Is Roots Real Estate Legit? Complaints, Reg A Filings (2026)
Some links pay us a referral fee; each one says so. Disclosure
Vehicle file: Roots Real Estate Investment Community I, LLC — assets, distributions, repurchases and every filing, as filed with the SEC.Open the file →Filing alert · free
An email when Roots Real Estate Investment Community I files with the SEC
An email the day Roots Real Estate Investment Community I files something new, with the link to the document on the SEC site.
Quick Answer
Is Roots legit? Read from its documents as of November 2, 2026 (the date of its latest SEC filing), Roots Real Estate Investment Community I, LLC (SEC CIK 1866803, Atlanta) is a registered Regulation A Tier 2 issuer that files on or within a day of its deadlines, has audited accounts and has paid redemptions every period we checked. Its offering was qualified on June 21, 2022 and the current offering circular was filed on May 12, 2026. The 2025 accounts carry an unmodified opinion from Moore Colson & Company, P.C. The unit price set by the Manager is $159.25 since October 10, 2026, and the filings show $8,859,583 redeemed in 2025 and $6,765,560 in the first half of 2026. What the documents also show, and what any holder should weigh: the Manager values the properties itself, 533 of 581 properties came from its sponsor as of April 30, 2026, the fund lost $2,190,869 in the first half of 2026, and one regulator order exists, a $17,500 Texas fine dated April 30, 2024 for selling units without a dealer registration. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
Key Takeaways
- Registered and reporting: Regulation A Tier 2, initial offering qualified June 21, 2022, follow-on qualified August 29, 2025, current offering circular filed May 12, 2026, latest filing a Form 1-U on November 2, 2026.
- Audited: Moore Colson & Company, P.C. gave an unmodified opinion on the 2025 and 2024 accounts in a report dated April 30, 2026. The first-half 2026 accounts (Form 1-SA, September 28, 2026) are unaudited.
- On time: the last four annual reports and the last three semiannual reports were filed on or before the deadline we calculate; one semiannual report, for 2023, was filed one day after our count (our arithmetic).
- Unit price set by the Manager, October 10, 2026: $159.25, raised from $155.30. Every one of the nine resets we read, from October 2024 to October 2026, was an increase. No independent valuation firm is engaged.
- Redemptions paid: 22,266 units ($2,963,173) in 2024, 61,813 units ($8,859,583) in 2025, 43,905 units ($6,765,560) in the first half of 2026. The filings do not report how many units were requested.
- Related party: 533 of 581 properties acquired by April 30, 2026 were curated properties bought from the sponsor; $30,917,239 was lent to the sponsor at 7% (June 30, 2026).
- Three Form 1-U filings between October 6 and November 2, 2026 report 97 homes bought from sponsor-linked sellers for $31,159,739.12 against $34,803,500 of stated market value (our arithmetic).
- Regulators: a Texas State Securities Board consent order of April 30, 2024 (reprimand, $17,500 fine, sales to 266 Texas residents of almost $900,000). FINRA BrokerCheck shows no firm under the Roots, Roots REIT Management or Seed InvestCo names. Court records are not scored.
CSV · 84 rows
Roots Real Estate Investment Community I: registration, audit, filing dates, unit price, redemptions, sponsor purchases, fees and regulator checks
84 rows from Roots' Forms 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U, the May 12, 2026 offering circular and the Texas order, with the accession number or URL on every row. Our own arithmetic is labelled in the note column.
What "legit" means for a Reg A fund, test by test
Searches such as "is Roots legit" and "Roots complaints" ask whether the money is real and whether it can come back out. A filing cannot prove either. It can show whether the basics a regulated issuer owes its holders are in place. We used five tests and read each from the document that answers it.
| Test | What the documents show | Document |
|---|---|---|
| Registered with the SEC under Regulation A? | Yes. Tier 2. Initial offering qualified June 21, 2022; follow-on qualified August 29, 2025; circular filed May 12, 2026. Being qualified is a disclosure step: the SEC does not vouch for the units. | Form 253G2, May 12, 2026; Form 1-K, April 30, 2026 |
| Audited by an outside firm? | Yes for 2025 and 2024: Moore Colson & Company, P.C., Atlanta, unmodified opinion dated April 30, 2026. No for the six months to June 30, 2026. | Form 1-K; Form 1-SA, September 28, 2026 |
| Filing on time? | Mostly to the day. See the timeliness table below. | EDGAR; SEC Form 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U instructions |
| Documented redemptions? | Yes: units and dollars paid are reported each period. Requests received are not reported. The Manager may suspend the program at any time. | Form 1-K; Form 1-SA |
| Independent price check? | No. The circular says it has not engaged an independent valuation services firm. The unit price is the Manager's own calculation. | Form 253G2, May 12, 2026 |
On the first four tests the record is in order. On the fifth, and on related-party dealing, the filings disclose the arrangement and leave the checking to the holder. That is the honest meaning of "legit" here: disclosed, not independently verified.
Reg A status: what the filings say about registration
The circular states that the units are sold only to qualified purchasers under Regulation A Tier 2, which is exempt from state "Blue Sky" review as long as the offering meets that condition. The annual report adds that the follow-on offering, with a rolling 12-month maximum of $75,000,000, was qualified on August 29, 2025. The SEC's own Form 1-K instructions set the annual deadline at 120 calendar days after the fiscal year end and the Form 1-SA instructions set 90 calendar days after the half year; Form 1-U asks for current reports within four business days of an event.
The latest filing on EDGAR when we read it, on November 15, 2026, is a Form 1-U filed November 2, 2026. The circular also says the company neither charges nor pays broker-dealer distribution fees and will not pay the Manager or its affiliates selling commissions or dealer manager fees.
Are the reports filed on time? (our arithmetic)
| Report | Deadline we count | Filed | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Form 1-K for 2022 | May 1, 2023 (day 120, April 30, 2023, was a Sunday) | May 1, 2023 | On time |
| Form 1-K for 2023 | April 29, 2024 | April 29, 2024 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-K for 2024 | April 30, 2025 | April 30, 2025 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-K for 2025 | April 30, 2026 | April 30, 2026 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-SA, June 30, 2023 | September 28, 2023 | September 29, 2023 | One day after our count |
| Form 1-SA, June 30, 2024 | September 30, 2024 (day 90 was a Saturday) | September 27, 2024 | Early |
| Form 1-SA, June 30, 2025 | September 29, 2025 (day 90 was a Sunday) | September 29, 2025 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-SA, June 30, 2026 | September 28, 2026 | September 28, 2026 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-U, 40 homes bought September 30, 2026 | October 6, 2026 (four business days) | October 6, 2026 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-U, 41 homes bought October 15, 2026 | October 21, 2026 | October 21, 2026 | On the deadline |
| Form 1-U, 16 homes bought October 27, 2026 | November 2, 2026 | November 2, 2026 | On the deadline |
Reading: no report in this table is more than one day past our count, and most are filed on the last permitted day. We did not check whether EDGAR applied any grace to the 2023 report. For the Form 1-U rows we counted from the purchase dates in the body of each filing, because the cover pages of the October 21 and November 2 filings give their own filing dates as the date of the report.
The audit: who signed, and what the opinion says
The independent auditor's report in the Form 1-K for 2025 is signed by Moore Colson & Company, Atlanta, Georgia, dated April 30, 2026. Its opinion reads: “In our opinion, the consolidated financial statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects, the financial position of the Company as of December 31, 2025 and 2024.” The only going-concern language in the report is the auditor's standard description of its duties, and we found the words "material weakness" nowhere in the 1-K or the 1-SA when we searched the text on November 15, 2026. The Manager's own liquidity statement says it expects proceeds, operating cash flow and cash on hand to cover commitments “for at least one year from the date of the financial statements.”
A Tier 2 issuer does not need an auditor's report on internal controls, and the circular says so. The audit covers the accounts; it does not value the homes at today's market.
The unit price, reset by reset
The unit price is not a market price. The filings call it the net asset value per unit, calculated by the Manager and reset at the start of each quarter. Here are the nine resets we read.
| Effective date | Unit price set by the Manager | Raised from | Form 1-U filed |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 10, 2024 | $137.00 | $133 | October 15, 2024 |
| January 10, 2025 | $140.00 | $137 | January 15, 2025 |
| May 6, 2025 | $142.00 | $140 | May 7, 2025 |
| July 10, 2025 | $144.00 | $142 | July 11, 2025 |
| October 10, 2025 | $147.50 | $144 | October 10, 2025 |
| January 10, 2026 | $150.81 | $147.50 | January 14, 2026 |
| April 10, 2026 | $153.07 | $150.81 | April 14, 2026 |
| July 10, 2026 | $155.30 | $153.07 | July 13, 2026 |
| October 10, 2026 | $159.25 | $155.30 | October 13, 2026 |
From $147.50 on October 10, 2025 to $159.25 is up 7.97% in twelve months; from $137 on October 10, 2024 it is up 16.24% (our arithmetic). The October 13, 2026 filing also declared a quarterly distribution of $1.50 per unit, $1,453,758 in total, expected before October 31, 2026. Against $159.25, four $1.50 payments are 3.77% a year (our arithmetic).
Two things a holder can check. First, the circular describes the method: the Manager takes “estimated values of each of our real estate assets” and uses independent appraisal reports only “if the Manager deems it necessary.” Second, the price has risen at every reset in this table while the same company reported a net loss for the year 2025 ($2,422,553) and for the first half of 2026 ($2,190,869). Both can be true, because the loss is measured at historical cost less depreciation and the unit price is the Manager's estimate of current value. The two figures are not reconciled in a way a holder can audit from the filings alone.
Redemptions: what was paid, and what the filings leave out
The redemption program lets members ask each quarter to sell units back at the quarter's unit price. The annual report sets the limits: no more than 5% of issued units in a quarter, no more than $100,000 per member in a quarter, a request window that opens on the fifteenth day before quarter end, and a price that “may be decreased by 8%” in the first year of ownership. The Manager “reserves the right, in its sole and absolute discretion, to suspend the Company's offer for redemption at any time, without notice, for any reason or no reason.” The circular adds that investors are not buying “because of the possible quarterly redemptions.”
| Period | Units redeemed | Amount paid | Stated price range | Implied average (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 22,266 | $2,963,173 | $128.00 to $137.00 | $133.08 |
| 2025 | 61,813 | $8,859,583 | $137.00 to $147.50 | $143.33 |
| January to June 2026 | 43,905 | $6,765,560 | $147.50 to $153.07 | $154.10 |
| July 1 to September 18, 2026 | 19,186 | $2,954,360 | not stated | $153.99 |
What the table shows and does not show:
- Paid, not requested. The filings give units and dollars redeemed. They do not give units requested, so a reader cannot tell from the documents whether any request was prorated. In the first half of 2026 the 43,905 units paid are 6.44% of the 681,396 units outstanding on January 1, 2026, against a cap of 5% per quarter, about 34,070 units at the start of the year (our arithmetic).
- One figure to check. For the first half of 2026 the filing states a price range of $147.50 to $153.07 per unit, yet $6,765,560 divided by 43,905 units is $154.10, which is $1.03 above the top of that range (our arithmetic). The filing says the units are “approximately” 43,905; it does not explain the gap.
- Units are growing faster than exits. Units outstanding went from 681,396 on December 31, 2025 to 865,457 on June 30, 2026 and about 980,779 on September 18, 2026. New money covered the redemptions: $19,914,033 of units issued against $2,954,360 redeemed between July 1 and September 18, 2026. Redemptions paid from new money is how this structure works while it is growing; it is also why it matters what happens if sales slow.
Buying from the sponsor: what the filings say about related parties
The company is managed by Roots REIT Management, LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of its sponsor, Seed InvestCo, LLC. The circular describes the model: the sponsor buys and renovates homes, a third-party certified appraiser values them, and the sponsor sells them to the company “at or below such appraised fair market value”, with the sponsor likely to “realize gain”. Our existing pages on this are the Roots review and the analysis of the 78 homes bought on August 25, 2026.
| Item | What the filings show | Date |
|---|---|---|
| Homes bought from the sponsor | 366 of 476 properties acquired (77%, our arithmetic) | December 31, 2025 (Form 1-K) |
| Homes bought from the sponsor | 533 of 581 properties acquired (92%, our arithmetic) | April 30, 2026 (circular) |
| Advances to the sponsor | $30,917,239 note receivable at 7%; $1,026,842 interest income in the half year | June 30, 2026 (Form 1-SA) |
| Fees to the Manager | 10% of rents collected; 3% acquisition fee; 3% disposition fee; $500 per new lease and $250 per renewal; a fixed monthly repairs amount per property | Form 1-K, April 30, 2026 |
| Property management fees paid to the Manager | $757,492 in the first half of 2026, against $109,943 in the first half of 2025 | Form 1-SA |
| Selling commissions or dealer-manager fees | None payable to the Manager or its affiliates | Circular, May 12, 2026 |
The three most recent purchase filings give each home a price to Roots and a "current market value":
| Form 1-U filed | Homes | Seller as described in the filing | Price paid by Roots | Stated market value | Price as share of value (our arithmetic) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| October 6, 2026 | 40 | Flipside 21, LLC, partially owned by the sponsor | $14,550,000 | $16,426,500 | 88.6% |
| October 21, 2026 | 41 | Flipside 14, LLC (partially owned), the sponsor itself, and Cultivate George Fund LLC (wholly owned) | $11,281,375.12 | $12,537,000 | 90.0% |
| November 2, 2026 | 16 | Flipside 24, LLC, partially owned by the sponsor | $5,328,364 | $5,840,000 | 91.2% |
| Total | 97 | $31,159,739.12 | $34,803,500 | 89.5% |
The filings list "allocated purchase price" and "current market value" for each group of homes; they do not attach an appraisal. Whether that gap is a discount to the buyer or a markup built into the stated value cannot be told from these filings. The sponsor's gain on each sale is, by the circular's own description, expected.
Regulators and courts: what we searched on November 15, 2026
| Where we looked | What we found | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Texas State Securities Board | Consent Order No. REG-24-CAF-03, signed April 30, 2024. The order finds that from September 2022 through January 2024 the company made sales in Texas to 266 residents totaling almost $900,000 while not registered as a dealer, reprimands it and fines it $17,500. It approves the company's dealer registration application of January 12, 2024. It is a registration violation; the order says it was entered into “solely for the purpose of resolving the investigation.” | Found |
| The offering circular of May 12, 2026 | The word Texas appears nowhere in the circular text we saved. A Tier 2 circular is not required to list every state order, so this is a fact to know, not an accusation. | Checked |
| SEC litigation releases and administrative proceedings | A web search for the company's name with the SEC returned only its own filings. The SEC's search page could not be read by our tools, so we did not run the search on sec.gov itself. | Not scored by direct search |
| FINRA BrokerCheck | Firm searches on November 15, 2026 for Roots Real Estate Investment Community I, Roots REIT Management, Seed InvestCo, RootsCom and Roots Real Estate returned no firm under those names. The circular says the company pays no broker-dealer distribution fees. | None found |
| Georgia Secretary of State, Securities Division | A web search for an order against the company, the Manager or the sponsor returned none. The Division's own enforcement database was not read. | Not scored by direct search |
| Courts | Court records not scored (CourtListener unavailable on November 15, 2026). The Form 1-SA says only that the company may face litigation in the normal course and that management expects no material adverse effect. | Not scored |
A fine for selling in a state before registering as a dealer is a regulatory fact worth knowing. It is not a finding about the properties, the accounts or where the money went.
What the complaints are about, and what counts as a record
Most "Roots complaints" searches are about three things the documents themselves confirm: the redemption program is discretionary, the unit price is an internal figure, and the sponsor sells homes to the fund it manages. Those are disclosed features, not hidden ones. Review sites are not records, and we count them only as that site's own figure. When we read Trustpilot's page for investwithroots.com on November 15, 2026 it showed 47 reviews and a 4.4 score, the latest dated May 5, 2026. The CFPB complaint database blocked automated reading on that date, so we have not re-run it here; our Roots review reports the search we ran on November 11, 2026.
What a reader can do with this
- Ask for the redemption history in requests, not just payments. The 1-K and 1-SA give units paid. Ask Roots how many units were requested in each of the last four quarters and whether any request was prorated.
- Ask what supports the unit price. The circular says appraisals come “if the Manager deems it necessary.” Ask which properties were appraised in the quarter the price was set and by whom.
- Compare the filing's redemption price range with its dollar total. The first-half 2026 figures differ by $1.03 a unit (our arithmetic). Ask Roots to reconcile them.
- Read each Form 1-U that reports a purchase from the sponsor. The seller, the price and the stated value are on the first page. Our reading of the 78 homes of August 25, 2026 shows what the price and value columns can and cannot prove.
- Compare it with other Reg A funds before adding to it. Our Roots versus Fundrise comparison sets liquidity, fees and structure side by side.
- Treat the redemption cap as a ceiling you may not reach. A 5% quarterly cap, an 8% first-year cut and a manager's right to suspend mean the money is not on call.
Frequently asked questions
Sources: Roots Real Estate Investment Community I, LLC (SEC CIK 1866803): Form 1-K for 2025, accession 0001493152-26-020769 (April 30, 2026); Form 1-SA for June 30, 2026, accession 0001493152-26-044493 (September 28, 2026); offering circular Form 253G2, accession 0001493152-26-022456 (May 12, 2026) and supplement 0001493152-26-046794 (October 13, 2026); Forms 1-U of October 15, 2024, January 15, May 7, July 11 and October 10, 2025, January 14, April 14, July 13, October 6, October 13, October 21 and November 2, 2026; EDGAR submissions list; SEC Form 1-K, 1-SA and 1-U instructions; Texas State Securities Board Order No. REG-24-CAF-03 (April 30, 2024); FINRA BrokerCheck firm search; Trustpilot page for investwithroots.com. Read on November 15, 2026. This is analysis of public documents, not investment, legal or tax advice.
Keep reading.
- 0118 min read
Average Down Payment on a House: What 2.77 Million Buyers Put Down
Median down payment on a house in 2025 federal data: 10% and $30,000 on 2.77 million loans, by loan type, age and state, plus a $385,000 payment example.
- 0218 min read
Chattel Loan Rates 2025: Home-Only Loans Had a 9.47% Median Rate, 6.75% With Land
2025 HMDA data on 127,410 manufactured-home purchase loans: home-only (chattel-type) loans had a 9.47% median rate and 74.1% denial rate, home-and-land 6.75%.
- 0318 min read
Credit Union Mortgage Lenders Ranked, 2025: Navy Federal 80,547
2025 HMDA: Navy Federal made 80,547 loans; credit unions' median rate 6.5%, total costs $3,871 vs $6,199 at non-banks, but 17.3% denied. Top 25 ranked.