Social Security Overpayment 2026: 50% Withholding, Waiver, Appeal
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Quick answer
When SSA says you were overpaid, the default for a new Title II (retirement, survivor or disability) overpayment is to withhold 50 percent of your monthly benefit once the notice period ends. SSA's emergency message EM-25029 REV says: “Effective April 25, 2025, overpayment notices provided a default Title II overpayment benefit withholding rate of 50 percent of the monthly benefit.” You can contest the overpayment (reconsideration, 60 days), ask SSA to waive it (any time, Social Security Act §204(b)), or ask for a lower rate; contacting SSA to ask for reconsideration or a waiver stops collection until SSA decides. For a $2,400 benefit and an $18,000 debt, 50 percent withholding clears the debt in 15 months and 10 percent in 75 months (our arithmetic). Information as of November 19, 2026.
Key takeaways
- The rate moved three times in 13 months. EM-24011 set a default of “10 percent” (or $10 a month) from March 25, 2024; a March 7, 2025 SSA press release announced a return to 100 percent for notices from March 27, 2025; EM-25029 set 50 percent for notices from April 25, 2025. EM-25029 REV (August 28, 2025) is still the current instruction and we found no later change as of November 19, 2026.
- Notices issued before April 25, 2025 keep 10 percent, unless you incur a new overpayment; then all debts go to 50 percent. SSI overpayments stay at 10 percent (EM-25029 REV; 20 CFR 416.571).
- Deadlines: 60 days to ask for reconsideration (20 CFR 404.909(a)(1)); a waiver can be requested “at any time” (SSA POMS GN 02250.001D); a waiver request made within 30 days of the notice means no recovery until the first waiver decision (20 CFR 404.506(c)).
- A $250,000 household usually fails the “defeat the purpose” waiver test, which caps resources at $6,000 (or $10,000 with one other household family member). The other waiver ground, “against equity and good conscience,” has “no income and resource limitations” (SSA POMS GN 02250.150), but you must be without fault either way.
- SSA's FY2026 report: $29,543 million in receivables, $6,390 million collected (up from $4,925 million in FY2025), and $558 million waived, of which $349 million (our sum) was Social Security retirement, survivor and disability (OASI $139 million, DI $210 million). Treasury offset collected $573 million (about $60 million in FY2025).
- Which collection tool SSA can use depends on whether you still receive benefits. Benefit withholding applies if you do. Tax refund offset and wage garnishment are for people who are no longer receiving Title II benefits (SSA POMS GN 02201.030; 20 CFR 422.403(c)(1)).
Update alert · free
An email when the social security rule changes
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
CSV · 134 rows
Social Security overpayments: withholding rates, appeal and waiver rules, SSA debt data and a repayment example
134 rows: SSA emergency messages and POMS on the default withholding rate, 20 CFR rules on reconsideration and waiver, the collection tools, SSA's FY2022 to FY2026 debt, collection and waiver figures by program, an SSA OIG audit and our arithmetic for an $18,000 overpayment.
How the default withholding rate changed, 2024 to 2026
Most pages on this subject mix three different rates. The documents separate them by the date on the notice.
| Date | Default rate for a Title II overpayment | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Before March 25, 2024 | Full benefit. EM-24011: “Policy has been to default to full benefit withholding to recover a Title II overpayment.” | SSA EM-24011 SEN |
| March 25, 2024 | 10 percent of the monthly benefit, or $10 a month, whichever is more; not for a fraud conviction or similar fault | SSA EM-24011 SEN |
| March 7, 2025 (announced) | 100 percent for new overpayments, with notices mailed from March 27, 2025 | SSA press release, March 7, 2025 |
| April 25, 2025 | 50 percent of the monthly benefit for notices issued from this date | SSA EM-25029 and EM-25029 REV |
| Operating month 08/2025 | 50 percent also applies to matured overpayments, except fraud or similar fault and cross-program recovery; the 10 percent rate applied through operating month 07/2025 to debts noticed earlier | SSA EM-25029 REV (August 28, 2025) |
| November 19, 2026 | 50 percent is still the default; SSI overpayments stay at 10 percent | SSA EM-25029 REV; POMS GN 02201.009 (revised September 30, 2026) |
Two details matter for planning. First, EM-25029 REV says that if you have an older overpayment and incur a new one, “all outstanding overpayments will default to the 50 percent benefit withholding rate once withholding for the new overpayment begins (unless a lower repayment rate is separately negotiated or there is fraud or similar fault).” Second, SSA's own manual has not been updated everywhere. POMS GN 02210.001, last revised June 25, 2024, still says SSA recovers by “withholding the 10% of the individual’s benefit payment(s),” while POMS GN 02201.009 (revised September 30, 2026) lists “A different rate of withholding, when we propose 50 percent benefit withholding” as part of the notice. If your notice and a POMS page disagree, the date on your notice and EM-25029 REV decide which rate applies to you.
The FY2025 Agency Financial Report adds that “There are exceptions to this change, such as when an overpayment resulted from fraud, where 100 percent withholding applies.” We did not find a later SSA document changing the 50 percent rate, but we could only read what SSA publishes on its reference site. The 2025 law (Public Law 119-21) is not part of this history: we found no provision in the SSA documents above that touches overpayment recovery.
The clock: what happens after the notice
SSA does not start withholding the day it finds an overpayment. POMS GN 02201.009F says “we send the individual an overpayment notice approximately 90 days before initiating recovery,” and EM-25029 REV says the recovery date is set so that “all individuals have at least 60 days to appeal before withholding begins.” Under the regulation, the notice must also say that if you do not ask for waiver or reconsideration “within 30 days of the date of the overpayment notice, adjustment or recovery of the overpayment will begin” (20 CFR 404.502a(h)), so use the earlier date as your working deadline.
| Your move | Deadline | What happens to collection | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ask for reconsideration (you dispute that you were overpaid, or the amount) | 60 days after you receive the notice; later with good cause | Recovery is stopped while SSA reviews; if SSA affirms, recovery begins or resumes in 60 days even if you ask for a hearing | 20 CFR 404.909(a)(1); SSA POMS GN 02201.025 |
| Ask for waiver (you owe it, but it was not your fault and recovery is unfair) | Any time, including after recovery began or ended | Within 30 days of the notice: no recovery until the first decision. Later: SSA stops recovery until the first decision | 20 CFR 404.506(c); SSA POMS GN 02250.001D |
| Ask for a lower withholding rate | Before withholding starts, or any later month (effective the month you ask) | SSA negotiates; no change if fraud or similar fault; the denial is not appealable as an initial determination | SSA POMS GN 02210.030 |
| Pay in full or in installments | Any time | A refund request is in the notice; installments are offered when benefit withholding is not available | SSA POMS GN 02201.009B; 20 CFR 404.502a(d) |
A waiver request can be made orally, and for a debt of $2,000 or less the form is not required (POMS GN 02250.001C). For larger debts SSA's form is SSA-632-BK. If SSA cannot approve on the paper review, the regulation gives you a file review and a personal conference where you may be represented by an attorney (20 CFR 404.506(d) to (g)). If waiver is denied, “adjustment or recovery of the overpayment begins even if the individual appeals” (20 CFR 404.506(h)).
Waiver: the three tests, and where a household with real money stands
Social Security Act §204(b), 42 U.S.C. 404(b), says there is “no adjustment of payments to, or recovery by the United States from, any person who is without fault if such adjustment or recovery would defeat the purpose of this subchapter or would be against equity and good conscience.” So there are two layers: fault first, then one of two grounds.
| Test | What it asks | Number or rule | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Without fault | Did you give an incorrect statement you knew or should have known was wrong, fail to give information you knew or should have known was material, or accept a payment you knew or could have been expected to know was incorrect? | SSA's own error does not decide it: “Although the Administration may have been at fault in making the overpayment, that fact does not relieve the overpaid individual” | 20 CFR 404.507 |
| Defeat the purpose | Do you need substantially all of your current income for ordinary and necessary living expenses? | Household income not more than $250 above expenses, and resources no more than $6,000 ($10,000 with one other household family member, plus $1,200 for each additional) | SSA POMS GN 02250.100B; 20 CFR 404.508 |
| Against equity and good conscience | Did you change your position for the worse or give up a valuable right because of the overpayment or a notice that a payment would be made, or live in a separate household and not receive the overpayment? | “There are no income and resource limitations”; financial circumstances “are not material” | SSA POMS GN 02250.150; 20 CFR 404.509 |
| Small debt | Original overpayment of $2,000 or less and you are not at fault | Recovery waived under the administrative tolerance | SSA POMS GN 02250.350B |
For a household with $250,000 or more, the defeat-the-purpose test is usually closed. The POMS says that for this test “resources include cash or other liquid assets or any real or personal property that could be converted to cash to repay an overpayment,” with exclusions that include one home and two vehicles. Anything liquid above $6,000 ($10,000 with one other household family member) fails it. The route that remains is equity and good conscience, which turns on facts rather than on your balance sheet: did you rely on the payment and change position (SSA's regulation example is a worker who resigned because of an erroneous award), or did you rely on misinformation from an official source (POMS GN 02250.150B). That is a question of evidence you can gather before you answer SSA.
SSA's data show waivers are a small part of the debt, not a typical outcome. In the Social Security retirement and disability programs combined, waivers were 4.4 percent of new receivables in FY2026 and 3.7 percent in FY2025 (our arithmetic from the table below).
What SSA can do beyond withholding your benefit
Benefit withholding is the first tool while you are still paid. The others are for debts SSA cannot recover from a monthly payment.
| Tool | Who it reaches | Rules | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Benefit withholding | People still receiving Title II benefits | Default 50 percent; a hardship rate may be as low as $10 a month (“not less than $10”); not available if the overpayment was caused by an intentional false statement or willful concealment | 20 CFR 404.502(c); SSA POMS GN 02210.030 |
| Medicare Part B premium | Part B enrollees | The Part B premium is applied first and the balance of the benefit goes toward the overpayment | 20 CFR 404.502(d) |
| Treasury Offset Program (tax refunds and other federal payments) | Debtors not entitled to benefits, debt $25 or more, past due | Pre-offset notice, then 60 days; a waiver request or installment agreement stops referral. SSA resumed TOP in March 2025 after a pause that began in March 2020 | SSA POMS GN 02201.030 |
| Administrative wage garnishment | Debtors not receiving Title II benefits; not federal wages | Up to 15 percent of private-sector disposable pay | 20 CFR 422.403(c)(1); SSA FY2026 Agency Financial Report |
| Credit bureau reporting | Overdue debts over $25 of people no longer entitled to benefits | Written notice and at least 60 calendar days first; you may dispute or ask for an installment plan | 20 CFR 422.305; SSA POMS GN 02201.032 |
The same rules do not govern SSI. For SSI, “Any adjustment or recovery of an overpayment for an individual in current payment status is limited in amount in any month to the lesser of (1) the amount of the individual's benefit payment for that month or (2) an amount equal to 10 percent of the individual's total income” (20 CFR 416.571).
What SSA's own reports show: receivables, collections and waivers
SSA's Agency Financial Reports publish the whole debt book. The table is built from the FY2026 report (the first fiscal year entirely after the 50 percent default) and its restated prior years. Dollar amounts are in millions.
| Fiscal year | Total receivables | New receivables | Collected | Waived | Delinquent debt at year end |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FY2026 | $29,543 | $11,808 | $6,390 | $558 | $7,865 |
| FY2025 | $26,874 | $10,860 | $4,925 | $1,554 | $7,275 |
| FY2024 | $24,381 | $10,491 | $4,940 | $303 | $6,917 |
| FY2023 | $23,154 | $10,049 | $4,922 | $267 | $6,587 |
| FY2022 | $21,571 | $8,582 | $4,665 | $278 | $6,339 |
Read it with two cautions. The FY2025 report itself states that SSA “recovered $4.508 billion” in FY2025, while the FY2026 report restates FY2025 total collections as $4,925 million; the FY2026 report also notes that totals exclude debts with long payment plans, and that the SSI waivers in FY2025 include the Campos settlement. The FY2025 waiver total is therefore not a measure of how often waivers are granted for Social Security benefits. The program columns separate it:
| Program (USD millions) | FY2026 new receivables | FY2026 collected | FY2026 waived | FY2025 new receivables | FY2025 collected | FY2025 waived |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retirement and survivors (OASI) | $4,164 | $2,694 | $139 | $3,601 | $2,277 | $92 |
| Disability (DI) | $3,751 | $1,716 | $210 | $3,080 | $1,140 | $155 |
| OASI plus DI (our arithmetic) | $7,915 | $4,410 | $349 | $6,681 | $3,417 | $247 |
Collections on retirement, survivor and disability debts rose 29.1 percent from FY2025 to FY2026 (our arithmetic). The reports do not say the 50 percent default caused it, so treat the timing as a coincidence we can show and a cause we cannot.
| How SSA collected (USD billions) | FY2025 | FY2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Benefit withholding, retirement, survivor and disability | $2.483 | $2.997 |
| Treasury Offset Program, retirement, survivor and disability | $0.037 | $0.341 |
| Treasury Offset Program, all programs | $0.060 | $0.573 (net of reversals) |
| Administrative wage garnishment, retirement, survivor and disability | $0.001 | $0.001 |
| All internal collections, all programs | $4.447 | $5.817 |
Benefit withholding is where the money comes from: $2.997 billion of the $4.069 billion of retirement, survivor and disability internal collections in FY2026. The garnishment line is $0.001 billion. SSA's FY2026 report says that since the March 2025 restart Treasury “has offset over 323,000 Federal and State payments and collected $645 million” of its delinquent debt, and that about 58,200 debts are on payment plans that run past December 31, 2049.
What produces the overpayments? For FY2025 reviews, SSA estimated about $1.7 billion in retirement and survivor overpayments (about 0.12 percent of outlays) and about $2.8 billion in disability overpayments (about 1.86 percent), and the report says that of the retirement and survivor total “approximately $1.6 billion in overpayments were administrative errors within the agency’s control.” In disability, the report puts the split at about $1.5 billion within the agency's control and about $1.3 billion caused by recipients or their payees. Because 20 CFR 404.507 says SSA's own mistake does not by itself excuse repayment, a large share of debts that began as SSA errors still reach beneficiaries as bills. SSA's Office of the Inspector General reported in a May 11, 2026 news release that in a sample of 250 low-dollar retirement, survivor and disability overpayments, 50 were cases where collection efforts were not cost-beneficial, and projected that SSA spent about $4.6 million pursuing nearly 16,000 overpayments totaling about $2.6 million.
Worked example: a $2,400 benefit and an $18,000 notice (our arithmetic)
A retiree gets $2,400 a month and receives a notice saying $18,000 was overpaid. The notice is dated after April 25, 2025. We ignore the Part B premium, income tax withholding and interest; the numbers are only the debt divided by the monthly amount.
| Path | Monthly amount taken | Benefit left | Months to clear $18,000 | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Default 50 percent withholding | $1,200 | $1,200 | 15 | EM-25029 REV |
| 10 percent (notice dated before April 25, 2025, and no new overpayment) | $240 | $2,160 | 75 (6.25 years) | EM-25029 REV; POMS GN 02210.001 |
| Lowest payment that clears the debt within 60 months | $300 (12.5 percent) | $2,100 | 60 | SSA POMS GN 02210.030B |
| A 36-month plan | $500 (20.8 percent) | $1,900 | 36 | Our arithmetic |
| Payment that clears it in 12 months | $1,500 (62.5 percent) | $900 | 12 | More than the default; shown for reference |
| Rate below $300 (more than 60 months) | As low as $10 | $2,390 or more | Over 60 | Needs Form SSA-634; resources below $3,000 considered (GN 02210.030C) |
Two readings. First, at 50 percent the debt is gone in 15 months, but you live on $1,200 a month for those 15 months. The POMS rule for a plan within 60 months needs no financial form: SSA negotiates a rate that recovers the debt within 60 months with a minimum of $10 a month (GN 02210.030B). That is $300 here, 12.5 percent of the benefit. Second, below that line SSA asks for Form SSA-634 and weighs resources against $3,000 (GN 02210.030C), so for a household with substantial savings a rate below $300 is unlikely. The text of GN 02210.030 was last revised October 8, 2024, before the 50 percent default, so ask the field office how it applies the rule to a 50 percent notice.
If a waiver is granted. If SSA waives the full $18,000, the debt is $0. If waiver comes after six months at 50 percent, SSA has withheld $7,200 and $10,800 remains to waive. POMS GN 02250.001F says SSA “may also refund the overpaid amounts that we have recovered or withheld,” so the $7,200 may come back; the text says “may,” and we did not verify how often it does.
What changed, 2024 to 2026
| Date | Change | Source |
|---|---|---|
| March 25, 2024 | Default cut from full withholding to 10 percent | SSA EM-24011 SEN |
| June 2024 | Debt system date limit moved from December 31, 2049 to October 14, 2073 | SSA FY2026 Agency Financial Report, Note 6 |
| March 7, 2025 | SSA announced 100 percent withholding for notices from March 27, 2025 | SSA press release |
| March 2025 | Treasury Offset Program use resumed after a pause that began in March 2020 | SSA POMS GN 02201.030; FY2026 Agency Financial Report |
| April 25, 2025 | Default set at 50 percent for notices from that date | SSA EM-25029 |
| August 2025 | Pre-offset notices to debtors with debts incurred after March 2020 resumed | SSA FY2026 Agency Financial Report |
| August 28, 2025 | EM-25029 REV: how reconsideration and waiver work for notices before and after April 25, 2025 | SSA EM-25029 REV |
| March 2026 | SSA began sending debts to Treasury's Centralized Receivables Service; nearly 3,800 debts totaling $111 million in FY2026 | SSA FY2026 Agency Financial Report |
| May 11, 2026 | SSA OIG news release on an audit of low-dollar overpayments | SSA OIG |
| September 30, 2026 | POMS GN 02201.009 revised; notice lists a different rate of withholding when SSA proposes 50 percent | SSA POMS |
What a reader can do with this
- Read the date on the notice first. Before April 25, 2025 is 10 percent; on or after is 50 percent, with the new-overpayment exception that pulls older debts up to 50 percent.
- Decide which of three things you are disputing. That you were overpaid or the amount (reconsideration, 60 days), that recovery is unfair although you owe it (waiver), or the speed of repayment (a lower rate). Each has a different form and a different effect on collection.
- Act inside 30 days if you can. A waiver request within 30 days of the notice means no recovery until the first decision (20 CFR 404.506(c)). Ask in writing and keep a copy.
- Gather the fault and reliance evidence now. Letters from SSA, what you reported and when, and anything showing you changed plans because of the payment.
- If your benefit already started, check the earnings and the benefits behind the debt. A work-earnings overpayment on a reduced-benefit claim is covered in our Social Security earnings test guide; a retroactive-pay overpayment after the repeal of the windfall elimination provision and the government pension offset is background in our Social Security Fairness Act back-pay guide. We did not find an SSA document on how the repeal's back pay interacts with overpayment recovery.
- Plan the rest of the budget. A 50 percent cut for 15 months sits next to a 2027 cost-of-living change (see the 2027 COLA guide) and the longer-term picture in the Trustees report guide.
- If you withdrew a claim, repaying benefits is a different process (see our withdrawal of application guide).
This is a summary of public law and official data, not legal or tax advice. Benefits rules vary by case; talk to a licensed attorney (and read your SSA notice) before acting.
FAQ
Sources, read and saved on November 19, 2026: SSA Emergency Messages EM-24011 SEN (March 25, 2024), EM-25029 (April 25, 2025) and EM-25029 REV (August 28, 2025); SSA press release of March 7, 2025 (Internet Archive copy); SSA POMS GN 02201.009 (September 30, 2026), GN 02201.025, GN 02201.030, GN 02201.032, GN 02210.001, GN 02210.030, GN 02250.001, GN 02250.100, GN 02250.150 and GN 02250.350; 42 U.S.C. 404 (law.cornell.edu); 20 CFR 404.502, 404.502a, 404.506, 404.507, 404.508, 404.509, 404.909, 416.571, 422.305 and 422.403 (eCFR, up to date as of November 17, 2026); SSA Agency Financial Reports for FY2025 and FY2026 (the FY2026 report read from an Internet Archive copy of ssa.gov); SSA Office of the Inspector General news release of May 11, 2026. The 50 percent, 10 percent and 60-month repayment figures in the worked example are our arithmetic from those rules.