CrowdfundedWealth

South Sea Bubble: What Isaac Newton's Records Show He Lost

ResearchBy Jorge22 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the financial bubbles in history numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

In April 1720 Isaac Newton sold South Sea Company stock at about £350 for each £100 of stock, a profit the historian Andrew Odlyzko puts at about £20,000; by mid-June he appears to have put the money back in at about double that price, and by mid-1722 his portfolio was worth about £21,000 against about £32,000 at the start of 1720. That is a loss of about £11,000, or about £13,000 against doing nothing, not the £20,000 of the legend, and he still left a sworn estate of £30,333 when he died in March 1727. Odlyzko rebuilt this from Bank of England ledgers because the South Sea Company's own stock ledgers did not survive, so every figure below is a reconstruction with the gaps he names. Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst put the 1720 rise for the South Sea Company and its Atlantic-trade peers at a factor of 7 to 10, and Odlyzko has the price below £300 by the end of September 1720.

Key takeaways

  • Odlyzko's preliminary paper (November 9, 2017) reconstructs Newton's position at the start of 1720 as about 10,000 South Sea Stock worth about £13,000 plus government securities worth around £19,000, a total of £32,000, and by mid-1722 as about 22,000 South Sea Stock worth £21,000: a loss of about £11,000, and likely around £13,000 against doing nothing. A documented figure sits under that: Newton held 21,696.32 of South Sea Stock on June 25, 1722.
  • The £20,000 figure is family lore first printed in 1797. William Seward wrote that Newton lost twenty thousand pounds, as his niece used to say. Odlyzko shows how pairs of trades can be read to produce it: he sold the bulk of his holding in April 1720 for a profit of about £20,000 and then repurchased about half as much stock at about double the price.
  • The saying about calculating the motions of the heavenly bodies is not in the earliest source. The earliest version found was published in 1820 from notes Joseph Spence took before he died in 1768 and says only that Newton “could not calculate the madness of the people.” Odlyzko writes that the heavenly-bodies phrase was apparently added later by other writers.
  • The South Sea Company sold stock in four Money Subscriptions in 1720 at £300 (April 14, 1720), £400 (April 28, 1720) and £1,000 (June 17 and August 24, 1720) for each £100 of stock, with a down payment and the rest paid over time. Newton signed for 500 stock in the fourth, a £5,000 contract with £1,000 paid on signing; Odlyzko estimates that deposit would have been worth about £540 by August 1723.
  • Prices from the sources: about £350 in April 1720, about £700 on June 14, 1720, about £800 on August 4, 1720, about £750 on August 22 to 23, 1720, under £300 by the end of September 1720; the Oxford Newton and the Mint page gives a peak of £1,050 and £124 in December 1720. A buyer from mid-1719 who simply held was up almost 50% in capital by mid-1723, per Odlyzko; the losses fell on people who bought in the summer of 1720.

CSV · 90 rows

Isaac Newton and the South Sea Bubble: holdings, trades, losses, prices and payment terms

90 rows from Odlyzko's reconstruction of Newton's accounts, his Physics Today article, the Oxford Newton and the Mint page and the NBER price study: positions, documented holdings by date, each trade, the four money subscriptions and the 1720 price timeline.

The story, with dates

Isaac Newton was Master of the Royal Mint from 1699 until his death in 1727, and in 1720 he was almost 80, with Mint earnings that Odlyzko puts at about £2,000 a year and dividends of around £1,500 a year (he hedges both figures). He had been investing in South Sea Stock since the 1710s. The dates below are the ones in Odlyzko's paper, which uses the old-style (Julian) calendar England followed until 1752; the Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst price study marks Gregorian dates with [G], eleven days later.

DateWhat happenedSource
Jun 24, 1712Newton on the South Sea Company's voter list with one vote: at least 1,000 and under 3,000 of stockOdlyzko, section 8 (voter lists)
Dec 25, 1717At least 10,000 of South Sea Stock (four votes, the maximum)Odlyzko, section 8
Apr 14, 1720First Money Subscription opens at £300 for each £100 of stockOdlyzko, section 13
Apr 19, 1720Newton's letter authorizes his agent to sell 3,000 South Sea Stock, “only part of his holdings”Odlyzko, section 6 item D
Apr 19 and 23, 1720Physics Today: he liquidated his stake in those two instructions at a large profitOdlyzko, Physics Today (July 1, 2020)
Apr 28, 1720Second Money Subscription at £400Odlyzko, section 13
Apr 29 to May 23, 1720Series of purchases of Bank of England-administered government annuities, 26,000 in total (par value)Odlyzko, section 11 (Bank of England ledgers)
Jun 14, 1720The 26,000 is transferred out of his account in one day; South Sea Stock trades around £700Odlyzko, section 11
Jun 17, 1720Third Money Subscription at £1,000; Newton is not on its listOdlyzko, section 13
Jul 14, 1720Subscription converting Bank-administered annuities into South Sea Stock opens; Odlyzko thinks Newton submitted his remaining 6,000 on or soon after this dateOdlyzko, section 11
Jul 27, 1720Newton's letter subscribes his £650 a year of annuities into South Sea StockOdlyzko, section 12
Aug 24, 1720Fourth Money Subscription at £1,000; Newton signs for 500 stock, the maximum allowedOdlyzko, section 13 (Parliamentary Archives)
Sep 19, 1720 (Gregorian)South Sea shares begin to crash in the daily price seriesFrehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst, NBER Working Paper 15332
Mar 25, 1721Next £1,000 instalment on his subscription would have been dueOdlyzko, section 13
Jun 25, 1722Documented holding: 21,696.32 of South Sea StockOdlyzko, section 6 item G
Mar 20, 1727Newton dies; estate holds 14,000 Bank of England Stock, 5,000 South Sea Stock and 5,000 Old South Sea AnnuitiesOdlyzko, section 6 item I

Newton's position, as the ledgers let Odlyzko rebuild it

Odlyzko's paper explains why a reconstruction is needed: the South Sea Company's stock ledgers, which would show every trade, were apparently discarded in the 1860s, and “Records of South Sea Stock transactions have not survived.” The Bank of England's ledgers for its own stock and for the annuities it administered did survive, and they show Newton's other moves. The table separates what is documented from what Odlyzko infers.

DateItemFigureDocumented or inferred
Start of 1720South Sea Stock, market valueabout 10,000 stock, about £13,000Inferred (paper, section 2)
Start of 1720Government securitiesaround £19,000Inferred (section 2)
Start of 1720Total portfolio£32,000Inferred (section 2)
Apr 19, 1720Letter to sell South Sea Stock3,000 stock, “only part”Documented (letter)
Apr 29 to May 23, 1720Government annuities bought26,000 par valueDocumented (Bank of England ledgers)
Jun 14, 1720Those annuities transferred out26,000, same dayDocumented; use of the money inferred
Jul 27, 1720Annuities of £650 a year subscribed into South Sea Stockworth about £22,750 at the timeDocumented letter; value inferred
Aug 24, 1720Fourth Money Subscription500 stock, £5,000, £1,000 downDocumented (Parliamentary Archives)
Jun 25, 1722South Sea Stock21,696.32Documented (letter of Aug 8, 1722)
Mid-1722Whole portfolioabout 22,000 stock, £21,000Inferred (section 2)
Mar 20, 1727Sworn estate£30,333Documented

Three results follow, all Odlyzko's. First, against the start-of-1720 portfolio, the 1720 to mid-1722 change is a loss of about £11,000, “and likely somewhat more, around £13,000,” compared with sitting still. Second, the pair of trades in 1720 looks worse in isolation: he sold at about £350 and bought back at about double that, so he could have regarded that pair alone as producing losses of £20,000 or more. Third, Physics Today puts his net worth at just over £30,000 before the bubble and about £20,000 by mid-1721, which it summarises as having “lost all his early profits and a good bit more besides.”

Our arithmetic from his numbers: £32,000 down to £21,000 is a fall of about 34% in the portfolio; £11,000 is a little over three and a half years of the roughly £3,000 to £3,500 a year he earned from the Mint and from dividends.

Reading the sale: what each document says

The documents agree he sold in April 1720 and disagree about how much, which is the main revision between the 2017 draft and the 2020 article.

DocumentWhat it says about the April to June 1720 sales
Newton's letter of April 19, 1720Authorizes sale of 3,000 South Sea Stock and says this is “only part of his holdings”
Odlyzko, preliminary paper (November 9, 2017)Infers he sold about 8,000 stock across April and May and repurchased under 4,000 in June if he used the proceeds of his June 14 annuity transfer
Odlyzko, Physics Today (July 1, 2020)Concludes he liquidated his whole stake, on Tuesday and Saturday, April 19 and 23, and “jumped back in almost at the peak”
Newton and the Mint, University of OxfordStates that “It is likely that Newton lost some money, but the evidence is inconclusive.”

The 1720 price timeline

The price series that fits on one page is the one Odlyzko gives from the Course of the Exchange (for each £100 of stock), plus the 1720 points he and the Oxford page quote. The daily series behind the 2013 Journal of Financial Economics paper by Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst is hosted by the Yale International Center for Finance for academic use, and we do not republish it; that paper dates the start of the South Sea crash to September 19, 1720 (Gregorian) and says Atlantic-trade firms “rose by factors of 7 to 10.”

DateSouth Sea price per £100 stockSource
Dec 31, 1711£75.00Odlyzko, Table 1 (Course of the Exchange)
Oct 14, 1715£93.75Odlyzko, Table 1
Dec 11, 1716£103.50Odlyzko, Table 1
Nov 19, 1719£119.25Odlyzko, Table 1
About Apr 19, 1720about £350Odlyzko, section 11
End of May 1720nearly £600Oxford, Newton and the Mint
Jun 14, 1720about £700 (Course of the Exchange: 710, 685, 700; Freke: 715, 690, 700)Odlyzko, section 11
End of June 1720£950Oxford, Newton and the Mint
Peak, summer 1720£1,050Oxford, Newton and the Mint
Aug 4, 1720about £800 (Course of the Exchange: 800, 790, 820), down from well over £900 at the peakOdlyzko, section 13
Aug 22 to 23, 1720around £750Odlyzko, section 13
End of Sep 1720below £300, many sales below £200 just beforeOdlyzko, section 13
Late summer 1720£190Oxford, Newton and the Mint
Dec 1720£124Oxford, Newton and the Mint
Aug 31, 1723£104.00 nominal; £162.07 adjusted for the stock dividends and the 1723 annuity splitOdlyzko, Table 1

The sources disagree on the summer: Odlyzko notes that Course of the Exchange and Freke's Prices of Stocks differ by the stock dividend, so the 1720 figures are only comparable within one source. From a peak of £1,050 to £190, the fall is about 82% (our arithmetic). Physics Today says that by October 1720 the stock was “less than a quarter” of its peak price.

How the money was raised: the terms behind the price

The price was only half the story. The documents show four ways investors paid and what each cost.

MechanismWhat the documents saySource
Money SubscriptionsInvestors could buy South Sea Stock for cash with an immediate down payment and the rest spread over extended periods; four of them in 1720 at £300, £400, £1,000 and £1,000 for each £100 of stockOdlyzko, section 13
Newton's contract in the fourth500 stock at £1,000 per 100 = £5,000; £1,000 on signing and the next £1,000 on March 25, 1721. The deposit was 20% of the contract (our arithmetic)Odlyzko, section 13
What the contract said on defaultOdlyzko quotes the preamble: a payment already made “shall be forfeited to the Said Governour and Company,” and concludes “Investors could walk away from their subscriptions”Odlyzko, section 14 (Parliamentary Archives HL/PO/JO/10/2/15728)
Converting government debtHolders of government annuities were invited to convert them into South Sea Stock; those who applied on August 4, 1720 “were doing so on blind faith” because the terms were announced on August 12, 1720 and applications were “taken as binding contracts”Odlyzko, section 12
Lending against the company's own stockOxford: the Company “began to act almost exclusively as a kind of bank, lending money to potential purchasers of its stock”Newton and the Mint, University of Oxford
Selling new stock at a higher pricePhysics Today shows the argument of the April 1720 Flying-Post article: 500 shares and $100,000 of assets is $200 a share; sell 2,000 new shares at $400 and it becomes $900,000 and 2,500 shares, $360 a shareOdlyzko, Physics Today
Dividends from new moneyIn the plan the company had to give Parliament after the bubble, “they were planning to pay the high dividends they promised mainly out of the funds they expected to obtain from sales of shares”Odlyzko, Physics Today

Odlyzko's section 14 settles a dispute among economists about whether a subscriber like Newton owed all the instalments or could stop; he reads the printed preambles as letting a subscriber stop at the cost of what was already paid, which is why he calls the receipts an enhanced option. For Newton that meant his loss on the fourth subscription was capped at the deposit. Odlyzko estimates that, held to mid-1723, the £1,000 would have become about £540: for every £100 paid the subscribers “received (by mid-1723) just a bit under 52 of Stock.” Our arithmetic: that is a loss of about 46%.

Another figure from the same contract: the price of £1,000 per £100 of stock was set when the market was around £750 on August 22 to 23, 1720, so he agreed to pay about 33% above the market price (£1,000 against £750, our arithmetic). Odlyzko's own words on the move: “Paying 200 for the option to buy later at a price of 1,000 something that is selling at that moment for 750 is not necessarily crazy in the case of a volatile security,” but it required “substantial faith.”

What the documents show that the headlines don't

  1. The legend's number is not the paper's number. The £20,000 loss is a figure Seward printed in 1797, from what Newton's niece used to say, two generations after Newton's death. Odlyzko's reconstruction gives about £11,000 against the start of 1720 and about £13,000 against doing nothing, and he shows the £20,000 appears if you count pairs of trades in isolation. He also writes: “His losses, even by conservative accounting, almost surely exceeded £10,000.”
  2. Newton was right first. In April 1720 he sold at about £350 and made a profit Odlyzko puts at about £20,000. The loss came from going back in at about double the price in June, with, in Odlyzko's words, “no sign of his trying to cash anything in after mid-June.”
  3. He did not lose everything. His portfolio went from about £32,000 to about £21,000 and he died in 1727 with a sworn estate of £30,333, of which the inventory lists 14,000 Bank of England Stock (about £17,500), 5,000 South Sea Stock (about £4,900) and 5,000 Old South Sea Annuities (about £4,800). Physics Today says the bubble “hardly ruined him financially.” In a later letter to a friend Newton wrote “I lost very much by the South Sea company which makes my pockets empty”; Physics Today calls that an exaggeration, because his pockets were not empty.
  4. The quote is not in the earliest source in the form people repeat. The earliest version Odlyzko found was published in 1820 from Spence's second memorandum book (1756), as reported by Lord Radnor: Newton “could not calculate the madness of the people.” The heavenly-bodies version is not in that source; Physics Today introduces it with “allegedly.” We treat it as unverified.
  5. The Bubble Act did not stop the company. Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst write that the Act of June 9, 1720 “did not directly concern the South Sea Company”: it chartered London Assurance and Royal Exchange Assurance and limited the chartering of competitors.
  6. The company did not die in 1720. Odlyzko says that by early 1722 it controlled over 80% of the British government debt, and Oxford says it operated until 1853. A footnote of his paper adds that its commercial activities never amounted to much.
  7. Holding would have worked. According to Odlyzko, anyone who bought South Sea Stock in mid-1719 and simply held until mid-1723 would have been rewarded by an almost 50% capital gain, in addition to dividends; Frehen and co-authors find that South Sea shares “were higher at the end of 1720 than at the beginning.” Odlyzko adds that early investors benefited at the expense of later ones.
  8. He was not alone. Physics Today puts the share of British investors drawn in at an estimated 80 to 90%, and quotes a London banker's June 1720 letter: “when the rest of the world is mad we must imitate them in some measure.”

What this means for your money

The 1720 documents describe four things a reader can check in any modern offering: how much is paid now and how much later, who lends against the shares, what you pay compared to what the assets are worth, and where the distributions come from.

1720 featureWhat to look for in a filing todayWhere to read more on our site
Down payment now, the rest on a schedule (the money subscriptions)Unfunded commitments and capital calls in a private fund or BDC. A $250,000 commitment with 20% called at signing is $50,000 paid and $200,000 still owed (our arithmetic); the subscription agreement says what happens if you miss a call[Ares Core Infrastructure Fund: sales by quarter and capital calls](/articles/ares-core-infrastructure-fund-2026)
A company lending to those buying its stockLoans to officers or affiliates and related-party transactions in the 10-K and 10-Q; the WeWork S-1 is a worked example of founder loans and leases[WeWork's S-1: what the filing showed](/articles/wework-s-1-adam-neumann-what-the-filing-showed)
Buying at a price far above the assetsPrice against net asset value: Capital Southwest sold stock at 141% of NAV in 2026, a case where the premium can be read in one number[CSWC: dividend, NII and shares sold at 141% of NAV](/articles/capital-southwest-cswc-dividend-nav-premium-2026)
Dividends paid out of new moneyCompare distributions to net investment income or cash flow, and see whether a regulator alleges the gap was filled by new investors: the SEC made that allegation about GPB Capital[What happened to GPB Capital](/articles/what-happened-to-gpb-capital)
Investors who can't make the board actWho controls distributions and redemptions, and what a court will order[Dodge v. Ford (1919): what shareholders could force](/articles/dodge-v-ford-motor-company-1919-what-shareholders-can-force)

What a reader can do with this

  • Separate the legend from the ledger. When a story gives one loss number, ask which two prices and dates it compares. Odlyzko's own conclusion is that the legend's number appears when the sale and repurchase are counted as one loss, not that Newton lost £20,000 in total.
  • Look at the day you would have bought, not the headline. The same stock was £119.25 in November 1719, about £350 in April 1720, about £700 in mid-June 1720 and under £300 by the end of September 1720. A buyer's result depended on the date, which a fund's NAV history and tender-offer prices let you check now.
  • Write down the payment schedule before you sign. Newton's contract needed £1,000 on August 24, 1720 and £1,000 more on March 25, 1721, and the forfeiture wording decided what he owed if he stopped. The equivalent in a modern fund is the subscription agreement and the schedule of capital calls.
  • Notice concentration. Odlyzko's paper concludes that by 1721 practically all of Newton's money was in South Sea securities, which is the part of the story you can check in your own statements.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 16, 2026: Andrew Odlyzko, “Newton's financial misadventures in the South Sea Bubble,” preliminary version of November 9, 2017 (SSRN 3068542), the draft of the paper later published in Notes and Records of the Royal Society, volume 73, issue 1, pages 29 to 59 (doi 10.1098/rsnr.2018.0018), whose final text may differ; Andrew Odlyzko, “Isaac Newton and the perils of the financial South Sea,” Physics Today, July 1, 2020 (doi 10.1063/PT.3.4521); Newton and the Mint, University of Oxford, “Newton and the South Sea Bubble”; Rik Frehen, William Goetzmann and K. Geert Rouwenhorst, “New Evidence on the First Financial Bubble,” NBER Working Paper 15332 (September 2009, revised November 2009), published in the Journal of Financial Economics, volume 108, issue 3, pages 585 to 607. Not retrieved: the final published text of Odlyzko's paper (blocked), the Yale daily price file (academic-use terms) and the text of the 1720 statute.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.