CrowdfundedWealth
Articles · Research note

What Happened to Wells Timberland REIT (CatchMark)? A $10 Share Became 0.4 CTT, Then 0.092 PCH, Then Rayonier

By Jorge··23 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Filing alert · free

An email when Rayonier files with the SEC

An email the day Rayonier files something new, with the link to the document on the SEC site.

Quick Answer

Wells Timberland REIT, the non-traded timber REIT sold through brokers at $10.00 a share from 2006 to 2011, no longer exists, and neither does the company that bought its successor. Each old share became 0.4 share of CatchMark Timber Trust (NYSE: CTT) in the October 2013 recapitalization; CatchMark merged into PotlatchDeltic on September 14, 2022 at 0.230 PotlatchDeltic share per CatchMark share; and PotlatchDeltic itself merged into Rayonier (NYSE: RYN) on January 30, 2026 for 1.8185 Rayonier shares plus $0.61 in cash per PotlatchDeltic share. On 1,000 old shares ($10,000 at the offering price) that chain is 400 CatchMark shares, then 92 PotlatchDeltic shares, then 167.302 Rayonier shares plus $56.12 in cash (our arithmetic). At the $21.50 Rayonier close of November 13, 2026 that is about $3,653, before the $1,716 of CatchMark cash dividends paid through June 15, 2022 and the PotlatchDeltic and Rayonier dividends that followed (our arithmetic). Wells Timberland itself paid no cash distribution before listing. As of November 14, 2026.

Key Takeaways

  • The chain does not end at PotlatchDeltic (PCH). PotlatchDeltic merged with and into a Rayonier subsidiary on January 30, 2026, its shares were halted after that day, and its Form 15 is dated February 12, 2026. A former Wells Timberland holder who kept everything now holds Rayonier shares.
  • The $10.00 price was the sponsor's price. Both public offerings sold at $10.00; the 10-K says selling commissions and dealer-manager fees came to about $24.7 million on about $307.2 million raised, 8.04% (our arithmetic), before other offering costs of about $1.8 million. The first value the company published, $6.56 as of September 30, 2012, was 34% below that price (our arithmetic).
  • No cash came back before the listing. The December 2012 10-K says “As of the date of this report, we have not paid any cash distributions.” The only payouts before December 2013 that we found were the stock dividends in its equity statements: 605,868 shares in 2010 and 557,633 in 2011. Cash dividends started with $0.11 a share for the first quarter of 2014.
  • The 2013 recapitalization turned one old share into four new ones worth 0.4 in total. A ten-to-one reverse split on October 24, 2013 was followed by a stock dividend of one Class B-1, one B-2 and one B-3 share for every Class A share; the 10-K calls the combined effect a 2.5-to-one reverse split. The class B shares were unlisted and converted into listed Class A shares over the following 18 months.
  • The IPO that set the first public price was $13.50 a share on December 12, 2013. At 0.4 shares, that valued one old $10 share at $5.40 (our arithmetic). In February 2014 an outside group offered holders $12 for Class A and only $10, $8.50 and $7 for Class B-1, B-2 and B-3.
  • The 2022 deal was at a price well below the old $10. PotlatchDeltic closed at $56.02 on May 27, 2022, which made 0.230 share worth $12.88 per CatchMark share; CatchMark closed at $8.30 that day. On the 0.4-share basis that is $5.15 per original $10 share (our arithmetic). The vote was 36,246,571 for and 75,795 against.

CSV · 92 rows

Wells Timberland REIT, CatchMark Timber Trust, PotlatchDeltic and Rayonier: offering terms, 2013 recapitalization, dividends and both mergers

92 rows from the 10-Ks, 424B4 prospectus, Schedule TO-T, 8-Ks and Form 15 filings of Wells Timberland REIT and CatchMark, the PotlatchDeltic S-4/A and CatchMark merger proxy, and the Rayonier and PotlatchDeltic 8-Ks, S-4/A and Q3 2026 10-Q.

Four names, one position: the chain in the filings

A holder who bought through a broker between 2006 and 2011 owned shares of a Maryland company registered with the SEC under CIK 1341141. That company changed its name and its listing once, and was then absorbed twice. The table follows what the filings say at each step.

StepDateWhat happenedPer original shareSource
Wells Timberland REIT, Inc. sells sharesAug 11, 2006 to Dec 31, 2011Two public offerings at $10.00 a share; about $307.2 million raised including a 2010 German offering1 share at $10.0010-K for 2012, accession 0001341141-13-000004
RecapitalizationOct 24 and 25, 2013Ten-to-one reverse split, then one Class B-1, B-2 and B-3 share for each Class A share0.4 share in total (0.1 Class A plus 0.1 each of B-1, B-2, B-3)10-K for 2013, accession 0001341141-14-000013
CatchMark Timber Trust lists on the NYSE as CTTDec 12, 2013First listed offering of 10,526,316 Class A shares at $13.500.4 share worth $5.40 at the IPO price (our arithmetic)424B4, accession 0001193125-13-471709
CatchMark merges into PotlatchDeltic (PCH)Sep 14, 20220.230 PotlatchDeltic share per CatchMark share, cash for fractions0.092 PotlatchDeltic share (our arithmetic)PotlatchDeltic 8-K, accession 0001193125-22-244731
PotlatchDeltic merges into Rayonier (RYN)Jan 30, 20261.8185 Rayonier shares and $0.61 in cash per PotlatchDeltic share0.167302 Rayonier share and $0.0561 (our arithmetic)Rayonier 8-K, accession 0001193125-26-032194

Until 2013 the company ran under an advisor, Wells Timberland Management Organization, LLC, and sold through a dealer-manager that its 10-K says a director indirectly owned; it moved to self-management in 2013. Wells Timberland REIT is a different SEC registrant from Wells Real Estate Investment Trust II, which became Columbia Property Trust; that one has its own page, What Happened to Columbia Property Trust (Wells REIT II)?.

What one old $10 share became, step by step

Per 1,000 original shares (a $10,000 purchase at the $10.00 offering price), the table applies each ratio in the filings in order. Fractions are paid in cash at each merger; the figures below keep the decimals so the arithmetic is visible. Every input has an accession number in the data file.

After this stepShares held per 1,000 original sharesValue per the filingsArithmetic
Bought at $10.00 (2006 to 2011)1,000 Wells Timberland shares$10,000 at the offering price1,000 x $10.00 (our arithmetic)
Company estimate, Dec 14, 20121,000$6,560 at $6.56 a share; redemption price $6.231,000 x $6.56 (our arithmetic)
Recapitalization, Oct 24 and 25, 2013400 CatchMark shares (100 Class A, 100 each of B-1, B-2, B-3)$5,400 at the $13.50 IPO price400 x $13.50 (our arithmetic)
Cash dividends, Mar 2014 to Jun 15, 2022400$1,716 in cash dividends, $4.29 a share400 x $4.29 (our arithmetic)
Merger with PotlatchDeltic, Sep 14, 202292 PotlatchDeltic shares$3,320 at CatchMark's $8.30 close of May 27, 2022; $5,154 at 92 x $56.02400 x 0.230 = 92 (our arithmetic)
Merger with Rayonier, Jan 30, 2026167.302 Rayonier shares (167 whole, cash for 0.302) plus $56.12$3,860.57 at the $22.74 Rayonier close of Jan 30, 202692 x 1.8185; 92 x $0.61; 167.302 x $22.74 + $56.12 (our arithmetic)
Rayonier close, Nov 13, 2026167.302$3,653.11 at $21.50167.302 x $21.50 + $56.12 (our arithmetic)

The $21.50 is the last daily bar for November 13, 2026 in the Yahoo Finance chart data we saved on November 14, 2026; the $22.74 comes from Rayonier's own Q3 2026 10-Q, which uses it as the Rayonier price at closing. These are market prices on one date each, not a valuation and not a forecast.

What the table leaves out matters. It does not include the PotlatchDeltic dividends from September 2022 to January 2026, which we did not read. Rayonier's 10-Q shows dividends of $0.26 a share in each of the first three quarters of 2026, which would be $130.50 on 167.302 shares if every record date fell after your shares converted (our arithmetic; we did not check record dates). A holder whose 1,000 shares were already on the books for every 2010 and 2011 stock-dividend record date would have owned about 5% more shares than the 1,000 (3.11% in 2010 and 2.19% in 2011, our arithmetic from 605,868 shares on 19,460,028 and 557,633 on 25,498,717).

The offering: $10 a share, about 8% off the top, and no cash back

Wells Timberland sold two public offerings. The initial offering began on August 11, 2006 for up to 85.0 million shares, of which 75.0 million were offered at $10.00 in the primary offering and 10.0 million were reserved for the distribution reinvestment plan; it ended on August 11, 2009 with about $174.9 million from about 17.6 million shares. The follow-on offering began on August 6, 2009 and stopped on December 31, 2011. Altogether the company reports about $307.2 million of gross proceeds including a 2010 German offering. The 10-K says “In both offerings, the Registrant sold its shares for $10.00 per share”.

Selling commissions and dealer-manager fees came to about $24.7 million, other organization and offering expenses to about $1.4 million and placement and structuring agent fees to about $0.4 million. The dealer-manager was entitled to selling commissions of up to 7.0% plus a 1.8% dealer-manager fee. On commissions and dealer-manager fees alone that is 8.04% of gross proceeds, or about $0.80 of each $10.00 (our arithmetic); with the other two items the total is 8.63% (our arithmetic).

There was no cash payout. The 10-K for 2012 states “As of the date of this report, we have not paid any cash distributions.” The company paid stock dividends instead, annualized at 3% in 2010 and 2% in 2011. If you bought after the record dates you did not get them; the 10-K warns that such an investor’s interest “was diluted”. It also says the redemption plan could pay at most $10.00 per share before the first valuation. The 10-K says ordinary redemptions were not made because there were no distribution reinvestment proceeds to fund them, and the plan had been suspended on October 1, 2012.

At the end of February 2013 the company had 31,770,130 shares outstanding held by approximately 10,597 holders of record.

The $6.56 estimate: where the first 34% went

On December 14, 2012 the board announced an estimated share value of $6.56 as of September 30, 2012, a value it set with outside appraisers for the timber and an accounting firm for the rest. The 8-K builds it from four lines, per share: timber assets $11.70, debt minus $4.18, preferred equity minus $1.24 and other net assets $0.28. The preferred equity was held by the sponsor's parent. The same 10-K says the stock dividends had diluted the estimate by $0.25 a share, and that the redemption price after the estimate would be 95% of it, $6.23. In January 2012 the advisor decided to forgo more than $27 million in advisory fees, and the 8-K says that, and a cut in the preferred dividend rate from 8.5% to 1.0% in May 2011, had a positive and immediate impact on the estimate (the 2012 cash-flow statement carries a $27,315,249 non-cash write-off of amounts due to affiliates).

Because the 2013 recapitalization multiplied the share price by 2.5, the same estimate on the new share basis is $16.40 (2.5 x $6.56, our arithmetic), which explains why the 10-K for 2013 shows redemptions in October 2013 at an average of $15.58 a share, 2.5 times the $6.23 redemption price.

The 2013 recapitalization: one share became four, and none of the extras could be sold

Before listing, the company reorganized its stock. On October 24, 2013 it carried out a ten-to-one reverse split and renamed all common stock Class A. On October 25, 2013 it declared a stock dividend of one Class B-1, one Class B-2 and one Class B-3 share for each Class A share. The Class B shares were identical to Class A except that they were not listed and converted one for one into Class A at six, 12 and 18 months after the listing. Its 10-K says “The combined effect of the ten-to-one reverse stock split and the stock dividend is equivalent to a 2.5-to-one reverse stock split.”

For holders that means 1,000 old shares became 100 Class A plus 100 Class B-1, 100 B-2 and 100 B-3 (our arithmetic). The company had already terminated its distribution reinvestment plan on September 18, 2013 and its redemption plan effective October 31, 2013, so the only ways to turn the shares into cash were to sell on the NYSE after December 12, 2013 or to find a buyer for the Class B shares. The Class B shares were converted into listed Class A in three steps; the company filed Form 15 notices dated June 13, 2014 (B-1), December 15, 2014 (B-2) and February 27, 2015 (B-3).

The listing priced 10,526,316 Class A shares at $13.50, with underwriting discounts of $0.945 a share. In December 2013 the stock traded between $13.40 and $14.00. The company declared its first cash distribution on December 19, 2013: $0.11 a share for each class, payable March 17, 2014.

What an outsider offered for the Class B shares

On February 18, 2014 a group of CMG-named funds and CMG Partners filed a Schedule TO-T for up to 800,000 Class A shares (5.2% of the class) and up to 200,000 shares of each Class B class. Its prices were $12 for Class A, $10 for Class B-1, $8.50 for Class B-2 and $7 for Class B-3, in cash. The filing counted about 10,600 holders of record with 15,460,638 Class A shares and 3,172,454 shares of each Class B class on January 9, 2014.

ClassOutsider's offer, Feb 18, 2014Converted into listed Class AReference price in the filings
Class A$12 a shareAlready listed$13.50 IPO price on Dec 12, 2013; $13.40 to $14.00 range in Dec 2013
Class B-1$10 a shareForm 15 dated Jun 13, 2014Same as Class A once converted
Class B-2$8.50 a shareForm 15 dated Dec 15, 2014Same as Class A once converted
Class B-3$7 a shareForm 15 dated Feb 27, 2015Same as Class A once converted

The point for a holder is the gap, not the bidder. The Class B shares were worth the same as Class A once they converted, but an outside buyer offered 17% less for B-1 and 42% less for B-3 than for Class A (our arithmetic), before the conversion dates passed. The filings do not say how many holders accepted.

CatchMark as a listed company: cash dividends of $4.29 a share through June 2022

CatchMark paid cash dividends every year after the listing. The equity statements in its 10-Ks show per-share dividends of $0.47 in 2014, $0.50 in 2015, $0.53 in 2016, $0.54 in 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020, and $0.48 in 2021. The 10-Q for the second quarter of 2022 shows $0.075 a share paid on March 15 and June 15, 2022. That adds up to $4.29 a share from 2014 through June 15, 2022 (our arithmetic), or $1.716 for each original share at 0.4 CatchMark share, and $1,716 on 1,000 original shares. A third-quarter 2022 payment is not in the filings we read, so the sum stops at June 15, 2022.

YearCash dividend per CatchMark sharePer 1,000 original shares (400 CatchMark shares)
2014$0.47$188
2015$0.50$200
2016$0.53$212
2017$0.54$216
2018$0.54$216
2019$0.54$216
2020$0.54$216
2021$0.48$192
Jan 1 to Jun 15, 2022$0.15$60
Total$4.29$1,716

For readers comparing timber REITs, our Weyerhaeuser page covers the largest timber REIT from its own filings.

September 14, 2022: PotlatchDeltic buys CatchMark for stock

PotlatchDeltic agreed to buy CatchMark on May 29, 2022 in an all-stock deal. The merger agreement, announced May 31, 2022, set 0.230 PotlatchDeltic share for each CatchMark Class A share, plus cash for fractions. The ratio was fixed, so the value moved with PotlatchDeltic’s price: $56.02 on May 27, 2022 made it $12.88 per CatchMark share, while $49.69 on August 1, 2022 made it $11.43. CatchMark’s own close on May 27, 2022 was $8.30, and the proxy puts the implied value at a 55% premium to it. Stockholders voted on September 13, 2022: 36,246,571 for, 75,795 against and 70,634 abstaining, with 73.86% of the votes entitled to be cast present. The merger took effect at 4:00 p.m. New York time on September 14, 2022. PotlatchDeltic issued approximately 11,540,441 shares for CatchMark stock and partnership units, and CatchMark’s Form 15 is dated September 26, 2022, signed by its successor.

The proxy tells U.S. holders what the exchange meant for tax: the parties intended it to qualify as a reorganization, so a U.S. holder “will not recognize any gain or loss upon the exchange” and the holder’s basis in the PotlatchDeltic shares equals the basis of the CatchMark shares given up. Cash in lieu of a fractional share was taxed as capital gain or loss. The filings we read do not include a separate Form 8937 for the exchange, and Rayonier’s tax-basis page did not load for us, so treat the proxy as the documented source.

An important point for Wells Timberland holders: a 2022 exchange at about $12.88 for a share whose cost basis is $25 (the $10 original, spread over 0.4 share) did not create a realized loss in the merger, because the exchange was not taxed (our reading of the proxy). The basis, and the unrealized loss, carried into the PotlatchDeltic and then the Rayonier shares.

January 30, 2026: PotlatchDeltic itself disappears into Rayonier

On October 13, 2025 PotlatchDeltic and Rayonier signed a merger-of-equals agreement. It closed on January 30, 2026. PotlatchDeltic merged with and into a Rayonier subsidiary, Redwood Merger Sub, LLC, and each PotlatchDeltic share was converted into 1.8185 Rayonier common shares and $0.61 in cash. Rayonier’s 10-Q says the exchange ratio was adjusted from 1.7339 to 1.8185 for the stock component of a one-time $1.40 a share special dividend that Rayonier declared to holders of record on October 24, 2025. Rayonier issued about 140.9 million shares for 77,466,233 PotlatchDeltic shares outstanding. Nasdaq halted the PotlatchDeltic shares after the close on January 30 and was to file a Form 25 on February 2, 2026; Rayonier Operating Company LLC, as successor, signed the PotlatchDeltic Form 15 on February 12, 2026.

For a former CatchMark holder, the PotlatchDeltic shares simply became Rayonier shares: 92 per 1,000 original shares became 167.302 shares plus $56.12 in cash. Rayonier (NYSE: RYN) had 295,091,442 common shares outstanding on October 30, 2026.

On taxes, Rayonier’s registration statement says that, if the merger qualifies as a reorganization, a U.S. holder who receives shares and cash “generally will recognize gain (but not loss) in an amount equal to the lesser of” the total gain on the exchange and the cash received. On a position carried with a cost basis well above the value of what was received, the total gain is zero, so under that formula no gain is recognized on the $56.12, and the loss is not recognized in the merger either (our reading; the formula applies to your own basis, which only you or your broker can compute). The loss is realized only when the Rayonier shares are sold.

What a Wells Timberland holder or heir can do with this

  • Find which of the four names your statement shows. An old Wells Timberland REIT statement matches 0.4 CatchMark share per share in 2013, 0.092 PotlatchDeltic share per old share in 2022 and 0.1673 Rayonier share per old share since January 30, 2026 (our arithmetic). A statement showing CTT or Class B-1, B-2 or B-3 shares is from 2013 to 2015 and later. PCH shares exist only on statements before January 30, 2026.
  • Check the share count before the 2013 recapitalization. A 2012 statement showing 1,000 shares corresponds to 400 CatchMark shares after October 25, 2013, not 100: the Class B dividend is part of the 0.4. Stock dividends in 2010 and 2011 are on top of what you bought.
  • Ask the current holder of record for a basis history. Cost basis for a Wells Timberland position goes through three events: the 2013 reverse split and stock dividend, the 2022 exchange (no gain or loss, basis carried over) and the 2026 exchange (gain recognized only up to the $0.61 cash, our reading). The 2013 10-K we read does not say how the original basis was divided among the four classes, so ask your broker or a tax professional for the allocation. Rayonier lists tax-basis information on its investor-relations site; that page did not load for us on November 14, 2026, and no Form 8937 appears in the EDGAR lists for the CatchMark or PotlatchDeltic filers we read.
  • Ask where the shares sit. The filings we read do not name Rayonier’s transfer agent for former PotlatchDeltic holders. Wells Timberland’s registrar was DST Systems, Inc. in 2013, and CatchMark’s was ComputerShare Inc. in 2014. Your broker, or Rayonier’s investor relations department, can tell you who holds your position today.
  • If the owner has died. Our inherited-shares page explains how heirs deal with repurchase and re-titling of non-traded REIT shares, and our inheritance tax page covers what heirs owe by asset. For the comparison with other non-traded REITs that listed, see our listing discount page.
  • Do not rely on the 2022 headline. PotlatchDeltic is not the end of the chain. Read anything that stops there with the Rayonier merger in mind.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 14, 2026: Wells Timberland REIT / CatchMark Timber Trust (CIK 1341141) Form 10-K for 2012 (0001341141-13-000004), Form 8-K on the estimated per-share value of December 14, 2012 (0001341141-12-000061), Form 10-K for 2013 (0001341141-14-000013), 424B4 prospectus of December 12, 2013 (0001193125-13-471709), Forms 15-12G of June 13, 2014, December 15, 2014 and February 27, 2015 (0001341141-14-000052, 0001341141-14-000091, 0001341141-15-000016), the CMG Schedule TO-T of February 18, 2014 (0001197042-14-000005), Forms 10-K for 2015, 2018 and 2021 (0001341141-16-000064, 0001341141-19-000018, 0001341141-22-000014), Form 10-Q for the second quarter of 2022 (0001341141-22-000038), the definitive merger proxy of August 10, 2022 (0001193125-22-216955), the Form 8-K of the special meeting of September 13, 2022 (0001193125-22-243807) and the Form 15-12G of September 26, 2022 (0001193125-22-250580); PotlatchDeltic (CIK 1338749) Form S-4/A of August 8, 2022 (0001193125-22-214102), Form 8-K of September 14, 2022 (0001193125-22-244731), Form 8-K of January 30, 2026 (0001193125-26-032108) and Form 15-12G of February 12, 2026 (0001193125-26-048878); Rayonier Inc. (CIK 52827) Form S-4/A of December 22, 2025 (0001193125-25-327456), Form 8-K of February 2, 2026 (0001193125-26-032194) and Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026 (0000052827-26-000106); and the Yahoo Finance daily bar for Rayonier (RYN) saved on November 14, 2026 for the $21.50 close of November 13, 2026. Per-1,000-share figures, sums and percentages are our arithmetic. The filings we read do not give the PotlatchDeltic dividends paid between September 2022 and January 2026. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.