search.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.