CrowdfundedWealth

Leonard v. PepsiCo: What the Pepsi Harrier Jet Ruling Says

ResearchBy Jorge18 min read

Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure

Update alert · free

An email when the fine print in investment offers numbers change

When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.

Quick answer

In 1996 a Pepsi commercial ended with a teenager landing a Harrier fighter jet at his high school and the words “HARRIER FIGHTER 7,000,000 PEPSI POINTS”; a viewer who worked out that the catalog let him buy missing points at ten cents each mailed in 15 original points and a check for $700,008.50, PepsiCo returned the check with free product coupons, and on August 5, 1999 a federal judge in New York granted PepsiCo summary judgment. The opinion (Leonard v. PepsiCo, Inc., 88 F. Supp. 2d 116, S.D.N.Y.) gives three separate reasons: the commercial was an advertisement and not an offer, no objective person could reasonably have concluded it offered a Harrier Jet, and there was no signed writing as the New York Statute of Frauds requires for a sale of goods of $500 or more. The court put the jet's cost at roughly $23 million against about $700,000 of points, which our arithmetic makes 3.0%. The Second Circuit affirmed on April 17, 2000 “for substantially the reasons stated in Judge Wood's opinion.” The lesson for an investor: the document that carries the terms (the catalog and order form there; the offering circular, prospectus or private placement memorandum in an investment) decides what can be enforced, not the commercial. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

Key takeaways

  • The commercial priced the jet at 7,000,000 Pepsi Points and the catalog's Order Form listed 53 items with prices from 15 to 3300 points, with no Harrier Jet on it. The catalog said additional points could be bought for ten cents each, with at least fifteen original points per order, so the jet's price converts to $700,000.00 (our arithmetic: 7,000,000 points at $0.10).
  • On or about March 27, 1996 the plaintiff sent an Order Form with “1 Harrier Jet” written in, 15 original points and a check for $700,008.50. PepsiCo's fulfillment house rejected it on or about May 7, 1996, 41 days later (our arithmetic), calling the jet “fanciful.”
  • The court's three reasons, in its Conclusion: the commercial was “merely an advertisement, not a unilateral offer,” the tongue-in-cheek attitude would not lead a reasonable person to think a soft drink company would give away fighter planes, and there was no writing to satisfy the Statute of Frauds.
  • The court's own numbers for the second reason: 7,000,000 Pepsis, or roughly 190 a day for a hundred years, or about $700,000 of purchased points, against a jet that costs roughly $23 million. Our arithmetic: 7,000,000 Pepsis is about 291,667 cases of 24 cans, if each Pepsi earned one point as the court's count assumes.
  • The case took more than three years before the merits: the court calls it “three years of jurisdictional and procedural wrangling,” with suits in New York and Florida, a transfer ordered on November 6, 1996 and a fee award of $88,162 that PepsiCo agreed on February 22, 1999 not to enforce.
  • The ruling does not say it was foolish to buy points. It says the catalog and Order Form, not the television commercial, held the terms, and the jet was in neither. That is the reading that matters for a prospectus, an offering circular or a private placement memorandum.

CSV · 58 rows

Leonard v. PepsiCo: points prices, catalog rules, timeline and the court's reasons

58 rows from the 1999 district court opinion and the 2000 Second Circuit affirmance: points prices, the 10-cent rule, the check, dated letters and lawsuits, the three reasons, and labelled arithmetic.

The story, with dates

Pepsi ran a promotion called Pepsi Stuff in which drinkers collected Pepsi Points from specially marked packages and redeemed them for merchandise with the Pepsi logo. Before going national, the opinion says, PepsiCo tested it in the Pacific Northwest from October 1995 to March 1996, and a catalog went to consumers in the test market, including Washington State, where the plaintiff lived. The plaintiff saw the commercial there. The table is built from the court's recitation of the facts, which the court says is drawn from the parties' sworn statements of uncontested facts.

DateWhat happenedWhere in the record
October 1995 to March 1996PepsiCo tests Pepsi Stuff in the Pacific Northwest; a catalog is distributed to the test market88 F. Supp. 2d at 118
1996 (commercial)Subtitles price a T-shirt at 75 points, a leather jacket at 1450 and shades at 175; the last subtitle reads “HARRIER FIGHTER 7,000,000 PEPSI POINTS”At 118-19
On or about March 27, 1996Plaintiff sends an Order Form with “1 Harrier Jet” and “7,000,000” written in, 15 original points, and a check for $700,008.50, after raising about $700,000 “through acquaintances”At 119
On or about May 7, 1996PepsiCo's fulfillment house rejects the submission, returns the check and encloses free product couponsAt 120
On or about May 14, 1996Plaintiff's counsel demands transfer of the jet within ten business daysAt 120
May 30, 1996A vice president of the advertising agency BBDO New York writes that “no reasonable person would agree” with the plaintiff's analysisAt 120
On or about June 17, 1996Plaintiff mails a similar demand to PepsiCoAt 120
July 18, 1996PepsiCo files a declaratory judgment action in New York (96 Civ. 5320)At 120
August 6, 1996Plaintiff sues in Florida state court; removed to federal court in September 1996At 120
November 6, 1996The Florida federal judge finds the forum has no meaningful relationship to the controversy and orders a transferAt 120
December 2, 1996The Florida suit arrives in New York as 96 Civ. 9069At 121
November 24, 1997PepsiCo's declaratory action is dismissed for lack of personal jurisdictionAt 121
December 15, 1997Voluntary dismissal of the Florida-origin case allowed, on condition that the plaintiff pay certain attorneys' feesAt 121
October 1, 1998Court orders the plaintiff to pay $88,162 in attorneys' fees within thirty daysAt 121
February 22, 1999Second Circuit endorses stipulations dismissing the appeals; PepsiCo agrees not to enforce the fee award; summary judgment motion followsAt 121
August 5, 1999Summary judgment granted to PepsiCo; the Clerk is told to close the casesAt 116 and 132
April 17, 2000Second Circuit affirms in a per curiam opinion (argued March 21, 2000)210 F.3d 88

The catalog and the price list, as the court describes them

The commercial said the details were elsewhere: footnote 2 of the opinion records a message at the bottom of the screen at the catalog shot, “Offer not available in all areas. See details on specially marked packages.” The table sets out the points terms the court quotes, with our cash conversion at the catalog's ten cents per point.

Item or rulePoints or termCash at 10 cents a point (our arithmetic)Source in the opinion
Jacket Tattoo (lowest-priced item on the Order Form)15$1.50At 119
T-shirt (subtitle in the commercial)75$7.50At 118
Shades (subtitle in the commercial)175$17.50At 118
Leather jacket (subtitle in the commercial)1450$145.00At 118
Fila Mountain Bike (highest-priced item on the Order Form)3300$330.00At 119
Harrier Fighter (last subtitle of the commercial; not on the Order Form)7,000,000$700,000.00At 119
Buying missing points“additional Pepsi Points may be purchased for ten cents each”n/aAt 119
Minimum original points per orderAt least fifteenn/aAt 119
How to orderOnly with the original Order Formn/aAt 119
Items listed on one side of the Order FormFifty-three; no Harrier Jet entryn/aAt 119

Our arithmetic on those terms: the jet's 7,000,000 points are 2,121.2 times the 3300 points of the most expensive item the Order Form lists. The plaintiff's 7,000,000 points less the 15 original ones leaves 6,999,985 to buy, which at ten cents is $699,998.50; the check was for $700,008.50, and the opinion does not explain the $10.00 difference. The opinion gives the sum as 7,000,000 Pepsis, which is about 291,667 cases of 24 cans if each Pepsi earned one point (our arithmetic).

The court's reasons, in order

The Conclusion on page 132 says “there are three reasons why plaintiff's demand cannot prevail as a matter of law.” Each is a separate ground; the court says in footnote 14 that more discovery could bear only on the second.

StepWhat the court heldAuthority or number it relies onPage
1. An advertisement is not an offerThe general rule is that an advertisement does not constitute an offer; the plaintiff's own letter and Order Form would be the offer, and “There would be no enforceable contract until defendant accepted the Order Form and cashed the check.”Restatement (Second) of Contracts section 26, comment b, quoted at 123; Mesaros v. United States122-24
1a. The exception for a clear adAn advertisement that is “clear, definite, and explicit, and leaves nothing open for negotiation” can be an offer, but this one “specifically reserved the details of the offer to a separate writing, the Catalog,” and had no words of limitation such as “first come, first served”Lefkowitz v. Great Minneapolis Surplus Store (Minnesota, 1957), quoted at 124124-25
2. No objective person would take it as an offerThe test is what an objective, reasonable person would have understood the commercial to convey; “no objective person could reasonably have concluded that the commercial actually offered consumers a Harrier Jet”Kay-R Elec. Corp. v. Stone & Webster; Mesaros; Corbin on Contracts127
2a. A jury was not needed“Such an inquiry is commonly performed by courts on a motion for summary judgment.”Krumme; Bourque; Wards Co.128
2b. Why it is evidently a jokePuffery (“mere puffery”); a youth who “could barely be trusted with the keys to his parents' car”; an adolescent fantasy; the jet's military mission; and the priceUnited States Marine Corps fact file (December 5, 1995)128-29
2c. The price7,000,000 Pepsis, or roughly 190 a day for a hundred years, or approximately $700,000 of points; “The cost of a Harrier Jet is roughly $23 million dollars”; “a deal too good to be true”Court's own count; a plaintiff's business plan filed in the earlier case129
2d. The changed commercialsPepsiCo twice changed the commercial, first to 700,000,000 points and then to 700,000,000 plus “(Just Kidding)”; the court found this not probative of the original's seriousnessPlaintiff's Exhibits C and D, cited at 130130
3. Statute of FraudsA contract for the sale of goods for $500 or more needs a signed writing; “There is simply no writing between the parties that evidences any transaction”; the commercial is not a writing and the Order Form did not bear PepsiCo's signatureN.Y.U.C.C. section 2-201(1)131-32
Fraud claimJudgment for PepsiCo: the plaintiff alleged only that PepsiCo never intended to honor its “offer”Grappo v. Alitalia; N.Y.U. v. Continental Ins.132

What the documents show that the headlines don't

1. The arithmetic was not the problem. The opinion never says the plaintiff misread the catalog's ten-cent rule or the order of operations. It accepts that points could be bought and that fifteen original ones had to go with the order. What failed was the step before: the Harrier Jet was “conspicuously absent from the Order Form,” and the Order Form was the only way to order.

2. The commercial pointed away from itself. The court twice uses the fact that the commercial sent viewers to a separate writing. At 124 it says the commercial “specifically reserved the details of the offer to a separate writing, the Catalog,” and footnote 2 shows the on-screen line telling viewers to see details on the packages.

3. The court decided on the plaintiff's own papers. The court rejected the argument that PepsiCo's later change to 700,000,000 points showed the original was serious. It wrote that the increase “may have been prompted less by the fear that reasonable people would demand Harrier Jets and more by the concern that unreasonable people would threaten frivolous litigation,” and, at 129, that the plaintiff was aware the jet cost about $23 million when he set out to gather the money.

4. The Statute of Frauds stands alone. Even if the commercial had been an offer, and a reasonable person had believed it, the absence of a signed writing was “an entirely separate reason for granting summary judgment.” The Second Circuit's per curiam opinion lists all three grounds and affirms “for substantially the reasons stated in Judge Wood's opinion.”

5. The money in the court file is mostly procedure. The only dollar order against the plaintiff, $88,162 in attorneys' fees on October 1, 1998, came from the Florida filing the court called a forum with “no meaningful relationship to the controversy,” and PepsiCo agreed on February 22, 1999 not to enforce it. The merits took one opinion.

What this means for your money

The case is about one question that comes up in every investment offer: which document are you able to enforce? Here a court treated the television commercial as a way to invite orders and the catalog and Order Form as the place where terms live. A reader who has money in, or is looking at, a real estate crowdfunding platform, a private placement or a Regulation A offering faces the same split: the platform's ads, webinars and emails on one side, and the offering circular, prospectus or private placement memorandum on the other.

In the Pepsi caseIn an investment offerWhat to read
The commercial: “HARRIER FIGHTER 7,000,000 PEPSI POINTS”The platform's ad, webinar, deck or email: projected returns, “liquid,” “backed by real estate”Treat as marketing; the Pepsi court treated an ad as an invitation, not terms
The catalog and Order Form: the only way to order, 53 items, no jetThe offering circular (Form 1-A), prospectus or private placement memorandum: who may amend terms, fees, redemption and what is promisedOur guides to the [private placement memorandum](/articles/private-placement-memorandum-ppm-how-to-read-2026) and the [Form D filing](/articles/form-d-filing-how-to-read-2026), and our census of [Reg A real estate offerings](/articles/reg-a-real-estate-offerings-2026)
“Offer not available in all areas. See details on specially marked packages.”Risk-factor and “no assurance” language, and the line that a plan may be suspended or amendedHow a board's discretion plays out in practice: [Dodge v. Ford and what REIT holders can force](/articles/dodge-v-ford-motor-company-1919-what-shareholders-can-force)
No signed writing, so no claim under the Statute of FraudsThe subscription agreement and what you signedThe Pepsi court found no signed writing; whether a promise outside your signed documents can be enforced is a question for a lawyer

This opinion is about contract formation in a consumer promotion. Securities law has its own rules on what an issuer and a seller may say in marketing, and the opinion does not address them; a securities lawyer is the person to ask if you think you were told something that is not in the documents. For how platform failures have played out, see our real estate crowdfunding failures page.

What a reader can do with this

  • Find the binding document before you wire money. For a Regulation A offering that is the offering circular on EDGAR; for a private placement, the memorandum and the subscription agreement; for a public non-traded fund, the prospectus. If a sales page promises something you cannot find there, ask for it in writing.
  • Read the amendment and suspension language. The catalog here said how points could be bought and how to order; an investment document says who may change redemption, distributions or fees. That sentence decides what you can force.
  • Ask what is “not available in all areas.” The footnote that mattered in 1996 was a line on the screen pointing to the packages. In an offering it is the legend on page one and the state notices.
  • Keep what you signed and what you were sent. The court looked at the Order Form, the letters and the catalog. A file of your own documents is what a lawyer will ask for first.
  • For a real dispute, see a lawyer licensed where you live. This page reads one 1999 contract case, not securities rules.

This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.

FAQ

Sources, read on November 16, 2026: Leonard v. PepsiCo, Inc., 88 F. Supp. 2d 116 (S.D.N.Y. August 5, 1999), opinion and order of Judge Kimba M. Wood, text from Justia (law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/FSupp2/88/116/2579076/, read through the Internet Archive) with page numbers of the Federal Supplement reporter, and a PDF copy of the same opinion for the passage at 128-29; Leonard v. PepsiCo, Inc., 210 F.3d 88 (2d Cir. April 17, 2000) (per curiam), text from Justia (law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F3/210/88/483989/). Court records beyond the two published opinions were not scored. Figures marked “our arithmetic” are our own calculations from the court's numbers.

Affiliate Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This does not affect our ratings. Learn more.