CrowdfundedWealth
Articles · Research note

What Happened to Landmark Apartment Trust? A $10 Share Paid $8.17

By Jorge··15 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the landmark apartment trust numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick Answer

Landmark Apartment Trust, Inc. no longer exists as a public filer. Sold to the public from July 19, 2006 at $10.00 a share as NNN Apartment REIT (later Grubb & Ellis Apartment REIT, Apartment Trust of America from December 29, 2010, Landmark Apartment Trust of America from August 3, 2012), it was bought for cash. On January 27, 2016 each common share was converted into the right to receive $8.17 in cash, without interest, paid by an entity formed by affiliates of Starwood Capital Group and Milestone Apartments Real Estate Investment Trust. The company filed a Form 15 the same day (SEC CIK 1347523) and has filed nothing since. For a holder who bought at $10.00 in the offering, the merger cash was 81.7% of the original price (our arithmetic). At the closing each stockholder ceased to have any rights other than the right to receive that cash, so there is no successor stock to hold.

Key Takeaways

  • The offering allowed commissions of up to 7.0%, a marketing support fee of up to 2.5%, an extra due diligence reimbursement of up to 0.5% and organizational and offering expenses of up to 1.5% of gross proceeds. The 10-K said it anticipated that 88.5% of proceeds would go to real estate, so up to $1.15 of each $10.00 went to fees and expenses (our arithmetic).
  • The company accepted 15,738,457 shares ($157,218,000) in its initial offering, which ended on July 17, 2009, and 2,992,777 shares ($29,885,000) in a follow-on that was suspended on December 31, 2010.
  • Distributions were paid at an annualized 7.0% of $10.00 from March 2007 to February 2009, 6.0% from March 2009 to February 2011 and 3.0% from March 1, 2011. The share repurchase plan was terminated in February 2011 and pending requests were not fulfilled.
  • The company's estimated value per share was $10.00 on December 31, 2010 and December 31, 2011, then $8.15 from the August 3, 2012 recapitalization. The 10-K said $8.15 was based solely on the price set in that transaction, not on an appraisal.
  • Unsolicited tender offers for up to 1,300,000 shares came at $4.15 (October 2014), $5.10 (October 2015) and $7.00 (November 2015); the board recommended that stockholders reject each one. The merger price was $8.17.
  • The merger agreement is dated October 22, 2015. At the January 22, 2016 special meeting the votes were 29,185,400.9 for, 352,434.432 against and 430,556.689 abstaining. The mergers were valued at about $1.9 billion including debt.

CSV · 53 rows

Grubb & Ellis Apartment REIT, Apartment Trust of America and Landmark Apartment Trust: offering terms, distributions, estimated values, the 2012 recapitalization, unsolicited offers and the January 2016 cash merger

53 rows from the 10-Ks for 2006, 2007, 2010 to 2014, the August 2012 recapitalization 8-K, the 2014 and 2015 tender offer documents, the December 2015 merger proxy statement, the January 2016 8-Ks and the Form 15.

Five names, one SEC registrant

Statements from the broker-dealers that sold the shares can show any of these names. All of them are the same SEC registrant, CIK 1347523.

NameFromWhat changed
NNN Apartment REIT, Inc.Incorporated December 21, 2005Non-traded apartment REIT; offering effective July 19, 2006
Grubb & Ellis Apartment REIT, Inc.2008 (10-K for 2007)Renamed when Grubb & Ellis became the sponsor
Apartment Trust of America, Inc.December 29, 2010Corporate name changed by charter amendment
Landmark Apartment Trust of America, Inc.August 3, 2012Renamed in the recapitalization with the Elco Landmark companies
Landmark Apartment Trust, Inc.October 23, 2014Dropped "of America"; operating partnership renamed Landmark Apartment Trust Holdings, LP

The company is a sister of another Grubb & Ellis non-traded REIT, but a different registrant: see what happened to Healthcare Trust of America (Grubb & Ellis Healthcare REIT).

What the original buyer paid for

ItemFigureSource
Offering effectiveJuly 19, 200610-K for 2006
Primary offeringUp to 100,000,000 shares at $10.0010-K for 2006
Distribution reinvestment planUp to 5,000,000 shares at $9.5010-K for 2006
Selling commissionsUp to 7.0% of gross proceeds10-K for 2006
Marketing support fee and due diligenceUp to 2.5%, plus an accountable 0.5%10-K for 2006
Organizational and offering expensesUp to 1.5%10-K for 2006
Anticipated to real estate88.5% of offering proceeds10-K for 2006
Initial offering, ended July 17, 200915,738,457 shares, $157,218,00010-K for 2010
Follow-on, suspended December 31, 20102,992,777 shares, $29,885,00010-K for 2010

The first dealer manager named in the 10-K for 2006 was NNN Capital Corp. By the 10-K for 2010, the managing broker-dealer had been Grubb & Ellis Securities, Inc. until Grubb & Ellis Securities terminated the dealer manager agreement effective December 31, 2010. A successor dealer manager had not received a FINRA no-objections notice by then, and the follow-on was suspended.

Distributions, repurchases and the $10 to $8.15 value

PeriodWhat the filings say
March 2007 to February 2009Distributions at an annualized 7.0% of $10.00
March 2009 to February 2011Reduced to an annualized 6.0% of $10.00
From March 1, 2011Annualized 3.0% of $10.00, equal to 3.68% of the $8.15 value and $0.025 per unit a month
2010Valid redemption requests for 442,705 shares; 263,430 shares redeemed for $2,612,000 (average $9.92)
February 2011Share repurchase plan terminated; pending requests will not be fulfilled
December 31, 2010 and December 31, 2011Estimated value $10.00 a share, the offering price
From August 3, 2012Estimated value $8.15 a share, set by the recapitalization price

The 10-K for 2010 said the redemption plan was funded only from distribution reinvestment proceeds and that, since the first quarter of 2009, the board repurchased only for death or qualifying disability. A holder who needed to sell in 2011 had no company redemption path; the plan was ended in February 2011.

The $10.00 value in 2010 and 2011 was the offering price, not an appraisal. The $8.15 that followed was described in the 10-K for 2012 as based solely on the price per share established in the recapitalization “pursuant to arm’s length negotiations”, and the company warned there was no assurance stockholders could receive $8.15. It is a negotiated price, not a property valuation.

August 3, 2012: the recapitalization

On August 3, 2012 the company, then called Apartment Trust of America, entered into agreements to acquire a portfolio of 20 apartment communities with 5,719 units for consideration valued at about $435.9 million, including about $176.1 million of common units valued at $8.15 per unit and the assumption of about $251.8 million of mortgage debt. It also agreed to sell about $1.65 million of common stock at $8.15 a share to Elco Landmark Residential Holdings, LLC, to pay transaction costs, ended its agreement with its external advisor and renamed itself Landmark Apartment Trust of America.

Nothing in this 8-K swapped an old holder's share for a different security. An original share stayed one share, and new units and shares were issued to the contributors at $8.15. What changed was the price at which the company said it was worth issuing equity.

Holders of record stayed almost flat through the period: about 6,105 on March 25, 2011, 6,129 on March 16, 2012, 6,193 on March 6, 2013 and 6,217 on March 19, 2015.

2014 and 2015: unsolicited offers and a lawsuit

DateEventDetail
October 3, 2014Tender offer by MacKenzie Realty Capital, Inc.Up to 1,300,000 shares at $4.15 a share; the board unanimously recommended that stockholders reject it
October 15, 2015Tender offer by MacKenzie Realty Capital, Inc.Up to 1,300,000 shares at $5.10 a share
November 23, 2015Amended company statement on the MacKenzie Capital Realty, Inc. offerUp to 1,300,000 shares at $7.00 a share, $1.17 below the merger price
August 12, 2014Complaint filed in the Superior Court of Orange County, CaliforniaAlleges that the company, its operating partnership, its former advisor and two officers took part in fraudulent transfers of assets from an affiliate of Grubb & Ellis Company; the company said the claims were without merit
August 6, 2015Fifth amended complaint, same courtReported in the 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2015

A holder who tendered at $4.15 or $5.10 sold for about half or a little over half of the $8.17 that the merger later paid (our arithmetic: 50.8% and 62.4%). We found no filing that reports how the complaint ended. The company stopped reporting when it filed the Form 15.

October 2015 to January 2016: the cash merger

DateEventDetail
October 22, 2015Merger agreementWith Monument Partners, L.L.C., formed by affiliates of Starwood Capital Group and Milestone Apartments Real Estate Investment Trust
December 2, 2015Record date37,564,488 common shares, 7,628,285 Series D preferred and 2,691,102 Series E preferred outstanding
December 7, 2015Definitive proxy statement$8.17 a share in cash; no public trading market for the common stock; no appraisal rights
January 22, 2016Special meeting29,185,400.9 votes for, 352,434.432 against, 430,556.689 abstaining; the 8-K filed that day misprints the year of the meeting as 2015
January 27, 2016ClosingEach common share converted into the right to receive $8.17, without interest; value about $1.9 billion including assumed debt
January 27, 2016Form 15Filed the same day; holders of record stated as none

The closing 8-K described the buyer's funding as equity financing of up to $600.0 million from its sponsors plus refinancing proceeds and cash on hand. The proxy statement also said the common stock would be deregistered if the merger closed and that the company expected to keep paying regular dividends at a monthly rate not to exceed $0.025 per common share until the closing.

What one original $10 share became (our arithmetic)

The first four lines below are inputs read from the filings; the last two are our sums. They assume a holder who bought at $10.00 in the first offering before March 2007 and kept the share to the closing; the results are before tax and ignore reinvestment.

StepResultSource
Paid$10.00 a share10-K for 2006
Distributions, March 2007 to February 2009$1.40 (7.0% of $10.00 for 24 months)10-K for 2010
Distributions, March 2009 to February 2011$1.20 (6.0% of $10.00 for 24 months)10-K for 2010
Distributions, March 2011 to December 2014$1.15 (46 months at $0.025)10-K for 2011 and 10-K for 2014
Cash at the January 27, 2016 closing$8.17 a share8-K of January 27, 2016
Sum through December 2014 plus merger cash$11.92, which is $3.75 of distributions plus $8.17our arithmetic

Distributions in 2015 were capped at $0.025 a month per share until closing under the proxy statement, so up to $0.30 more for the year (our arithmetic); the filings we read do not total what each holder received. A holder who bought in the 2009 to 2010 follow-on at $10.00 received fewer months of distributions. Part of any distribution can be a return of capital that lowers the tax basis.

Worked example for 1,000 shares bought at $10.00 (our arithmetic): $8,170 in cash at closing, against $10,000 paid. A holder who tendered 1,000 shares at $4.15 in October 2014 would have received $4,150.

What a former holder can do with this

  • Match your statements to this company. Statements titled NNN Apartment REIT, Grubb & Ellis Apartment REIT, Apartment Trust of America, Landmark Apartment Trust of America or Landmark Apartment Trust all refer to CIK 1347523. Landmark Apartment Trust, Inc. merged with and into Monument Intermediate Holdings, L.P. on January 27, 2016.
  • Check that the $8.17 reached you. The proxy statement said that, soon after the effective time, you would receive a letter of transmittal or instructions describing how to exchange your shares for the merger consideration. If you never received money and your broker has no record of it, ask the broker or the exchange agent named in the letter, with the old statements in hand.
  • Taxes. The proxy statement said the merger consideration would be treated as a sale of common stock at $8.17 a share, with gain or loss measured against your basis, which generally equals the price paid less any distributions that were a return of capital. Your broker's tax forms for the year of the sale and your own purchase records are the documents to use, and a tax professional can check the basis.
  • Nothing to hold now. Each share was converted into cash and the Form 15 ended the company's reporting. The company has filed no reports since January 27, 2016.
  • If the holder has died. The process for a broker account or an old paper certificate depends on how the shares were registered; start with the broker of record or the exchange agent, and ask for their estate checklist.

For a similar chain on another non-traded REIT where a tender offer set a price, see our page on non-traded REIT tender offers.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 15, 2026: Landmark Apartment Trust, Inc. (formerly Grubb & Ellis Apartment REIT, Inc.) Forms 10-K for 2006 (accession 0000892569-07-000414), 2007 (0000892569-08-000482), 2010 (0000950123-11-029240), 2011 (0001193125-12-143207), 2012 (0001193125-13-117384), 2013 (0001193125-14-110820) and 2014 (0001347523-15-000003); Forms 8-K of August 8, 2012 (0001193125-12-343936), October 29, 2014 (0001193125-14-387135), January 22, 2016 (0001193125-16-435707) and January 27, 2016 (0001193125-16-439481); Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2015 (0001347523-15-000047); Schedules TO-T of October 3, 2014 (0001550913-14-000018) and October 15, 2015 (0001550913-15-000088); Schedule 14D-9 of October 10, 2014 (0001193125-14-368917) and the amendment of November 23, 2015 (0001347523-15-000058); definitive proxy statement of December 7, 2015 (0001193125-15-396411); Form 15 of January 27, 2016 (0001193125-16-439548). This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.