CrowdfundedWealth

Fairway Mortgage Review 2026: HMDA Data, Complaints, CFPB Order

ReviewBy Jorge24 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the fairway mortgage numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation reported 103,995 records in the 2025 federal HMDA file, of which 74,450 were loans it originated ($24.54 billion): 50,721 conventional, 16,473 FHA, 6,517 VA and 739 USDA, as of the data we read on November 17, 2026. It ranked 12th among 2,046 filers by loans originated (11th in FHA). Of those loans 64,285 (86.3%) were home purchases. On first-lien purchase applications it denied 4.2% (2,432 denials against 55,507 loans), against 14.2% for all lenders, and it denied 3.3% of conventional purchase applications against 15.3% nationally. On 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans its median rate was higher than the national median for the same loans, 6.75% against 6.5% on conventional and 6.5% against 6.25% on FHA, while its median total loan costs were $5,887 against $5,592 on conventional and $11,152 against $11,262 on FHA. The CFPB complaint database lists 36 complaints for 2025 (0.48 per 1,000 originated loans, our arithmetic) and 38 for 2026 through October 26. A federal consent order entered on December 3, 2024 resolves a CFPB and Justice Department redlining case about Birmingham, Alabama, with a $1.9 million civil money penalty.

Key takeaways

  • Scale, from the 2025 HMDA file: 103,995 records reconcile to 74,450 originated loans, 666 approved but not accepted, 4,845 denied, 20,613 withdrawn, 745 closed incomplete, 298 purchased loans, and 2,378 preapproval requests (2,031 denied and 347 approved but not accepted). Originated volume was $24,539,200,000.
  • Mix: 68.1% conventional (50,721 loans, 14th nationally), 22.1% FHA (16,473, 11th), 8.8% VA (6,517, 18th) and 1.0% USDA (739, 7th). By purpose, 64,285 loans (86.3%) were home purchases, 5,239 refinances, 3,123 cash-out refinances, 432 home improvement and 1,371 other purpose.
  • Denials on first-lien purchase loans (denied divided by originated plus denied, our arithmetic): conventional 3.3%, FHA 6.6%, VA 3.2%, all types 4.2%. For all lenders: 15.3%, 13.1%, 8.4% and 14.2%. Among the 15 other largest lenders the median denial rate is 10.4% conventional, 19.4% FHA and 8.9% VA; only three of them denied fewer conventional purchase applications.
  • Cost of a 30-year owner-occupied purchase loan, Fairway against all lenders: conventional rate 6.75% against 6.5%, points $2,429 against $2,483, total loan costs $5,887 against $5,592; FHA 6.5% against 6.25%, $2,461 against $2,938, $11,152 against $11,262; VA 6.25% against 6.125%, $2,815 against $2,743, $6,583 against $6,585. A lender credit is reported on 15.4% of its conventional loans against 33.7% nationally.
  • Channel: all 55,507 first-lien purchase originations were submitted directly to Fairway; across all lenders 20.3% (647,034 of 3,181,822) came in some other way. Only 230 of the 55,507 (0.4%) were reported as not sold during 2025: 32.6% went to Freddie Mac, 22.7% to Ginnie Mae and 18.9% to Fannie Mae.
  • CFPB complaints under Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation: 23 in 2024, 36 in 2025 (27 about mortgages) and 38 for January 1 to October 26, 2026. In 2025 the largest groups were trouble during the payment process (9), applying for a mortgage (8) and closing (7).
  • Regulatory documents: a consent order in case 2:24-cv-01405 (N.D. Alabama, December 3, 2024, $1.9 million penalty, at least $7 million loan subsidy fund); a HUD Mortgagee Review Board settlement voted on February 24, 2022 ($96,960); a California DFPI consent order of December 2025 ($160,000); and a Vermont order of October 20, 2021 ($54,450). Fairway neither admitted nor denied the findings in the court and California orders.
  • Fairway has no SEC filings: an EDGAR company search on November 17, 2026 returned no matching companies, so there is no 10-Q or 10-K to read. HMDA has no credit scores and the CFPB does not verify complaints.

CSV · 326 rows

Fairway Independent Mortgage: 2025 HMDA record, 30-year purchase costs against peers, CFPB complaints and regulatory orders

326 rows: the 103,995 HMDA records reconciled by action, loan types and purposes, purchase denial rates and reasons, 30-year purchase medians against 15 large lenders, CFPB complaint counts by year and issue, and the court, HUD, California and Vermont documents. One source per row.

Which Fairway number is right: 103,995 or 74,450

Both are correct counts of the same 2025 file. The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) requires lenders to report every application they decide on or that ends, and every loan they buy; the CFPB released the 2025 data on March 31, 2026. Fairway filed 103,995 records. Only 74,450 are loans it made. The rest are applications that did not end in a Fairway loan, plus 298 loans bought from other lenders.

2025 HMDA actionRecordsWhat it means
Loan originated74,450Closed loans, $24,539,200,000
Approved, not accepted666Offer made, borrower did not take it
Denied4,845Application refused
Withdrawn by applicant20,613Borrower walked away before a decision
Closed incomplete745File never completed
Purchased loan298Bought from another lender, not Fairway's origination
Preapproval denied2,031Preapproval request refused
Preapproval approved, not accepted347Preapproval offered, not used
All records103,995Sum of the eight lines

The loan counts in the rest of this page are the 74,450, or the narrower first-lien purchase file where we say so. Our own page on the largest lenders of 2025 ranks Fairway 12th by the same count.

What it lends: conventional, mostly for purchases

Loan typeOriginatedDollarsShare of its loansNational rankDenial rate, all purposes
Conventional50,721$16.92 billion68.1%14th5.5%
FHA16,473$4.69 billion22.1%11th8.3%
VA6,517$2.78 billion8.8%18th4.2%
USDA739$151.8 million1.0%7th7.6%
All74,450$24.54 billion100%12thn/a

The denial rate in this table is denied divided by originated plus approved-not-accepted plus denied, across all loan purposes (our arithmetic from the HMDA 2025 backbone). Rank is by number of originated loans among the 2,046 filers in that file.

What stands out against the usual large lender is the purpose: 64,285 of the 74,450 originated loans (86.3%) were home purchases, with 5,239 refinances (7.0%), 3,123 cash-out refinances (4.2%), 432 home-improvement loans and 1,371 for other purposes. A lender whose book is mostly purchases serves a different customer from one that mostly refinances its own past borrowers, and that shapes every figure below. Another 6,774 loans were second liens, 5,974 of them for home purchases (in the subordinate-lien extract, 5,952 of those closed-end and 22 lines of credit), which fits a buyer who borrows a first mortgage and a smaller second loan together.

Denials: 3.3% on conventional purchases against 15.3% nationally

For purchases we read Fairway's loan-level records in the file of first-lien, closed-end, non-reverse, non-business-purpose purchase loans (originated or denied; the file has no other actions). Denial rate here is denied divided by originated plus denied (our arithmetic from HMDA 2025 records).

First-lien purchase, 2025Fairway originatedFairway deniedFairway denial rateAll lenders denial rateMedian of the other large lenders
Conventional34,9281,1853.28%15.34%10.40%
FHA14,3711,0086.55%13.07%19.41%
VA5,4841823.21%8.38%8.89%
USDA724577.30%13.57%n/a
All types55,5072,4324.20%14.20%n/a

Fairway is the 8th largest lender in this file by purchase loans originated (55,507 of 3,181,822). Its denial rate is the fourth lowest of the 16 lenders (Fairway and the 15 other largest lenders by 2025 originations) on conventional, FHA and VA purchases. Only CrossCountry Mortgage, Guild Mortgage and CMG Mortgage denied fewer conventional purchase applications (2.08%, 2.43% and 3.14%).

A low denial rate has more than one reading that HMDA cannot separate: the lender may screen applicants before an application is filed, or its underwriting may be looser on the margin, or its applicants may be stronger. The first denial reason entered for its 2,432 purchase denials was debt-to-income ratio on 697 (28.7%), collateral on 377 (15.5%), credit history on 310 (12.7%), unverifiable information on 279 (11.5%), an incomplete application on 263 (10.8%), other on 219 (9.0%), insufficient cash on 160 (6.6%) and employment history on 125 (5.1%), plus 2 for mortgage insurance denied.

Rate, points, lender credits and total loan costs on a 30-year purchase loan

Rates exist in HMDA only for loans that closed, so we compare like with like: first-lien, owner-occupied, one-unit, 360-month purchase loans, originated, for Fairway and for all lenders. Total loan costs are the Closing Disclosure's section D (origination charges, services you could not shop for and services you could shop for); they exclude taxes and government fees, prepaid items, initial escrow and owner's title insurance, so they are not "all closing costs". Points and lender credits are reported only when they exist; the medians below are among loans that report a number (shares in the last two rows).

30-year purchase loans, 2025Fairway conventionalAll lenders conventionalFairway FHAAll lenders FHAFairway VAAll lenders VA
Loans in the filter31,9631,709,79514,028600,8945,384317,166
Median note rate6.75%6.5%6.5%6.25%6.25%6.125%
Median discount points$2,429$2,483$2,461$2,938$2,815$2,743
Median lender credit$175$554$100$367$150$500
Median total loan costs$5,887$5,592$11,152$11,262$6,583$6,585
Median loan amount$335,000$345,000$275,000$305,000$365,000$355,000
Share reporting a lender credit15.4%33.7%21.4%34.3%21.5%39.6%
Share paying discount points56.6%48.2%54.3%57.8%62.6%59.0%

Two things follow from the table. Fairway's total loan costs are close to the national median on all three products (within $295), and its points are at or below the national median on conventional and FHA. But its median note rate is 0.125 to 0.25 points higher, and it reports a lender credit far less often (15.4% of conventional loans against 33.7%), which is how a lender gives back part of a higher rate at closing. Among the 15 other large lenders the median note rate is 6.625% on conventional and 6.25% on FHA, so Fairway sits at the top of that range: three lenders (Fairway, CrossCountry Mortgage and Freedom Mortgage) have a 6.75% conventional median.

Fairway and six of the largest lenders, conventional 30-year owner-occupied purchase loans, 2025

LenderPurchase denial rateMedian rateMedian discount pointsMedian total loan costs
Fairway Independent Mortgage3.28%6.75%$2,429$5,887
Rocket Mortgage12.66%6.625%$2,813$5,951
United Wholesale Mortgage7.96%6.624%$2,329$7,223
CrossCountry Mortgage2.08%6.75%$3,160$6,892
Guild Mortgage2.43%6.625%$3,001$6,165
Guaranteed Rate3.39%6.625%$2,112$6,217
CMG Mortgage3.14%6.625%$2,769$6,616

The peer set is the 15 largest lenders by 2025 originations other than Fairway; every one is in the data file. For the same product, our Guild Mortgage review shows a lender with a similar purchase denial rate (2.43% on conventional) and a different cost profile.

What the rate gap costs on $335,000 over 30 years (our arithmetic)

ComparisonRateMonthly principal and interestOver 30 years
Fairway median, conventional purchase6.75%$2,172.80$782,209
All-lender median, conventional purchase6.5%$2,117.43$762,274
Difference0.25 points$55.38 a month$19,935

The $335,000 is Fairway's own median conventional purchase loan. The gap in total loan costs between Fairway and the national median is $295, paid once, so over 30 years the rate matters about 68 times more than the cost gap (our arithmetic: $19,935 against $295). Two cautions: the median is a description of a book, not a quote, and HMDA has no credit score, loan-to-value is not matched and a rate lock on a different day moves the rate. A buyer who pays points to lower the rate would see a different picture. The only price for you is a Loan Estimate for your own file.

Channel, buyers of its loans, states and age

  • Direct only. All 55,507 first-lien purchase originations were coded as submitted directly to Fairway; none came through a broker. Across all lenders 647,034 of 3,181,822 (20.3%) were not submitted directly. Our page on mortgage brokers against lenders shows what that difference does to rates and costs for wholesale lenders.
  • Sold quickly. Only 230 of the 55,507 (0.4%) carry the code for not sold during 2025. By purchaser: Freddie Mac 18,110 (32.6%), Ginnie Mae 12,594 (22.7%), Fannie Mae 10,470 (18.9%), other purchasers 9,950 (17.9%), credit unions, mortgage companies or finance companies 3,076 (5.5%). HMDA does not say who services the loan after the sale.
  • States. Texas 6,297 loans (11.3%), Arizona 3,204, Georgia 2,883, Illinois 2,761, Indiana 2,748, Florida 2,447, North Carolina 2,245, Wisconsin 2,229, Ohio 2,170 and Minnesota 2,006.
  • Jumbo. 1,021 of 55,507 (1.8%) were above the conforming limit.
  • Age. The primary applicant was 25 to 34 on 19,071 loans (34.4%), 35 to 44 on 13,904 (25.1%) and under 25 on 4,320 (7.8%). Our page on first-time-buyer lenders by borrower age compares lenders on the same proxy.

What the CFPB complaint database says

The CFPB publishes the complaints consumers submit about financial companies, sent to the company for a response. It does not verify what the consumer says, so a count is a measure of how many people complained, not how many were right. The exact company name in the database is Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation (the search also lists unrelated companies whose names start with Fairway, which we did not count).

Measure202420252026 to October 26
All complaints233638
About mortgages202734
About credit reporting283
Trouble during payment process6910
Applying for a mortgage or refinancing789
Closing on a mortgage476
Struggling to pay mortgage327
Improper use of your report273

In 2025 the 36 complaints against 74,450 originated loans are 0.48 per 1,000 (0.36 per 1,000 counting only the 27 mortgage complaints, our arithmetic). Complaints about applying or closing were 15 in 2025 (8 and 7), 0.20 per 1,000 originated loans. The company responded in time to all 36, with 35 closed with an explanation and one closed with monetary relief; of the 38 complaints in 2026, 35 were closed with an explanation and 3 were still in progress at the time of our pull. The most recent complaint we saw was received on October 26, 2026. The count is small for a lender of this size: our Freedom Mortgage review shows what a servicing-heavy lender looks like in the same database. We did not compute complaint rates for the other large lenders here, because servicing books differ too much for a per-origination comparison to be fair.

On October 15, 2024 the CFPB and the United States Department of Justice filed a complaint against Fairway in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Alabama (case 2:24-cv-01405). The CFPB's enforcement page describes it as alleging that Fairway engaged in unlawful discrimination “including by redlining majority-Black and high-Black areas in the Birmingham MSA”, under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, Regulation B and the Consumer Financial Protection Act; it adds that the Justice Department also alleged a violation of the Fair Housing Act. The court entered a consent order on December 3, 2024 (Document 12). In it Fairway “neither admits nor denies the allegations in the Complaint, except as specified in this Order”.

What the complaint alleges, in its own HMDA comparison for 2018 through 2022: of 10,247 applications Fairway generated in the Birmingham metropolitan area, 3.7% were for properties in majority-Black areas, against 12.2% of the 70,712 applications of its peer lenders; of the 7,913 loans it made, 3.3% were in those areas against 10.1% of its peers' 43,371 loans. The complaint adds that, nationwide, Fairway generated the ninth most mortgage loan applications and originated the fifth most loans of all lenders based on 2022 HMDA data.

Term of the consent orderWhat it requiresParagraph
Redlining prohibitionFairway is permanently restrained from redlining Majority-Black Neighborhoods in the Birmingham metropolitan area6
Loan subsidy fundInvest at least $7,000,000 so that Qualified Applicants get purchase, refinance and home improvement loans on a more affordable basis; subsidies capped at $14,000 per Qualified Applicant unless the plaintiffs agree24 and 25
New officeWithin 7 months of the effective date, open or acquire one loan production office or full-service retail office in a Majority-Black Neighborhood, with a full-time loan officer22 and 23
Advertising and outreachSpend at least $500,000 over the term29
Consumer educationSpend at least $250,00033
Community partnershipsSpend at least $250,00036
Civil money penaltyPay $1,900,000 to the CFPB within 10 days of the effective date39 and 40
TermProvisions other than the redlining prohibition end on the later of 5 years from the effective date or 5 years from any contempt motion70

The monetary and spending minimums in the order add up to $9.9 million ($7 million plus $1.9 million plus $0.5 million plus two sums of $0.25 million, our arithmetic), of which $1.9 million is the penalty. A five-year term from December 3, 2024 runs to December 3, 2029 at the earliest (our arithmetic). A “Qualified Applicant” is defined as an applicant for a loan on a residential property in a Majority-Black Neighborhood that will serve as the applicant's principal residence and is qualified under Fairway's underwriting standards; a Majority-Black Neighborhood is a census tract in the Birmingham area where more than 50% of residents are Black or African American in the 2020 Census.

Fairway disputes the allegations. Its own statement of October 15, 2024 says it “continues to deny that the Company engaged in any discriminatory behavior” and that it settled “to curb the further expenditure of resources”. The same statement describes Fairway as ranking number one for customer satisfaction among mortgage origination companies in the J.D. Power 2023 study; we did not read that study, so the claim is the company's.

Three other regulators

DateRegulator and documentWhat it saysPenalty
February 24, 2022 (published March 23, 2023)HUD Mortgagee Review Board, Federal Register notice FR-6379-N-01, docket 21-2192-MRSettlement agreement; the Board alleged Fairway failed to adopt and implement a quality control plan in compliance with FHA requirements and failed to comply with FHA's self-reporting requirements; the settlement did not constitute an admission of liability or fault$96,960
October 20, 2021Vermont Department of Financial Regulation, stipulation and consent order, docket 21-037-BUnder the Security Breach Notice Act, a phishing attack between August 2020 and January 2021 reached 33 Vermont consumers; the Department says notices to consumers and to the Department were late$54,450
December 19 and 31, 2025 (signatures)California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation, consent order, NMLS 2289Resolves concerns about unlicensed mortgage loan origination activity at a licensed California branch in 2021 and 2022; independent audit of January 1, 2023 to the effective date; a further $500 for each employee the audit finds engaged in unlicensed activity$160,000

None of these three orders is about the price or terms of a loan. The HUD matter is about FHA program compliance, the Vermont one about data security and notice, and the California one about licensing of staff. The California order says the branch and its manager “are no longer associated with Fairway as of 2022”; we did not find the audit report it requires. We searched the CFPB enforcement actions list, HUD, the Department of Justice and the sites of the California and Vermont regulators; NMLS Consumer Access (where all state actions are listed) and other state regulators could not be reached by us, so this table is what we read and not a complete list. The company states in its own press release that it is licensed in all 50 states; we did not verify that.

Is there an SEC filing to read

No. An EDGAR company search for “fairway independent” on November 17, 2026 returned no matching companies, so there is no 10-Q, 10-K or other report with its profit, loan servicing portfolio or legal reserves. HMDA, the CFPB database and the orders above are the public record.

What HMDA cannot tell you about Fairway

  • It has no credit score, so a lender with a lower denial rate may simply see stronger applicants, or screen before the application.
  • Rate and cost figures describe loans that closed in 2025, at 2025 prices. A 2026 quote can differ.
  • Medians describe the middle loan, not your loan; discount points and lender credits are missing on loans that did not carry them, so the shares matter as much as the medians.
  • The peer medians give each lender one vote whatever its size, and builder-owned lenders and lenders with large VA books differ from Fairway.
  • HMDA does not show who services a loan after it is sold, so the complaint count cannot be tied to the loans counted here.
  • Complaints are unverified, and the legal documents report allegations that Fairway neither admitted nor denied.

What a reader can do with this

  • If you are buying with a conventional or FHA loan, ask Fairway and two other lenders for a Loan Estimate on the same day and compare the interest rate, discount points, lender credits and total loan costs line by line. The medians above show where each lender's typical loan sits: Fairway's rate was higher but its points and fees were not.
  • Ask directly about a lender credit. Fairway reported one on 15.4% of its conventional loans in 2025, against 33.7% nationally, and the credit can offset part of a higher rate.
  • If you are buying a principal residence in a majority-Black census tract in the Birmingham area, the consent order requires Fairway to run a loan subsidy program; ask Fairway whether it is open to you and what it pays. We have not seen the program's terms.
  • If you already have a Fairway loan, keep dated copies of what you send and receive. Complaints can be filed with the CFPB; our counts show few in the past three years.
  • For other lenders ranked by volume and denials, see the page on the largest lenders of 2025.

Frequently asked questions

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice. Sources: FFIEC and CFPB HMDA data for 2025 (data browser aggregations and loan-level files for Fairway Independent Mortgage Corporation, LEI 549300MGPZBLQDIL7538, and the 15 other largest lenders), the CFPB's release of March 31, 2026, the CFPB Consumer Complaint Database as queried on November 17, 2026, the CFPB enforcement page, the complaint of October 15, 2024 and the consent order of December 3, 2024 in case 2:24-cv-01405 (N.D. Ala.), the HUD Mortgagee Review Board notice in the Federal Register of March 23, 2023, the California DFPI consent order signed in December 2025, the Vermont DFR order of October 20, 2021, Fairway's statement of October 15, 2024, and an EDGAR company search of November 17, 2026.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.