CrowdfundedWealth

Peter Minuit, Manhattan and $24: What the 1626 Letter Says

ResearchBy Jorge16 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the money history from primary documents numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

The one document from 1626 that records the Manhattan purchase is a letter dated November 5, 1626, and it says the settlers bought the island “for the value of 60 guilders.” It names no beads, no Peter Minuit and no dollars. The “$24” first shows up in a history printed in 1846, which writes “sixty guilders, or twenty-four dollars,” a conversion at 40 US cents to the guilder (our arithmetic: 24 divided by 60). The 1626 ship that brought the news carried 7,246 beaver skins; at the 7 to 8 guilders a pelt that the New Amsterdam History Center gives for the mid-17th century, those pelts alone were worth about 50,722 to 57,968 guilders (our arithmetic), so the island cost roughly 0.1% of one cargo. For scale today, the NYC Department of Finance puts the market value of Manhattan's taxable property at $526,180.6 million for fiscal year 2026 (July 2026 report). $24 compounded for 400 years reaches that figure at about 6.13% a year (our arithmetic); at 5% it would be about $7.2 billion, at 8% about $562 trillion.

Key takeaways

  • The source is one letter. Pieter Schaghen wrote from Amsterdam on November 5, 1626 (received November 7, 1626) to the States General about the ship Arms of Amsterdam, which had sailed from the Mauritius River on September 23, 1626. The New Amsterdam History Center calls it the only known record of the event.
  • The sentence in Dutch: “t’eylant Manhattes van de wilde gekocht, voor de waerde van 60 guld: is groot 11000 morgen.” The New Netherland Institute translates it: “They have purchased the Island Manhattes from the Indians for the value of 60 guilders. It is 11,000 morgens in size.” The saved text of the letter has no name for the buyer and lists no goods.
  • The dollar figure is from 1846. O'Callaghan's History of New Netherland (title page 1846) prints “sixty guilders, or twenty-four dollars”; the New Amsterdam History Center says he applied 40 US cents to the guilder, and calls the result misleading both as a 17th-century value and as a present-day one.
  • The island was cheap, but the ship was not. The cargo list counts 7,246 beaver skins; with the beaver price the New Amsterdam History Center gives (7 to 8 guilders), 60 guilders buys about 7.5 to 8.6 pelts (our arithmetic). The 1846 history counts 8,130 beaver skins for the same shipment: the two documents disagree and both are shown below.
  • The compounding story depends entirely on the rate. Our arithmetic on $24 over 400 years (1626 to 2026): 5% gives $7,176,800,430, 6% gives $318,095,369,845, 7% gives $13,605,744,645,294 and 8% gives $561,970,394,044,937. Manhattan's fiscal 2026 taxable market value is $526,180.6 million, which sits between the 6% and 7% results.
  • We could not give an official 2026 equivalent of 60 guilders. The International Institute of Social History discontinued its guilder-to-euro conversion tool (notice dated June 14, 2021), saying it “presented an oversimplified picture.”

CSV · 52 rows

The Manhattan purchase: the 1626 Schagen letter, the 1846 conversion to $24, beaver-pelt prices and the NYC Department of Finance market value of Manhattan

52 rows: the letter's price, size and cargo, the 1846 conversion, mid-17th-century beaver prices, the status of the IISH converter, Manhattan's FY2026 taxable market value and our arithmetic of $24 compounded at 5%, 6%, 7% and 8%. Source and link on every row.

The story, dated from the documents

Every American schoolchild is told that Peter Minuit bought Manhattan for $24 of beads. The paradox is in the paperwork: the letter that records the price states it in guilders, mentions no beads and does not mention Minuit, and the dollars were added two centuries later. The 1846 history that prints “twenty-four dollars” does mention beads once, in the account of Hudson's trade in 1609, and not in its sentence about the purchase.

DateEventSource
Apr 6, 1609Henry Hudson sails from the Texel; later that year the Half-Moon trades with natives on the river that now bears his nameO'Callaghan, History of New Netherland (1846), vol. 1
About 1624The Dutch colony in New Netherland begins, after an earlier period of trading postsNew Amsterdam History Center
Jul 27, 1626The ship Arms of Amsterdam arrives at ManhattanNew Amsterdam History Center
Sep 23, 1626The ship sails from the Mauritius River (the Hudson) for Holland with its cargoSchaghen letter
Nov 4, 1626The ship reaches Amsterdam after about six weeks at seaNew Amsterdam History Center
Nov 5, 1626Pieter Schaghen writes to the States General: the island Manhattes bought “for the value of 60 guilders,” 11,000 morgensSchaghen letter
Nov 7, 1626The letter is receivedSchaghen letter
Sep 8, 1664The English take New Amsterdam on the date the 1846 history gives; “the name of the city was changed to that it now bears”O'Callaghan, History of New Netherland (1846), vol. 2
1846O'Callaghan prints “sixty guilders, or twenty-four dollars”; the New Amsterdam History Center says he used 40 US cents to the guilderO'Callaghan vol. 1; New Amsterdam History Center
Jul 2026NYC Department of Finance publishes its FY2026 report: Manhattan taxable market value $526,180.6 millionNYC Department of Finance

Who Pieter Schaghen was depends on which source you read: the New Netherland Institute calls him the representative of the States General in the Assembly of the Nineteen of the West India Company; the New Amsterdam History Center says he sat on the Company's board and in the States General, and was a merchant and grain dealer. The saved text of the letter shows no mention of Minuit, and in the 1846 history the buyer is “the Director General and Council,” with Minuit named as the Director of the colony in that period. Where this page says “Minuit” it means that office, not a line of the letter.

What the letter says against what the story says

PointThe story most people knowWhat the 1626 letter says
Price$24“for the value of 60 guilders” (the Dutch: “voor de waerde van 60 guld”)
What was paidBeadsNo goods are listed; the New Amsterdam History Center reads “value of” as trade goods worth 60 guilders and says typical goods included wool blankets, metal utensils and decorative glass beads, as an inference
Who boughtPeter MinuitNo name; the letter says “our people” (the colony) bought it
Who sold“Indians” or a chief“van de wilde” in the Dutch, “from the Indians” in the New Netherland Institute translation; no seller is named
SizeThe island of Manhattan“groot 11000 morgen,” 11,000 morgens; the New Netherland Institute adds about 22,000 acres in brackets
Date of sale1626Not stated; the letter, written November 5, 1626, reports a completed purchase
Why the letter was writtenTo record a famous bargainTo report the ship's arrival, the harvest and a cargo of 7,246 beaver skins; the sale is one sentence among them

What the documents show that the headlines don't

  1. The letter is a news item, not a deed. The purchase is one sentence between the report that the colonists were “in good spirit” and the harvest samples (wheat, rye, barley, oats, buckwheat, canary seed, beans, flax). The New Amsterdam History Center says an official conveyance was probably drawn up and signed but has not survived, so this letter is the only known record.
  2. “Value of 60 guilders” is a measure, not a bag of beads. The Dutch says “voor de waerde van 60 guld,” the value of 60 guilders, and the New Amsterdam History Center's translation reads “60 guilders worth of trade.” Nothing in the saved letter says what the goods were.
  3. The $24 is an exchange-rate decision made in the 1840s. The 1846 history prints it in a sentence that names no goods. The same book prints “six hundred guilders ($240)” in volume 2, the same 40 cents to the guilder. The New Amsterdam History Center says the resulting figure has little relation to present-day dollar values.
  4. The two documents count the cargo differently. The letter lists 7,246 beaver skins; the 1846 history says “eight thousand, one hundred and thirty beaver skins” for the same ship. Both are in the CSV.
  5. Both sides may not have been selling the same thing. The New Amsterdam History Center writes that, to the Dutch, purchase meant exclusive and permanent possession, while to the Native Americans “it was a question of permission to use the land for the time being.” That is the historians' reading; the letter itself records only the Dutch side.

The money arithmetic

The guilder side comes from beaver prices because the usual converter is gone. The International Institute of Social History states that it has “discontinued the Guilder to Euro conversion tool,” which “presented an oversimplified picture,” and points to the underlying data instead; we did not turn that data into a euro figure, and any website that gives one for 1626 is using its own method.

MeasureFigureHow
Price in the letter60 guildersSchaghen letter
1846 conversion$24 (40 US cents per guilder)O'Callaghan vol. 1; New Amsterdam History Center
One merchantable beaver pelt, mid-17th centuryAbout 7 to 8 guildersNew Amsterdam History Center
60 guilders in pelts7.5 pelts at 8 guilders; 8.6 pelts at 7 guildersOur arithmetic: 60 / 8 and 60 / 7
Beaver skins in the 1626 cargo7,246 (letter) or 8,130 (1846 history)Schaghen letter; O'Callaghan vol. 1
Value of the letter's 7,246 pelts50,722 to 57,968 guildersOur arithmetic: 7,246 x 7 and 7,246 x 8; the New Amsterdam History Center gives 50,000 to 60,000
Island price against that cargoAbout 0.10% to 0.12%Our arithmetic: 60 / 57,968 and 60 / 50,722

Now the famous thought experiment, with every rate stated. The starting sum is the 1846 figure of $24, compounded once a year for 400 years (1626 to 2026), with no taxes, no inflation adjustment and no losses (our arithmetic). The comparison value is the NYC Department of Finance's fiscal year 2026 market value of Manhattan's taxable properties: $526,180.6 million across 163,702 parcels, which excludes fully exempt properties and includes buildings, not only land.

Annual rate$24 after 400 years (our arithmetic)Against Manhattan FY2026 taxable market value
5%$7,176,800,4301.4% of it
6%$318,095,369,84560.5% of it
7%$13,605,744,645,294About 25.9 times it
8%$561,970,394,044,937About 1,068 times it
6.13% (break-even)$526,180.6 millionEqual

Read the table the other way round. The price paid grew to Manhattan's present taxable market value only at about 6.13% a year for four centuries, and a one-point change in the rate moves the answer by more than 40 times (our arithmetic). The $24 itself is a number from 1846, not 1626, which makes the whole exercise a comparison between a conversion and an assessment. The market value is also the Department of Finance's estimate for tax purposes, not a sale price, and it covers 163,702 taxable parcels, with Manhattan at about a third of the city's $1,574,378.8 million (33.4%, our arithmetic).

What this means for your money

  • Read the source document, not the summary. The 60 guilders, the date and the missing beads were all checkable in a one-page letter. A famous number that no one has traced to its document is a claim, not a fact. For a fund, the equivalent is the filing behind a marketing figure.
  • A small sum looks huge when someone picks the rate. The same $24 is $7 billion at 5% and $562 trillion at 8%. When a pitch shows what a small amount “would be worth” after decades, ask which rate, whether taxes, fees and inflation are inside it, and who earned that rate over the whole period.
  • A price paid is not a value received. The Dutch paid 60 guilders and, in the letter's own words, got a place of 11,000 morgens; the Native Americans, per the historians quoted above, may have been granting use. Two sides can sign the same deal and hold different assets, which is why the terms of any investment, such as redemption rights in a fund, matter more than the headline price.
  • Use the right yardstick across centuries. The 40-cent conversion treats a 17th-century money of account as a 19th-century coin. Beaver prices are a better local yardstick for 1626 than any dollar figure; for today, the official data are assessments, rents and filings.

The same habit of going to the document runs through our look at how Lizzie Magie's 1904 patent compares with the Monopoly patent, at how McDonald's earns rent as a real estate business, and at what Madoff victims actually got back. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

What a reader can do with this

  • Open the letter. Both transcriptions are free: the New Netherland Institute's page (Dutch and English) and the New Amsterdam History Center's article, which also reproduces the original image from the Nationaal Archief.
  • Name the rate when you read a compounding claim. Copy the table above and test any “what it would be worth” figure at 5%, 6%, 7% and 8%.
  • Check what a price is in. In 1626 it was guilders of “value”; in 1846, dollars at a chosen rate. In a fund it is a net asset value, a purchase price or a redemption price, and they are different numbers.
  • Look for the original before you repeat a number. The CSV above gives the source and link for every row.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 20, 2026: Pieter Schaghen, letter to the States General, Amsterdam, November 5, 1626, transcription and translation as published by the New Netherland Institute (“Peter Schagen Letter,” newnetherlandinstitute.org) and the New York State Library (nysl.nysed.gov/newnetherland/schaghentrans), and by the New Amsterdam History Center (“The Schaghen Letter,” newamsterdamhistorycenter.org, August 30, 2023), original at the Nationaal Archief, The Hague; E. B. O'Callaghan, History of New Netherland; or, New York under the Dutch, volumes 1 and 2 (D. Appleton and Company, 1846, via archive.org); International Institute of Social History, “Value of the Guilder versus Euro” (iisg.amsterdam, notice dated June 14, 2021); New York City Department of Finance, Annual Report of the New York City Real Property Tax, Fiscal Year 2026 (July 2026), Table 1. Compounding and ratios are our arithmetic.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.