Nassau Life vs PHL Variable: Only PHL Is in Rehabilitation; Nassau Life and Annuity Surplus $128.3M, June 2026
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Update alert · free
An email when the Nassau annuity numbers change
When a rate, rule or filing behind this page changes: what changed, the one number that matters, and the source to check it yourself.
Quick Answer
As of November 14, 2026, one insurer in the Nassau group is in court-supervised rehabilitation, PHL Variable Insurance Company (“PHL”), and the Nassau companies that issue annuities today are not. The Connecticut Superior Court placed PHL in rehabilitation on May 20, 2024, and the Rehabilitator's September 30, 2026 report says “The transition to liquidation is expected to occur in 2027.” Annuities are issued by Nassau Life and Annuity Company (“NLA”, Connecticut) and, in New York, by Nassau Life Insurance Company (“NNY”, formerly Phoenix Life Insurance Company). Both are separate legal entities from PHL, which their 2025 statutory statements call a “former affiliate.” NLA reported statutory capital and surplus of $128.3 million at June 30, 2026 ($145.6 million at December 31, 2025); NNY reported $358.7 million ($295.7 million); PHL reported negative $2.42 billion at December 31, 2025. The links that remain are real: reinsurance treaties between PHL and both Nassau insurers, and claims the Rehabilitator has preserved against “various entities within the Nassau Group,” which Nassau disputes.
Key Takeaways
- Only PHL is in a proceeding in the documents we read. The Connecticut Insurance Department's PHL page, last updated July 29, 2026, says “PHL Variable Insurance Company is under court-supervised rehabilitation.” We found no rehabilitation, supervision or liquidation order for NLA, NNY or Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas in their April 2026 statutory statements, their June 30, 2026 quarterly statements or KBRA's September 25, 2026 release, which affirmed all of them.
- Who issues what: “Annuities are issued by Nassau Life and Annuity Company (Hartford, CT).” In New York they are issued by Nassau Life Insurance Company (East Greenbush, NY), which was renamed from Phoenix Life Insurance Company in 2018 and absorbed Delaware Life Insurance Company of New York on July 5, 2023. Nassau's own page says the companies “are separate entities and each is responsible for its own financial condition and contractual obligations.”
- Statutory capital and surplus: NLA $145.6 million at December 31, 2025 and $128.3 million at June 30, 2026 (down 11.8% in six months, our arithmetic, after a $20.0 million surplus contribution and a $15.1 million net loss). NNY $295.7 million and $358.7 million (up 21.3%, after a $36.0 million parent contribution on February 6, 2026). PHL: negative $2,419.4 million at December 31, 2025.
- NLA cedes a large block of reserves to affiliates: $4,882.2 million to the captive Sunrise Re and $971.0 million of guaranteed-withdrawal-rider reserves to the Vermont captive Lynbrook Re at December 31, 2025. Lynbrook's accumulated losses were $776.8 million; NLA admits no value for it and states it has no guaranteed obligation or commitment to support it.
- Ties to PHL: NNY and NLA each reinsure PHL business, and PHL cedes fixed indexed annuity business to Nassau Re (Cayman). The Rehabilitator says the estate has claims against the Nassau Group and Golden Gate Capital; a policyholder suit filed September 25, 2026 makes allegations against both. Nassau says: “These claims are without merit and we will vigorously defend ourselves.” No document we read values these claims.
- Ratings, as Nassau lists them: AM Best B++ (Stable), most recent action February 27, 2026; KBRA BBB+ (Positive), September 25, 2026; Fitch BBB+ (Stable), July 2, 2026; S&P BBB- (Stable), July 7, 2025. KBRA says its Positive Outlook “remains in place pending resolution of the matter involving the rehabilitator of PHL,” among other conditions.
- Guaranty limits depend on where the holder lives and apply only if an insurer is liquidated: Connecticut $500,000 and New York $500,000 per life; Texas $250,000; California 80% of present value up to $250,000. None is triggered for NLA or NNY today. For PHL a liquidation order is expected in 2027.
CSV · 109 rows
Nassau Life and Annuity, Nassau Life Insurance and PHL Variable: issuers, capital, reinsurance, ratings, rehabilitation, guaranty limits
109 rows from the 2025 statutory statements of Nassau's two insurers, their June 30, 2026 quarterly statements, PHL's Form N-VPFS, KBRA's September 25, 2026 release, the Connecticut Rehabilitator's reports and four states' guaranty limits.
Which Nassau company is on your contract
Searches for “Nassau Re” and “Nassau annuity” land on a group name, but a contract is issued by one company, and the legal name on the statement decides everything below. The five names that appear in the documents are these.
| Name in the documents | Short name | Location | What the documents say it does | Status in the documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nassau Life and Annuity Company (does business as Nassau Life and Annuity Insurance Company in California) | NLA | Connecticut | Issues annuities outside New York; licensed to sell life, annuity and accident and health products in 49 states and the District of Columbia | No proceeding found; the 2025 statements say RBC ratios are “in excess of the minimum levels required” |
| Nassau Life Insurance Company, formerly Phoenix Life Insurance Company (renamed 2018); also holds the former Delaware Life Insurance Company of New York contracts (merged July 5, 2023) | NNY | New York | Issues annuities in New York; mostly a life insurer, with annuity reserves of $819.6 million against $9,823.4 million of reserves before reinsurance at December 31, 2025 | No proceeding found; committed to the New York regulator to hold RBC at or above 300% through June 2028 |
| PHL Variable Insurance Company | PHL | Connecticut | Sold Phoenix-branded variable annuities, fixed indexed annuities and universal life; its separate accounts still file with the SEC | In rehabilitation since May 20, 2024; liquidation expected in 2027 |
| Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas | NKS | Overland Park, Kansas | Offers Medicare Supplement insurance | No proceeding found; rated alongside NLA and NNY |
| Nassau Re (Cayman) Ltd. | Nassau Re | Cayman Islands | Reinsurer in the group; reinsures part of PHL's fixed indexed annuity business under a 2016 treaty; not a company that issues contracts to the public | Rated BBB+ by KBRA |
Sources: Nassau Financial Group website (About page and Financial Strength page, November 14, 2026); NLA and NNY statutory statements, Form N-VPFS filed April 28, 2026; Form 485BPOS of April 29, 2026 for the 2018 renaming; PHL Rehabilitator's Third Accounting and Status Report (November 20, 2025).
Two details help a holder who is unsure which name is theirs. First, the Connecticut Insurance Department tells PHL holders: “Please contact the Nassau Customer Service at (800) 541-0171” for policy status, premium, benefits and claims, and the May 1, 2026 Nassau Life prospectus summary gives 1-800-541-0171 as the number for information about Nassau Life. The phone line is shared, so the number does not tell you which company holds your contract; the issuer named on your statement does. Second, Nassau Re (Cayman) Ltd. is a reinsurer in the group, not a company that issues contracts to the public. Nassau's history page, which describes the purchase of Phoenix as made by Nassau, says Nassau was founded in 2015 and “signed the agreement to acquire Phoenix” soon after, and its ratings page says these insurance companies “became part of Nassau in 2016.”
Only PHL is in rehabilitation: what the documents show
The Connecticut Superior Court placed PHL and its two captive reinsurers, Concord Re and Palisado Re, in rehabilitation on May 20, 2024 (docket X06-UWY-CV-24-6085274-S). On December 31, 2025 the Rehabilitator reported that “all of PHL's blocks of business are materially impaired” and that a plan to rehabilitate without a liquidation order is not feasible. On September 30, 2026 he reported that NOLHGA, the national organization of state guaranty associations, had started a request for proposals with initial proposals requested by October 15, 2026, and that “The transition to liquidation is expected to occur in 2027.” He promised the next update on or around November 20, 2026. Our PHL Variable rehabilitation page has the moratorium caps, the 2026 election options and the Rehabilitator's 34% to 57% recovery estimate; we do not repeat them here.
Nothing comparable appears for the other Nassau companies. We searched the full text of the 2025 statutory statements of NLA and NNY, filed with the SEC on April 28, 2026, for “rehabilitation,” “moratorium,” “tolling” and “Golden Gate”: none appears. Both statements, dated April 2, 2026, say there were no material subsequent events requiring adjustment, and NNY discloses one: a $36.0 million capital contribution from its parent on February 6, 2026. KBRA, which rates the group, affirmed BBB+ for NNY, NLA, Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas and Nassau Re (Cayman) on September 25, 2026. That is evidence of what we found, not proof that nothing exists: our reading stops at the documents named on this page.
Even the prospectus language differs. The PHL variable annuity prospectus summary of April 29, 2026 states: “There is a significant risk that the financial guarantees and obligations under your contract will not be fulfilled.” The Nassau Life Flex Edge Success summary of May 1, 2026 uses the ordinary wording that benefits “are subject to the claims-paying ability of Nassau Life” and does not mention PHL.
Three balance sheets, side by side
| Statutory figure | NLA | NNY | PHL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Capital and surplus, December 31, 2025 | $145.6 million | $295.7 million | negative $2,419.4 million |
| Capital and surplus, June 30, 2026 | $128.3 million | $358.7 million | No 2026 statement in the documents we read |
| Capital and surplus, December 31, 2024 | $165.9 million | $299.2 million | negative $2,267.2 million |
| Total admitted assets, December 31, 2025 | $6,749.9 million | $13,640.6 million | $3,610.2 million |
| Net income (loss), 2025 | negative $47.9 million | $1.2 million | Not shown here |
| Group's own solvency ratio, March 31, 2026 (statutory assets divided by statutory liabilities) | 102.1% | 102.7% | Not applicable |
Sources: NLA and NNY Form N-VPFS (accessions 0001104659-26-050083 and 0001104659-26-050078); Q2 2026 quarterly statements posted by Nassau; Nassau Corporate Profile; PHL Variable Accumulation Account Form N-VPFS (accession 0001104659-26-050101). The solvency ratio is Nassau's own measure and is not an RBC ratio; Nassau's footnote defines it as total statutory assets divided by statutory liabilities. The 2025 statements do not publish an RBC ratio for NLA or NNY.
Three points from the table. NLA's surplus fell in 2024, in 2025 and in the first half of 2026: from $175.8 million at December 31, 2023 to $165.9 million, $145.6 million and $128.3 million, even though its parent added paid-in surplus of $79.0 million (2023), $20.0 million (2024) and $40.0 million (2025) (the amounts are in the filing; the comparison is ours). NNY's surplus includes $126.5 million of surplus notes. And KBRA, in its own words, calls Nassau's “statutory capital profile” “generally solid, though certain capital ratios remain below benchmark levels, with some reliance on surplus notes and reinsurance support.” We do not rate any of these companies. The numbers are the filings' numbers.
Reinsurance and affiliate ties inside the group
Most of NLA's annuity risk sits in affiliates. At December 31, 2025 NLA's own balance sheet carried $1,301.4 million of reserves for future policy benefits, but the filing says $4,882.2 million of reserves were ceded under its “Sunrise” agreement with an affiliate captive, Sunrise Re, Inc., on a funds-withheld basis (roughly 3.8 times the reserves on NLA's own balance sheet, our arithmetic, though the two figures are on different bases). With funds withheld, the assets stay with NLA: its liability for funds held under reinsurance treaties was $4,767.8 million at December 31, 2025 and $5,115.8 million at June 30, 2026.
| Link | What the document says | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| NLA to Sunrise Re (affiliate captive) | Coinsurance funds withheld on 80% of fixed indexed annuity, fixed annuity and life products issued beginning in 2018 | Reserves ceded $4,882.2 million at December 31, 2025 ($3,857.4 million a year earlier) |
| NLA to Lynbrook Re (Vermont captive) | Coinsurance funds withheld on guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit riders on fixed indexed annuities | Reserves ceded $971.0 million ($810.9 million); accumulated losses of Lynbrook $776.8 million; NLA admits no value and says it has no guaranteed obligation or commitment of financial support |
| NLA, cessions to captives | Filing states: no cessions to captive reinsurers in which a non-zero primary security shortfall exists | Not applicable |
| NNY and PHL, treaty 1 | NNY assumes, on a 90% coinsurance basis, Phoenix Accumulator Universal Life III and IV sold by PHL in 2008 | Reserves ceded to NNY $55.7 million at December 31, 2025 |
| NNY and PHL, treaty 2 | NNY retrocedes, and PHL reinsures, 80% of group executive ordinary corporate-owned whole life that NNY assumed from a third party; NLA reinsures 100% of what PHL took, with a $150 million ceding allowance | MODCO reserves $1.4 billion at December 31, 2025 (assets stay with NNY) |
| PHL to Nassau Re (Cayman) | MODCO treaty from April 1, 2016 reinsuring 50% of PHL's existing fixed indexed annuity business | Not stated in the part we read |
| NNY, termination of all reinsurance | NNY estimates the aggregate reduction in surplus if all reinsurance agreements were terminated | $9.5 million (2025); the filing says affiliate amounts include PHL |
| Notes of Nassau-managed vehicles held | NLA and NNY hold notes of Nassau special purpose vehicles | NLA $128.4 million par ($101.0 million fair value); NNY $176.5 million par ($147.9 million fair value) |
Sources: NLA and NNY 2025 statutory statements, notes on reinsurance, investments in subsidiaries and related parties; PHL Form N-VPFS filed April 28, 2026; Rehabilitator's Third Accounting and Status Report (November 20, 2025), which lists NNY, NLA and Nassau Re (Cayman) Ltd. among PHL's reinsurers.
What this means for a holder is limited to what the filings say. The treaties with PHL are small against NNY's balance sheet in the one measure NNY gives (a $9.5 million surplus effect if all reinsurance were terminated), but they are not zero, and the NNY filing calls PHL a “former affiliate” while still carrying a $1.4 billion MODCO block with it. The Q2 2026 holding-company chart in NLA's quarterly statement still lists PHL Variable Insurance Company in a footnote, with a 44.04% equity interest in an entity of the group, and shows Golden Gate Capital Opportunity Fund entities at the top of the ownership chart. We cannot tell from the extract what that footnote is worth.
The Rehabilitator's claims against Nassau, and what Nassau says
The Rehabilitator's December 31, 2025 report says the estate may have claims against “various entities within the Nassau Group (PHL's former parent) and its parent, Golden Gate Capital, including claims for breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract and avoidable transfers,” and adds: “The Nassau Group and Golden Gate dispute the validity of any claims.” The July 9, 2026 status FAQs say the Rehabilitator “entered into a tolling agreement with the Nassau Group to preserve all claims,” that any settlement needs court approval after notice to policyholders, and that if no acceptable settlement is reached he intends to file a lawsuit. Bloomberg reported on September 29, 2026 that policyholders sued Golden Gate and Nassau Financial Group in Connecticut federal court the previous Friday, alleging among other things that reinsurance deals with affiliates concealed PHL's problems; Nassau's spokesperson called the claims without merit. Those are allegations, not findings.
For an NLA or NNY holder the open question is whether a settlement or judgment could ever weigh on the Nassau insurers or on the group above them. No document we read values any claim, and the 2025 statutory statements of NLA and NNY do not mention one. KBRA does name the risk: its Positive Outlook “remains in place pending resolution of the matter involving the rehabilitator of PHL, including the nature and potential magnitude of any claims or settlement, the timing and form of resolution, and any resulting reputational or financial impact on Nassau.” KBRA lists resolution that “materially weakens Nassau's financial or business profile” among the factors that could lead to a downgrade.
Ratings, with the date of the last action
| Agency | Rating (outlook) | Most recent action, per Nassau | Applies to |
|---|---|---|---|
| AM Best | B++ (Stable) | February 27, 2026 | NNY, NLA, Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas |
| KBRA | BBB+ (Positive) | September 25, 2026 | NNY, NLA, Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas, Nassau Re (Cayman) |
| Fitch | BBB+ (Stable) | July 2, 2026 | NNY, NLA, Nassau Re (Cayman) |
| S&P Global | BBB- (Stable) | July 7, 2025 | NNY, NLA, Nassau Life Insurance Company of Kansas |
Source: Nassau Financial Group, “Strength and Stability of Our Insurance Carriers,” read November 14, 2026; KBRA press release of September 25, 2026 (read on KBRA's site). We could not reach AM Best's, Fitch's or S&P's own releases (AM Best's site blocks automated access), so those three rows are Nassau's statement of the agencies' ratings. The S&P action is 16 months old.
The holding company is rated lower than the insurers: KBRA's issuer rating on Nassau Financial Group, L.P. is BB+, and so are the $425 million of 7.875% senior notes due 2030 of The Nassau Companies of New York, which Nassau Financial Group guarantees. A rating is an agency's opinion of claims-paying ability; it is not a statement about a particular contract, and we do not add our own.
What changes for the holder, and what does not
| Question | NLA contract | NNY contract (New York, ex-Phoenix Life, ex-Delaware Life NY) | PHL contract |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal status in the documents | No proceeding found | No proceeding found | Rehabilitation since May 20, 2024; liquidation expected in 2027 |
| Court-ordered cap on payments from the general account | None found | None found | Annuity death benefits of $250,000 or less paid in full; life death benefits of $300,000 or less paid in full; limits for larger amounts under the June 25, 2024 moratorium |
| Surrender or withdrawal | Contract terms apply; no court restriction found | Contract terms apply; no court restriction found | Non-variable contracts: not allowed except as the moratorium modifications permit; variable contracts: up to the separate-account value |
| Guaranty association | Not triggered: no liquidation | Not triggered: no liquidation | Triggered only by a liquidation order with a finding of insolvency; expected 2027 |
| Who answers the phone | Nassau Customer Service | Nassau Customer Service | Nassau Customer Service for policy questions; the Rehabilitator's call center for rehabilitation questions |
| Statutory capital and surplus | $128.3 million (June 30, 2026) | $358.7 million (June 30, 2026) | negative $2,419.4 million (December 31, 2025) |
| Prospectus risk wording | Claims-paying ability of Nassau Life | Claims-paying ability of Nassau Life | “significant risk” that obligations “will not be fulfilled” |
Sources: Connecticut Insurance Department General FAQs (July 9, 2026) and PHL page (last updated July 29, 2026); Nassau Life and PHL prospectus summaries (April 29 and May 1, 2026); statutory statements. “No proceeding found” means we found none in the documents named on this page.
A $400,000 annuity in four states
The guaranty association of the holder's state of residence pays if an insurer is liquidated, up to the limit in that state's law (in Connecticut, General Statutes Section 38a-860; the other states are in the table below). The figures below come from each state's statute or association. The Connecticut statute covers “five hundred thousand dollars in the present value of annuity benefits”; the New York corporation says its limit is “$500,000 per life” across policy types; the Texas association lists annuity benefits at “$250,000 per life”; the California association pays “80% of the present value up to a maximum of $250,000.” Our annuity guaranty limits table covers all states and shows the combined caps per life.
The worked example uses the structure of the Rehabilitator's own example F, a $650,000 annuity with a $250,000 guaranty limit and a $400,000 claim against the estate, with the Rehabilitator's 34% to 57% estimate for the part above the guaranty limit. It is arithmetic on a hypothetical PHL contract of $400,000 cash surrender value after a liquidation order, assuming each association pays the limit in the table below (Connecticut General Statutes Section 38a-860 and the New York, Texas and California associations' published FAQ limits). For an NLA or NNY contract the same table would show nothing paid, because no liquidation exists.
| Holder lives in | State limit on annuity benefits | Paid by guaranty association | Excess claim against PHL estate | Estimated estate payment (34% to 57%) | Total (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | $500,000 | $400,000 | $0 | $0 | $400,000 (100%) |
| New York | $500,000 per life, all policy types | $400,000 | $0 | $0 | $400,000 (100%) |
| Texas | $250,000 | $250,000 | $150,000 | $51,000 to $85,500 | $301,000 to $335,500 (75.3% to 83.9%) |
| California | 80% of present value up to $250,000 (80% of $400,000 is $320,000) | $250,000 | $150,000 | $51,000 to $85,500 | $301,000 to $335,500 (75.3% to 83.9%) |
Two cautions. The Rehabilitator expects the guaranty claims in his examples to be paid in full, but says “all coverage decisions will be made by the applicable guaranty association.” And Connecticut's statute limits coverage to residents, with narrow exceptions for non-residents of the state where the insurer is domiciled, so a holder who moves between states should ask the association of the state of residence at the time of liquidation. The Connecticut Insurance Department says coverage “may stay the same or change” depending on the policy and the state limit.
What a reader can do with this
This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
- Read the issuer name on your statement. NLA, NNY and PHL each have their own statutory statements; the name decides which table above applies. Names from the past (Phoenix Life, Phoenix Life and Annuity, Delaware Life of New York) are explained in the first table.
- Compare your balance with your state's limit, per person per insurer, using the four limits above or our guaranty table. The limit counts all contracts with one insurer, so two contracts at NNY and one at PHL are counted separately.
- If the contract is at PHL, the Rehabilitator's call center (1-877-800-2445) and the Connecticut Insurance Department page are the authority; non-variable contracts cannot be surrendered under the moratorium, so do not assume an exchange or a withdrawal is possible before asking. Our PHL page lists the 2026 election options, which are final once processed.
- If the contract is at NLA or NNY, ask in writing for the surrender schedule, the free-withdrawal amount and the crediting-rate terms, and read the tax side before moving money: see our deferred annuity taxation page and our 1035 exchange page. For how other insurers owned by investment groups compare, see our private equity-owned annuity insurers page.
- Watch the next dated documents: the Rehabilitator's update on or around November 20, 2026, and the third-quarter 2026 statements that Nassau posts on its Financial Strength page next to the June ones.
FAQ
Sources, read on November 14, 2026: Nassau Life and Annuity Company and Nassau Life Insurance Company 2025 statutory financial statements (Form N-VPFS, CIK 1023809 accession 0001104659-26-050083 and CIK 796154 accession 0001104659-26-050078, filed April 28, 2026); their June 30, 2026 quarterly statements and the Nassau Corporate Profile (assets.nfg.com); Nassau Financial Group website pages (About, Financial Strength, 1851 Legacy, Contact) and news release of October 1, 2026; Form 485BPOS and Form 497VPU for Nassau Life Variable Universal Life Account (April 29, 2026 and May 1, 2026); PHL Variable Accumulation Account Form N-VPFS (accession 0001104659-26-050101) and Form 497VPU (accession 0001104659-26-051764); KBRA press release of September 25, 2026; Connecticut Insurance Department PHL page (last updated July 29, 2026), General FAQs and Fourth Report FAQs (July 9, 2026), Distribution Analysis Summary (April 17, 2026); Connecticut Superior Court docket X06-UWY-CV-24-6085274-S: Rehabilitator's reports of December 31, 2025, November 20, 2025 and September 30, 2026; Bloomberg via Claims Journal (September 29, 2026); Connecticut General Statutes chapter 704a, sections 38a-858 to 38a-875; Life and Health Insurance Company Guaranty Corporation of New York FAQ; California Life & Health Insurance Guarantee Association FAQ; Texas Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association FAQ. Court records beyond those the Department posts were not read (CourtListener was unavailable on November 14, 2026). Figures marked “our arithmetic” are computed from those documents.
Keep reading.
- 0124 min read
PHL Variable Insurance in Rehabilitation Since May 2024: Liquidation Expected 2027, Est. 34%-57% Recovery
PHL Variable Insurance is in rehabilitation: annuity payouts capped at $250,000, liquidation expected 2027, claims above guaranty limits projected at 34%-57%.
- 0221 min read
Annuity Guaranty Association Limits by State, 2026 Table
Annuity guaranty limits for 50 states and DC: $250,000 in 40, up to $500,000 in four. We read 17 statutes; Minnesota’s $410,000 is not the MYGA limit.
- 0325 min read
Private Equity-Owned Annuity Insurers Compared in SEC Filings
Seven annuity insurers side by side from their SEC filings: owners, private credit, Bermuda reinsurance, fees, capital and ratings, as of November 10, 2026.